? re: subprime lending

Posted By Message

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

? re: subprime lending

PLEASE DON'T QUOTE

DH had good credit upon getting the loan for this home but had never even rented before, his income was WAY lower than it is now and currently the bank even after trying to consider us for HAMP cannot get our payments anywhere near or below the 31% necessary to qualify (the government will not allow them to go any lower)

anyway, my question is...considering he is making significantly MORE now than he was when he was first considered for the loan and they still can't get the payments lowered to anywhere near 31% of what he is making now...doesn't that say that he should not have qualified for the loan in the first place considering his income would not have supported it?

Obviously the bank won't comment on this because it is a legal matter and they bought out the loan so it wasn't even their doing in the first place. But I'm curious...I thought that income also played a big factor in obtaining a loan...not just good credit (it's not like his credit limit was high in the first place...just because someone can maintain a $2000 credit card doesn't mean they are a good candidate for a home loan)

thoughts? experience?

Message edited 2014-01-08 17:15:51.317000.

Posted 1/8/14 5:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Loans were easy to come by years ago. Banks were giving out loans to all, they even had no doc loans!! Many people that obtained mortgages then, would be pushed out of the bank today.

I think I may be missing something here. If he is making more money now, why does he have an issue with the mortgage now?


Our mortgage broker suggested that we never borrow more than 417k. She was very strict financially. We had a prequal for 650k. We took our brokers advice and kept the mortgage well under 417k. I think bankers need to be more conservative when telling a person what they can borrow

Posted 1/8/14 5:49 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

back then when we got the house we had another tenant who was paying half the mortgage and bills. This tenant did not have the credit to obtain the loan and so he made a deal with my husband that tenant would put money down on the home but DH would obtain the loan...they would fix the house up and split the profits. The market crashed and tenant moved out without any further payments or contributions. We were left to pay it all.

Posted 1/8/14 5:56 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Oh I see, can you get another tenant? That really stinksChat Icon

Fwiw, I know a lot of people that purchased homes during the upswing. Struggling a lot because they are being responsible about the debt they took on. It really takes a toll on people.

Message edited 2014-01-08 18:00:09.930000.

Posted 1/8/14 5:57 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

? re: subprime lending

I'm not too sure what you're asking, but are you trying to sue the bank for giving your husband the mortgage? He still took the mortgage knowing his income alone could not support it, but did he have signed contracts with the tenant that he would split the payments?

Posted 1/8/14 6:03 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Posted by Millie3

Oh I see, can you get another tenant? That really stinksChat Icon

Fwiw, I know a lot of people that purchased homes during the upswing. Struggling a lot because they are being responsible about the debt they took on. It really takes a toll on people.



it's not a 2 family home. it's a 1 family. The tenant was a good friend of DH which is why it worked fine then. The "tenant" tried to put another tenant in his place but she did not fulfill her obligations of payment and tenant did not do his part to substitute the difference. That tenant threatened to burn our house down when we told her she either had to pay or start looking for a place to live. She ended up moving out and we have been solo ever since. I don't want a stranger in my home with my kids in a 1 family home and honestly don't feel I should have to bc the tenant did not fulfill his end of our agreement.

Posted 1/8/14 6:04 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

It's not my intention to sue the bank. However, we have been working with them for over a year and they recently sent us a modification stating our payments would drop down by just a little over half of what they were. We made all the trial payments on time only to be told at the end of the trial and fulfilling our end of the obligation that they were approving us for the modification but not for the amount originally documented. The price would go back up to just $40 less than it was originally (almost double the documented modified amount) but extend the loan by 10 years. We are now pressured to make a decision on this immediately after they just did this and sent us the new documentation on the 2nd. The whole thing is just a disaster and I'm just seeing so many things done wrong and I'm questioning it.

kitten...nope...no contracts...the whole thing was done horribly. My husband was incredibly uninformed and as we were not married at the time I was not involved in any of the legalities and had no idea how bad this whole situation really was for DH...but now I've been living in it for about 6+ years so it affects me BIGTIME.

Message edited 2014-01-08 18:18:07.710000.

Posted 1/8/14 6:13 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by Millie3

Oh I see, can you get another tenant? That really stinksChat Icon

Fwiw, I know a lot of people that purchased homes during the upswing. Struggling a lot because they are being responsible about the debt they took on. It really takes a toll on people.



it's not a 2 family home. it's a 1 family. The tenant was a good friend of DH which is why it worked fine then. The "tenant" tried to put another tenant in his place but she did not fulfill her obligations of payment and tenant did not do his part to substitute the difference. That tenant threatened to burn our house down when we told her she either had to pay or start looking for a place to live. She ended up moving out and we have been solo ever since. I don't want a stranger in my home with my kids in a 1 family home and honestly don't feel I should have to bc the tenant did not fulfill his end of our agreement.



Why not sue the friend. You really have no recourse against the bank. As much as they may have given your DH a loan he didn't really qualify for he still have a responsibility to do his own due diligence in what he can afford. And IMO you should never bank on tenants when purchasing a house.

I'm sorry you guys are in a ****** situation but I'm not sure where you have recourse against the lender. And if you did it would be the original lender.

Posted 1/8/14 6:17 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

? re: subprime lending

What are your other options? Can you short sale?

Posted 1/8/14 6:19 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

That's the option we are looking at right now. The amount owed is not THAT much lower than what they have our homes value at but we need to get an appraisal to know exactly where we stand. I

Posted 1/8/14 6:22 PM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

? re: subprime lending

Are you working with an attorney? Honestly, whatever side deal your husband made with the tenant has no bearing on the mortgage between your husband and the bank. I can't answer whether your husband has a predatory lending action he can pursue, but an attorney should be able to answer that for you. Additionally, a modification that only reduces your payment by $40 a month does not sound like a good faith attempt at a modification and perhaps you should consider a call to the New York Attorney General can help you there.

Posted 1/8/14 6:23 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

I don't think you can do anything to the lender, and it would be the original lender anyway. But, I would tell them no. You are going to pay A LOT more on a 40 year loan. That's just wild to save $40 that will adjust come tax time anyway. Hmmm. I think I would say there is no way $40 would allow me to stay in this home, can I have your info on a short sale. I wouldn't flat out refuse at first.

Posted 1/8/14 6:26 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

we have contacted 2 different attorneys with no word back...looking into recs for more now.

Posted 1/8/14 6:27 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Also I think you may run into issues in the future with this other person being on your house. It would be good to consult an atty before you decline the banks offer. Just make sure it's an actual attorney.

Posted 1/8/14 6:30 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

thanks ladies. I'm so done with the whole situation that nothing would make me happier than to just sell it, walk away and start fresh elsewhere...even if it means we start off in an apartment. I honestly have no desire to go into any type of litigation where this house is concerned.

My only concern is that the "tenant" is concerned about his initial investment (a down payment) but with depreciation and the value of our home being nearly 100k less than when we bought it, I don't see how any return on investment can be expected. it was a bad investment. I'm just trying to prepare myself bc it sounds like that tenant wants to or wants us to fight for the home. I just don't think I have fight in me. I'm done.

Posted 1/8/14 6:43 PM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

? re: subprime lending

Can people sue banks for predatory lending? If so, I have a good case.

Posted 1/8/14 7:16 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Posted by meloyellow

thanks ladies. I'm so done with the whole situation that nothing would make me happier than to just sell it, walk away and start fresh elsewhere...even if it means we start off in an apartment. I honestly have no desire to go into any type of litigation where this house is concerned.

My only concern is that the "tenant" is concerned about his initial investment (a down payment) but with depreciation and the value of our home being nearly 100k less than when we bought it, I don't see how any return on investment can be expected. it was a bad investment. I'm just trying to prepare myself bc it sounds like that tenant wants to or wants us to fight for the home. I just don't think I have fight in me. I'm done.



Does he have a contract stating he gave the DP? I mean, what kind of recourse would he have now anyway since he isn't paying towards anything? He wants money back from his investment? How about tallying up from when he bailed and deduct it from his "investment" and he'll see what he owes you.

Posted 1/8/14 9:44 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

Posted by alli3131

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by Millie3

Oh I see, can you get another tenant? That really stinksChat Icon

Fwiw, I know a lot of people that purchased homes during the upswing. Struggling a lot because they are being responsible about the debt they took on. It really takes a toll on people.



it's not a 2 family home. it's a 1 family. The tenant was a good friend of DH which is why it worked fine then. The "tenant" tried to put another tenant in his place but she did not fulfill her obligations of payment and tenant did not do his part to substitute the difference. That tenant threatened to burn our house down when we told her she either had to pay or start looking for a place to live. She ended up moving out and we have been solo ever since. I don't want a stranger in my home with my kids in a 1 family home and honestly don't feel I should have to bc the tenant did not fulfill his end of our agreement.



Why not sue the friend. You really have no recourse against the bank. As much as they may have given your DH a loan he didn't really qualify for he still have a responsibility to do his own due diligence in what he can afford. And IMO you should never bank on tenants when purchasing a house.

I'm sorry you guys are in a ****** situation but I'm not sure where you have recourse against the lender. And if you did it would be the original lender.



If there were no contracts, then there is no way to sue the friend unfortunately. I mean, of course they could TRY. But I don't think that they would be successful and would incur legal feesChat Icon

ETA: I am confused, the tenant is concerned about his DP being returned? If there were no contracts signed between your DH and this guy then f him.

If there are contracts, you really should need to speak to an attorney

Message edited 2014-01-08 22:51:51.457000.

Posted 1/8/14 10:48 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: ? re: subprime lending

agree with you ladies wholeheartedly. no contracts so really there is nothing.

Posted 1/8/14 11:42 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: ? re: subprime lending


I personally think you should look into selling.

Set up an appt. with a reputable agent to discuss your options, then go from there.

The ones on here look like they are really good and know their stuff.

It's an unfortunate situation that your DH got himself into but it does not sound like there is anything he can do to "sue" anyone.

Either he keeps the house and accepts that, or considers the above option.

Or, maybe even consider a renter? (Not someone to move in with you, but maybe a family looking to rent and you guys rent elsewhere).

I feel bad because you write about this so much, I can see how it really is eating away at your life.

Chat Icon

Posted 1/9/14 7:37 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How do you feel about this? "Subprime help: Some loan rates to be frozen" SweetestOfPeas 12/6/07 93 Home
Does anyone know when the Kindle will have library lending? sfp0701 7/18/11 1 StoryBoard
NYPL lending period is 21 days! Love that! fabrichick 12/23/10 3 StoryBoard
How do you feel about lending your clothes to someone? 4ForMe 4/19/09 32 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone ever use Lending Tree? Plus credit inq ques BabyAvocado 5/8/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Good RE lawyer rec? (also warning about lending tree) PiyoPika566 8/22/05 24 Home