question regarding lease...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
question regarding lease... The community I live in decided to put a "state of the art gym" and an increase in maintenacne (not sure about that one) and plugged $175 into my rent check for the month. Is this legal? Ive never heard of such a thing??? |
|
Posted 6/27/11 7:39 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: question regarding lease... If you have a lease no they cannot just change the rent. But as far as how the maintenance part of your lease is written, then maybe. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 7:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... if they consider it a major capital improvement, then yes, they can. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 7:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... This is how it reads.... |
|
Posted 6/27/11 8:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by PrincessP This is how it reads.... "As a result of the increase in wages for bldg employess relating to the maintenance and upkeep of the amenities at the property and construction of the new gym, the landlord is imposing an annual ammenity charge of 175. We enclose herewith a rider to the lease which we require you to sign and return with your payment. Please mail payment and rider to..... So basically its a amenity fee paid on a yearly basis, which isnt really uncommon....I would think that its legal, especially since they are making you sign a rider. Message edited 2011-06-27 20:19:31.143000. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 8:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by newbie00 Posted by PrincessP This is how it reads.... "As a result of the increase in wages for bldg employess relating to the maintenance and upkeep of the amenities at the property and construction of the new gym, the landlord is imposing an annual ammenity charge of 175. We enclose herewith a rider to the lease which we require you to sign and return with your payment. Please mail payment and rider to..... So basically its a amenity fee paid on a yearly basis, which isnt really uncommon....I would think that its legal, especially since they are making you sign a rider. Even if Ive been living here 5 yrs and sign a lease every yr and this yr I signed one not stating any of these new stipulations? |
|
Posted 6/27/11 8:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... It does not seem that out of the ordinary to me. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 8:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by mzsocialworker1 It does not seem that out of the ordinary to me. I deal with lease issues all the time with my clients. On average, their rent increases by $50.00- $100.00 each year. They also live in the same apartment complexes anyone on LI would live in. There are also often extra fees and security added, and this is all legal. I dont understand what you mean. I am not saying that these things DONT happen. What I am saying is that my lease agreement was signed in Jan of 2011. I dont think stipulations should change until a new lease is signed in jan 2012. What if I dont want to pay it? I still cant leave bc I am bound til jan 2012 but yet I never said yes in the jan 2011 agreement. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 8:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... I'm not an expert like the above poster appears to be everytime there is an apartment/rental issue....but, that doesn't sound legal to me. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 9:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by BargainMama I'm not an expert like the above poster appears to be everytime there is an apartment/rental issue....but, that doesn't sound legal to me. I doubt they can change the terms mid year and make you sign the rider. They are probably just hoping you will and send your money in. It seems like you would just be bound by the terms and conditions in the lease you signed in January, which includes using the ammenities without a charge. Then when it's time to renew, they would just add that clause in the lease you are signing. I personally wouldn't send the money in or sign the rider. If they question it, let them know you will be happy to sign it when you renew your lease (if you do so). This is my exact reasoning for not wanting to sign/pay it. I am still waiting to know why I am obligated to pay it. From the above that I am reading, I am hearing this is normal. I am not sure why? |
|
Posted 6/27/11 9:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... what kind of building is it? how many units? that might dictate the law. |
|
Posted 6/27/11 9:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by BargainMama I'm not an expert like the above poster appears to be everytime there is an apartment/rental issue....but, that doesn't sound legal to me. I doubt they can change the terms mid year and make you sign the rider. They are probably just hoping you will and send your money in. It seems like you would just be bound by the terms and conditions in the lease you signed in January, which includes using the ammenities without a charge. Then when it's time to renew, they would just add that clause in the lease you are signing. I personally wouldn't send the money in or sign the rider. If they question it, let them know you will be happy to sign it when you renew your lease (if you do so). Honestly, I never claimed to be an "expert" and there's no reason for snark like I have noticed every time with YOU when I answer a post like this. I do deal with housing issues in my work on a pretty regular basis so I am just saying it seems pretty normal to me. This is a message board. The OP and anyone can take what is said on here with a grain of salt.
|
|
Posted 6/28/11 5:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Posted by BargainMama They are probably just hoping you will and send your money in. It seems like you would just be bound by the terms and conditions in the lease you signed in January, which includes using the ammenities without a charge. Then when it's time to renew, they would just add that clause in the lease you are signing. I personally wouldn't send the money in or sign the rider. If they question it, let them know you will be happy to sign it when you renew your lease (if you do so). I agree with this but would probably look at the lease I did sign to see if there was anything about increased maintenance fees. |
|
Posted 6/28/11 7:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: question regarding lease... Honestly, I wouldn't take this kind of advice from a message board. I would read the fine print in your lease, and if there's nothing that refers to maintenance fees, then I would consult with an attorney who knows the specific law on lease riders in NY |
|
Posted 6/28/11 7:16 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I am changing the question...if you have turned in lease recently have you had to pay a fee? | JerseyMamaOf3 | 9/29/08 | 19 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Dumb question...what does lease with option to buy mean? | alnem | 11/7/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question re: security deposits - when there is no lease | mitabtrfly | 12/11/07 | 22 | Home |
| Question, has anyone ever done a Lease Swap with their car | MrsM-6-7-08 | 11/19/07 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| lease question | MeeshkaMich | 7/31/07 | 2 | Home |
| lease question | MeeshkaMich | 7/1/07 | 1 | Home |







