Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Posted By Message

Shop24-7
I love my little girl!

Member since 10/09

2026 total posts

Name:

Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

DH & I are pregnant with our first child - due in August.

We registered this weekend & DH wants to register for 'Your Baby Can Read'.

Has anyone used this program and is it worth the $$?

Posted 5/17/10 11:59 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

This topic comes up every few weeks or so. some are for it 100%. some are against it. As an educator, I am 100% against it and place more value with parents sitting and reading with their children for at least 20 minutes to a half hour each day. I read with Abby for 15 minutes in the am and DH does it at night. you would be surprised at how much she knows including letters and numbers.

Posted 5/17/10 12:11 PM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

we don't have it. Never thought of getting it. DS loves his books and brings them to us all day long to read to him.

Posted 5/17/10 12:14 PM
 

Shop24-7
I love my little girl!

Member since 10/09

2026 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Posted by Goldi0218

This topic comes up every few weeks or so. some are for it 100%. some are against it. As an educator, I am 100% against it and place more value with parents sitting and reading with their children for at least 20 minutes to a half hour each day. I read with Abby for 15 minutes in the am and DH does it at night. you would be surprised at how much she knows including letters and numbers.



I agree with you completely. I am a licensed special educator and have strong hesitations about the program. I'm all for reading with your children every day.

However, I jsut figured I would through this question out there to see if anyone did feel it was worth the investment.

Thanks! Chat Icon

Posted 5/17/10 12:18 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

My Mom is a PhD in reading, I asked her opinion on it and she said used the right way 'it doesn't hurt' it teaches sight recognition, which is part of learning how to read. It cannot replace significant parental interaction, but used in conjunction with reading to your child and having real world conversations it can be another tool.

We were talking recently and she said that having enriched conversations (not direct question/answer conversations) with and around your child have shown to have a dramatic effect on language and vocabulary. It is more than just reading to your child, having imaginative conversations around them is important as is talking about stories you read while reading them, asking questions to get the child thinking about the future of the story, what could happen, what has happened how characters feel. These are all things she recommends doing from birth. She feels comprehension needs to be taught with letter/word recognition not later.

Message edited 2010-05-17 12:26:26.180000.

Posted 5/17/10 12:25 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Posted by NinaLemon

My Mom is a PhD in reading, I asked her opinion on it and she said used the right way 'it doesn't hurt' it teaches sight recognition, which is part of learning how to read. It cannot replace significant parental interaction, but used in conjunction with reading to your child and having real world conversations it can be another tool.

We were talking recently and she said that having enriched conversations (not direct question/answer conversations) with and around your child have shown to have a dramatic effect on language and vocabulary. It is more than just reading to your child, having imaginative conversations around them is important as is talking about stories you read while reading them, asking questions to get the child thinking about the future of the story, what could happen, what has happened how characters feel. These are all things she recommends doing from birth. She feels comprehension needs to be taught with letter/word recognition not later.



Your mother is brilliant. I agree ONE MILLION percent. Every interaction with your child can be an incredible experience for learning - EVERY one of them.

Posted 5/17/10 12:27 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Posted by Goldi0218

Posted by NinaLemon

r.



Your mother is brilliant. I agree ONE MILLION percent. Every interaction with your child can be an incredible experience for learning - EVERY one of them.



Thank you Chat Icon I think she is pretty awesome too Chat Icon She always says exactly what you just said too, that every moment is a learning opportunity, it is so true and very rewarding for both the child and the parent Chat Icon

Posted 5/17/10 12:34 PM
 

Shop24-7
I love my little girl!

Member since 10/09

2026 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Posted by NinaLemon

My Mom is a PhD in reading, I asked her opinion on it and she said used the right way 'it doesn't hurt' it teaches sight recognition, which is part of learning how to read. It cannot replace significant parental interaction, but used in conjunction with reading to your child and having real world conversations it can be another tool.

We were talking recently and she said that having enriched conversations (not direct question/answer conversations) with and around your child have shown to have a dramatic effect on language and vocabulary. It is more than just reading to your child, having imaginative conversations around them is important as is talking about stories you read while reading them, asking questions to get the child thinking about the future of the story, what could happen, what has happened how characters feel. These are all things she recommends doing from birth. She feels comprehension needs to be taught with letter/word recognition not later.




Your mother is so right! Thank you so much!

Posted 5/17/10 12:42 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

I work in early intervention and agree your money would be better spent on other items for your baby.

Posted 5/17/10 12:48 PM
 

dapnkap
Our 3 angels

Member since 7/07

4824 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

My MIL got this for DD at Christmas and we use it in conjunction with other books, videos, puzzles, etc.

Posted 5/17/10 12:50 PM
 

conigs25
So in love with this kid!

Member since 5/06

11197 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

As a certified reading teacher i can tell you that i dont believe this can help your baby read any etter than any other program. IMO reading to your child and YOU being his/her teacher is invaluable

Message edited 2010-05-17 12:53:14.733000.

Posted 5/17/10 12:51 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

Its absolutely not meant to replace any of the interactions you are supposed to have with your child. Its an extra tool, and far better than anything on TV for kids.

IMO, don't buy it, you can get it used on e-bay for cheap, and when its time for your LO, I think there will be so many used copies running around you can get it then.

There are bits and pieces of a lot of value in there, its based on validated research and theories about how infants learn. Its not 100% how I'm going to do things and the creator does not recommend watching the DVDs all day long all the time. He says something along the lines of, "if you will allow your child to watch TV, try this, but interaction with your child is primarily what is going to teach them language"

For example:
DS is at 2 months, we play some of the games suggested by the workshop video. We use the mirror to make faces to encourage mouth motor skills. I stick out my tongue, he pauses and laughs. Now he's starting to try to stick his toungue out too. He always laughs after he tries. Its so much fun, if DS is cranky, this is almost surefire to change his mood.

We sing songs about things we interact with. Like "here is your bottle, lets eat your bottle, yummy yummy bottle". He has already started baby talk, when he says words that sound like they could be real words, we encourage it and praise him. We have tons of fun. This is only in addition to the things we are already doing, talking to him, reading to him, singing to him. The videos kind of show you how to do it, to keep a child's attention.

I wonder if anyone who's actually seen this program, disapprove?

Posted 5/17/10 12:57 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Question about 'Your Baby Can Read'

My DH bought it (against my better judgment) and after trying it for a few days I had him return it. We did get to keep a book and something else that I have gone over with my DD a few times... maybe flash cards, I'm not sure.

I prefer to read stories to my DD rather than just recite words and have her say them back to me. I read to my DD every night and I see her learning and comprehending what's going on, which I don't see with the YBCR program.

For example, Hansel and Gretel was one of her favorite stories a few months ago so we read it every night. We'd get to the point where Hansel was locked in the cage and from the pictures plus the text that I read my DD would point and comment that "the boy is sad" and then ask me why? And then she'd say the witch was bad, or she was mean. She really *gets* the story.

Flash cards don't inspire conversations with my daughter.

Posted 5/17/10 1:08 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
i read the entire baby laughs book tonight!! raken40 7/26/07 6 Pregnancy
when can we read to the baby? Bklyngrl 5/6/07 6 Pregnancy
Anyone read the book The Baby Whisperer? Charly 1/10/07 9 Parenting
Want to get ready to read to the baby (belly) Ang-Rich 12/7/06 15 Pregnancy
anyone read the baby whisperer? 04bride 10/7/06 10 Parenting
did you read the story about the "mermaid"baby(pic at bottom) janet 6/1/05 7 Families Helping Families ™