Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Posted By Message

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Because I've heard a lot of people use the Queen Ester story as a vindication of interfaith marriages.

I'm geniunely confused. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I don't want to post this on facebook because it's orthodox friends on there who are posting about it, and they're kind of umm..intense about it, so I figured I'd ask here.

Can't we all just dress up and get drunk? Chat Icon

Posted 2/28/10 1:32 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Purim

Posted 2/28/10 7:29 AM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

... and eat HamentaschenChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/28/10 7:46 AM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Personally, I've never heard the Purim story being used as a lesson about interfaith marriages. However, if you think about it, the celebration of the Jewish people surviving leads to thoughts about how we can continue to survive. I am not saying that I am against intermarriage - to each his or her own - but, one of the reasons for the decreasing numbers of Jewish people (particularly among the Conservative movement, which is how I identify), is because of intermarriage.

Haman hated the Jews before Esther and Ahashverous (I know I spelled his name wrong) got married. For all we know, if the king hadn't married a Jewish woman, Haman might have been successful, because the king may not have been motivated to save the Jews.

As with all Jewish questions, there are many interpretations, and no answers! Those are just my thoughts at the moment.

Posted 2/28/10 6:30 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Posted by JenniferEver



Can't we all just dress up and get drunk? Chat Icon



Chat Icon

This is how I feel about everything!!

Posted 2/28/10 7:13 PM
 

Ltdentway99
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1752 total posts

Name:

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

No, it's not about assimilation. It's about resisting being murdered. Some people compare Hamen to the current King of Persia.

Message edited 2010-03-01 11:47:01.733000.

Posted 3/1/10 11:46 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

It's all a matter of interpretation I guess.

I guess because I have done a lot of reading on interfaith, I got one perspective, so I was pretty surprised about seeing an orthodox friend with a call to fight assimilation on Purim.

The way I've heard it described is first of all, it's an intermarriage (albeit a really different situation), but also about how one way to promote survival of Jews is to intermarry, which spreads the culture to others who might not have had it before, as in beyond the pre-set demo, and also to promote tolerance.

I'm all for just dressing up and getting wasted.

Love those Jewish holidays!

Posted 3/1/10 12:42 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

Posted by JenniferEver

Can't we all just dress up and get drunk? Chat Icon



Sounds like a good plan to me!

I never really considered Purim to be about assimilartion. I think of it as a celebration of surviving what could've been another Holocaust. I think of Esther as a Jewish Helen of Troy, but with a positive spin: our beautiful girl saved the lives of her people instead of causing a war.

Underlying theme of every major Jewish holiday: They tried to kill us. We won. Let's eat!!

Posted 3/1/10 1:45 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

To me it is about exploiting my cute kid in an overpriced Halloween costume that only got one wearing and me semi-rocking a straw cowboy hat:
External Image

Im kvelling because she did not freak out at the megillah reading with all of the groggers.

BTW, how many of us made groggers as kids with two small paper plates stapled together and dried beans or peas on the inside? I did that in nursery school.

Posted 3/1/10 2:51 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

AWWW, Leslie I have to finally meet Abby soon! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/1/10 10:28 PM
 

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?

It is not a story vindicating interfaith marriage or resisting assimilation. It is a story about Jewish survival in the face of evil.
If you think about it from the perspective of jews living during the inquisition in spain and portugal, it makes a lot of sense that way. They did anything they needed to do to survive as Jews, although many times secretly.

People interpret biblical stories in many different ways, many times to skew things in their favor. Think about all the wars that have been started over biblical interpretation.

If this story of Esther makes people feel that they now have a biblical example of interfaith marriage and it makes them happy, then so be it!

I taught an adult ed program last week about Purim and this is one of the things i discussed:

"This theme of Jewish survival as a tiny minority in the midst of a sea of often-hostile nations is a central element in the story of the Jewish people.
It is our story, an indelible feature of our consciousness as a community and as individuals. Therefore, when the time comes on Purim to read that story, there is no more important duty to fulfill. All of us gather to hear it. The large crowd and the carnival atmosphere of this day are expressions of our joy at the fact of our survival and our belief that the struggle against bigotry and persecution can be won again as it was in ancient times. Purim is most of all a happy story—a story of survival and triumph over evil.

The story of Purim is about hunger for power and about hatred born of the Jews’ refusal to assimilate and their unwillingness to compromise religious principle by bowing before the secular authority. It is an old story. However, it has been repeated many times, making it both an ancient and modern story.
While this is the popular understanding of the meaning of Purim,
the original meaning of the Book of Esther, which became overshadowed by later history, was to tell the story of 2 assimilated Jews who tried to make it as gentiles, but could not.This understanding of the story remains relevant for Jews today. The story further emphasizes the tragic necessity of Jews to defend themselves against those who would kill them."

Message edited 2010-03-02 10:15:29.247000.

Posted 3/2/10 9:51 AM