|
Re: Purim - Is it really about resisting assimilation?
Posted 3/2/2010 9:51:04 AM by evnme It is not a story vindicating interfaith marriage or resisting assimilation. It is a story about Jewish survival in the face of evil. If you think about it from the perspective of jews living during the inquisition in spain and portugal, it makes a lot of sense that way. They did anything they needed to do to survive as Jews, although many times secretly. People interpret biblical stories in many different ways, many times to skew things in their favor. Think about all the wars that have been started over biblical interpretation. If this story of Esther makes people feel that they now have a biblical example of interfaith marriage and it makes them happy, then so be it! I taught an adult ed program last week about Purim and this is one of the things i discussed: "This theme of Jewish survival as a tiny minority in the midst of a sea of often-hostile nations is a central element in the story of the Jewish people. It is our story, an indelible feature of our consciousness as a community and as individuals. Therefore, when the time comes on Purim to read that story, there is no more important duty to fulfill. All of us gather to hear it. The large crowd and the carnival atmosphere of this day are expressions of our joy at the fact of our survival and our belief that the struggle against bigotry and persecution can be won again as it was in ancient times. Purim is most of all a happy story—a story of survival and triumph over evil. The story of Purim is about hunger for power and about hatred born of the Jews’ refusal to assimilate and their unwillingness to compromise religious principle by bowing before the secular authority. It is an old story. However, it has been repeated many times, making it both an ancient and modern story. While this is the popular understanding of the meaning of Purim, the original meaning of the Book of Esther, which became overshadowed by later history, was to tell the story of 2 assimilated Jews who tried to make it as gentiles, but could not.This understanding of the story remains relevant for Jews today. The story further emphasizes the tragic necessity of Jews to defend themselves against those who would kill them." |