proposed changes to 529 savings plan

Posted By Message

2010inHiding
LIF Infant

Member since 6/13

277 total posts

Name:

proposed changes to 529 savings plan

did you guys hear this? thoughts?

As part of the President’s recently released tax plan, a key tax benefit from 529 college savings plans would be eliminated: Families would no longer be able to withdraw savings from these accounts tax-free.

To be sure, earnings would still be allowed to grow tax-deferred, but any withdrawals would be treated as student income—and taxed accordingly. (Withdrawals from existing 529 plans would likely remain tax-free.)

Posted 1/23/15 10:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

What? That's awful!

How the heck are we supposed to save for these kids for college?

Just a question- I put money in there that's already been taxed- does that mean it would be free on withdrawal? I am pretty sure even though I give the accountant the amount yearly that he doesnt deduct it.

Posted 1/23/15 10:27 AM
 

ChilisWife
God Bless America

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
A.K.

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

I think its awful and unfair. It penalizes people who invested already and it will discourage people from opening new 529s.

Posted 1/23/15 10:27 AM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

Do you know when this is supposed to start? I kept putting off my youngests 529 plan, but wonder if I could still hurry up and open it before this goes into affect.

Posted 1/23/15 10:38 AM
 

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

I don't think Congress will approve this plan- it likely won't happen.

Posted 1/23/15 11:01 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

Posted by mommy2B3

Do you know when this is supposed to start? I kept putting off my youngests 529 plan, but wonder if I could still hurry up and open it before this goes into affect.



It's not going to work that way - if it gets passed. They will most likely go by the date you're pulling the funds, not the date you opened the account ........

Right now you can't deduct your contributions. So everything you're putting IN you've already paid taxes on. The beneift is supposed to be the the gains grow tax free, and you are not taxed when you take a disbursement. - So basically, all of your investment gains are tax free.

I don't see how they can pass this, there would be zero benefit to a 529 plan w/o that tax free distribution

Message edited 2015-01-23 11:15:21.327000.

Posted 1/23/15 11:14 AM
 

ppm80
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

336 total posts

Name:

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

This is to help fund the "free" community colleges envisioned by Obama. I am baffled by this plan because 529s are an almost exclusively middle class tool. Lower income people doesn't have the extra cash to tie up in a 529, and the wealthy, to the extent they even need to "save for college," just use much more sophisticated funding vehicles (or just pay in gangster rolls, haha).

There is still a benefit to tax deferral if you think that when you withdraw funds, you will be in a lower tax bracket compared to now, and I believe that financial aid formulas treat money in 529s more favorably than money in other investments. Also, you do get a state tax deduction for contributions to a 529 (up to $5000 in contributions for a single filer, up to $10000 for married filing jointly). But still! How is this not an increase on middle class taxes??

By the way, the way it would work is the earnings from funds already in a 529 would be grandfathered when withdrawn (they wouldn't be taxed), but earnings on money contributed AFTER the new rules are enacted would be taxed.

ETA: Prior to 2001, earnings on 529s were taxed when withdrawn. So Obama's plan is actually just a rollback of a tax incentive. But it still feels like a broken promise and violation of expectations, grandfathering notwithstanding. These community colleges are not "free" since the middle class is paying for them.

Message edited 2015-01-23 11:55:10.043000.

Posted 1/23/15 11:44 AM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by mommy2B3

Do you know when this is supposed to start? I kept putting off my youngests 529 plan, but wonder if I could still hurry up and open it before this goes into affect.



It's not going to work that way - if it gets passed. They will most likely go by the date you're pulling the funds, not the date you opened the account ........

Right now you can't deduct your contributions. So everything you're putting IN you've already paid taxes on. The beneift is supposed to be the the gains grow tax free, and you are not taxed when you take a disbursement. - So basically, all of your investment gains are tax free.

I don't see how they can pass this, there would be zero benefit to a 529 plan w/o that tax free distribution



Ughh, I figured the older plans would be grandfathered in or something. Thanks for explaining it though.

Hopefully it doesn't pass. However I feel like the government is very fiscally irresponsible, so I wouldn't put it past them.

Posted 1/23/15 11:47 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

This is exactly why I was never an advocate for 529plans. In Nj there is no state tax benefit and I always felt the federal government would renege on their promises for this money. I would rather save in my own accounts to use my money as I see fit.

Posted 1/23/15 2:27 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

Seems very unfair. It's likely that many of us will be in higher tax brackets when our kids start school. I know many kids that went to undergrad for free plus living expenses then went straight to grad school because mom never worked, dad has off the books income, etc. the middle class kids had to take loans, work while in school, and start working right after to pay off those Loans.

I just feel as a middle class person, we are being set up to fail. As for free community college, nothing is free. What will happen to the cost of 4 year and grad school if every person is going to CC for "free".

People try to do the right thing by contributing to 529, for what?

I never opened a 529 , just never felt right about it

I know I sound bitter Chat Icon but my parents couldn't even pay for my tuition or books when I was in school since they "made too much money".

Posted 1/23/15 2:55 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

This is outrageous and disgusting.

People worked hard and earmarked that money for their kids' futures on the express promise that it would not be taxed.

No one would do that---would make their own money off limits to themselves in the here & now--unless they were expressly relying on the promise of the savings.

The mammas are gonna hate the democrats if this happens.

Posted 1/23/15 8:14 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

this is one of the dumbest things i've ever heard. so you're taxed 2x on this money then? awesome.

Posted 1/23/15 9:50 PM
 

ppm80
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

336 total posts

Name:

Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan

You're only taxed once on the contributions, since the are not and will not be taxed at withdrawal. Right now the earnings are untaxed. If Obama's plan goes through and the tax incentive is rolled back, then the earnings will be taxed, too, at withdrawal.

Posted 1/23/15 10:22 PM