|
Re: proposed changes to 529 savings plan
Posted 1/23/2015 11:44:35 AM by ppm80 This is to help fund the "free" community colleges envisioned by Obama. I am baffled by this plan because 529s are an almost exclusively middle class tool. Lower income people doesn't have the extra cash to tie up in a 529, and the wealthy, to the extent they even need to "save for college," just use much more sophisticated funding vehicles (or just pay in gangster rolls, haha). There is still a benefit to tax deferral if you think that when you withdraw funds, you will be in a lower tax bracket compared to now, and I believe that financial aid formulas treat money in 529s more favorably than money in other investments. Also, you do get a state tax deduction for contributions to a 529 (up to $5000 in contributions for a single filer, up to $10000 for married filing jointly). But still! How is this not an increase on middle class taxes?? By the way, the way it would work is the earnings from funds already in a 529 would be grandfathered when withdrawn (they wouldn't be taxed), but earnings on money contributed AFTER the new rules are enacted would be taxed. ETA: Prior to 2001, earnings on 529s were taxed when withdrawn. So Obama's plan is actually just a rollback of a tax incentive. But it still feels like a broken promise and violation of expectations, grandfathering notwithstanding. These community colleges are not "free" since the middle class is paying for them. |