Pricing and offer question
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Pricing and offer question If you saw a house that was priced for something39 like 739, 839, 539, etc... would you offer anything under that main number. For instance if the house was 639 would you offer 585 or 599??? Just curious to see what the consensus is..DH and I are having a debate |
|
Posted 5/21/10 5:21 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
| |
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question At 639k my first offer would be 550k. |
Posted 5/21/10 5:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by ave1024 At 639k my first offer would be 550k. Maybe 575k if the comps in the area are all above 600k. If you offer 599k first, then the only way you can negotiate is up. At that price range, I would not offer that close to asking. wow you're good..see I didn't think to go that low and DH is all about starting out really low...I feel like so much lower than the asking is a really low ball offer, he does not...I guess he's right for once
|
|
Posted 5/21/10 5:32 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by pickles16 wow you're good..see I didn't think to go that low and DH is all about starting out really low...I feel like so much lower than the asking is a really low ball offer, he does not...I guess he's right for once It really depends on the comps in the area. There is no way to know unless you look at how other houses in the area sold for. I mean if every single house in the area sold for over 600k, then it's unlikely they would even entertain a 550k offer. But when I put in an offer of 550k, I am also coming in with 20% down, no sale contingency or house to worry about selling, and I can show plenty of other assets besides the 20%. So it's a more sure-fire deal. There may be higher offers, from buyers that can only put 5-10% down too. In the lower market, for houses priced at 400k you probably have to come closer to asking since there is more competition. My first house was in the 400 area and the last group of houses I was looking at were in the 600 range. I don't think there is as much competition in the 600k market so you can come in lower with your asking price. |
Posted 5/21/10 5:37 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question Oh one other thing... it also depends on how long the house has been on the market. |
Posted 5/21/10 5:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by ave1024 Oh one other thing... it also depends on how long the house has been on the market. With a new listing I think the first 3-4 weeks, you won't see ANY sellers coming that low. If there was a 650k house that came on the market and I didn't want to pay more than 575k, I would probably WAIT a few weeks before I even went and saw it. I would figure the sellers would never take an offer that low initially. So i'd like to wait it out. If someone got to it before me, they probably paid way more than I would have.[/QUOTE/] ITA wit all ur points in this post and before...We are ideal buyers..we do not have any contingencies,we're putting more than 20% down and are ready to go and very flexible with close time, as we own a home now that we do not need to sell in order to buy so we can close whenever the seller wants..it is a new listing, and are very familiar with the comps in the area...the area has actually been very slow and prices just keep dropping and things are on the market for at least a few months before they go, and the comps are in our favor...the house JUST came on, so we would wait, but don't want to get screwed in the end...so we want to time it correctly.... Message edited 2010-05-21 17:44:19.080000. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 5:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question ITA with everything ave1024 said.. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 6:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question It def depends on how much the comps are going for in the area. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 6:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question There is no set answer to this, it totally depends on the house. We saw a house that we LOVED within 1 week of being on the market. It was listed at a fair price of $569 and someone got the house for $569 all cash. We were willing to pay asking as well but only 50% down. I was wishing the other offer would fall through because we were "next" in line, but unfortunately they closed last week. So you never know! |
|
Posted 5/21/10 6:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by julz33 There is no set answer to this, it totally depends on the house. We saw a house that we LOVED within 1 week of being on the market. It was listed at a fair price of $569 and someone got the house for $569 all cash. We were willing to pay asking as well but only 50% down. I was wishing the other offer would fall through because we were "next" in line, but unfortunately they closed last week. So you never know! I def get that...we offered on a house we knew was priced right very close to the asking and were beat out by a cash offer, also within one week of it being on the market..this house is not well priced..we've been following pricing very closely so we know when it's a good deal or not KWIM |
|
Posted 5/21/10 7:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question We are paying $14K under asking, but the house was priced right. Our original offer was $30k under asking, and we are essentially meeting in the middle. The sale of my place, well- -that's another story. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 8:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Our house was listed at 545K which was a VERY fair price when I look back at the other stuff we saw in the same price range, and further east. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 8:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by ave1024 If you offer 599k first, then the only way you can negotiate is up. At that price range, I would not offer that close to asking. But what if it's a hot or high demand area? Can you really say generally speaking that you would not offer that? |
|
Posted 5/21/10 11:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by pickles16 Posted by ave1024 At 639k my first offer would be 550k. Maybe 575k if the comps in the area are all above 600k. If you offer 599k first, then the only way you can negotiate is up. At that price range, I would not offer that close to asking. wow you're good..see I didn't think to go that low and DH is all about starting out really low...I feel like so much lower than the asking is a really low ball offer, he does not...I guess he's right for once I agree with you. I would not want my offer flat out looked over b/c someone else bid higher. |
|
Posted 5/21/10 11:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by ave1024 Oh one other thing... it also depends on how long the house has been on the market. With a new listing I think the first 3-4 weeks, you won't see ANY sellers coming that low. If there was a 650k house that came on the market and I didn't want to pay more than 575k, I would probably WAIT a few weeks before I even went and saw it. I would figure the sellers would never take an offer that low initially. So i'd like to wait it out. If someone got to it before me, they probably paid way more than I would have. Good points...so what if you did want to bid when it first came on? |
|
Posted 5/21/10 11:32 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by Goobster Good points...so what if you did want to bid when it first came on? I would bid carefully and make sure I was aware of ALL the comps in the area, as well as how long they sat on the market. A good buyer's agent comes in very handy here. Every situation is different. Of course if you absolutely LOVE the house, you could bid more I suppose. House buying is not always about getting the best "deal". You also need to live in it (and enjoy it) for the forseeable future. |
Posted 5/22/10 12:17 AM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question Also keep one thing in mind. If you have been looking at houses in the same neighborhood for a while (i'd say at least three months)... you probably already know where the good deals are with the new listings. |
Posted 5/22/10 12:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by ave1024 Also keep one thing in mind. If you have been looking at houses in the same neighborhood for a while (i'd say at least three months)... you probably already know where the good deals are with the new listings. ![]() We've been loooooking for a while...we def know a good deal when we see one, that's why we struck on that one house that we got out bid by a cash offer for it..we KNOW this house is not a good deal where it's priced..the houses seem to sit for a while in this area and slowly drop before any activity...it's a lot of older ppl moving out to florida/downsizing etc..and younger couples/families moving in...so these ppl arent in a rush to sell so they can wait, but they rarely win in the end, bc they end up lowering the prices significantly...I just happen to really like this house and don't want to be the first "low" bid but also want to get the house..it's only been on the market for a week..so don't want to upset them and give them a realistic yet low bid... |
|
Posted 5/22/10 8:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by pickles16 Posted by ave1024 Also keep one thing in mind. If you have been looking at houses in the same neighborhood for a while (i'd say at least three months)... you probably already know where the good deals are with the new listings. ![]() We've been loooooking for a while...we def know a good deal when we see one, that's why we struck on that one house that we got out bid by a cash offer for it..we KNOW this house is not a good deal where it's priced..the houses seem to sit for a while in this area and slowly drop before any activity...it's a lot of older ppl moving out to florida/downsizing etc..and younger couples/families moving in...so these ppl arent in a rush to sell so they can wait, but they rarely win in the end, bc they end up lowering the prices significantly...I just happen to really like this house and don't want to be the first "low" bid but also want to get the house..it's only been on the market for a week..so don't want to upset them and give them a realistic yet low bid... Are you not working with a realtor? I would have them talk to the listing agent to get a feel for the seller's state of mind. We saw a house that was totally overpriced, but when our realtor inquired and told them that-- which we felt was the case-- their realtor agreed and had already had a meeting set up with the seller to discuss actually selling. Sometimes yuo need to do a little fact finding with the situation before you can put your offer in-- because based on a list price that's not right-- you have no clue where to come in. |
|
Posted 5/22/10 8:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by randella Posted by pickles16 Posted by ave1024 Also keep one thing in mind. If you have been looking at houses in the same neighborhood for a while (i'd say at least three months)... you probably already know where the good deals are with the new listings. ![]() We've been loooooking for a while...we def know a good deal when we see one, that's why we struck on that one house that we got out bid by a cash offer for it..we KNOW this house is not a good deal where it's priced..the houses seem to sit for a while in this area and slowly drop before any activity...it's a lot of older ppl moving out to florida/downsizing etc..and younger couples/families moving in...so these ppl arent in a rush to sell so they can wait, but they rarely win in the end, bc they end up lowering the prices significantly...I just happen to really like this house and don't want to be the first "low" bid but also want to get the house..it's only been on the market for a week..so don't want to upset them and give them a realistic yet low bid... Are you not working with a realtor? I would have them talk to the listing agent to get a feel for the seller's state of mind. We saw a house that was totally overpriced, but when our realtor inquired and told them that-- which we felt was the case-- their realtor agreed and had already had a meeting set up with the seller to discuss actually selling. Sometimes yuo need to do a little fact finding with the situation before you can put your offer in-- because based on a list price that's not right-- you have no clue where to come in. We are. The sellers realtor isn't familiar with the area.. No clue why they hired her, I think they're friends, but her area of expertise is NOT this town..so when our realtor tried to talk to her about numbers, her stock answer was it just came on the market I don't know where they're going to want to end up...which is total BS in my opinion...she's been annoying to even set up a showing with bc she's off doing her regular area and seems like she's fitting in showings... Believe me, we're huuuge researchers and DH is beyond calculated he'll never put an offer in without fact checking and researching at least 50 times...he's a bit overly anal
|
|
Posted 5/22/10 8:43 AM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Pricing and offer question Posted by pickles16 We are. The sellers realtor isn't familiar with the area.. No clue why they hired her, I think they're friends, but her area of expertise is NOT this town..so when our realtor tried to talk to her about numbers, her stock answer was it just came on the market I don't know where they're going to want to end up...which is total BS in my opinion...she's been annoying to even set up a showing with bc she's off doing her regular area and seems like she's fitting in showings... Believe me, we're huuuge researchers and DH is beyond calculated he'll never put an offer in without fact checking and researching at least 50 times...he's a bit overly anal It really doesn't matter if the seller's realtor is not familiar with the area. You want to make sure your buyers agent is. If they don't want to budge on price, wait it out. |
Posted 5/22/10 3:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pricing and offer question we found when we bid too low we lost out on houses we really liked... so to be competitive we started out about 20k below asking. we ended up paying 5k below asking (what they countered everyone's offers with) because we really liked the house and did not want to see it go... and it was also priced right for the market & area |
|
Posted 5/22/10 4:42 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ebay question: Buy it now or best offer? | Katie111806 | 11/29/07 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question about Sales agreement (offer) | tann22 | 2/27/07 | 3 | Home |
| Offer question on price | dbleplay17 | 2/24/07 | 6 | Home |
| Offer Question | dbleplay17 | 2/24/07 | 2 | Home |
| Question about when an offer is accepted | babydreams | 5/30/06 | 4 | Home |
| I got my first offer on my co-op - home equity question | DjPiLL | 9/14/05 | 19 | Home |










No clue why they hired her, I think they're friends, but her area of expertise is NOT this town..so when our realtor tried to talk to her about numbers, her stock answer was it just came on the market I don't know where they're going to want to end up...which is total BS in my opinion...she's been annoying to even set up a showing with bc she's off doing her regular area and seems like she's fitting in showings...
Believe me, we're huuuge researchers and DH is beyond calculated he'll never put an offer in without fact checking and researching at least 50 times...he's a bit overly anal