Poverty Levels - what do YOU think?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? What do you think the poverty level should be for: |
|
Posted 12/29/12 3:36 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? What are the federal poverty levels set at now? I know that when I was just out of college making 30k without OT in 1999 and I was barely making ends meet. My apartment cost 725. ETA: This was in Washington DC. I lived in Georgetown and then in Friendship Heights. I remember it was really hard, and I did not have CC debt. I was very frugal. I had a hand me down car, and no computer at home. Message edited 2012-12-29 17:05:18.180000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 3:48 PM
|
|
|
DumpsterBaby
Member since 5/11 2210 total posts Name: |
Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? DH and I make over $100k combined and it's tough. The LI cost of living is over the top, which hurts young couples like myself. We don't fall into a lot of the pitfalls that our friends do, like fancy cars and expensive homes, but I can't imagine surviving on any less than we currently make. |
Posted 12/29/12 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Poverty Level $$ |
|
Posted 12/29/12 4:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? That is absolutely ludicrous. According to this chart, I should be able to provide for a family of well over 10 people by myself.....absolutely not possible. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by EatingMyVeggies What do you think the poverty level should be for: - a single person - a family of 4 Try to go by your own life experiences of what things cost, not what the gov't deems to be poverty level...and let's assume it would be for NY. If you are a LIFer from another state, join in but maybe specify that you live outside of NY. thought this might be interesting..I looked them up this afternoon and was surprised. Do you agree or disagree with the current poverty levels? The income for a family of 4 to be considered under the poverty line is is just over 23,000 and a single person just over 11,000. By agree or disagree do you mean, do we think that the income cutoffs are appropriate? I would have no way of knowing. As a single person on my own providing for myself, I made 25,000 base at the age of 20 and around 40 by 25 while I was still in college part-time. I paid 600 a month rent, 242 a month towards a car lease, and tuition and just made it. I couldn't imagine trying to support a family on that. Especially in NY. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? I'm not sure that poverty means having your own apartment. I would define it as dire straits. Multiple people in an apartment and probably public housing. I think using numbers like that can get you by on under $20K Message edited 2012-12-30 16:25:00.480000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? A family of four making $24,000 a year is ABOVE the poverty line? Wow. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 5:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Message edited 2013-09-01 09:09:48.500000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 5:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? In NY, probably under 40K. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 9:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Since my husband had to retire, we bring in less the 50 grand a year... It is HARD. We had to have my Mom and brother move in with us so we could split the rent and utilities. DS is 3. No preschool. No daycare. Between rent, utilities, car payment, dr appointments (up to 15-20 a month for the 3 of us), and medications, we barely scrape by at the end of the month. Even when hubby and I were both working and we were bringing in $100K (before taxes) a year, it was hard sometimes.. It should be higher here. My friend is a single mom with 2 kids and can't get ANY state/county help because she makes about $10 more over the level they consider needs help! She lives in a one bedroom apt with her mother and 6 birds!!! Message edited 2012-12-29 22:46:08.167000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 9:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Message edited 2013-09-01 09:35:40.200000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 10:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by olive98 Posted by NewLeaf2012 My friend is a single mom with 2 kids and can't get ANY state/county help because she make about $10 more over the level they consider needs help! She lives in a one bedroom apt with her mother and 6 birds!!! I dont think the government should help anyone who chooses to have 6 pets. Thats my opinion. True poverty is not being able to feed your kids The issue with that angle - what if she had the 6 pets before she lost a high-paying job or something? |
|
Posted 12/29/12 10:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by olive98 Posted by NewLeaf2012 My friend is a single mom with 2 kids and can't get ANY state/county help because she make about $10 more over the level they consider needs help! She lives in a one bedroom apt with her mother and 6 birds!!! I dont think the government should help anyone who chooses to have 6 pets. Thats my opinion. True poverty is not being able to feed your kids The issue with that angle - what if she had the 6 pets before she lost a high-paying job or something? I agree. ALso, should you have to eat the 6 birds before the gov't kicks in? IN all seriousness, I hate to see people with 12 dogs claiming welfare as it seems they would have more money if they stopped takng in dogs. But I don't think the application let's you claim dogs so it probably doesn't matter much. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by CrankyPants Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by olive98 Posted by NewLeaf2012 My friend is a single mom with 2 kids and can't get ANY state/county help because she make about $10 more over the level they consider needs help! She lives in a one bedroom apt with her mother and 6 birds!!! I dont think the government should help anyone who chooses to have 6 pets. Thats my opinion. True poverty is not being able to feed your kids The issue with that angle - what if she had the 6 pets before she lost a high-paying job or something? I agree. ALso, should you have to eat the 6 birds before the gov't kicks in? IN all seriousness, I hate to see people with 12 dogs claiming welfare as it seems they would have more money if they stopped takng in dogs. But I don't think the application let's you claim dogs so it probably doesn't matter much. She is living with her mom who has 6 birds...THEY AREN'T her birds!!! She works her a$$ off and can barely give her kids a glass of milk some days..she had to move in with her mom and her birds 5 years ago and hasn't been able to get out. I HATE seeing people on welfare who are dressed better then most working class people and have a mouth full of GOLD teeth!!! She doesn't get anything! Message edited 2012-12-29 22:47:54.720000. |
|
Posted 12/29/12 10:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by DumpsterBaby DH and I make over $100k combined and it's tough. The LI cost of living is over the top, which hurts young couples like myself. We don't fall into a lot of the pitfalls that our friends do, like fancy cars and expensive homes, but I can't imagine surviving on any less than we currently make. I think the federal poverty levels are a joke, and when you factor in minimum wage, there's just no way ANYONE can survive on that no matter where they live. It's awful that for some people it pays to be unemployed! this exactly. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 12:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? poverty levels are a joke and just show that the government is so out of touch with average costs of living per area. The cost of living in NY is ridiculous...but we all stay bc this is where we have our family. Message edited 2012-12-30 01:02:45.200000. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 12:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by DumpsterBaby DH and I make over $100k combined and it's tough. The LI cost of living is over the top, which hurts young couples like myself. We don't fall into a lot of the pitfalls that our friends do, like fancy cars and expensive homes, but I can't imagine surviving on any less than we currently make. I think the federal poverty levels are a joke, and when you factor in minimum wage, there's just no way ANYONE can survive on that no matter where they live. It's awful that for some people it pays to be unemployed! DH and I make a decent amount UNDER 100k and I would describe it as rough as well, but we certainly aren't starving. We have a nice apartment, two average cars and aren't living paycheck to paycheck. Honestly I think you make do with what you have. Someone making 250k a year might also say its rough. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 10:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by MrsMeloyellow poverty levels are a joke and just show that the government is so out of touch with average costs of living per area. The cost of living in NY is ridiculous...but we all stay bc this is where we have our family. DH makes 63k take home pay (actually more like 75-80kk take home when you factor in vacation checks). Sounds like a decent take home salary...but when you deduct mortgage / home insurance / taxes...whats left is not enough to cover what i consider basics. We have a car payment (used 2005 vehicle, so nothing over the top or extravagant), car insurance, oil bill (thats the killer!) electric (another killer), food shopping, diapers & wipes, one credit card bill (less than 2k cc debt), cell phones, cable etc. Now...I could easily get a job and help out....BUT...I was making 600 a week before I became a SAHM...how much of that pay would be eaten up by day care? is it worth it for me to send my child to be raised by a stranger to come home with $60-100 in my pocket a week or maybe not even that? If we got rid of the car, ate peanut butter and jelly, got rid of cell phones and cable...then sure...we could afford to stay in our home...but I have a son who needs real food. We live on LI...so we kind of do need a car. If we didn't have a car the cost of LIRR + public trans. would kill us anyway so either way we'd end up paying. DH makes too much to qualify for any assistance, be it home energy assistance or other. So, the only option is to move out and go back to apartment life or find a cheaper home. But, finding a cheaper home on LI isn't easy...especially when you start considering school districts and crime rates because you have a child. I'm sure we COULD find cheaper...but it would probably be a dilapidated home that we can't afford to fix. 63k a year elsewhere would be more than enough to get by...but here on LI we pay top dollar for EVERYTHING...energy, taxes, gasoline, LIRR, home cost, insurance. So many people are getting priced out of NY and it only continues to get worse. I don't think it is the governments responsibility to assist me in obtaining the lifestyle *I* think is acceptable...but I do think for the sake of the country they really need to address some issues. Like child care costs. We need to come up with a plan to make child care more affordable or have programs available to people who "can't afford to work"...It has become a sad reality that there are many people who have found they "can't afford to work" due to child care costs. I'm certain more people would join the work force & contribute to the economy if their jobs were still financially worthwhile after factoring in child care I feel similarly. I made over $60K this year with bonuses, however, what needs to also be factored in is I pay for all of our family health insurance since my employer does not cover that. So basically, 1/2 my paycheck weekly goes to that, which leaves $$$ for the basics only. We have no choice though because DH is self-employed so we need health insurance. Jobs that pay my base salary that also cover health insurance for family are very hard to come by, if you even get a response back. Fortunately, family watch DS otherwise we would not be able to afford daycare. We bought a small starter house at the height of the market, which is also close to the water so we are not in great shape in that department, either. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 10:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by BunnyWife Poverty Level $$ So basically NYC and a small town in Alabama are considered the same? Thats nuts! What a JOKE! (not you the stats) I was making $14k a year in San Antonio back in 1997. So thats without tax and without inflation. I had my own apt, my own car payment and my own life. I paid $550 for rent $330 for the car and all of life's little extras, light, phone, tv, insurance, medicines etc. I wasn't barely scrapping by I was barely eating. I lived off rice, bread, corn and koolaid. I lived without a pan for 2yrs because I had nothing to cook in it. Guess what? I didn't qualify for food stamps. I ran out of gas twice or more a month but I made it. If poverty level for a single person is at 11k, that's insane! They didnt consider ME at poverty level back then. its WHAT you do with the money (in my opinion) My problems were: I had internet I had a cat I had health issues I had a car on an upside loan My four C's in life at that time were Car, Cat, Computer, Career. Not in that order. I lived alone since I was 18. In 1995 my SS salary reported was $10k and I still couldn't get food stamps. Back then i owned a POS car and my rent was around $400 a month, no computer, no cat. I was living in a rough neighborhood and pretty scared a lot of the time. I guess what I'm saying is yes.. those numbers ARE poverty level FOR sure! But what goes into making the number, I dont know. Do I think one value means more or less in another state, yes of course. But I'll go further, it also depends WHAT you are spending on. Do we really need a TV in every room or a huge house? I learned very quickly and the hard way, the more money you have, the easier it is to spend. Our parents lived with less and saved more. This is why I love my hubby. He and I come from similar struggles. So when we decide Oh we WANT that but.. meh, its not life changing, we dont regret it or let it bother us. We dont NEED very much and are very willing to give up any fluff if needed. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? When I was younger, on my own, I made about 10k a year and rented one bedroom in an apt. and didn't have a car and was barely eating. I was so, so broke. And that was in Chicago, where my rent was $400 a month for a nice apartment. On LI, I would have been homeless, seriously. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by MrsMeloyellow Now...I could easily get a job and help out....BUT...I was making 600 a week before I became a SAHM...how much of that pay would be eaten up by day care? is it worth it for me to send my child to be raised by a stranger to come home with $60-100 in my pocket a week or maybe not even that? Were you taking home $600/week? Honestly you could 100% find a good daycare for less than $300 a week. Bringing home an extra $1200+ a month is a big deal if you are struggling so much Message edited 2012-12-30 12:35:40.317000. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 12:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by jgl Posted by MrsMeloyellow Now...I could easily get a job and help out....BUT...I was making 600 a week before I became a SAHM...how much of that pay would be eaten up by day care? is it worth it for me to send my child to be raised by a stranger to come home with $60-100 in my pocket a week or maybe not even that? Were you taking home $600/week? Honestly you could 100% find a good daycare for less than $300 a week. Bringing home an extra $1200+ a month is a big deal if you are struggling so much really? I have not found those prices at all. I guess I'm not looking into the right places. Although, DH doesn't even WANT me going back to work...thats a separate issue...I've mentioned it several times...but maybe if i find better prices he will change his mind. Wish I didn't have to...it'll kill me to be away from my son...but at least I got to spend this much time with him. ETA: I should mention, I do things to make extra money...it's just not consistent. I host parties on weekends for BIL but some weekends there are no parties and others I can make $100-150 a weekend by hosting 2-3 parties. I also am a unit leader with avon so i do have a check coming in from that every 2 weeks + commission...but again...the amount is not always consistent. it's not the same as coming home with an extra $1200 a month...but I am working on it. We also weren't supposed to be carrying the cost of this home on our own...we had a partner that was supposed to partner with us to flip the house...but he bailed and here we are. We are taking steps to get out of this situation but bc of the current housing market...it's not so simple to just up and leave the house and move on to something we can better afford. It's not like we bought this house we knew we couldn't afford, had a baby and decided i'd quit my job. It's a long, complicated story and road to how we got here...our partner put a tenant in his place who didn't pay bills...alot of drama occured, she threatened to burn down the house while i was pregnant...so she was asked to leave. Partner has not paid his share since. then my sister who was living with me and contributing also moved out. It's just an unfortunate situation, and while yes...I could be working and am not. I do try to bring in income other ways. it's just not enough to cover the 1/2 of the mortgage and utitlities that were expected to be paid by the partner when we agreed to buy this home. Message edited 2012-12-30 13:40:03.793000. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 1:12 PM
|
|
|
DumpsterBaby
Member since 5/11 2210 total posts Name: |
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by Jbon630 Posted by DumpsterBaby DH and I make over $100k combined and it's tough. The LI cost of living is over the top, which hurts young couples like myself. We don't fall into a lot of the pitfalls that our friends do, like fancy cars and expensive homes, but I can't imagine surviving on any less than we currently make. I think the federal poverty levels are a joke, and when you factor in minimum wage, there's just no way ANYONE can survive on that no matter where they live. It's awful that for some people it pays to be unemployed! DH and I make a decent amount UNDER 100k and I would describe it as rough as well, but we certainly aren't starving. We have a nice apartment, two average cars and aren't living paycheck to paycheck. Honestly I think you make do with what you have. Someone making 250k a year might also say its rough. Of course it is all relative. We don't have much CC debt, but I have student loans. By no means are we starving, and I never implied that, but still sometimes there's lean weeks and there's hearty weeks. It definitely matters what people make of it, but still in my opinion, LI is tough and I personally wouldn't want to make due on less than what we currently make. |
Posted 12/30/12 1:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Poverty Levels - what do YOU think? Posted by MrsMeloyellow Posted by jgl Posted by MrsMeloyellow Now...I could easily get a job and help out....BUT...I was making 600 a week before I became a SAHM...how much of that pay would be eaten up by day care? is it worth it for me to send my child to be raised by a stranger to come home with $60-100 in my pocket a week or maybe not even that? Were you taking home $600/week? Honestly you could 100% find a good daycare for less than $300 a week. Bringing home an extra $1200+ a month is a big deal if you are struggling so much really? I have not found those prices at all. I guess I'm not looking into the right places. Although, DH doesn't even WANT me going back to work...thats a separate issue...I've mentioned it several times...but maybe if i find better prices he will change his mind. Wish I didn't have to...it'll kill me to be away from my son...but at least I got to spend this much time with him. ETA: I should mention, I do things to make extra money...it's just not consistent. I host parties on weekends for BIL but some weekends there are no parties and others I can make $100-150 a weekend by hosting 2-3 parties. I also am a unit leader with avon so i do have a check coming in from that every 2 weeks + commission...but again...the amount is not always consistent. it's not the same as coming home with an extra $1200 a month...but I am working on it. We also weren't supposed to be carrying the cost of this home on our own...we had a partner that was supposed to partner with us to flip the house...but he bailed and here we are. We are taking steps to get out of this situation but bc of the current housing market...it's not so simple to just up and leave the house and move on to something we can better afford. It's not like we bought this house we knew we couldn't afford, had a baby and decided i'd quit my job. It's a long, complicated story and road to how we got here...our partner put a tenant in his place who didn't pay bills...alot of drama occured, she threatened to burn down the house while i was pregnant...so she was asked to leave. Partner has not paid his share since. then my sister who was living with me and contributing also moved out. It's just an unfortunate situation, and while yes...I could be working and am not. I do try to bring in income other ways. it's just not enough to cover the 1/2 of the mortgage and utitlities that were expected to be paid by the partner when we agreed to buy this home. Depending on the age of your child the pp is correct. It might very well be under $300 a week. I was home with my son until he was about 20 months so I know it's hard but if you are really struggling that much, it might be worth looking into. I have a very good day care that DS goes to part time and I'm pretty sure it's under that for full time. Let me know if you want the info. They are a chain so there might be one near you. You also have to factor in that it's tax deductible so it costs less than it sounds like it does. On the other side, you have to factor in the costs of working but for me personally that doesn't amount to much. Other than a few pairs of dress pants that I would own anyway, I don't dress that differently at work than I did at home. It's the same sweaters and such. Plus, I still ate when I was home with him - if anything I spent more money because I was always looking to get out of the house so I'd grab a latte or a snack on the go. |
|
Posted 12/30/12 4:23 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Family of 4 needs combined income of $68K to avoid poverty... | EclecticEsq10810 | 4/9/11 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Does anyone have a friend or friends who are always crying poverty... | beautyq115 | 12/22/06 | 19 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| HCG Levels.. has this happened to you? | sweetbabydreams | 1/11/08 | 2 | Pregnancy |
| Question about beta levels.. please help. | reggie | 10/12/07 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| update on results: GD Test, iron levels, blood pressure AND a FOOD QUESTION!!!! | Kerie-is-so-very | 8/10/07 | 11 | Pregnancy |
| Can you guys help me make sense of my levels and chart? | GabsMom | 7/5/07 | 5 | Infertility |















