Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Posted By Message

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Potty seat vs. standalone potty

I can't believe I'm writing this already. Kieran is only 17 months and we had no intention of starting potty training this early. But for the past few months, every once in a while, I would sit him on the toilet if I had a sense that maybe he might pee soon (before bathtime, if I went to change him after a few hours and he had a dry diaper, etc.), for maybe 30 seconds or so, until he told me he was all done. I've done this maybe a totaly of 8-10 times in his life. Well the other night, he peed as soon as I sat him down. He looked down and watched it happening and started laughing and got so excited! Ever since then, he's asked to sit on the toilet a few times when I am changing him, although he hasn't peed again since. Also, for the past few weeks, he's been telling us when he poops. As soon as he poops (or farts- sometimes he gets confused lol), he touches his diaper and says "poop" (more like "puh" actually). Soo... I'm thinking maybe we'll slowly start to introduce him to the idea of pottying. No rush, no pressure, just an introduction, at his own pace. So I want to buy a potty, but don't know which is better- a potty seat to go on the toilet or a standalone potty? I feel like maybe the potty seat, since he is already used to sitting on the actual toilet and seems to like it. I don't know that he would understand what a regular potty is for. But maybe I'm overthinking this?? Are there pros/cons to each in your opinion? Thanks for any and all advice- I'm clueless about this!!

Posted 7/9/11 3:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LJSMommy
Love him!

Member since 10/07

3189 total posts

Name:

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Potty seats are WAY easier!! Nothing to clean up!!

A step stool & a potty seat is it!!

Posted 7/9/11 3:40 PM
 

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

I skipped the potty chairs because they are grossChat Icon I also thought once they learn on that then you have to re-train them on the big potty. With my oldest DD I use the seat on top of the toilet and she only needed it for a few months. She trained at 27 months. My youngest DD trained at 24 months and she never needed the seat. She used the regular potty with no troubles.

Posted 7/9/11 3:46 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Posted by ABCiverson

I skipped the potty chairs because they are grossChat Icon



This is how I feel about them too! But I didn't know if I was being unreasonable and maybe this was one of those gross parts of parenting that I was just gonna have to get over! Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/11 3:50 PM
 

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by ABCiverson

I skipped the potty chairs because they are grossChat Icon



This is how I feel about them too! But I didn't know if I was being unreasonable and maybe this was one of those gross parts of parenting that I was just gonna have to get over! Chat Icon



If your DC isn't afraid of the regular potty then that's what i'd use. Also its got to be a pain to get them to pee in public when there is no toilet chair to use.

Posted 7/9/11 3:56 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Potty seats gross me out too personally. So we used the toilet seat. Though my DD refused to train until she turned 3.5 years, so I'm no expert Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/11 4:01 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

I just bought DD a porrty seat (although they gross me out) I thought it would be easier to introduce her on there first. The one I got is pretty cool - its 3in1 so its a potty and then the seat comes off and you can put it on the toilet and use the base as a step stool.

I picked that one bc DD is 18 months and she will look at the toilet and say peepee - sometimes she even pulls her diaper off but I tried to sit on the big potty and she got scared so I thought this would make for a good transition

Posted 7/9/11 5:50 PM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

we have this thing and it is AWESOME... it has an adult-sized hiney hole and a toddler-sized hiney hole.

I wanted DS to get used to using a real "big person" toilet, not a baby one. It's lightweight plastic and has a gentle close, so he can never hurt his hands. and he loves using the big person toilet bc it flushes and he waves bye bye to his pee/poo. LOL

toilet seat

External Image

I bought it in Walmart, it was $25.

Posted 7/9/11 7:42 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

Posted by Shorty

we have this thing and it is AWESOME... it has an adult-sized hiney hole and a toddler-sized hiney hole.

I wanted DS to get used to using a real "big person" toilet, not a baby one. It's lightweight plastic and has a gentle close, so he can never hurt his hands. and he loves using the big person toilet bc it flushes and he waves bye bye to his pee/poo. LOL

toilet seat

External Image

I bought it in Walmart, it was $25.



what a great find! Thanks!

Posted 7/9/11 8:17 PM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: Potty seat vs. standalone potty

We are starting with a little potty. He uses it for #2, #1 he just does in our potty. My DS is kinda tiny and he needs to be able to place his feet on the ground for "pushing". If he used a potty seat, his feet wouldn't even touch the step stool. We have a travel one, but he doesn't seem comfortable using it. I'm not worried about the transition because he understands the idea of what "going on the potty" is, now he just needs to be big enough to do it on the big potty. If your DS is little, I would think about the height factor. Hope that helps! Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-07-09 21:35:56.013000.

Posted 7/9/11 9:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Which potty training seat do you have? Can you recommend one? Bridex100 5/25/10 0 Parenting
Please recc your potty seat you put on top of the toilet. itsbabytime 3/29/10 13 Parenting
What do you think of this fold up travel potty seat? waterspout4 9/9/09 7 Parenting
Spinoff: What potty seat has the best boy 'splash' guard? waterspout4 4/8/09 4 Parenting
Is it really hard to transition from the potty seat to the toilet? PrincessP 12/22/08 11 Parenting
potty seat MyChip-n-Dales 11/17/08 9 Parenting