Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted By Message

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Poor Grammar in songs...

Does it ever bother you? I ask this because I was listening to my radio at work and an old song came on and I was listening to it and there is a line that uses poor grammar and for some reason it bothers me...

The line is from I'll be there by the Jackson 5

"And if you ever find someone new...I hope he better be good to you...cause if he doesn't I'll be there"

For some reason the use of the word doesn't in this sentence doesn't sit right with me...as if it's in the wrong tense... of course I am not always grammatically correct anyway, so not sure why it bothers me...It is to say that on the flip side the line is "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there", which I know is wrong.

Just wondering if I am the only one.

I think I just have to much time on my hands to think about things like this...and I actually have a full time job Chat Icon

Posted 7/8/10 3:53 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

always. poor grammar and bad rhyming will cause me to not listen to a song ever again.

Posted 7/8/10 4:03 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Not really, I chalk it up to artistic license.

Although, if people start using said "bad grammar" in normal life because they heard it in the song, that annoys me.

Posted 7/8/10 4:05 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

YES!!!

The Timberland song 'The Way I Are' really bothers me... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/8/10 4:15 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

I am easily irritated by poor grammar (although I can't spell so I should be understanding!).

The example you gave is grammatically correct. "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there" is the correct form. You may drop the "be good to you" and it will be understood and still correct. The verb "to do" requires an action, which in this case is to "be good".

I think what you are thinking is to replace it with "isn't". "If he isn't good to you, I'll be there" would be a more common way to say it in conversation. In this case the verb relates to the subject "he" and if he is "good".

Posted 7/8/10 4:31 PM
 

julesrbf
Baby Girl

Member since 6/09

3882 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

"T to the A to the S T E Y girl you tasty."

The MOST annoying and egregious lyric to any song if you ask me, but there are scores more.

Message edited 2010-07-08 16:34:15.970000.

Posted 7/8/10 4:33 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by NinaLemon

I am easily irritated by poor grammar (although I can't spell so I should be understanding!).

The example you gave is grammatically correct. "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there" is the correct form. You may drop the "be good to you" and it will be understood and still correct. The verb "to do" requires an action, which in this case is to "be good".

I think what you are thinking is to replace it with "isn't". "If he isn't good to you, I'll be there" would be a more common way to say it in conversation. In this case the verb relates to the subject "he" and if he is "good".



See what do I know! I would have used isn't... I guess if I broke it out it would be "if he does not be good to you"...which to me sounds wrong.

Edited: to get rid of redundancy

Message edited 2010-07-08 16:36:07.803000.

Posted 7/8/10 4:35 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by NinaLemon

I am easily irritated by poor grammar (although I can't spell so I should be understanding!).

The example you gave is grammatically correct. "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there" is the correct form. You may drop the "be good to you" and it will be understood and still correct. The verb "to do" requires an action, which in this case is to "be good".

I think what you are thinking is to replace it with "isn't". "If he isn't good to you, I'll be there" would be a more common way to say it in conversation. In this case the verb relates to the subject "he" and if he is "good".



I have to agree.

A more common example -- "If John doesn't be careful with the knife, he will cut himself." OR dropping the "be careful" -- "John better be careful. If he doesn't, he will cut himself."

Posted 7/8/10 4:38 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by Kara

Posted by NinaLemon

I am easily irritated by poor grammar (although I can't spell so I should be understanding!).

The example you gave is grammatically correct. "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there" is the correct form. You may drop the "be good to you" and it will be understood and still correct. The verb "to do" requires an action, which in this case is to "be good".

I think what you are thinking is to replace it with "isn't". "If he isn't good to you, I'll be there" would be a more common way to say it in conversation. In this case the verb relates to the subject "he" and if he is "good".



I have to agree.

A more common example -- "If John doesn't be careful with the knife, he will cut himself." OR dropping the "be careful" -- "John better be careful. If he doesn't, he will cut himself."



This is good to know - i don't know that I would ever say it that way, but good to know if I heard someone else do it, they wouldn't be wrong.

Posted 7/8/10 4:44 PM
 

Danyell48
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/09

391 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by Maria31

YES!!!

The Timberland song 'The Way I Are' really bothers me... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon




That one kills me!! I can't stand it.

Posted 7/8/10 9:30 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Poor grammar in songs is usually a result off trying to fit something in time or a rhyme. It still drives me nuts.

Posted 7/8/10 10:00 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by debsabourin13

Posted by Kara

Posted by NinaLemon

I am easily irritated by poor grammar (although I can't spell so I should be understanding!).

The example you gave is grammatically correct. "If he doesn't be good to you I'll be there" is the correct form. You may drop the "be good to you" and it will be understood and still correct. The verb "to do" requires an action, which in this case is to "be good".

I think what you are thinking is to replace it with "isn't". "If he isn't good to you, I'll be there" would be a more common way to say it in conversation. In this case the verb relates to the subject "he" and if he is "good".



I have to agree.

A more common example -- "If John doesn't be careful with the knife, he will cut himself." OR dropping the "be careful" -- "John better be careful. If he doesn't, he will cut himself."



This is good to know - i don't know that I would ever say it that way, but good to know if I heard someone else do it, they wouldn't be wrong.



Oh, I wouldn't either. I actually had to think about it before I realized it could be considered grammatically correct.

Posted 7/8/10 10:16 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

okay...how about this one. It has bothered me for forever...
Backstreet Boys "All I have to Give" (I know, I know...lame song, lame band...moving on)

"Does his friends get all your time?"

This sounds wrong to me...this is why I could never be a song writer...

"I wanna tell her that I love her but the point is probably moot", however is one of my top 5 favorite lines in a song for it's creative use of vocabulary to complete a rhyme. Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/10 12:59 PM
 

ladybug8
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

2660 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

I'm ok with it--I like to think of it as informal English. I wouldn't want to see it in an essay but I'm fine with it in a song. Sometimes the lack of subject/verb agreement gives songs an edge. However-I don't like when "words" such as "conversate" are used.
Chat Icon

I always laugh when I hear, "We don't need no education."Chat Icon

Posted 7/9/10 1:27 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

I didn't think the Jackson 5 song is grammatically incorrect, but I do think it's poetic license...except for making up words. Then I suspend your poetic license...

Posted by ladybug8

However-I don't like when "words" such as "conversate" are used.
Chat Icon

I always laugh when I hear, "We don't need no education."Chat Icon


Exactly!

Posted 7/9/10 1:35 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Message edited 2011-11-27 17:16:18.887000.

Posted 7/9/10 3:11 PM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

I thought the word "conversate" was a real word for a very long time- I even used it in a sentence once at work. Someone corrected me, I'm a teacher Chat Icon . So much for turning to Biggie Smalls for my vocabulary words Chat Icon .

It doesn't bother me though Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-07-09 17:03:15.777000.

Posted 7/9/10 5:02 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Poor grammar and incorrect spelling of words drive me crazy!

Posted 7/9/10 7:44 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Not in the least bit...

Im actually surprised it bothers anyone...

It's a song not a term paper or legal document....

Posted 7/9/10 7:49 PM
 

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Hey teacher leave them kids alone

Posted 7/10/10 8:49 AM
 

Songwriter76
LIF Adult

Member since 4/08

902 total posts

Name:
David

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

The "Ill Be There" always bothered me too.

In general though, it doesn't bother me. Tom Petty uses "ain't" all the time and it always sounds MUCH more rock and roll than if he said, "isn't."

Posted 7/10/10 3:31 PM
 

Jen2999
Baby girls & beagles rock!

Member since 8/06

10356 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Poor Grammar in songs...

Posted by debsabourin13

okay...how about this one. It has bothered me for forever...
Backstreet Boys "All I have to Give" (I know, I know...lame song, lame band...moving on)

"Does his friends get all your time?"

This sounds wrong to me...this is why I could never be a song writer...

"I wanna tell her that I love her but the point is probably moot", however is one of my top 5 favorite lines in a song for it's creative use of vocabulary to complete a rhyme. Chat Icon



OMG the backstreet boys one drove me nuts!!!!!

HAHAHA funny.

Posted 7/10/10 4:13 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
OMG..This poor woman!! Mrs-Boop 8/17/05 26 Families Helping Families ™
my poor D Jesaroo 8/9/05 16 Pets
My poor kitty...... Diane 6/30/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
My poor DH... KPtoys 6/21/05 30 Families Helping Families ™
Poor Dharma UPDATE @ bottom Jesaroo 6/12/05 20 Pets
my poor lizzy! janet 6/7/05 2 Pets