Please help me understand this

Posted By Message

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Please help me understand this

Someone I know did a short sale on their home about 3 years ago. (They wanted to get out of the house because they were getting divorced) 3 years later is approved on a $430,000 mortgage with new husband that, has mediocre credit. (interest rate of 2.6%)

So thats it? Its that "easy" to walk away from your mortage? Although I would not do a short sale, seems kind of frustrating for me, who is paying a mortgage on a house that I can't get out of (because we desperately need a bigger home)

This person seems to have no repercussions to not paying their bank back 100%. Oh and I should mention they just purchased a new car a month ago.

Posted 7/27/11 9:51 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jam11308

Member since 11/07

7273 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Are you sure that the dh has mediocre credit? Also, how much does he make vs. what he owes? Is it possible that he made the purchases on his own without her name being on anything? Just because she says that "they" bought something doesn't mean that she's actually on the paperwork, kwim?

Message edited 2011-07-27 09:54:55.853000.

Posted 7/27/11 9:54 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Please help me understand this

You may not know all of the details.

Most of the time if they are solvent they will owe the bank and the taxes due on the shortfall.

If, at the time they proved they were unsolvent they "could" walk away from it but their credit will suffer.

Also, that 2.6% interest rate was bought down with points which will get added to the overall cost of their mortgage.

Lots of nuts and bolts to it.

I'm sure others more qualified than me will come along with more clarity.

I am underwater on a property and because I am solvent I cannot short sell or foreclose without owing the mortgage company over 100K and the IRS close to $40K.

Posted 7/27/11 9:54 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Please help me understand this

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?

Posted 7/27/11 9:56 AM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Maybe the first house was under the husband's name and not the wife's? So even though she lived in it and paid the mortgage (or didn't...) she wasn't technically responsible for the default on the loan?

Or maybe, similarly, the 2nd home was purchased in only the new husband's name?

My home was purchased in only my name, and the mortgage is only mine. My broker actually encouraged us to do this, because if anything wacky happened in the future and we couldn't pay our mortgage we could always buy a new house in my husband's name.

Posted 7/27/11 9:57 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

It's quite possible that the husband bought the house by himself without her name on it. There's so any factors that could be involved though, KWIM?

Posted 7/27/11 9:57 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by JAAMS

It's quite possible that the husband bought the house by himself without her name on it. There's so any factors that could be involved though, KWIM?



I know that the first house was purchased with her and her ex-dh. They were both on the mortgage. They had tons of financial problems that destroyed their credit. And then eventually a short sale.

The 2nd house with the new Dh was def put in both their names. The only major credit he had (besides an auto loan) was a mortgage for about 2 years that was recently paid off.

I dunno, it just annoys me. I know I shouldn't concern myself with other people's business but I need to move so badly and I can't. And I can't get a loan for a dormer because there is no equity in my house. So I am stuck living in the smallest house in the world and it bothers me to hear stories like the above.

Posted 7/27/11 10:02 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by Blu-ize

You may not know all of the details.

Most of the time if they are solvent they will owe the bank and the taxes due on the shortfall.

If, at the time they proved they were unsolvent they "could" walk away from it but their credit will suffer.

Also, that 2.6% interest rate was bought down with points which will get added to the overall cost of their mortgage.

Lots of nuts and bolts to it.

I'm sure others more qualified than me will come along with more clarity.

I am underwater on a property and because I am solvent I cannot short sell or foreclose without owing the mortgage company over 100K and the IRS close to $40K.




Ya - I am sure there are things that I don't know or don't understand.

Posted 7/27/11 10:03 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by JAAMS

It's quite possible that the husband bought the house by himself without her name on it. There's so any factors that could be involved though, KWIM?



I know that the first house was purchased with her and her ex-dh. They were both on the mortgage. They had tons of financial problems that destroyed their credit. And then eventually a short sale.

The 2nd house with the new Dh was def put in both their names. The only major credit he had (besides an auto loan) was a mortgage for about 2 years that was recently paid off.

I dunno, it just annoys me. I know I shouldn't concern myself with other people's business but I need to move so badly and I can't. And I can't get a loan for a dormer because there is no equity in my house. So I am stuck living in the smallest house in the world and it bothers me to hear stories like the above.



What's stopping you from doing a short sale? I agree with others in that a. you don't know the situation and b. that is envy talking and can only harm you.

Posted 7/27/11 10:27 AM
 

avabrodymamma
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

914 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

A short sale is not a foreclosure.

From what I understand, a person can do a short sale in order to avoid a foreclosure and ruining their credit.

Posted 7/27/11 10:38 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...

Posted 7/27/11 10:42 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by DRMom

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by JAAMS

It's quite possible that the husband bought the house by himself without her name on it. There's so any factors that could be involved though, KWIM?



I know that the first house was purchased with her and her ex-dh. They were both on the mortgage. They had tons of financial problems that destroyed their credit. And then eventually a short sale.

The 2nd house with the new Dh was def put in both their names. The only major credit he had (besides an auto loan) was a mortgage for about 2 years that was recently paid off.

I dunno, it just annoys me. I know I shouldn't concern myself with other people's business but I need to move so badly and I can't. And I can't get a loan for a dormer because there is no equity in my house. So I am stuck living in the smallest house in the world and it bothers me to hear stories like the above.



What's stopping you from doing a short sale? I agree with others in that a. you don't know the situation and b. that is envy talking and can only harm you.



We would not do a short sale because of the impact is must have on your credit. We borrowed X amount of dollars and we need to pay X back. Its the right thing to do.

And I do know most of the situation as this person is very close to me. I was there for every detail when she was going through the divorce/short sale. Maybe I just don't understand how it impacts your credit and that is what I am curious about. I would think it would be a major impact, along the lines, but not as serious as a foreclosure. Because again, you didn't pay back your obligation and that should say something for when you apply for a new mortgage.

I am not envious. I am not envious of someone who, in my opinion weasled their way out of their mortgage. I am more frustrated that they did that with no consequences. Maybe her new Dh carried her through the approval but he has light credit so I just don't get it.


Posted 7/27/11 10:43 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by bicosi

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...



I know to some extent its none of my business. But I am saying, in general, if someone does a short sale, they can easily get a new mortgage a few years down the line. Then why am I the arsehole paying my mortgage back on a house that basically worthless Chat Icon

Posted 7/27/11 10:45 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...



I know to some extent its none of my business. But I am saying, in general, if someone does a short sale, they can easily get a new mortgage a few years down the line. Then why am I the arsehole paying my mortgage back on a house that basically worthless Chat Icon



I know.. it completely SUCKS.. :( sorry if I came off rude.. it's just that we don't always know every little detail so we can't really judge based on what we do know, kwim?

Posted 7/27/11 10:49 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by bicosi

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...



I know to some extent its none of my business. But I am saying, in general, if someone does a short sale, they can easily get a new mortgage a few years down the line. Then why am I the arsehole paying my mortgage back on a house that basically worthless Chat Icon



I know.. it completely SUCKS.. :( sorry if I came off rude.. it's just that we don't always know every little detail so we can't really judge based on what we do know, kwim?



no worries. My hormones are all out of whack lately and for some reason this situation is just irking me. Especially because we are preparing for a 2nd baby in the smallest house in the world!

But it is what it is.

Posted 7/27/11 11:07 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Please help me understand this

my cousin did that. Walked away from a house after a divorce completely foreclosed. Then purchased a house three years later that is MASSIVE and must of cost $$$. I have no clue how she did it.

Posted 7/27/11 11:12 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Please help me understand this

The mortgage thing is definitely a big mess, and I am sure situations like this do not help matters for many individuals out there who are doing the right thing.

I do know from personal experience though that people who get approved for bigger houses and bigger mortages don't necessarily have it easier.

I know someone who while he has a bigger and better home than us, also is paying out his a$$ on interest, and often has to borrow money from his parents at 35 years old each month to pay all of his bills.

He refinanced several times and will be paying something insane like $7K a month when he is at retirement age because he couldn't purchase a small starter home like us.

I think this is the problem on Long Island for many..............not everyone can start out modestly...........it always has to be the biggest or the best and then this causes problems for everyone with being approved for a mortgage.

Anyways, I still stand by my OP which is that dwelling on it is certainly not going to change things.

When I get down like this, I always remind myself that our home, while small, still meets our needs.

We have a huge yard and plenty of space.

We are close to family and near everything in general.

Bottom line, we also have a home to call our own which so many people do not.

It's all about perspective KWIM?


Posted 7/27/11 11:17 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...



I know to some extent its none of my business. But I am saying, in general, if someone does a short sale, they can easily get a new mortgage a few years down the line. Then why am I the arsehole paying my mortgage back on a house that basically worthless Chat Icon



I know.. it completely SUCKS.. :( sorry if I came off rude.. it's just that we don't always know every little detail so we can't really judge based on what we do know, kwim?



no worries. My hormones are all out of whack lately and for some reason this situation is just irking me. Especially because we are preparing for a 2nd baby in the smallest house in the world!

But it is what it is.





Just think though of the positives you will be instilling in your children based on the fact that you ARE living modestly.

You won't be raising brats who expect everything be handed to them right away ;).



Posted 7/27/11 11:19 AM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Maybe the new guy had a very large down payment?
And I am not 100% on this but I think a short sale does not ruin your credit as much as forclosure would, in a short sale you are not flat out not paying , the bank is agreeing to letting you settle for less.

Posted 7/27/11 11:20 AM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me understand this

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by bicosi

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I dunno.

I try not to compare myself to others, because there is usually more to it that I am not aware of.

Not only that, but worrying about others and their situation is the root of all evil.

JMO, but what good can come of it?




Ditto to this and honestly, it's NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS...



I know to some extent its none of my business. But I am saying, in general, if someone does a short sale, they can easily get a new mortgage a few years down the line. Then why am I the arsehole paying my mortgage back on a house that basically worthless Chat Icon



I know.. it completely SUCKS.. :( sorry if I came off rude.. it's just that we don't always know every little detail so we can't really judge based on what we do know, kwim?



no worries. My hormones are all out of whack lately and for some reason this situation is just irking me. Especially because we are preparing for a 2nd baby in the smallest house in the world!

But it is what it is.





Just think though of the positives you will be instilling in your children based on the fact that you ARE living modestly.

You won't be raising brats who expect everything be handed to them right away ;).






Thanks. I know. DH says the same things. Pls, regardless of how small my house is, I have a beautiful daughter with another baby on the way. We are lucky enough to make it on one salary and I can be a SAHM. Its all the things I wanted. I know one day I will have the house I want. I would just rather it be sooner than later!!!!

Posted 7/27/11 11:25 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Moms with babies - what nicknames do you have that will have to stop once they understand you? lipglossjunky73 9/2/07 51 Parenting
Do you feel like sometimes you don't really understand... LIMOMx2 5/22/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
when did your DC understand how to use a sippy cup? burberrygirl 5/11/07 11 Parenting
What can a 5-6 yr old possibly understand about war? JennChris 2/7/07 5 Parenting
What part of No Thank you do you not understand??? dooodles 12/30/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
We registered at BRU this weekend but what I don't understand... preciouslove 1/23/06 5 Pregnancy