Pinterest Illegal?

Posted By Message

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Pinterest Illegal?

Linky
I guess you can judge for yourself

Posted 2/29/12 10:11 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Interesting - I think I have wondered that before.

Posted 2/29/12 10:26 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Hmmm, I would assume that since you are linking and giving credit, it's okay. But then again, I don't know.

Posted 2/29/12 10:37 AM
 

Andrewz00
Look! I changed it!

Member since 4/10

1789 total posts

Name:
Andrew

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by jilliibabii

Hmmm, I would assume that since you are linking and giving credit, it's okay. But then again, I don't know.



Thats what im thinking... its not much different then bookmarking your fav sites across the internet... its just easier to look at.. and they are all linked back to the original source...

Posted 2/29/12 11:15 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

All I know is if it is found illegal and shut down for whatever reason, this site would suffer.
What would we post about all day long?
At any given time there are at least 5 active threads titled- "Pintrest"

Chat Icon

Posted 2/29/12 11:21 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by Andrewz00

Posted by jilliibabii

Hmmm, I would assume that since you are linking and giving credit, it's okay. But then again, I don't know.



Thats what im thinking... its not much different then bookmarking your fav sites across the internet... its just easier to look at.. and they are all linked back to the original source...



This is what I am thinking as well.

As an aside, I sure hope they don't take Pinterest away one day!! I would be so sad. Chat Icon

Posted 2/29/12 11:21 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

it is not like you are pinning it and taking credit for it...you are pinning it to one area..but it is linked still to the original page...how can that be a bad thing...isn't it like free advertising for them?!?!?Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/29/12 12:04 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

It was an interesting article- on the one hand, I do think it makes you less likely to go to the sites, but I have also seen recipes and things about decluttering, where I've wanted more info and clicked through to the site. If anything, I can see people who have blogs and sites coming up with ways to "tease" pinners and get them to click through for more info.

My cousin has a small bridal business and I know she's finding it a great way to promote her business. But I am also pretty sure she owns the rights to the professional photos she uses or has an arrangement, and she takes her own photos of her merchandise.

Posted 2/29/12 12:10 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by MrsProfessor

It was an interesting article- on the one hand, I do think it makes you less likely to go to the sites, but I have also seen recipes and things about decluttering, where I've wanted more info and clicked through to the site. If anything, I can see people who have blogs and sites coming up with ways to "tease" pinners and get them to click through for more info.

My cousin has a small bridal business and I know she's finding it a great way to promote her business. But I am also pretty sure she owns the rights to the professional photos she uses or has an arrangement, and she takes her own photos of her merchandise.



I've posted some recipes from my blog on pinterest and I couldn't have been prouder when I saw them repinned, especially by strangers. I also have a FB page linked to my blog and it gives me the "stats" about who is visiting my page, who is talking about it, etc. My page popularity went up 298% after pinning on pinterest. Chat Icon Not that it's THAT great since it's mostly just family and friends who like my site, but still, I can't see this as a bad thing!

Posted 2/29/12 12:35 PM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

It has def encouraged me to go to websites that I didn't know I needed in my life until I knew they existed.Chat Icon

Posted 2/29/12 1:46 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

I dont know I have gone and visited sites I never would have known about before. I would think the website owners would be happy they are getting more hits. It's sort of like forwarding a link to a website but easier and better jmo

Posted 2/29/12 2:18 PM
 

KNic19
Baby's First Christmas

Member since 7/09

3541 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by Sweetlax22

It has def encouraged me to go to websites that I didn't know I needed in my life until I knew they existed.Chat Icon



This exactly. I now have a website that I cannot live without that I NEVER would have found if it wasn't for Pinterest.

Posted 2/29/12 10:17 PM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Definately illegal if you're grabbing photos that you did not take yourself. If you read the terms of service when you upload you are stating that you have full rights to the image and you are granting Pinterest the right to store a full resolution copy on their servers to do whatever they want to in the future. If you do not own the copyright to the photo you're pinning you're violating their terms of service.

As a photographer that has work posted for sale on commercial stock photo sites I do NOT want anyone grabbing the watermarked images just because the like them (which also violates the terms of the stock photo sites) and pinning them on Pinterest. And I definately do not want anyone grabbing those same images off of someones blog because they like it, then uploading them to Pinterest, in effect, giving away MY image.

As a Pinterest pinner, you may not be profiting but you may very well be taking my photo off someone's blog (where they paid to use it) and you're putting it on Pinterest thereby telling them (via their terms of service) that you have own the rights to the photo when you don't, and you're making it available for anyone else that wants to download it, thereby potentially taking money from me and it's not linking back to the commercial sites that sell my work, but to a random blog instead.

If you want to read about the concerns relating to copyright violations you can find more on this photographers's blog

Posted 2/29/12 11:14 PM
 

MrsS1976
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

534 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Photographer/Lawyer deletes her account out of fear:

http://articles.businessinsider.com/2012-02-28/tech/31106641_1_repinning-copyright-entire-image

Posted 3/2/12 2:28 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by KLSbear

Definately illegal if you're grabbing photos that you did not take yourself. If you read the terms of service when you upload you are stating that you have full rights to the image and you are granting Pinterest the right to store a full resolution copy on their servers to do whatever they want to in the future. If you do not own the copyright to the photo you're pinning you're violating their terms of service.

As a photographer that has work posted for sale on commercial stock photo sites I do NOT want anyone grabbing the watermarked images just because the like them (which also violates the terms of the stock photo sites) and pinning them on Pinterest. And I definately do not want anyone grabbing those same images off of someones blog because they like it, then uploading them to Pinterest, in effect, giving away MY image.

As a Pinterest pinner, you may not be profiting but you may very well be taking my photo off someone's blog (where they paid to use it) and you're putting it on Pinterest thereby telling them (via their terms of service) that you have own the rights to the photo when you don't, and you're making it available for anyone else that wants to download it, thereby potentially taking money from me and it's not linking back to the commercial sites that sell my work, but to a random blog instead.

If you want to read about the concerns relating to copyright violations you can find more on this photographers's blog



Seems there are ways to stop pinning on your site: http://socialtimes.com/pinterest-lets-publishers-protect-their-images-from-getting-pinned_b90016

Also, I know DH when he sends images to clients he locks them so they can't be copied/downloaded. Not sure if that is something that can be done once a pic is up on the web, but something to look into.

Posted 3/2/12 8:56 AM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by CaMacho

Posted by KLSbear

Definately illegal if you're grabbing photos that you did not take yourself. If you read the terms of service when you upload you are stating that you have full rights to the image and you are granting Pinterest the right to store a full resolution copy on their servers to do whatever they want to in the future. If you do not own the copyright to the photo you're pinning you're violating their terms of service.

As a photographer that has work posted for sale on commercial stock photo sites I do NOT want anyone grabbing the watermarked images just because the like them (which also violates the terms of the stock photo sites) and pinning them on Pinterest. And I definately do not want anyone grabbing those same images off of someones blog because they like it, then uploading them to Pinterest, in effect, giving away MY image.

As a Pinterest pinner, you may not be profiting but you may very well be taking my photo off someone's blog (where they paid to use it) and you're putting it on Pinterest thereby telling them (via their terms of service) that you have own the rights to the photo when you don't, and you're making it available for anyone else that wants to download it, thereby potentially taking money from me and it's not linking back to the commercial sites that sell my work, but to a random blog instead.

If you want to read about the concerns relating to copyright violations you can find more on this photographers's blog



Seems there are ways to stop pinning on your site: http://socialtimes.com/pinterest-lets-publishers-protect-their-images-from-getting-pinned_b90016

Also, I know DH when he sends images to clients he locks them so they can't be copied/downloaded. Not sure if that is something that can be done once a pic is up on the web, but something to look into.



I appreciate the info but unfortunately that's just a half-a$$ed attempt by Pinterest to pretend they are doing something. If you install the code on your site and someone trys to grab the photo it pops up a message telling them that you don't want your photo pinned on Pinterest, but from what I've read it doesn't stop them from still pinning it if they want to.

My photos I'm referring to are not on a site of my own where I could add the code anyway, they are on the commercial sites that are clearly selling them or on blog sites that my agents have sold them to so adding the "no pinning" code would be up to every individual site that has purchased images.
I'm not sending any photos direct to clients, it's all done through my agents and I generally have no idea where they've gone.

Photo theft is rampant and it's not easy to stop but Pinterest enables stealing photos just like Napster enabled stealing music and all the torrent sites enable stealing other intellectual property like movies, books, etc. There is a growing attitude on the net that "it's OK because nobody's really losing anything tangible." In reality, if my photo that I offer for sale is used without paying me then it was stolen from me even if I didn't lose a tangible asset because I lost out on the amount it should have sold for. Photographers shouldn't have to run around policing people telling them "hey, don't steal this" with code embedded in a site anymore than they should have to post a sign on the front door of their house telling people not to steal stuff.

Posted 3/2/12 5:48 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by KLSbear

Posted by CaMacho

Posted by KLSbear

Definately illegal if you're grabbing photos that you did not take yourself. If you read the terms of service when you upload you are stating that you have full rights to the image and you are granting Pinterest the right to store a full resolution copy on their servers to do whatever they want to in the future. If you do not own the copyright to the photo you're pinning you're violating their terms of service.

As a photographer that has work posted for sale on commercial stock photo sites I do NOT want anyone grabbing the watermarked images just because the like them (which also violates the terms of the stock photo sites) and pinning them on Pinterest. And I definately do not want anyone grabbing those same images off of someones blog because they like it, then uploading them to Pinterest, in effect, giving away MY image.

As a Pinterest pinner, you may not be profiting but you may very well be taking my photo off someone's blog (where they paid to use it) and you're putting it on Pinterest thereby telling them (via their terms of service) that you have own the rights to the photo when you don't, and you're making it available for anyone else that wants to download it, thereby potentially taking money from me and it's not linking back to the commercial sites that sell my work, but to a random blog instead.

If you want to read about the concerns relating to copyright violations you can find more on this photographers's blog



Seems there are ways to stop pinning on your site: http://socialtimes.com/pinterest-lets-publishers-protect-their-images-from-getting-pinned_b90016

Also, I know DH when he sends images to clients he locks them so they can't be copied/downloaded. Not sure if that is something that can be done once a pic is up on the web, but something to look into.



I appreciate the info but unfortunately that's just a half-a$$ed attempt by Pinterest to pretend they are doing something. If you install the code on your site and someone trys to grab the photo it pops up a message telling them that you don't want your photo pinned on Pinterest, but from what I've read it doesn't stop them from still pinning it if they want to.

My photos I'm referring to are not on a site of my own where I could add the code anyway, they are on the commercial sites that are clearly selling them or on blog sites that my agents have sold them to so adding the "no pinning" code would be up to every individual site that has purchased images.
I'm not sending any photos direct to clients, it's all done through my agents and I generally have no idea where they've gone.

Photo theft is rampant and it's not easy to stop but Pinterest enables stealing photos just like Napster enabled stealing music and all the torrent sites enable stealing other intellectual property like movies, books, etc. There is a growing attitude on the net that "it's OK because nobody's really losing anything tangible." In reality, if my photo that I offer for sale is used without paying me then it was stolen from me even if I didn't lose a tangible asset because I lost out on the amount it should have sold for. Photographers shouldn't have to run around policing people telling them "hey, don't steal this" with code embedded in a site anymore than they should have to post a sign on the front door of their house telling people not to steal stuff.



Can't you pretty much take any photo off the web though? I've saved a bunch of photos from the Internet right onto my iPad, or is that different?

Posted 3/3/12 3:55 AM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Pinterest Illegal?

Posted by Mrs213

Can't you pretty much take any photo off the web though? I've saved a bunch of photos from the Internet right onto my iPad, or is that different?



Can it be done? Yes, it's impossible to stop people from grabbing photos off the web. Even if the web programmer disables the right-click function you can still do a screen grab.

Should it be done is another thing. In example, I take a photo of guacamole and chips and it's offered for sale via iStockphoto, Shutterstock, etc. It's purchased by the
Hass Avacado Board
for use on their website. You decide to copy the photo and recipe to your computer for later use. I don't really care and would really never know.

Now some random blogger decides to grab my image to use on their own blog, like this one did It's pretty clear from the crappy pixelation that they grabbed a lo-resolution image from somewhere without purchasing a license. This is the type of usage I object to because I'm selling this image and it seems pretty obvious that they haven't purchased it. They will be gettting a DMCA takedown notice.

Pinterest is increasing the likeliness that unauthorized use happens and a great majority of the time the image isn't linking back to the site that sells it. Impossible to stop and the biggest problem is the attitude that it's OK to do.

Posted 3/3/12 11:07 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do you follow anyone on Pinterest for decorating inspiration? NewlyMrs 2/28/12 0 Home
I finally joined Pinterest, but now I don't know how to use it! Help. pnbplus1 2/7/12 3 Families Helping Families ™
What is the most interesting thing you have found on Pinterest? Ayne11 1/24/12 17 Families Helping Families ™
So, has anyone done anything for the kids from Pinterest? CathyB 8/10/11 14 Parents of School-Aged Children
Spinoff: All this illegal apartment talk got me thinking.. jana 2/28/08 23 Home
settle a debate-is it illegal to buy cigarettes online? LFitzy79 10/26/07 5 Families Helping Families ™