Photography moms

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Photography moms

What do you think of these photos? These are the edited, final products.
Crituque please.

So I'd like some more opinions/feedback. I just don't know if I'm expecting too much from a professional. She is a partner in a photography business (but strangely has no portfolio online) so I expected top notch photos. She does weddings so again I expected better than this.
I know editing takes time but that's par for the course when being a photographer....No?

Photos

Message edited 2010-11-05 15:41:26.347000.

Posted 11/4/10 6:32 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Photography moms

I get a message:

This album might not be shared with you

Posted 11/4/10 6:34 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by leighla

I get a message:

This album might not be shared with you



Hmmmm. OK let me see.

Posted 11/4/10 6:34 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Does this work?

Photos

Posted 11/4/10 6:35 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

I'm viewing from my laptop, so I might not even be right since its obviously not calibrated, but some of the white balance looks off, and some look underexposed.

Posted 11/4/10 6:39 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by Michelle1123

I'm viewing from my laptop, so I might not even be right since its obviously not calibrated, but some of the white balance looks off, and some look underexposed.



OK. Do you feel like they are ready to print edited?

Posted 11/4/10 7:09 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Photography moms

To me they were not edited properly. The one of all four of you the kids skin tone is totally different. Also Miranda's hair was on her forehead that could have been edited. I see what you're saying if you are annoyed. Also would depend how much I paid KWIM...

Posted 11/4/10 7:15 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Whey do some of them have someone cut off?

Posted 11/4/10 7:16 PM
 

Bluepixie
Mamarazzi

Member since 6/07

2618 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Photography moms

Cute session!

They do look a bit underexposed. Did you edit them? Maybe brighten them up a little before you print.

Posted 11/4/10 7:16 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

At least I know I'm not crazy.
Had I paid full price for this it would have been a $175 sitting fee.
I got this at a silent auction for Miranda's school but I was under the impression after reading the bio and all that I was getting a good deal. She is a wedding/portrait photographer.
While they aren't absolutely terrible they aren't what I am used to. I went back and forth with using this or just paying for my usual photographer who I love. Given that times are tight I opted to use what I already paid for.
I have the original unedited files (which don't look much different). Do you think I could get someone to edit them for me since I have copyright? Chat Icon I love some of them and need to make our holiday card from these.

Uggh! Very frustrating.

Posted 11/4/10 7:20 PM
 

Bluepixie
Mamarazzi

Member since 6/07

2618 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Photography moms

Just sent you FMChat Icon

Posted 11/4/10 7:36 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by Mssissy

Whey do some of them have someone cut off?



Hmmm I didn't notice that. I need to go look again.
Any in particular?
I know I can salvage enough to get what I want but I'm just used to not being able to decide because I love my photos so much.

Posted 11/4/10 8:30 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by Michelle1123

I'm viewing from my laptop, so I might not even be right since its obviously not calibrated, but some of the white balance looks off, and some look underexposed.



I say the same....

They definitely need to be warmed up....

(And Im on my MAC)

The last pic..the one of the 2 of you. Looks a bit better. Did the photographer use a flash with that one and not the others?

Posted 11/4/10 8:50 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Photography moms

needs to be warmed up (white balance was off looks like it was edited but on a default setting) some exposures are a bit off but there are many ways of fixing that depending if in raw or just shot in jpg.

The photos themselves are nicely setup (posed) but the way they are shot eh. I would email/call them back and say hey love the shots just seems like they need more warming up, brightening up a bit and see what happens. I know I am not a editing pro with skin tones because my job asks for way to much red and un-natural look for every photograph (i honestly can't stand it) and I go very natural when I do my own editing.

Posted 11/4/10 9:01 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

speaking strictly from a critique standpoint....

- the white balance is off
- cropped limbs are a no-no in professional photography
- some of the poses are not flattering. They are taken from an upward angle, which is truly not flattering for anyone.

Posted 11/4/10 9:06 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

I did call her with a list of edits. I felt like I was being so picky but I'm used to what I consider perfection from the photographer I normally use (most of you have seen our sessions with her) and this just didn't come close.
I know people have different styles/skills but this just seemed like no effort or creativity was put into it.
I noticed dirt on tights, stray hairs, colors off, etc. and I pointed them out.
My fault for not getting my hair done but I just assumed that would be edited b/c my hair always has been perfect with my previous photographer.
IDK, maybe I'm expecting too much but if you want to build business I feel like you have to put out excellent work. I feel like I wouldn't recommend this photographer. Maybe I'm being too harsh.

Posted 11/4/10 9:07 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by nrthshgrl

speaking strictly from a critique standpoint....

- the white balance is off
- cropped limbs are a no-no in professional photography
- some of the poses are not flattering. They are taken from an upward angle, which is truly not flattering for anyone.




Yeah fatties like DH and I certainly don't need the upward angle.

Posted 11/4/10 9:08 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?

Posted 11/5/10 3:42 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Photography moms

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



I honestly don't think they are bad. They are quite a few cute one.

They do feel "posed" though. It's mostly staged and does not look "relaxed" at all. Like it was "forced" a bit.

I would ask for the RAW version. That way they can be edited much better than on a JPEG version. If she is a true professional photographer she will (or should have!) shoot in RAW.

Posted 11/5/10 3:49 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by smdl

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



I honestly don't think they are bad. They are quite a few cute one.

They do feel "posed" though. It's mostly staged and does not look "relaxed" at all. Like it was "forced" a bit.

I would ask for the RAW version. That way they can be edited much better than on a JPEG version. If she is a true professional photographer she will (or should have!) shoot in RAW.



Yeah that's the other thing.
She gave DH this whole schpeal on why she shoots in Jpeg and not RAW Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
So I can only get the Jpegs. It's not so much the poses it's more the editing. I have a few cute ones and they're sufficient to hang up but I'm just so disappointed in the lack of time put into editing.

Posted 11/5/10 3:58 PM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Photography moms

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



Legally other people are not suppose to edit other photographers final products. Its considered copyright infringement. Also editing JPGS is not the ideal situation. There are definitely color issues. If all you are spending is $60 for the high res files it seems like the photographer is still probably portfolio building and learning....

Stinks that there isn't much you can do. You said it was something you won right? So no money lost? Only other thing is to ask the photographer to re-evaluate the edit, maybe warm them up some?

SOrry I'm not much help!

Posted 11/5/10 10:45 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by Blissful

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



Legally other people are not suppose to edit other photographers final products. Its considered copyright infringement. Also editing JPGS is not the ideal situation. There are definitely color issues. If all you are spending is $60 for the high res files it seems like the photographer is still probably portfolio building and learning....

Stinks that there isn't much you can do. You said it was something you won right? So no money lost? Only other thing is to ask the photographer to re-evaluate the edit, maybe warm them up some?

SOrry I'm not much help!



No I paid for it. I won it at a silent auction so it wasn't free.
I have to buy $60 worth of pictures and I'll get the Jpeg files since she doesn't shoot in raw.
She is not portfolio building. She's a partner in a wedding photography business. Chat Icon
So no one can edit them even if I have the files?

Posted 11/5/10 10:58 PM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Photography moms

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by Blissful

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



Legally other people are not suppose to edit other photographers final products. Its considered copyright infringement. Also editing JPGS is not the ideal situation. There are definitely color issues. If all you are spending is $60 for the high res files it seems like the photographer is still probably portfolio building and learning....

Stinks that there isn't much you can do. You said it was something you won right? So no money lost? Only other thing is to ask the photographer to re-evaluate the edit, maybe warm them up some?

SOrry I'm not much help!



No I paid for it. I won it at a silent auction so it wasn't free.
I have to buy $60 worth of pictures and I'll get the Jpeg files since she doesn't shoot in raw.
She is not portfolio building. She's a partner in a wedding photography business. Chat Icon
So no one can edit them even if I have the files?



Oh that stinks. Legally No, no one else can edit them, its considered copyright infringement which comes with a heavy penalty because you are essentially "changing her art".... I'm not saying no one will do it but its illegal. Also editing JPGs is very difficult and you'll never get the quality of a RAW file. Any way of speaking to the other partner and seeing if they can redo them? Honestly they look like unedited JPGs to me Chat Icon


Edited to add: oh and the fact that she doesn't shoot RAW is a huge Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-11-05 23:07:19.147000.

Posted 11/5/10 11:06 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

no help or advice but I would like to tell you that you have a great smile!Chat Icon

Posted 11/5/10 11:17 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Photography moms

Posted by Blissful

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by Blissful

Posted by monkeybride

Bumping for more feedback.

Do I just order my $60 to get my disc and call it a day and hopefully find someone to do better editing or do I keep nit picking until they are what I expect?



Legally other people are not suppose to edit other photographers final products. Its considered copyright infringement. Also editing JPGS is not the ideal situation. There are definitely color issues. If all you are spending is $60 for the high res files it seems like the photographer is still probably portfolio building and learning....

Stinks that there isn't much you can do. You said it was something you won right? So no money lost? Only other thing is to ask the photographer to re-evaluate the edit, maybe warm them up some?

SOrry I'm not much help!



No I paid for it. I won it at a silent auction so it wasn't free.
I have to buy $60 worth of pictures and I'll get the Jpeg files since she doesn't shoot in raw.
She is not portfolio building. She's a partner in a wedding photography business. Chat Icon
So no one can edit them even if I have the files?



Oh that stinks. Legally No, no one else can edit them, its considered copyright infringement which comes with a heavy penalty because you are essentially "changing her art".... I'm not saying no one will do it but its illegal. Also editing JPGs is very difficult and you'll never get the quality of a RAW file. Any way of speaking to the other partner and seeing if they can redo them? Honestly they look like unedited JPGs to me Chat Icon


Edited to add: oh and the fact that she doesn't shoot RAW is a huge Chat Icon



Thanks Maria.
I guess at this point I'll just cut my losses. Hope she corrects the list of edits I gave to her and print up the ones I like and make my Christmas card and call it a day and schedule a spring shoot with my tried and true photographer who I will NEVER stray from again, even if it's for a good cause.

Posted 11/5/10 11:32 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Photography Moms... I have a question... JDsWife 8/9/10 4 Parenting
Photography Moms-- Nikon D40? should I buy it? JenBenMen 2/3/09 16 Parenting
Photography Moms MrsPowers 12/26/09 5 Parenting
photography moms.... need help with a lens MrsS518 12/9/09 32 Parenting
Photography moms- props aliwnec10 9/3/09 4 Parenting
Photography moms- need advice on zoom lense aliwnec10 1/28/09 6 Parenting