PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted By Message

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

OK - Long story short,

At the 18 mth appt, ped had me fill out a questionaiire and based on my answers determined that DS had a developmental delay and sent me to a neurologist who said his findings were inconclusive.

I called EI and had him evaluated. The director of the agency spoke to me for about 20 minutes and then she said she had concerns and that it sounded like PDD.

The special ed and speech teachers came and evaluated him. They said they see a speech delay and his scores are very low but they were NOT worried about PDD at this time and were NOT recommending a psychological eval.

The OT came. He said there were some fine motor skill delays and some sensory delays. He did NOT see pdd AT ALL. He was surprised that someone even mentioned it to me.

LAST NIGHT the director called to review the results of his evaluations. Nothing I didn't expect. He'll get speech, OT and special ed. BUT then she said, "I would be remiss if I didn't tell you that some of what I've read can be early indicators of PDD. I know I haven't met your son, but I've read many evaluations and this is what it seems like to me. I realize the Sp. Ed teacher told you that she is not concerned at this time, but this is what I'm thinking."

SERIOUSLY? She has never even MET him! I told her the OT ALSO felt that it wasn't PDD and she kind of got mad and said it wasn't his place to diagnose. I questioned her about the "benefits" of diagnosing him now instead of giving him therapy for 6 months and seeing if the therapy works. She said, "instead of two 45 min sessions, he'll get 7-10 hours of ABA. This therapy works and it is very expensive."

I can't help it - I feel like a conspiracy theorist, but I can't help but feel like she has already made up her mind about my son without ever meeting him. I feel like this is a dollars and cents thing - the agency must make $$ some how.... why the push when the other professionals have said to hold off?

I just don't feel like he'll get a fair evaluation from the agency. I can't explain why I feel this way.

Can anyone recommend a private psychologist who would do an evaluation? I just want to rule it out and move on.

Message edited 2009-04-02 20:47:34.273000.

Posted 4/2/09 8:32 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

colesmom
Brady's mom too!

Member since 5/05

1989 total posts

Name:
Lea

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

If you can Fm me your phone # - I have a ton of info for you, but have a hard time sittting at the computer. I'd be happy to talk with you.

Posted 4/2/09 8:48 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Honestly.....

Im not reading what she is saying as a $$$ thing. I kind of feel like she is looking out for his best interest and doesnt want to waste precious time...

It's sometimes hard to hear things about our children..trust me I know.

But what if the Special Ed teacher and the OT are the ones that are wrong?

When my daughter was born 2 of the 3 peds didnt think their was anything wrong with her...if not for the insistance of the 3rd ped it would of been years before she was diagnosed. She would have gone years without EI services etc...

Message edited 2009-04-02 20:50:17.210000.

Posted 4/2/09 8:49 PM
 

SpencersMommy
I'm one lucky girl

Member since 11/07

3494 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Chat Icon

Posted 4/2/09 8:52 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

I'm sorry to hear that you are getting mixed messages. I'm a social worker and I work with some kids that have a diagnosis of PDD. We have had several of them re-assessed at the Cody Center located in Stony Brook.

Cody Center

I also asked a colleague about private psychogists and Kristen Memoloi-Ruthowski was recommended. I am in the process of getting the contact information for you.

Posted 4/2/09 8:54 PM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by hbugal

Honestly.....

Im not reading what she is saying as a $$$ thing. I kind of feel like she is looking out for his best interest and doesnt want to waste precious time...

It's sometimes hard to hear things about our children..trust me I know.

But what if the Special Ed teacher and the OT are the ones that are wrong?

When my daughter was born 2 of the 3 peds didnt think their was anything wrong with her...if not for the insistance of the 3rd ped it would of been years before she was diagnosed. She would have gone years without EI services etc...




I hear what you are saying, but I have a friend who does ABA and she was the one who planted the seed long before this experience... she said, "you have to remember - this is a business" and for some reason that's how I felt when i spoke to her.

The reason i'm concerned is that she hasn't met him and hasn't interacted with him. SOMETHING doesn't feel right - I want to follow up with a psychological - but not through her agency.... I feel like she's already decided what the outcome will be and I just think if it does come down to a diagnosis, I'll always feel like it was a misdiagnosis and i won't accept it. i want someone from the outside - someone I feel is unbiased - to do it, KWIM?

Posted 4/2/09 8:54 PM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by Bubbs

I'm sorry to hear that you are getting mixed messages. I'm a social worker and I work with some kids that have a diagnosis of PDD. We have had several of them re-assessed at the Cody Center located in Stony Brook.

Cody Center

I also asked a colleague about private psychogists and Kristen Memoloi-Ruthowski was recommended. I am in the process of getting the contact information for you.




Thank you SO MUCH!!!!

Posted 4/2/09 8:55 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

You should make an appointment with a developmental pediatrican, but also continue with the psycholgical evaulation with EI. Compare the two and go from there. IME, some educators are quick to say there is no major issue, but you have to keep in mind that they aren't qualified to diagnose.

Chat Icon

Posted 4/2/09 8:56 PM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by EmmaNick

You should make an appointment with a developmental pediatrican, but also continue with the psycholgical evaulation with EI. Compare the two and go from there. IME, some educators are quick to say there is no major issue, but you have to keep in mind that they aren't qualified to diagnose.

Chat Icon



I know and i'm trying not to get my hopes up - it's just that the director is an audiologist/speech therapist and she can't diagnose either - especially OVER THE PHONE. I can't really explain the vibe I got from her, I just really want an outside person!

Thanks soooo much for the suggestion!

Posted 4/2/09 8:59 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by mom2aidan

Posted by hbugal

Honestly.....

Im not reading what she is saying as a $$$ thing. I kind of feel like she is looking out for his best interest and doesnt want to waste precious time...

It's sometimes hard to hear things about our children..trust me I know.

But what if the Special Ed teacher and the OT are the ones that are wrong?

When my daughter was born 2 of the 3 peds didnt think their was anything wrong with her...if not for the insistance of the 3rd ped it would of been years before she was diagnosed. She would have gone years without EI services etc...




I hear what you are saying, but I have a friend who does ABA and she was the one who planted the seed long before this experience... she said, "you have to remember - this is a business" and for some reason that's how I felt when i spoke to her.

The reason i'm concerned is that she hasn't met him and hasn't interacted with him. SOMETHING doesn't feel right - I want to follow up with a psychological - but not through her agency.... I feel like she's already decided what the outcome will be and I just think if it does come down to a diagnosis, I'll always feel like it was a misdiagnosis and i won't accept it. i want someone from the outside - someone I feel is unbiased - to do it, KWIM?



Most definitely!!!!!

What about having him evaluated by The Center for Autism?

They did my daughter's evaluation. I couldnt say anything more about them then that they are AMAZING. (My daughters Autistism DX isnt easy b/c she also has Mosaic Down Syndrome) It cant hurt to give them a call...

Fay J Linder Center for Autism

Posted 4/2/09 9:00 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by mom2aidan

Posted by EmmaNick

You should make an appointment with a developmental pediatrican, but also continue with the psycholgical evaulation with EI. Compare the two and go from there. IME, some educators are quick to say there is no major issue, but you have to keep in mind that they aren't qualified to diagnose.

Chat Icon



I know and i'm trying not to get my hopes up - it's just that the director is an audiologist/speech therapist and she can't diagnose either - especially OVER THE PHONE. I can't really explain the vibe I got from her, I just really want an outside person!

Thanks soooo much for the suggestion!



Over the phone wouldn't alarm me to be honest. If she is a director of the agency, then she reads reports of kids on the spectrum all day long and is trained to know when to rec. a psychological evaulation. I really don't think they are out to conspire against you. What agency are you with?

Posted 4/2/09 9:02 PM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by hbugal

Posted by mom2aidan

Posted by hbugal

Honestly.....

Im not reading what she is saying as a $$$ thing. I kind of feel like she is looking out for his best interest and doesnt want to waste precious time...

It's sometimes hard to hear things about our children..trust me I know.

But what if the Special Ed teacher and the OT are the ones that are wrong?

When my daughter was born 2 of the 3 peds didnt think their was anything wrong with her...if not for the insistance of the 3rd ped it would of been years before she was diagnosed. She would have gone years without EI services etc...




I hear what you are saying, but I have a friend who does ABA and she was the one who planted the seed long before this experience... she said, "you have to remember - this is a business" and for some reason that's how I felt when i spoke to her.

The reason i'm concerned is that she hasn't met him and hasn't interacted with him. SOMETHING doesn't feel right - I want to follow up with a psychological - but not through her agency.... I feel like she's already decided what the outcome will be and I just think if it does come down to a diagnosis, I'll always feel like it was a misdiagnosis and i won't accept it. i want someone from the outside - someone I feel is unbiased - to do it, KWIM?



Most definitely!!!!!

What about having him evaluated by The Center for Autism?

They did my daughter's evaluation. I couldnt say anything more about them then that they are AMAZING. (My daughters Autistism DX isnt easy b/c she also has Mosaic Down Syndrome) It cant hurt to give them a call...

Fay J Linder Center for Autism



Thank you so much for the recommendation - I think this place sounds great!

Posted 4/2/09 9:04 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

ONLY a psychologist or an MD are allowed to make such diagnostic.

Not the special ed, not the OT. This is TOTALLY out of their scope of practice to tell you whether they "think" DC is on the spectrum or not.

When DS went through the evaluations recently, the special ed person "suggested" DS had an OT and psychologist doing an evaluation also.

ONLY the psychologist made such diagnostic. She used several "tools" as far as the "grading". ADOS, etc... I asked how she based her diagnostic. I asked a lot of questions. She explained to me what she was looking for, what DS "should" be doing, what he wasn't doing, my "interview" with her and the questions I answered.

We awaiting an appt with another specialist. A developmental and behavioral specialist. That test is usually done in 2 sessions.

When we started the evaluations I had no idea that DS would be diagnosed with Autism. I was devastated. I called EI because of feeding issues. So imagine! You are NEVER ready to hear it.

Get the evaluation by the psychologist from EI and get another opinion from a developmental Dr.

ETA: Be open minded but don't be afraid to question. There is a difference between being in denial and really not believing in what people are telling you because you question the validity of their words/actions.

The psychologist from our agency assured me that she would not make such diagnostic just in order for us to qualify for services. She said that it is too devastating of a news and would be completely unethical on her part.

Good luck!Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-04-02 21:17:00.497000.

Posted 4/2/09 9:07 PM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by smdl

ONLY a psychologist or an MD are allowed to make such diagnostic.

Not the special ed, not the OT. This is TOTALLY out of their scope of practice to tell you whether they "think" DC is on the spectrum or not.

When DS went through the evaluations recently, the special ed person "suggested" DS had an OT and psychologist doing an evaluation also.

ONLY the psychologist made such diagnostic. She used several "tools" as far as the "grading". ADOS, etc... I asked how she based her diagnostic. I asked a lot of questions. She explained to me what she was looking for, what DS "should" be doing, what he wasn't doing, my "interview" with her and the questions I answered.

We awaiting an appt with another specialist. A developmental and behavioral specialist. That test is usually done in 2 sessions.



This is what I was told as well! Just to clarify, the SP ed teacher said that from what she saw she didn't think that a psychological was necessary at this time.... give it 6 months of therapy and reassess

The director is an audiologist by trade - I know she's read a lot of reports but I just *feel* like she already has him diagnosed in her mind.... I get a feeling from her that makes me really uncomfortable....

I really want to get to the bottom of this with professionals I feel I can trust.

Posted 4/2/09 9:13 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by mom2aidan

Posted by smdl

ONLY a psychologist or an MD are allowed to make such diagnostic.

Not the special ed, not the OT. This is TOTALLY out of their scope of practice to tell you whether they "think" DC is on the spectrum or not.

When DS went through the evaluations recently, the special ed person "suggested" DS had an OT and psychologist doing an evaluation also.

ONLY the psychologist made such diagnostic. She used several "tools" as far as the "grading". ADOS, etc... I asked how she based her diagnostic. I asked a lot of questions. She explained to me what she was looking for, what DS "should" be doing, what he wasn't doing, my "interview" with her and the questions I answered.

We awaiting an appt with another specialist. A developmental and behavioral specialist. That test is usually done in 2 sessions.



This is what I was told as well! Just to clarify, the SP ed teacher said that from what she saw she didn't think that a psychological was necessary at this time.... give it 6 months of therapy and reassess

The director is an audiologist by trade - I know she's read a lot of reports but I just *feel* like she already has him diagnosed in her mind.... I get a feeling from her that makes me really uncomfortable....

I really want to get to the bottom of this with professionals I feel I can trust.



Who is your agency? The psychologist from agency we have was very nice and thorough in the tools she used for her diagnostic.

Posted 4/2/09 9:18 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Sophie is right. I am a special educator and though I have over 13 years of classroom experience with children on varying places within the spectrum, I would NEVER diagnose based on a report. I would recommend further testing or evaluations as an advocate for a child if I suspected something, but teachers are not diagnosticians. In my setting, the SLP's are considered teachers by their licensing as well as clinicians but they do not diagnose.

Posted 4/2/09 9:38 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by hbugal

Posted by mom2aidan

Posted by hbugal

Honestly.....

Im not reading what she is saying as a $$$ thing. I kind of feel like she is looking out for his best interest and doesnt want to waste precious time...

It's sometimes hard to hear things about our children..trust me I know.

But what if the Special Ed teacher and the OT are the ones that are wrong?

When my daughter was born 2 of the 3 peds didnt think their was anything wrong with her...if not for the insistance of the 3rd ped it would of been years before she was diagnosed. She would have gone years without EI services etc...




I hear what you are saying, but I have a friend who does ABA and she was the one who planted the seed long before this experience... she said, "you have to remember - this is a business" and for some reason that's how I felt when i spoke to her.

The reason i'm concerned is that she hasn't met him and hasn't interacted with him. SOMETHING doesn't feel right - I want to follow up with a psychological - but not through her agency.... I feel like she's already decided what the outcome will be and I just think if it does come down to a diagnosis, I'll always feel like it was a misdiagnosis and i won't accept it. i want someone from the outside - someone I feel is unbiased - to do it, KWIM?



Most definitely!!!!!

What about having him evaluated by The Center for Autism?

They did my daughter's evaluation. I couldnt say anything more about them then that they are AMAZING. (My daughters Autistism DX isnt easy b/c she also has Mosaic Down Syndrome) It cant hurt to give them a call...

Fay J Linder Center for Autism



I worked here for 4 years! They did merge with AHRC recently - so they go by a different name now, I think....

The best way to Dx PDD or Autism is the ADOS - I know an amazing psychologist that I would personally trust my own child with - FM me if you want more info! Chat Icon

Posted 4/2/09 10:18 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

As an evaluator, I would never, nor would the director of my agency, ever call up and say they suspected PDD. If I have concerns regarding PDD or any other diagnosis, I would make a referral for a psychologist through EI to rule out any behavioral impairments, not necessarily PDD or autism. Just a FYI, all the places that are on this thread are great! In addition, Hofstra has recently started doing evaluations/counseling/etc. I have students that are currently being evaluated through them and other students that are receiving therapy through them.
In addition, it really concerns me that a person would look at a report and make such a conclusion and, in essence, tell you that their own staff were not qualified enough to make a decision regarding another eval. If she is so concerned, why didn't she send out a psychologist with the core evaluation! Audiologist/speech therapist or not, I have been working with students diagnosed on the spectrum for over ten years and I would NEVER read a report and state, especially to the parent, that I felt the child had PDD! We all have behaviors that could be symptoms of PDD. To have a diagnosis of Autism or any other pervasive developmental disorder, one must have several interacting symptoms based on the DSM IV! HTH!

Posted 4/3/09 12:48 AM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: PDD - Upset - recommend a psychologist - LONG

Posted by ejm1219

As an evaluator, I would never, nor would the director of my agency, ever call up and say they suspected PDD. If I have concerns regarding PDD or any other diagnosis, I would make a referral for a psychologist through EI to rule out any behavioral impairments, not necessarily PDD or autism. Just a FYI, all the places that are on this thread are great! In addition, Hofstra has recently started doing evaluations/counseling/etc. I have students that are currently being evaluated through them and other students that are receiving therapy through them.
In addition, it really concerns me that a person would look at a report and make such a conclusion and, in essence, tell you that their own staff were not qualified enough to make a decision regarding another eval. If she is so concerned, why didn't she send out a psychologist with the core evaluation! Audiologist/speech therapist or not, I have been working with students diagnosed on the spectrum for over ten years and I would NEVER read a report and state, especially to the parent, that I felt the child had PDD! We all have behaviors that could be symptoms of PDD. To have a diagnosis of Autism or any other pervasive developmental disorder, one must have several interacting symptoms based on the DSM IV! HTH!



This is EXACTLY how I feel.

I want to clarify - neither the sp. ed evaluator or OT evaluator tried to "diagnose" DS. The director told me that if they saw something suspicious they would recommend a psychological. BOTH therapists said they didn't think it was necessary at this time. I'm wondering why the director is questioning their determination when they had a chance to interact with DS and she has not.

I'm going ahead with an OUTSIDE evaluation. I'll be FMing you for some recommendations. I REALLY appreciate your support!

Posted 4/3/09 9:12 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can anyone recommend an awesome adolescent psychologist? ~Melissa~ 2/11/08 0 Health!
please recommend a Psychologist/psychiatrist.... renee92405 4/20/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
Recommend a psychologist/therapist? newshound 6/2/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
Please recommend your deck company Kate 4/2/09 2 Home
How upset would you be if....now with pic- UPDATE Beth 4/1/09 32 Pets