Paraguard vs Mirena

Posted By Message

ILJ619
LIF Adult

Member since 6/06

1985 total posts

Name:
Irene

Paraguard vs Mirena

Need pros and cons please. I did a search but would like to get some current feedback on pain, effectiveness, side effects?

Also did you have to pay upfront first and then insurance will reimburse? TIA!

Posted 2/23/09 12:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NJmom
.

Member since 8/05

4987 total posts

Name:

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

I got the Mirena in August and love it! Getting it wasn't any worse than a pap. I didn't have any pain or cramping. The only annoying side effect was that I had spotting for the first few months. Now my periods are VERY light. My ob/gyn said 20% won't get a period at all. I didn't want the paraguard because it can make your periods heavier. The Mirena has hormones, but a very tiny amount. I've been able to continue EBF without any problems.

Before I had it put in, my ob/gyn office contacted my ins company to find out my coverage. Once they found out it was covered and I gave them the okay they ordered it. My insurance covered it completely so I only had a copay.

Posted 2/23/09 12:50 PM
 

MommyTeffi
Yummy!!!

Member since 2/06

1827 total posts

Name:

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

I have Mirena after the birth of my second child (over a year). Prior to my pregnancies, I was always on the pill. I didn't experience any lasting discomfort from the insertion. It was about 15 seconds of pain while it was put in. I took some Motrin the first night.

I've had no side effects from Mirena. I still get a period but it is very quick and light. It works differently for everyone. My insurance paid for it and I was only responsible for my copay ($10).

I choose Mirena over Paraguard due to the recommendation of my doctor based on the success rate and feedback from her other patients. I plan to have more children and hope not to have any difficulty conceiving due to Mirena.

Mirena has hormones ( no estrogen)which are localized to the uterus and is good for 5 years. Paraguard is hormone free and lasts 10 years. HTH.

Posted 2/23/09 12:50 PM
 

dani731
Blessed!!!

Member since 1/08

3355 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

I am getting Mirena in a few weeks. Once I get my next period, I have to call to make the appt to have it put in. I can't wait. I do not want to go back on the pill, so this iss the best option for me. My Doc office did a pre-certification for it to see if it was covered & it is so I only have to pay the co-pay which for me is $25.

Posted 2/23/09 1:00 PM
 

gpsyeyes
She's my world!!!

Member since 8/06

1184 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

I had paraguard - i was over 35 & smoked, so Mirena wasn't an option. Anyway, first 3 months was painful - but bearable. After that it was fine. Here's my problem, though... I got pregnant! Apparently it moved sometime between my check-up in February & April of that year!

Posted 2/23/09 1:21 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

Pretty much what everyone said above for the Mirena. I got it almost 3 years ago and love it! Did not hurt and after some slight bleeding for a month Chat Icon my next period was hardly there and now I don't even get one Chat Icon I don't have any side effects from it.

Back when I got it, I had a HUGE issue and a very hard time with my insurance company getting it covered. I would call dozens of times, usually getting a male insurance rep and when I asked if the Mirena was covered, they had no idea what I was talking about Chat Icon It was torture!! In the end, they didn't cover it (I really think I just didn't get my point across and fight hard emough) and I paid for it out of my own pocket - something like $500 worth Chat Icon Worth every penny to me and when my 5 years up, I will definitely look to get it again and this time fight to make insurance cover it. (looking back, I probably could have filed a claim to be reimbursed, but I never did Chat Icon )

Posted 2/23/09 1:27 PM
 

ILJ619
LIF Adult

Member since 6/06

1985 total posts

Name:
Irene

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

Posted by gpsyeyes

I had paraguard - i was over 35 & smoked, so Mirena wasn't an option. Anyway, first 3 months was painful - but bearable. After that it was fine. Here's my problem, though... I got pregnant! Apparently it moved sometime between my check-up in February & April of that year!



LOL Oh my! I guess that answers my effectiveness question for that one. Chat Icon

Posted 2/23/09 1:36 PM
 

ILJ619
LIF Adult

Member since 6/06

1985 total posts

Name:
Irene

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

Posted by chmlengr

Pretty much what everyone said above for the Mirena. I got it almost 3 years ago and love it! Did not hurt and after some slight bleeding for a month Chat Icon my next period was hardly there and now I don't even get one Chat Icon I don't have any side effects from it.

Back when I got it, I had a HUGE issue and a very hard time with my insurance company getting it covered. I would call dozens of times, usually getting a male insurance rep and when I asked if the Mirena was covered, they had no idea what I was talking about Chat Icon It was torture!! In the end, they didn't cover it (I really think I just didn't get my point across and fight hard emough) and I paid for it out of my own pocket - something like $500 worth Chat Icon Worth every penny to me and when my 5 years up, I will definitely look to get it again and this time fight to make insurance cover it. (looking back, I probably could have filed a claim to be reimbursed, but I never did Chat Icon )



See here is why I asked about insurance bc I found it odd that my doctor wants me to pay him upfront first even though they said my insurance covers it. Then, they submit a claim to my insurance company and they pay the dr and the dr sends me a check for what they covered? I was like what? I found that very odd and he is a very reputable dr and delivered my kids. That part seemed shady to me!

Posted 2/23/09 1:39 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

My dr highly recommended mirena over paraguard, bc PG causes heavy bleeding and more people get pregnant while using it than mirena. I have some heart issues and can't really use hormonal BC , but Mirena has very low hormones and it's safe even for me. I haven't decided on it yet , but I hear good things about it. I asked her if the insurance would cover it and she said she 'll call and talk to them and in most case they do cover. If you decide to go for Mirena don't call the insurance yourself, have the dr call them.
Also have you considered "Nuva ring"? I tried it for few months and it's soooo easy to use and I really liked it. The only problem was that I had few side affects(which was related to my heart issue) but most people I know really love it and have been using it for a long time.

Posted 2/23/09 1:42 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Mirena vs. Paraguard IUD lmb03 8/13/08 2 Parenting
Which IUD? Mirena or Paraguard? monkeybride 12/9/05 4 Parenting
Mirena? nhnic 1/2/07 4 Parenting
Mirena - Simplify Your Life Sweepstakes (12/31) mommy2bunnies 10/12/06 0 Parenting
Mirena users - I have a question for you CunningOne 7/10/06 5 Parenting
Is anyone on Mirena? baghag 2/21/06 0 Families Helping Families ™