Pacifier Problems

Posted By Message

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Pacifier Problems

My daughter was 17 months when we finally got rid of the bottle for good. This past weekend we switched her to a toddler bed bc I am due with daughter #2 in May and we don't want her to think the baby "stole her crib" so we wanted to give plenty of time for her to adjust. She has been doing great in the bed and it has been a week. So now comes the problem, the pacifier. She was only using the pacifier for naps and bedtime and at daycare she doesnt use a pacifier at all! Now for the last 2 months at home she is always asking for the pacifier and I made the mistake of giving in bc now everytime she walks in the door she asks for it. My husband wants me to just cut it off cold turkey. She literally screamed for 2 hours, sobbing and begging for it. It made me sick to my stomach she was so hysterical. I feel like she has been through enough transitions lately so I feel like we should give in. Husband was pissed bc he said she is going to cry now, tomorrow, 6 months whenever we take it away and while I get his point I just don't think its a battler we need to fight right this second. I know it will be hell when we take it away but as long as she doesn't use it out of the house (which we never take it out with us) I can't deal with it now. At 19 months I still feel like she IS a baby
frown emoticon
Thoughts??

PS
We tried cutting the tip off the pacifier and she was like wtf is this and threw it across the room LOL

Posted 12/29/15 6:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Pacifier Problems

That's a lot for a 17 month old to drop the bottle, transition to a bed and take the pacifier.

Posted 12/29/15 7:25 PM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Pacifier Problems

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

That's a lot for a 17 month old to drop the bottle, transition to a bed and take the pacifier.



Thank you. I said the same thing to my husband. I think he is being totally unreasonable and he doesn't understand why it is sucha big deal at all. I said she is still a baby!! She won't be going to college with a pacifier I am sure of that, it just doesn't seem worth a battle at this moment.

Posted 12/29/15 7:36 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Pacifier Problems

Agree. Seems like a lot at once. 17 months is still a baby :/ I'd give it some more time.

Posted 12/29/15 9:14 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Pacifier Problems

I would let her keep the paci until after baby is born OR do it like 1-2 months before baby arrives

Message edited 2015-12-29 21:22:50.550000.

Posted 12/29/15 9:22 PM
 

ChristinaM128
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

4043 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Pacifier Problems

We did it when dd was 2. I know it may be different for you b/c 2 is when the new baby will come, and that will be its own adjustment. But it really only took about 3 weeks (we VERY GRAUDUALLY cut the tip - first time I was too ambitious with the cut and she also just chucked it and screamed). You can probably start in feb/March and have it done before the baby comes. She just had a lot of other adjustments. Good luck!

Btw, my dd has been great about every aspect of getting things ready for the baby, but When she saw the packs of pacifiers, I swear she started salivating and her eyes got really big!

Posted 12/29/15 9:55 PM
 

Jpteach95
LIF Infant

Member since 8/13

315 total posts

Name:

Pacifier Problems

We transitioned off bottle at 13 months (he only had 1 a day at bedtime), into a bed at 2. The new baby slept in our room for 6 months so
We knew we had the time to make him feel like the move wasnt baby stealing his crib. By that time he had paci only at nap and at bedtime (not at all at daycare-- not even for nap). We gave him till 3. I reminded him a ton that at 3 they were gone. He slept with one in his mouth and one in each hand.

So I did what sleep trainer taught us for getting him to STTN. All 3 for 3 nights. Next 3 nights only 2. Next 3 only 1. Then none. Had whining fist couple of nights then none. He did great and never asked again.

Plan will be same for DS2.

Posted 12/29/15 10:12 PM
 

DLMheartsCRM
LIF Infant

Member since 8/11

208 total posts

Name:

Re: Pacifier Problems

You're going through a lot of transitions at once. I say leave the paci issue alone for now.


We took DD off the bottle super early, she was about 14 months. She just got off the paci at about 3. I know it's a lot later than others but she has ASD and it helped soothe her. We had to help her quit, so we got rid of all other Paci's (or as she calls them "Happys") and kept one and cut the tip off it. If she wanted a happy, she had to use that one. Since the suction was no longer there, she lost interest fast. It took about a week for her to adjust but it can be done.

Posted 12/29/15 11:59 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Pacifier Problems

I wouldn't battle over the pacifier at this age especially with all of the other transitions. My kids didn't have any issues giving up the bottle, but they both loved the paci. They were only using it for sleeping and long car rides as they got older although my younger one probably would've used it 24/7 if I allowed it. I didn't think either one would give it up willingly. They both gave it up on the older side, but it was comforting to them and helped them fall asleep. My older one gave it up as he was potty training at 2y9m. My younger one gave it up around potty training too at 3. With him, he dropped it in the toilet by accident when he went to pee. We threw it out and it was the perfect opportunity to get rid of it. I don't think he would've willingly given it up any other way. I was actually surprised that he didn't really ask for it after that.

Posted 12/30/15 7:15 AM
 

NYCGirl80
I love my kiddies!

Member since 5/11

10413 total posts

Name:

Re: Pacifier Problems

Way too much change at such a young age. Leave the pacifier for now.

Posted 12/30/15 8:35 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Pacifier Problems

DD kept the paci until 3 years old...and it was an easy transition because she was ready.
Trust me, when they are ready there will be a LOT less crying than when they are not.

For the record, her teeth are perfect as is her speech.
There is too much of a rush these days to turn babies into grown children.

I think it's way too much at once and I would let her keep the pacifer. Sometimes I feel like forcing things too early does them more trauma and harm than good

Message edited 2015-12-30 13:06:59.863000.

Posted 12/30/15 1:05 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Pacifier Problems

Yeah, too much all at once. Your husband is wrong. Right now it provides her comfort and she is going through a lot of changes. Give her that paci and wait until she is 2 or way after the baby is born.

Posted 12/30/15 1:08 PM
 

islandersgirl74
Love Being A Mommy!

Member since 6/06

5804 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Pacifier Problems

My daughter is 2 and we just took the paci away. She's going thorough many changes right now so if it soothes her, I say you should let her keep it a little longer.

Posted 12/30/15 9:57 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Pacifier Problems

There is something with men and getting their babies off the paci!!! We were extremely lucky and were able to transition DS off the bottle at a year when we transitioned to milk. He is still teething, still a baby in my eyes and yet DH wants to get him off the paci. I figure by 2-2&1/2 and we will be ok. Good luck, I do agree your DH is being a little unreasonable.... And unrealistic.

Posted 12/30/15 11:15 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Pacifier Problems

If the bottle was switched 2 months ago I think that's "over"
She's still in the transition mode to her bed
While I agree with your husband that a toddler doesn't need to be walking around the house with a pacifier in their mouth, I might wait until February. Does he want to cut it out for naps and sleep too?

Posted 12/31/15 5:36 AM
 

cowgirlkate
Twins times TWO!

Member since 1/11

1197 total posts

Name:

Re: Pacifier Problems

I am glad I read this thread. My older two never took a paci and one of my younger twins won't take it either. It is just my one daughter. They are 11 months, almost a year. I plan to take bottle at 13 months after milk transition, but I just love the pacifier for her so much. It makes her so calm instantly and she rarely cries. I just know I don't want to toss it anytime soon. I say if it makes your life easier and it isn't really hurting her, do what you need to do for now.

ETA: My daughter only gets it for naps, bedtime, or if shes in her carseat at nap or bedtime. I agree that it shouldn't be used other times of the day, even for younger ones.

Message edited 2015-12-31 08:32:15.767000.

Posted 12/31/15 8:30 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
When did your DC start using the pacifier? Anyone able to not use a pacifier at all? Bridex100 4/4/11 16 Parenting
Anyone else have "texture" problems with food? MrsProfessor 6/20/05 29 Families Helping Families ™
we withdrew our offer...the house had a lot of problems raken40 6/13/05 6 Home
has anyone else had problems using hotmail today? pschica 6/4/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone Having Problems with Photo Albums??? Jesaroo 5/10/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone having problems resizing images??? Stefanie 5/10/05 5 Families Helping Families ™