Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted By Message

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Another OJ case....

PRETORIA, South Africa — The South African judge in Oscar Pistorius’ murder trial said Thursday that prosecutors have not proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the double-amputee Olympic athlete is guilty of premeditated murder. She also indicated he could not be found guilty of a lesser murder charge.

“Culpable homicide is a competent verdict,” the judge said, but did not deliver any formal verdicts in the shooting death of Pistorius’ girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp before calling for a lunch break in the proceedings.

Masipa on Thursday was explaining her reasoning behind the upcoming verdicts in the case against the double-amputee Olympic athlete. Masipa said there were “just not enough facts” to support the finding of premeditated murder in Steenkamp’s fatal shooting.

External Image

Posted 9/11/14 7:17 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

I don't think this is another OJ case. From what I have read/seen of the trial, they didn't prove premeditated murder. I think he meant to kill her, but that it was more "heat of the moment."

Message edited 2014-09-11 07:29:33.630000.

Posted 9/11/14 7:29 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

I don't know what to think of this case.

There seem to be so many supporters of this guy.

Who knows.....

Posted 9/11/14 7:30 AM
 

TyReseGreen
Lil Prince is here

Member since 8/11

6338 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Not guilty of premeditated murder doesn't mean he didn't kill her. It just means it was spur of the moment killing.

Oj on the other hand was found not guilty of murder even though I can't see how he is not guilty.

Message edited 2014-09-11 07:36:32.610000.

Posted 9/11/14 7:35 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Murder is off the table, not just premeditated murder....

Posted 9/11/14 7:54 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Lesser charges
Of the additional three charges, the most serious one is related to ammunition found in his house when police searched it after the killing.
He did not have a proper license for it, but he maintains he was storing it in his safe for his father.
If he is found guilty of the ammunition charge, he could face up to 15 years in prison, though the judge could opt for a lesser punishment such as a fine or the loss of his gun license.
Two other charges are related to allegations that he recklessly fired a gun in public -- once in a restaurant in 2012, and again out of the sunroof of a car last year. Pistorius denies both.
The maximum penalty for each charge is five years behind bars. If he is convicted of either, he could face a lesser sentence, such as a fine or the loss of his gun license.
Possible sentences
There is no minimum sentence for culpable homicide in South African law -- it's up to the judge to decide.
And there's one final possibility: If the judge does not think the prosecution has proved its case, she will find him not guilty, and Pistorius will be a free man.

Posted 9/11/14 7:56 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

I don't think he planned to murder her so I agree with no premeditated murder. But he did kill her and I don't think it was just out of fear, I believe it was out of rage... so I hope he doesn't go guilty for that!

Posted 9/11/14 8:13 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Oh I didn't realize murder was completely off the table. yikes.

Posted 9/11/14 8:14 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by BaysideForever

I don't think he planned to murder her so I agree with no premeditated murder. But he did kill her and I don't think it was just out of fear, I believe it was out of rage... so I hope he doesn't go guilty for that!



I agree with this. I don't think it was premeditated, but from what the news is saying it doesn't sound like he will even get the murder conviction. Which, in that case would be like OJ. A very well known athlete and local "hero" getting off on this.

Posted 9/11/14 8:15 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

NOT GUILTY. The judge seriously thinks he thought it was an intruder in the bathroom and that he thought Reeva was still in bed. He just got away with murder.

Pretoria, South Africa (CNN) -- The night he killed Reeva Steenkamp, Oscar Pistorius did not commit murder, the judge at his trial said Thursday.

He did not intend to kill her, Judge Thokozile Masipa said.
But his conduct was "negligent," she said before adjourning for the day, suggesting she will find the Olympian guilty of culpable homicide.

There is no minimum sentence for culpable homicide in South African law. It's up to the judge to decide.

As he fired four bullets into the bathroom of his home in Pretoria on Valentine's Day last year, he did not foresee the "possibility that he would kill the person behind the door, let alone the deceased, as he thought she was in the bedroom at the time," Masipa said.

Judge rejects premeditated murder charge Pistorius judge, stern yet compassionate From 'blade runner' to murder suspect

Evidence suggests that Pistorius genuinely believed the person in the bathroom was an intruder, although that is irrelevant to the case, the judge said.

Pistorius could have taken other actions when he thought there was an intruder, she said. "All the accused had to do was to pick up his cell phone to call security or the police," she said.

"He could have run to the balcony and screamed in the same way he screamed after the incident," she added, noting that Pistorius called security after the incident and could have done so when he heard what he thought was an intruder.

Posted 9/11/14 12:09 PM
 

BlessedMomma
LIF Adult

Member since 12/11

6163 total posts

Name:
Momma Bear

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

This is bs... he just got away with murder... what is wrong with people today unless we see something on a video we dont believe it... total bs...

Posted 9/11/14 12:33 PM
 

RainaK
LIF Adult

Member since 4/14

904 total posts

Name:
R

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by BlessedMomma

This is bs... he just got away with murder... what is wrong with people today unless we see something on a video we dont believe it... total bs...



I agree. I've followed this case closely and I was shocked today. I pray that he's found guilty of the lesser charge and gets significant prison time.

Posted 9/11/14 12:42 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by RainaK

Posted by BlessedMomma

This is bs... he just got away with murder... what is wrong with people today unless we see something on a video we dont believe it... total bs...



I agree. I've followed this case closely and I was shocked today. I pray that he's found guilty of the lesser charge and gets significant prison time.



Exactly! And that's why when I first posted this I said it was just like OJ...and IT IS!

Posted 9/11/14 12:51 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

NOT GUILTY. The judge seriously thinks he thought it was an intruder in the bathroom and that he thought Reeva was still in bed. He just got away with murder.


On the Judge:
He did not intend to kill her, Judge Thokozile Masipa said.




IMHO the judge absolutely got it right. Whenever I look at ANY case "in the news" I always thing about what evidence we (as the public) are TOLD and given, as opposed the facts of the case shown in court.

Based on this ruling sounds like the judge got it right. The prosecution did not PROVE beyond REASONABLE doubt he meant to kill her.

We can all think what we want. I give the judge a lot of credit for deciding for themselves based on the facts in court.

Posted 9/11/14 12:52 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

I agree it wasn't premeditated but he absolutely knew it was Reeva in the bathroom when he fired not one, but FOUR shots. It was rage, not planned...but murder nonetheless.

Posted 9/11/14 12:53 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Is culpable homicide there like manslaughter here?

I wonder what the verdict would have been if it was an actual intruder? Would it have been the same? It wasn't exactly self-defense if the person was on the other side of the door.

Posted 9/11/14 1:28 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by tourist

Is culpable homicide there like manslaughter here?

I wonder what the verdict would have been if it was an actual intruder? Would it have been the same? It wasn't exactly self-defense if the person was on the other side of the door.



Culpable homicide is the South African equivalent of Britain’s manslaughter, notes The Star. It has been defined in South Africa as “the unlawful negligent killing of a human being.” The key difference between culpable homicide and premeditated murder is that the latter requires planning.

While Pistorius could have gotten up to life in prison for the murder conviction, the culpable homicide charge carries a maximum penalty of 15 years in jail with no minimum sentence.

Posted 9/11/14 1:52 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

I agree it wasn't premeditated but he absolutely knew it was Reeva in the bathroom when he fired not one, but FOUR shots. It was rage, not planned...but murder nonetheless.



Well said!!

Posted 9/11/14 2:17 PM
 

LIRascal
drama. daily.

Member since 3/11

7287 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by Paramount

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

NOT GUILTY. The judge seriously thinks he thought it was an intruder in the bathroom and that he thought Reeva was still in bed. He just got away with murder.


On the Judge:
He did not intend to kill her, Judge Thokozile Masipa said.




IMHO the judge absolutely got it right. Whenever I look at ANY case "in the news" I always thing about what evidence we (as the public) are TOLD and given, as opposed the facts of the case shown in court.

Based on this ruling sounds like the judge got it right. The prosecution did not PROVE beyond REASONABLE doubt he meant to kill her.

We can all think what we want. I give the judge a lot of credit for deciding for themselves based on the facts in court.



How does their legal system work? Did they have to do what we do, which is prove it 100% beyond a reasonable doubt?

Asking because i know nothing about S. African law. It seems so different than the US with long recesses and allowing of court outbursts more than once...

Posted 9/11/14 2:32 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Oscar Pistorius - wasn't murder

Posted by LIRascal

Posted by Paramount

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

NOT GUILTY. The judge seriously thinks he thought it was an intruder in the bathroom and that he thought Reeva was still in bed. He just got away with murder.


On the Judge:
He did not intend to kill her, Judge Thokozile Masipa said.




IMHO the judge absolutely got it right. Whenever I look at ANY case "in the news" I always thing about what evidence we (as the public) are TOLD and given, as opposed the facts of the case shown in court.

Based on this ruling sounds like the judge got it right. The prosecution did not PROVE beyond REASONABLE doubt he meant to kill her.

We can all think what we want. I give the judge a lot of credit for deciding for themselves based on the facts in court.



How does their legal system work? Did they have to do what we do, which is prove it 100% beyond a reasonable doubt?

Asking because i know nothing about S. African law. It seems so different than the US with long recesses and allowing of court outbursts more than once...



This link will explain a lot. It is very different, no jury..etc etc. It's innocent until proven guilty, but only the judge makes that decision.
Click me

Message edited 2014-09-11 14:39:33.937000.

Posted 9/11/14 2:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Double amputee Olympian from South Africa Oscar Pistorious facing murder charges for shooting girlfriend MrsPJB2007 2/15/13 5 Families Helping Families ™