Opinions please- what would you do?

Posted By Message

sunny
Life is good!

Member since 5/05

8369 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Opinions please- what would you do?

Dd is 3yrs 4 months.
In July she will be starting a new school where there is a pool and they swim (instructional swim) 3 days a week, so I started her in swimming lessons now at safety swim so she could hopefully learn to at least hold her breath underwater. Parents do not stay in the pool room. We watch from the room next door through one way glass.

The first 2 lessons she did great. She took a little coaxing to get in the pool, and the instructors there suggested they just take her even if she screams, and I refused that. Instead I talked her into it.
The third lesson halfway through she was "swimming" on her back and she started screaming and crying on and off. The instructor was being very nice to her, but about five minutes before the lesson was over I went in to get her, again refusing to let them teach her while she cries. She told me later that swimming on her back is too scary.

The 4th lesson she never even made it into the pool, she started crying in the car halfway there that she was scared, the water is too deep, etc. I ended up sitting next the pool the whole lesson with her in my lap mostly crying and screaming that she will "never go in a pool again". Again, they wanted me to leave and take her crying and I refused.

So, do I bother going back? Am I torturing her? I think a pool is a scary place, and she has to go in it with a stranger holding her which is also scary, so I just can't let her scream the whole time. I also think the more I try to get her in the more she will refuse and it will stick in her head and make the whole situation worse.

What would you do? Should I just wait until she goes to the new school with a pool, when I won't be there maybe she will go in?

Message edited 2009-04-04 10:24:52.730000.

Posted 4/4/09 10:24 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

honestly, i would find a new place for lessons!! that seems so cruel to me, - they want to teach her to swim while she screams and cries? and why can't you be there with her?

i guess they have their reasoning but i don't think i would want my DS to learn to swim using a place like that...

Posted 4/4/09 10:26 AM
 

2BEANS
wow time is going fast.

Member since 9/07

16106 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

When I was younger my parents had me in swim lessons. I remember one time they were showing us how to jump off the diving boards. I didnt want to do it. I kept running away crying. One of the instructers took me and tossed me in while screaming.. I started freaking out in the pool. There was no one there to catch me.. I dont remember how long it took but finally an instructor helped me.. Im sure it wasnt long b/c that would be a law suit. But as a child I remember it feeling like forever. My point is.. I remember all this still to this day about 30 years later!! I did go back in pool..

I just feel your doing the right thing about not forcing your dd to go in pool while crying. Its very stressful for them and seems like alot of times people forget that. Is there anyway they would let you in someway go in the pool with her and help in the teaching?

Posted 4/4/09 10:31 AM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

Chances are when you are not around she will do better. That has been my experience( I have an 8 yr old) At this point she knows that if she cries, you will get her. You have said in front of her(i am assuming) to the teacher that you will not let her cry AND go in the pool, so... They are smart.

Posted 4/4/09 10:32 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

I have mixed feelings about this. In a way, yes, it does seem cruel- and the pool IS a scary place for some kids. But at the same time, you don't want her fearing it forever. But at the end of the day, it should be your decision, not the teacher's. You know your child better then anyone else.
I teach dance and at the start of the year I had a preschooler hysterical crying for her mom. The first few weeks the mom would just throw her into my room and leave. It was kind of uncomfortable for me, but we dealt with it fine- I just wish the mom had spoken to me about it beforehand. Now she's perfectly fine and loves coming in to dance. The mom knew the best way to handle it and I'm sure you know what's best for your DD too. Chat Icon

Posted 4/4/09 11:35 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

I have mixed feelings. I have seen many kids at the YMCA freak out. There is a reason they don't let the parents in there because the kids will go to them and play them. They used to let the kids sit on the side of the pool and coax them in - eventually they all go in.

Most kids are afraid of the water (and cry) when they first go in & have the iron grip on who is bringing them in. It takes awhile to get them used to it. I don't think it's helpful to Katie to hear you tell someone you're not going to let them take her into the pool screaming because now she knows screaming is what's going to get her out of the pool - even if she has to continue to up the ante by throwing a bigger fit each time.

Maybe look into another program if you're not comfortable with the one you've picked or opt for private lessons. One thing I think you need to do is stop watching her lessons.

eta. I would also FM waterspout4 since she teaches swimming lessons for her input.

Message edited 2009-04-04 12:11:13.713000.

Posted 4/4/09 12:10 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

I heard my ears ringing! Chat Icon

DO NOT GIVE IN!!! Saf-T-Swim seems very cruel, but for a very good reason. I never called a parent in. If I did, the child knew they could manipulate. I was screamed at, bit, punched, thrown up on hundreds of times. I was sent to the ER once because an 18 month old elbowed me so hard that I swelled immensely. We just knew my cheekbone was broken.

I called a parent in TWICE to stop a lesson. One time was because the child had the early stages of chicken pox. The other time was because the mom had slathered Aquafor on their child and I couldn't get a grip. (A one year old is like a greased pig Chat Icon )

It is very difficult to watch. As a parent, I would die watching that. No matter what age your child learns to swim will be difficult. Swimming on your back is always scary. I taught people in their 60s and 70s. What are the two scariest things for them? Inhaling water because they don't know proper breath control, and being on their backs. It never changes, no matter the age, unless they learn how to swim.

I actually have to get to bed now, but I could write for days on this subject. I will check tonight if there are more questions. Feel free to FM me. Chat Icon

ETA: Even while they scream, they are still learning. You'd be very surprised. Let the entire 30 minutes go and then go in to get her.

Message edited 2009-04-04 12:25:30.970000.

Posted 4/4/09 12:23 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

I have a friend that used to teach swimming, and she said that you need tough love when going thru this. She would take the kids screaming, but they would stop after a few minutes. Otherwise, no matter where you go, DD will continue to do this and never learn. JMHO I know it's hard, but I'm sure if you gave her to them and watched thru the glass, you will see that she will calm down in a few minutes. If not, then go get her. I think you should at least give it a shot.

Posted 4/4/09 12:39 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

Does she have to take the swim classes at her new school or are they optional? If they are optional and she isn't going to be left out of activities the other kids are doing, I would honestly wait a little longer and try it again. She's pretty young, and really does not need to know how to swim yet.

As she gets older, I agree with the tough love idea because it is important that she learn to swim. I learned when I was 8, and my mother took me to the Y. Even at 8, I cried and cried, but once I learned to hold my breat and put my head under water, I relaxed a lot.

But at 3? I don't know that you need to force her yet. I would give her a little more time and see if she becomes more interested in another 6 months or a year. Possibly she might want to do more this summer if there is a town pool you use or something like that.

Posted 4/4/09 12:47 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

Posted by ChrisDee

Chances are when you are not around she will do better. That has been my experience( I have an 8 yr old) At this point she knows that if she cries, you will get her. You have said in front of her(i am assuming) to the teacher that you will not let her cry AND go in the pool, so... They are smart.



ITA. Kids always behave differently when the parent isn't around. At this point, your DD knows that if she cries she can get out. I would bet that if she couldn't see you, she'd do it with no problems.

IMO learning how to swim at a young age is worth the crying.

Posted 4/4/09 12:57 PM
 

j-baby8
LIF Infant

Member since 3/09

59 total posts

Name:

Re: Opinions please- what would you do?

Would it be at all possible for you to take her to a local town pool and have her in the water with you a little bit first until she realizes that the water isnt going to harm her? I think that having you there with her, even if you're just holding her while standing in the water might be benificial to her to realize that you aren't going to harm her. Then, when you take her to her lesson, remind her before hand that you are watching out for her, and will be there if anything should happen to her but the "nice instructor lady" will make sure she is adequatly cared for.

If you are at all uncomfortable with the whole situation about them wanting to take your daughter kicking and screaming, you should remove her from the program.

Hope this idea helps!

Posted 4/4/09 1:36 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I need some opinions regarding SAHM vs. going back to work btrflygrl 1/31/06 18 Parenting
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
So my Dh just left he went out AGAIN! Opinions advice needed BADLY 04bride 11/22/05 20 Families Helping Families ™
what ipod to get for a guy for xmas?? need opinions ggt08 11/9/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Changed post DH will not move to coram so I need opinions about what suffolk towns are good , safe and have a good school district. MommyofG 9/22/05 51 Home
My swing is broken... dilemma.. looking for opinions. -Laurie- 9/22/05 5 Parenting