opinions on CIO

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: opinions on CIO

Way too young IMO-at they age they cry because the need something or because something is wrong.

Posted 12/17/08 8:41 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

boosh1002
We like hanging together!

Member since 5/05

5475 total posts

Name:
Mommy to twins

Re: opinions on CIO

Yes that it way too young for CIO. My kids werent off the middle of the night bottle till about 5 months.

Personally I am against CIO.

Posted 12/17/08 8:45 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: opinions on CIO

I was thinking about this last night in shower...I was never able to attempt CIO until he was 11 mos. And it did not work.

But in my moms group, one of the moms is a ped. Her daughter is 6 mos and still waking at night. She said she has told patients for years to have their babies CIO, but once she had her own everything changed. She said there is no way she could let her baby cry.

just food for though.Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 8:45 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



This is completely nutty IMO. After a cetain age (NOT 13 WEEKS) it's worse IMO to not help you child learn to sleep.

Think about how horrible you feel when you wake up throughout the night. Do you think your kid feels any better when they don't get a good nights sleep?

IMO I think it is our duty as parents to help our kids learn how to sleep well. I'm not saying that it has to be CIO-there are a bunch of methods that parents can try.

CIO works great in certain circumstances and certain kids and parents. We did CIO with DD at around 12 months. For the first night it was bad (she cried 25 minutes and it broke my heart), but a couple nights later she slept like a "baby" as the old saying goes. We are EXTREMELY BONDED, thank you very much.

Message edited 2008-12-17 08:48:55.300000.

Posted 12/17/08 8:46 AM
 

mcl916
my two loves

Member since 10/06

5133 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by hbugal

While I think he is too young for a true CIO I would maybe let him cry for a bit...

Like instead of going to him right away...make the bottle first (if you are bottle feeding) get yourself a drink of water etc...Im talking maybe 5 minutes.



I agree. I have done this a bunch of times and most of the time he is asleep by the time I get to him. Even now he will fuss during the night, but unless he is full out crying I don't get up and he falls back to sleep. At 12 weeks he is sleeping 12 hours so they don't necessarily need to eat every 3 hours (although every child is different so you baby may really need to eat all night).

Posted 12/17/08 8:49 AM
 

sarahbelle
Little drummer boy

Member since 5/05

2377 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: opinions on CIO

Is he getting enough to eat during the day? My little guy is almost 11 weeks and he only wakes once at night (usually between 2-4am) after he goes to sleep around 8:30.

Posted 12/17/08 8:50 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



This is completely nutty IMO. After a cetain age (NOT 13 WEEKS) it's worse IMO to not help you child learn to sleep.

Think about how horrible you feel when you wake up throughout the night. Do you think your kid feels any better when they don't get a good nights sleep?

IMO I think it is our duty as parents to help our kids learn how to sleep well. I'm not saying that it has to be CIO-there are a bunch of methods that parents can try.

CIO works great in certain circumstances and certain kids and parents. We did CIO with DD at around 12 months. For the first night it was bad (she cried 25 minutes and it broke my heart), but a couple nights later she slept like a "baby" as the old saying goes. We are EXTREMELY BONDED, thank you very much.



I agree with Cranky.....

It has nothing to do with the "bond", it has to do with helping your child learn to self soothe

that said, I rocked my dd to sleep for the first 12 months. She then began resisting my rocking. Now, she will CIO for 5-10 minutes (more like a whine than a cry) and fall asleep

I was a CIO failure but I think it IS a good tool to use at the right age (not before 6 months)

Posted 12/17/08 8:55 AM
 

cgdg61606
Little Brother Christopher

Member since 2/07

6815 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: opinions on CIO

My ped said at 6 months you can and should cry it out if necessary.

Also, my ped said it was normal for babies to wake for bottles up until 6 months. At 6 months, start trying to ween from that nighttime bottle, but even then, some babies still need it for a while.

Posted 12/17/08 9:04 AM
 

mommy2devin
2 Boys, I need calgon!

Member since 10/07

1572 total posts

Name:
Shannon

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



CIO is NOT easy by any means, but I truly believe it is MUCH harder on Mommy than baby. But comments like these go straight to my heart after having a night where we had to CIO again.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 9:09 AM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: opinions on CIO

Too young for CIO. IMO.

Posted 12/17/08 9:11 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by krissy888

I've been really surprised with ppl IRL telling me to let him CIO. Maybe they have done it this early on for their convenience?



My experience with talking to parents who have children even just a couple of years older than my DS is that their memories are fuzzy about when exactly their children did certain things. They might have used CIO, but it might have been at 6 months, not 3 and just don't remember that.

I think your DS is too young for CIO right now. At that age, my DS was only waking once per night for a bottle at about 3-4 am. The ped told me at that visit that I could try to stop giving the bottle by giving him an extra ounce in his daytime bottles and not running right in to get him. At about 3.5 months, I did that and it worked for us. Every baby is different, though. Eventually he will sleep through the night, just follow your mom instinct about when you think it is the right time to try. Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 9:20 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



This is completely nutty IMO. After a cetain age (NOT 13 WEEKS) it's worse IMO to not help you child learn to sleep.

Think about how horrible you feel when you wake up throughout the night. Do you think your kid feels any better when they don't get a good nights sleep?

IMO I think it is our duty as parents to help our kids learn how to sleep well. I'm not saying that it has to be CIO-there are a bunch of methods that parents can try.

CIO works great in certain circumstances and certain kids and parents. We did CIO with DD at around 12 months. For the first night it was bad (she cried 25 minutes and it broke my heart), but a couple nights later she slept like a "baby" as the old saying goes. We are EXTREMELY BONDED, thank you very much.



Thank you you wrote this much better then I could.

Last time I checked my child was happy, well rested, and very much bonded with me and my husband!

Posted 12/17/08 9:21 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by mommy2devin

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



CIO is NOT easy by any means, but I truly believe it is MUCH harder on Mommy than baby. But comments like these go straight to my heart after having a night where we had to CIO again.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Shannon - don't let comments like this one even get to you. The poster doesn't have a child old enough to do CIO - so until you are in another persons shoes it is very hard to judge! You know you are doing the right thing for your DS and that's all that matters! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 9:22 AM
 

jmf423
:)

Member since 5/05

6372 total posts

Name:

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



This is completely nutty IMO. After a cetain age (NOT 13 WEEKS) it's worse IMO to not help you child learn to sleep.

Think about how horrible you feel when you wake up throughout the night. Do you think your kid feels any better when they don't get a good nights sleep?

IMO I think it is our duty as parents to help our kids learn how to sleep well. I'm not saying that it has to be CIO-there are a bunch of methods that parents can try.

CIO works great in certain circumstances and certain kids and parents. We did CIO with DD at around 12 months. For the first night it was bad (she cried 25 minutes and it broke my heart), but a couple nights later she slept like a "baby" as the old saying goes. We are EXTREMELY BONDED, thank you very much.



Thank you you wrote this much better then I could.

Last time I checked my child was happy, well rested, and very much bonded with me and my husband!



Exactly my thoughts.

DS was rocked to sleep til 12 months. Once he stopped liking that we had a very hard time getting him to nap or sleep at night. My ped suggested CIO and it worked great for us in a very short amount of time (a few nights)

I wouldn't do it before he was one, and of course it wasn't my first choice but I knew he needed to sleep better. It was not easy for me to listen to him crying, but my son can now go to sleep just fine on his own and doesn't cry at all. Little kids are very smart and they learn VERY quickly that if they cry you will come back, but they learn just as quickly that crying won't always work and they realize its OK to go to sleep.

As far as the bonding goes, before - after - and during CIO ---- nothing has changed, we are extremely well bonded.

Message edited 2008-12-17 09:33:12.040000.

Posted 12/17/08 9:32 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by mommy2devin

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



CIO is NOT easy by any means, but I truly believe it is MUCH harder on Mommy than baby. But comments like these go straight to my heart after having a night where we had to CIO again.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Shannon - don't let comments like this one even get to you. The poster doesn't have a child old enough to do CIO - so until you are in another persons shoes it is very hard to judge! You know you are doing the right thing for your DS and that's all that matters! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree completely. There are 1000 great ways to parent and no one can tell you what will work for you and your child. Nor should anyone insinuate that because you chose a different path than they do that you will not be bonded to your kid. That is insane. It is hard to hear your child cry, the only way you can make it through is by knowing in your heart that it is best for you and your kid.

It breaks my heart to have to take DD to get shots. It is in her best interest to do it, but that doesn't make it easy. Because she cries, should I NOT take her for her shots? Of course not.

Everyone needs to find out what works for them. For some kids, CIO is not the right way and I commend parents who know that and figure out something else that will work for them.Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 9:45 AM
 

MrsDiamondgrlie
Bailey

Member since 5/05

12810 total posts

Name:
D

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by Karen

IMO, he is way too young. I think at that age it is definitely possible that he is still hungry.

I think 6 months is the rule that most go by.



I agree.

Posted 12/17/08 9:45 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by Diana1215

The poster doesn't have a child old enough to do CIO - so until you are in another persons shoes it is very hard to judge! :

\

I agree COMPLETELY Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 9:49 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: opinions on CIO

Definitely too young.

DD is 11 months and I still can't bring myself to CIO. I probably never will.

When she was as young as your DC, we would put her down at bedtime which was about 8:00, but then we gave her a "dream feed" before we went to bed around 10-11:00 to help her sleep a little longer. It helped us get her to sleep a 5 hour stretch vs. a 3 hour stretch.

Posted 12/17/08 10:20 AM
 

mommy2devin
2 Boys, I need calgon!

Member since 10/07

1572 total posts

Name:
Shannon

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by mommy2devin

Posted by hope07

I wouldnt do cry it out at any age. In my opinion it breaks the babies try in you and the bond between you and baby.



CIO is NOT easy by any means, but I truly believe it is MUCH harder on Mommy than baby. But comments like these go straight to my heart after having a night where we had to CIO again.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Shannon - don't let comments like this one even get to you. The poster doesn't have a child old enough to do CIO - so until you are in another persons shoes it is very hard to judge! You know you are doing the right thing for your DS and that's all that matters! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Diana- Thank you so much! I really appreciate the support b/c I do logically know that it is best for MY DS, but sometimes it's very hard when I start to question my decisions as his mommy. Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/08 10:38 AM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: opinions on CIO

Posted by eroxgirl

Definitely too young.

DD is 11 months and I still can't bring myself to CIO. I probably never will.

When she was as young as your DC, we would put her down at bedtime which was about 8:00, but then we gave her a "dream feed" before we went to bed around 10-11:00 to help her sleep a little longer. It helped us get her to sleep a 5 hour stretch vs. a 3 hour stretch.



I agree - too young IMO. DS is 9 months and I attempted CIO twice last week and we both failed miserably. Then we were traveling this past weekend so I put it on hold and to be honest with you, I don't know if I will attempt it again until he is closer to the 1 year mark like some other posters have said or he is done with being rocked to sleep.

We did something similar to what Rebecca did - put him down at around 9:00 after a bottle and he would sleep at least 6 hours, waking once for about 5 minutes for a quick feeding.

Posted 12/17/08 10:38 AM
 

S00N2BEAMOM
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/07

390 total posts

Name:

Re: opinions on CIO

My son wasn't sleeping throught the night yet at 13weeks and what we did was pushed back his bedtime and try to make his last feeding a bigger one 5-6ozs. It worked better for us because it enabled us to get more sleep when he was sleeping. At first he was going to sleep at 8pm and waking up at 2am. We now give him his last bottle around 9:45 and we try to get him to take at least 6oz he'll usually do between 6-8hrs ...if he wakes in the night we will not give him anymore than a 4oz bottle. He's been sleeping through the night 2 out of 3 times. Good luck you will get there eventually!

Message edited 2008-12-17 10:56:41.453000.

Posted 12/17/08 10:56 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Opinions needed - CIO related missrock 6/11/07 1 Parenting
BTDT moms- need opinions on CIO! casey31 4/29/07 22 Parenting
need opinions on planning trip for out of state wedding Myrockette 3/24/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
So, I need opinions... LIPrincess 3/23/06 9 TTC
decided to at least start pumping...questions and opinions? mable 3/22/06 12 Parenting
Need your opinions ladies!! CityNYGirl 3/22/06 9 TTC