Thoughts on an only child....

Forum Opinion Poll
I was one- I loved it! 3 5.36%
I was one- I hated it! 8 14.29%
I would never do it- the child will be lonely/spoiled, etc... 26 46.43%
I want a large family. 14 25.00%
We are only having 1 child for financial reasons. 2 3.57%
We are only having 1 child for medical reasons. 3 5.36%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Only Child-Poll

Posted By Message

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Only Child-Poll

Hi, Does anyone have just one child? Do you plan on more? What are your thoughts on raising an "only"?

Posted 2/10/07 10:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I'm really close with my brother, so I really wanted at least 2 kids. But I do not think that being an only child equals being spoiled or lonely. There are plenty of spoiled kids with sibs, and I'm sure there are also kids with sibs who don't have similar interests who feel lonely.

Posted 2/10/07 10:27 PM
 

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Only Child-Poll

I'll go first...

We only have 1 child right now. To be honest, I never thought about how many children I wanted. I just knew I wanted a baby.

We get comments from people on a daily basis as to when we are having baby #2. We don't know if and when we may have another. I am 34. my husband is 37.

I love my DD more than anything esle in the world, but motherhood is the toughest job ever! I don't know if I can handle it again. I also really enjoy the one-on-one time that I have with her.

People tell us- if she is an only child- she will be bored,lonley,spoiled and feel cheated. They also say that she won't have any family when we die- and will be all alone...(nice thought)..

We decided we will discuss the matter again when DD is 4- right now, who knows!!!


*****The negatives I mentioned-(lonely,spoiled,etc) are not my opinion- but what other people have said to me.

Message edited 2007-02-10 22:34:27.310000.

Posted 2/10/07 10:30 PM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: Only Child-Poll

I dunno maybe its silly- but I dont think its fair to just have one...

What happens when you and your DH pass away- siblings need eachother to get through times like that...Chat Icon

Posted 2/10/07 10:34 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I grew up as one of 6, so I only knew a large family and want one for myself. I have 2 and I see another, but I am not sure DH is there with me yet. I don't believe that onlies are spoiled, etc., they can be exceptional children. But it was just not for us.

Posted 2/10/07 10:40 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Only Child-Poll

Im very much a people person, so I feel that it's almost unfair to put someone in a situation to grow up with no siblings.

Im one of 4 and loved growing up with brothers and my twin sister.

I love big families and see no number too big Chat Icon Chat Icon

I dont think that only children are necessarily spoiled (although my hubby happened to be Chat Icon)

My mom was an only child and hated every minute. longed for siblings her whole life. Now she's surrounded by her 4 kids, S&DILs, and 8 grandchildren.

I dont think there's a wrong or right or what should or shouldnt be done, & I do thank God for blessing me with my children. I absolutely would have considered adoption if I would have had trouble TTcing.

Having children was and will always be the most important thing in my life.

Posted 2/10/07 10:47 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Only Child-Poll

I agree with you that child rearing is the most difficult job in the world as well as being the most rewarding. I have one at the moment and plan on having another. A friend of mine is an only child and her mom is very sick at the moment. She is making all the decisions about her moms health issues etc and its really wearing on her....she has said several times that she wishes she had a sibling to discuss this with and to share the responsibility of her mom. For this reason she is having four kids - she has three now.

Its a very personal decision and you do what is best for you and your family. I dont think an only child equals a child that is spoilt as my cousin is an only child and is in no way spoilt and I have a friend with a 5 year old only child who is the most well behaved child you could imagine.

I know when I was growing up it was nice to have siblings to complain to when my parents were driving me nuts so I would like my DD to have that opportunity tooChat Icon

Posted 2/10/07 11:31 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Only Child-Poll

Posted by Princessmaris

I dunno maybe its silly- but I dont think its fair to just have one...

What happens when you and your DH pass away- siblings need eachother to get through times like that...Chat Icon




I agree!

Posted 2/10/07 11:33 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Only Child-Poll

My answer is not on your poll, so I will just say that I want two children, but not because I think only children are spoiled and lonely, just because that's what I want to complete our family.

Posted 2/10/07 11:34 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

Posted by prncssrachel

My answer is not on your poll, so I will just say that I want two children, but not because I think only children are spoiled and lonely, just because that's what I want to complete our family.




I agree. Also there is a thing called secondary infertility when you cannot have another one. God willing I would love to give Victoria a sibling but if not I am thrilled to just have her Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/07 7:58 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

Posted by Princessmaris

I dunno maybe its silly- but I dont think its fair to just have one...

What happens when you and your DH pass away- siblings need eachother to get through times like that...Chat Icon




I was only going to have 1 child after my terrible pregnancy with Damien.

When a close friend (only child) of mine lost both her parents with in a two year period I decided we would have another. She really wished she had a sibling to go through it with.

Of course now I am thrilled with our little girlChat Icon

Posted 2/11/07 8:46 AM
 

krashnburn
I am Batman!

Member since 5/05

4093 total posts

Name:
I'm Batman, I tell you!

Re: Only Child-Poll

I didn't vote because I am one and I loved it and hated it. I loved it because I got all the attention and was bit spoiled. I never had to worry about sharing (which honestly I guess carried over to adulthood because I had a really hard time in the college dorm learning to have people taking/using my stuff. Thank goodness I did this or DH would have left me when we moved in together.) But I also hated it. At nights and one rainy days when I couldn't play with the neighborhood kids, I was bored. I became an avid reader at a young age--which turned out to be a good thing, in my opinion. I would like to have another after this one, so they have someone else, but it's not too crazy. DH has one sib an thought that was perfect.


ETA AFter reading above posts, I want to clarify "spolied". I was spoiled in the sense that I was able to get what I wanted from family members on holidays and birthdays. I did not get what I wanted all the time as we had no money or car or anything when I was growing up. My mom always compares me to other children and says you were never like that, you were always well behaved and well mannered. She also comments on how I was so good at enteraining myself she never thought I looked like I was missing anything.

Message edited 2007-02-11 09:12:02.903000.

Posted 2/11/07 9:05 AM
 

mishy
My Girls

Member since 10/05

2427 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I am an only child and was fine during my childhood but both of my parents passed away before I turned 21, my dad when I was 11 and my mom when I was 21, so yes I don't have any siblings to lean on, and on the other hand I have had an extremely difficult pregnancy which mentally I don't know if I can go through again. So I am still up in the air if we will try in a few years.. I know my DH will want to..

Posted 2/11/07 9:08 AM
 

luvmiboy
I love my sister!!!!!!

Member since 3/06

2100 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Only Child-Poll

Posted by MelTodd604

Posted by Princessmaris

I dunno maybe its silly- but I dont think its fair to just have one...

What happens when you and your DH pass away- siblings need eachother to get through times like that...Chat Icon




I agree!



me too!

Posted 2/11/07 9:45 AM
 

JD02
LIF Infant

Member since 5/06

344 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Only Child-Poll

I agree with this too. I lost my father to cancer 18 months ago, and six months after he passed away my mother was diagnosed with cancer. My brother, sister and I rely on each other completely. I can't imaging going through this without them. Especially after one parent passes away, the caregiving and decision-making rests with the children -- which can be completely overwhelming with three of us - I can not imagine doing it alone. But I understand my situation is unique.

Also, growing up I loved having siblings. I also think its easier having more than one child as they get older because they can occupy each other (so many people have told me this).

Posted 2/11/07 10:33 AM
 

-Laurie-
Hi!

Member since 5/05

2536 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I'd love to give Jack a sibling, but I'm about to throw in the towel since we are suffeing thru Secondary If, I can get pregnant very easily but I have trouble sustaining the pregnancies and after 4 miscarriages and alot of testing they can't find a reason.
Physically and Emotionally I can't continue to keep getting pregnant and losing them. We're going to give it one or two more chances but after that I'm about ready to say "when"

Posted 2/11/07 10:50 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I know only children who are really happy and well adjusted and have a strong social network. More effort has to be made to create that, but I think it can be done.

I am 35 and my baby is due next month. Ideally, I want her to have a sibling, but between my age and some other factors, it may not happen.

I have 2 brothers and luckily I have a good relationship with them and their wives. But I also have family members who are estranged from their siblings, so I don't believe that giving your child a sibling means that he/she has a friend for life. It's great when you have strong sibling relationships, but it's heartbreaking when you don't. In the end, it's a very personal decision with a lot of factors.

Posted 2/11/07 11:49 AM
 

antoinette
boy mamma

Member since 5/05

2975 total posts

Name:
Antoinette

Re: Only Child-Poll

WE have been contemplating this alot- I love my BRyan to peices and he is a greatkid but honestly being a mom is so hard and finacially its hard for us too. Dh doesnt have a great paying job which is why I had to go back to work. Its hard with the baby in daycare I cant imagine adding another one to the mix right now . Me and my brother are 7 years apart and I always thought I never wanted to have my children so far apart in age but it looks like we may be in that situation. I def think we are going to have another one but I think we are going for the 4 or 5 year separation in age. For me growing up wasnt too bad- I grew up almost as an only child- got lots of attention and was spoiled a little. Then my brother came around when I was 7 and it was no big thing for me cause I was happy to have a little baby to take care of. Its a really hard decision to make.

Posted 2/11/07 11:58 AM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: Only Child-Poll

My perspective is a little different. I always wanted two children and never thought much more about. When my oldest approached 3 we started trying but had real difficulty. Its hard to explain that during that period I really had to think about what I wanted and how far I was willing to go to accomplish it.

I am one of two and although my sister and I were never best friends growing up we are now. I know that's not always the case. Having a sister has made dealing with the issues of aging parents and illness SO much easier and less isolating. In addition, the fact that my children have cousins who are almost siblings is truly a blessing that I (not a religious person at all) thank God for everyday.

I think when considering whether to add more children to our families we sometimes get bogged down in the "small" stuff. That is why I waited until my daughter was almost 3 to start trying. This was a mistake and when I look back now I see that the "problems" I thought existed (daycare, career, etc..) were just things that needed to be worked out. My experience is this stuff always gets resolved.

I know this is a really hard decision and I wish you luck and peace whatever you decide.

Posted 2/11/07 12:14 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Only Child-Poll

I answered that I was one and I loved it which was mostly true growing. It never really bothered me. There are many time I only want to have Miranda. I think part of that is because I'm an only child so I'm not sure how you love another baby (I know you do I just can't fathom it yet).
Anyway now that I am an adult (actually as an older teenager) is when I wished I had a sibling. My parents are divorced and my mom has a lot of health and financial problems and the burden falls on only me. A lot of the stress has caused us to have a real love/hate relationship. Also I wish I had nieces and nephews of my own, not just DH's but that won't happen either. I know that eventually we will have another baby because I do love being a mother and I want DD to have siblings. I'm just not quite sure when I'll be ready. Hopefully after she's 2 as planned.

Posted 2/11/07 12:49 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do you think it is strange if your mom or mil took money for watching your child? LIMOMx2 10/29/06 22 Parenting
Help! Anybody else have a child that did sleep through the night and stopped at 3 mos old cloddy 9/20/06 9 Parenting
OK - I need some fun ... who has the baldest child (inspired by PrincessRachel)? KAS 8/17/06 26 Parenting
At what age did your child take 8oz. of formula Spring Baby06 8/10/06 13 Parenting
How much do you spend when your child goes to a b.day party? / with poll Dani00518 6/12/06 13 Parenting
Do any teachers have any suggestions for what to do for the child that just doesn't care? VirginiaDeb 11/6/05 5 Families Helping Families ™