Ok, really... I need help

Posted By Message

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Ok, really... I need help

Alex stole again. She brought over a little doll to me tonight and asked me to braid its hair. When I asked where it came from, she took it back from me and said NEVER MIND and ran away. Long story short, she took it from school and snuck it in her backpack. It wasn't an innocent act - she knew it was wrong, that's why she snuck it in her backpack.

I don't know what to do. Last time I took away all her books, moved her TV out of her room, and she had no TV/Movie/Computer or Books for an entire week.

Obviously that didn't teach her a damn thing and clearly I'm not going about this the right way. Before I lose my mind entirely, please, someone, give me some words of wisdom and reassure me that my child isn't turning into a total delinquent Chat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 6:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Do you think it might be attention seeking? She steals, doesn't really hide what she stole from you but then gets attention because you reprimand?

When you took away her things, did you give them back or did you have her earn them back? Instead of it being a "time frame" type of punishment; make it a consequential punishment and she had to earn her privledge back.

Way back when I used to do Behavioral Mod, a big factor in trying to change behavior was realizing that behavior stems from either avoiding something you don't want or getting something you do want. Something is reinforcing her behavior and that reinforcer is what you have to get rid of. I would work on that. I would also institute 20 minutes of one on one time with her to do anything she wants. Undivided attention that is provided no matter what. Those were some of the things we did to help modified behavior. Maybe it will help.

Posted 1/17/11 7:12 PM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Ok, really... I need help

I would probably speak with the school counselor since this behavior is happening at school. They might be able to work with her, and you, to come to a solution. Good luckChat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 7:23 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

I'd just have her return it to school, apologize to the teacher (or whoever seems appropriate), and "write" a letter of apology (you write her words, she signs her name).

She's definitely NOT turning into a delinquent. It's a phase. Chat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 7:38 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by morgie124

Do you think it might be attention seeking? She steals, doesn't really hide what she stole from you but then gets attention because you reprimand?

When you took away her things, did you give them back or did you have her earn them back? Instead of it being a "time frame" type of punishment; make it a consequential punishment and she had to earn her privledge back.

Way back when I used to do Behavioral Mod, a big factor in trying to change behavior was realizing that behavior stems from either avoiding something you don't want or getting something you do want. Something is reinforcing her behavior and that reinforcer is what you have to get rid of. I would work on that. I would also institute 20 minutes of one on one time with her to do anything she wants. Undivided attention that is provided no matter what. Those were some of the things we did to help modified behavior. Maybe it will help.

I am extremely impressed with your knowledge!!! This is a beautifully written response, and I agree with this!!!

Posted 1/17/11 7:43 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by morgie124

Do you think it might be attention seeking? She steals, doesn't really hide what she stole from you but then gets attention because you reprimand?

When you took away her things, did you give them back or did you have her earn them back? Instead of it being a "time frame" type of punishment; make it a consequential punishment and she had to earn her privledge back.

Way back when I used to do Behavioral Mod, a big factor in trying to change behavior was realizing that behavior stems from either avoiding something you don't want or getting something you do want. Something is reinforcing her behavior and that reinforcer is what you have to get rid of. I would work on that. I would also institute 20 minutes of one on one time with her to do anything she wants. Undivided attention that is provided no matter what. Those were some of the things we did to help modified behavior. Maybe it will help.

I am extremely impressed with your knowledge!!! This is a beautifully written response, and I agree with this!!!



Maybe she is attention seeking - DH isn't around as much because he's working on the house, so it's pretty much her, YaYa and me on the weekends. And she has been talking quite a bit lately about how much she's going to miss her school and teachers when she goes to Kindergarten, and lately she has been crying that she doesn't want to move houses.

We did a week of no TV, Movies, Computer or books, but slowly introduced it back as she "earned" it back from good behavior.

So, I had a long talk with her tonight and explained that we all make mistakes and what is important is to make the mistake "right". I asked what she thought she could do to make it "right" and she said she would give the doll back to the teacher and tell the truth, that it wasn't hers. She told me she was jealous because she liked the doll and wanted it, so I explained how hurt she would be if someone took one of her toys, and told her that she can't take things, but has to do good things to earn her own money so she can buy them for herself.

So, I took away her books again and some of her toys and explained that she has to earn them back with good behavior. We put the doll in her backpack tonight, and she is going to give it back.

This is a rough patch... and I don't like it!

Posted 1/17/11 7:51 PM
 

Katie111806
Team Pink!

Member since 12/06

5349 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Ok, really... I need help

When I was in kindergarten, I took lima beans that we used as Bingo markers from school. I thought they were so cool and loved how they unpeeled. When I got home from school I wouldn't let my mom help me change into my play clothes because I knew I stole them and didn't want her to see them in my pockets. Of course she knew something was up and she discovered them. She gave me a stern talking to and made me go to school the next day, lima beans in hand and apologize to my teacher. Of course she had called my teacher in advance to let her know to expect me to approach her and to insure I did it. I was so embarrassed and really learned a lesson. I've never "stolen" again and think about day the often. Was such a simple lesson but really had an impact on me. Maybe make her do something similar?
I assure you I didn't turn out to be a deliquent and your little girl won't either...I am sure it is just a phase!

Posted 1/17/11 8:00 PM
 

littlebeanz
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

1667 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

I would make her return it and say she is sorry to the child and teacher. I think that may help, shes not going to want to do it but I would have her do it anyway!

Posted 1/17/11 8:06 PM
 

Denise
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/09

572 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: Ok, really... I need help

How old is DD?

Posted 1/17/11 8:18 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by Denise

How old is DD?



5

Posted 1/17/11 8:48 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

No real advice but I bet its a phase. I did something like this when I was a kid, but I never shop lifted later or stole anything, I'm not a delinquent or anything either Chat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 9:08 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Posted by morgie124

Do you think it might be attention seeking? She steals, doesn't really hide what she stole from you but then gets attention because you reprimand?

When you took away her things, did you give them back or did you have her earn them back? Instead of it being a "time frame" type of punishment; make it a consequential punishment and she had to earn her privledge back.

Way back when I used to do Behavioral Mod, a big factor in trying to change behavior was realizing that behavior stems from either avoiding something you don't want or getting something you do want. Something is reinforcing her behavior and that reinforcer is what you have to get rid of. I would work on that. I would also institute 20 minutes of one on one time with her to do anything she wants. Undivided attention that is provided no matter what. Those were some of the things we did to help modified behavior. Maybe it will help.

I am extremely impressed with your knowledge!!! This is a beautifully written response, and I agree with this!!!



Maybe she is attention seeking - DH isn't around as much because he's working on the house, so it's pretty much her, YaYa and me on the weekends. And she has been talking quite a bit lately about how much she's going to miss her school and teachers when she goes to Kindergarten, and lately she has been crying that she doesn't want to move houses.




BETH!!!

This right here answers it all.

She is anxious about all the changes, so she is holding onto things. She will miss school, so she is taking somehting home from school to hold onto it!

ETA - I used to steal; things from my dad on his weekends. I didn't want to leave him to go back home to my mom. I was 6.

Message edited 2011-01-17 21:16:57.277000.

Posted 1/17/11 9:16 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Ok, well I feel just awful Chat Icon Poor doodle...

Posted 1/17/11 9:29 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by Bxgell2

Ok, well I feel just awful Chat Icon Poor doodle...

Don't feel awful Chat Icon

This is how she needs to learn how to work through her stuff. With your help!!!

Posted 1/17/11 9:34 PM
 

LadyBoo
LIF Zygote

Member since 12/10

41 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

I'll out myself here -

I went through a "phase" like that when I was about 7.


It had nothing to do with attention - I actually got too much attention. I knew it was wrong, but I saw something I wanted and I just took it.
I feel pretty bad for my parents now. I'm still not sure exactly what I was thinking.

Hang in there... you will laugh about it in 20 years!!!
Chat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 10:35 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Posted by InShock

I'd just have her return it to school, apologize to the teacher (or whoever seems appropriate), and "write" a letter of apology (you write her words, she signs her name).

She's definitely NOT turning into a delinquent. It's a phase. Chat Icon



I agree with this. that little bit of embarrassment of having to tell the teacher what she did, may help curb the behaviorChat Icon

Posted 1/17/11 10:38 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Ok, really... I need help

First of all....I don't think her behavior is all that abnormal for a 5 year old...and especially not for a 5 year old about to go through a pretty big life change. So I don't think you need to worry about bailing her out of jail when she's 12 just yet. Chat Icon
Second of all....I think I have a pretty different parenting style than you do, so you can ignore everything I have to say...but I just wanted to share my perspective. Chat Icon

The first thing that jumps out to me about your post is that she's gotten a lot of punishment for stealing this doll....
1. she knows you're disappointed with her (I know for my daughter, that's the worst punishment ever....)
2. She lost her books
3. She lost some toys
4. She disappointed her teacher
5. She's going to be embarrassed at school

And that's all on top of having to move the only home she's ever known! That's a lot for a 5 year old to handle!

I know that your parenting is very strict, and I admire that in you....but I also think you need to be aware that this is a difficult time for her. You and your husband have chosen to move, and her world changes because of that. She has no control over it, and if there's one thing I know about kids....it's that they want control! You also said your husband isn't around all that much...so she misses her daddy. I think perhaps easing up on the punishments (not eliminating them....just lessening them) until she's in the new house and comfortable might be an idea.

I was also thinking that since she's clearly created connections to the house and to her school....maybe work with her to think of something she can take from each of these places to bring with her to the new house. Talk with the teacher and see if there is a special place she likes in the classroom, or a favorite book she has from school....and see if she can take that when she leaves.
Talk to her about her favorite place in your current house and see what she can bring with her as a keepsake....so that she knows that while she might be leaving those places....she'll have something she can keep with her always.

She's clearly letting you know that something is going on with her new behavior. I think it's important that you keep communication lines open with her....and I worry that if there are so many punishments, she might not be as open for fear of the possible punishments.

I hope that made some sense.....and maybe helps a bit.

Posted 1/17/11 11:30 PM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, really... I need help

IDK, but it seems like a very severe punishment for a five year old. You want to keep her afraid of punishment. I am worried that the length and severity will harden or desensitize her to it. I would just have her return the doll to school with an apology letter.

Posted 1/18/11 8:02 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ok, really... I need help

Everyone's input is very helpful - thank you! I think I needed this, to talk it out, and figure out exactly what's going on here.

I agree, that perhaps the punishment is too severe, and that I have to find a good balance here, between supporting her and giving her the safety net that she so clearly needs right now, and disciplining her, to some degree, so that she knows this behavior is unacceptable.

So, we packed the doll in her bag and she is going to return it to the teacher today and tell the truth. I'm calling the teacher in a few hours to give her a heads up. Tonight, when Alex comes home, if she gave the doll back and apologized, then I'm going to bring her toys, TV, etc, back into her room, and tell her it's because she earned them back for apologizing and handling the situation like a big girl.

And I agree with everyone, clearly I need to spend some more one-on-one time with Alex to ease this transition for her. I found it incredulous to think she was so upset about kindergarten and moving THIS early. None of this is happening for months ahead, but then again, this is ALEX. She has always been a particularly precocious child, who thinks well ahead.

The good news is we have a vacation coming up next week, so we'll have a lot of family time then. And, afterwards, I'm going to schedule some fun days, with just me and her, which she's been asking for, and also ask DH to take a day or two off with her. I'm going to schedule a visit with her at the new school, and will go buy some books that we can read at night about the transition.

Thanks for the ideas and input everyone -it certainly helped to open my eyes to a problem I wasn't necessarily seeing at first glance Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/11 8:25 AM