ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

ok, can i ask a question about TV?

im SURE this has been discussed a million times on here already but as a new mom i'm going to start the discussion again! Chat Icon

why are so many people against letting their kids watch tv? i mean, i totally understand not plopping your kid in front of the tv for 5 hours, but i dont see anything wrong with letting them watch tv while mommy cleans, cooks, pays bills online -- whatever she needs to get done

i let DS watch some baby einstien (sp) dvds -- he loves them!

i've heard one reason is that tv causes autism & adhd -- both of which IMO i dont agree with... but i know nothing past that!

Posted 12/9/10 12:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Alll I know if it wasn't for Baby Einstein videos I would never shower, my house would be even messier than it already is, and she would never have a bottle made or her laundry done!

I'm all for it!

Posted 12/9/10 12:59 PM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

If it wasnt for Yo Gabba Gabba, I'd be dead!

Posted 12/9/10 1:00 PM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by BethanyLynn

If it wasnt for Yo Gabba Gabba, I'd be dead!



LOL!! my SIL says the same thing!! Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 1:00 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

For me-I just don't think that flashing color images is a good thing for my kid to be exposed to.

Also, it's not interactive so it can impact their communication skills. The TV characters do not react to anything you kids says/does s(smile, laugh, babble, etc).

The AAP recommends no TV below 2. We adhered to that for DD. Now at 3, she watched 1 or 2 shows during the week and a lot more on the weekends. I hate it.

DS-well, he watches more than we would like because his sister is watching.

Posted 12/9/10 1:02 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

God Bless the TV

We both work and when she was a newborn I worked later hours and got home late. If not for TV our world would come crushing down, my marriage would be in shambles and I think I would have had a nervous breakdown.

We watch TV together and she loves the educational tapes as well as f'in Barney *hate* and used to be into yo gabba gabba, sid the science kid and sesame street. Now adays its Barney, Cat in the Hat knows a lot about that, Wiggles and Blues Clues.

meh poohey on those who say ADHD and whatever. I find it hard to believe JUST TV does it. Altho AJ loves her TV when we come home its not on and she doesnt care. She gets plenty of outdoor time, craft time and has lately taken to eating in her kitchen table which can not view the TV so obviously she's a 'lucky one' i guess. haha

Posted 12/9/10 1:05 PM
 

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by BethanyLynn

If it wasnt for Yo Gabba Gabba, I'd be dead!



GOD BLESS YO GABBA GABBA!!!

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 1:09 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I like watching TV, so does DH, and I see nothing wrong with letting DS watch it too. He doesn't watch any TV during the day while the nanny is there and in the evenings he watches movies like Cars, Nemo and Shrek (one of his favorites!) while I am cooking dinner. On the weekends he watches morning cartoons and that's about it. My philosophy regarding TV is to each his/her own - I don't care if you don't let your kids watch any TV at all, or 80 hours a week, just don't comment on how much or how little TV my kids watch Chat Icon

Oh and FTR, this past weekend DS actually watched the Food Network with me (he loves to watch "cooking" Chat Icon) and then, of all things, Coraline, which he was fascinated by. I like to think I am expanding his horizons Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 1:10 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Sesame Street is a God send in our house. It's the only show DD (18 months) will pay full attention to. Gives me some time to focus on my DS (5 months) without being interrupted.
Other than that though, there's not much tv watching going on other than being on in the background.

I don't have a problem with the television.

Posted 12/9/10 1:16 PM
 

Livysmom
LIF Toddler

Member since 10/10

392 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Luckily for us DD has never showed too much interest in TV, except for that show Fresh Beat Band. She loves the singing i guess. Its the only show that she sits and watches and and does not move a muscle for the entire show. Once its over she s back to running around. She doesnt watch tv at daycare and even on the weekends she could care less. She'd rather be running around destroying my house. Chat Icon Fine with me!

Posted 12/9/10 1:18 PM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

This is an area that I feel very strongly about. I am a licensed school psychologist with a Master's in Education and a Mom...none which make me an expert, but they all contributed to helping me for my opinion on the issue. I don't like subjecting a young brain to the images, colors, lights, movement, sounds, linguistics etc. all at one time. It requires cognitive processing beyond the capacity of an infant's brain. In addition I think that all commercials are horrible for a young mind to absorb, as are the millions of messages, values, norms and behaviors that are aired. Several studies have shown that TV does NOT help babies in their development...even Baby Einstein. It's for the convenience of the parent, albeit a necessity at some points. Many studies also show a deleterious effect on a child's development. Here are a couple out of thousands of studies. Although it's important to remember that all studies have inherent flaws....the AAP would not make a recommendation based on a body of benign literature.

http://archpedi.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/short/164/12/1105?rss=1
Lowers Cognitive Development
Time/CNN Review of Study
Increases in Aggressive Behavior of 3 Year Olds

Link to Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine....Run a Search Using "Television" as keyword

Message edited 2010-12-09 14:45:50.753000.

Posted 12/9/10 1:21 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I think TV is like junk food-- some people don't allow any, some people allow it in small doses, and some people let the habit get out of control.

Posted 12/9/10 1:27 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

The tv is on in my house all day. DS doesn't care too much for it. He will sit through Blues Clues and some Sesame Street shows. It gives me a chance to get things done when I need too. Aside from that, he plays. The tv is on the weather channel a lot. He loves the music. He can play by himself and with me or hubby with the tv on, and it doesn't even phase him. Can't keep him in a bubble. The tv is always going to be an issue with some people. But if you are at someone else's house and the tv is on, what can you do?

Posted 12/9/10 1:33 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I think a lot of it is b/c people just dont' know how to do things in moderation - so a study comes out saying 'too much TV is bad for your kid" and people take it to the extreme and never put the TV on -

My son has been watching TV since he's born - My husband is the type that walks into the house and the 1st thing he does it put the TV on -So, he knows every show on Nick Jr. - He loves football, basketball and soccer games - He loves to watch my husband play the stupid Xbox ---

At 16 months he was speaking w/ a ridiculous vocabulary, and at 18 months in 3-4 work phrases, and now (19 moutns, sentences -

His communication skills are perfectly fine. His phycial skills are perfectly fine - He can whack a wiffle ball off of a T, hit a golf ball w/ a club and dribble a soccer ball -

He can eat with utensils, knows when to say Please, thank you and excuse me

He can put together a puzzle, he can name the simple shapes, he knows characters and names and animals and their corresponding sounds - he remembers the words and melody and sings songs - he loves his books -


He also makes a mad dash for the Living room the second he hears the Yo Gabba Gabba song -

Trust me, the TV has NOT rotten the kid's brain !!!

Posted 12/9/10 2:12 PM
 

DomesticDeeva
Tiebreaker on deck!!!

Member since 11/08

2088 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I am not against it for certain shows, like Yo Gabba Gabba, Fresh Beats (his 2 favs), sesame Street andSid the Science Kid. However, I dont let him watch Gossip Girl and Real Housewives with me.Chat Icon Or DH's violent video games. The channels that he does watch don't have commercials either.

He never just sits and stares @ the TV. He'll play and look up when a song or dance comes on.and I truly do feel like he is learning. IMO, I completely disagree that the shows are not interactive. He repeats after Moose and Zee's lessons, sings and dances with YGG and Fresh Beats. I see him developing memorization skills b/c shows that he has seen several times, he knows what is coming next, and does it or says it before they do. And when the weather is nice, he'd rather be outside playing.

To each his own, but I'm fine with my kids watching TV, in moderation of course.

Posted 12/9/10 2:19 PM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by CrankyPants

For me-I just don't think that flashing color images is a good thing for my kid to be exposed to.

Also, it's not interactive so it can impact their communication skills. The TV characters do not react to anything you kids says/does s(smile, laugh, babble, etc).

The AAP recommends no TV below 2. We adhered to that for DD. Now at 3, she watched 1 or 2 shows during the week and a lot more on the weekends. I hate it.

DS-well, he watches more than we would like because his sister is watching.



same reasons and i think they get more out of playing then watching. my 3 1/2 yr old gets maybe an hour or two a month (except if sick). i do let him watch leapster educational dvd's occasionally though.

my younger ds 1 1/2 watches when his brother does. i always feel guilty though.Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 2:22 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I was very strict no tv before one year.

and now, he's not really interested. he'd much rather run aroudn the house playing or "discovering" things which is fine by me.

while I am cooking he plays on the floor or with his play kitchen, or with his father.

I realize that some people need the tv. it provides "safe" time frame for them to get things done and for the child to be so occupied that they can do what they need without worry. this is not the case for us though, so his tv is very limited.

it has backfired on me though, b/c he won't snuggle up to watch Christmas movies with me now Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: the tv is ON in our house. it's just usually the news or Jeopardy Chat Icon which is kinda fun b/c he watches us yell at the tv too Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-12-09 14:33:58.137000.

Posted 12/9/10 2:32 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

If it wasn't for Mickey Mouse Clubhouse, I'd never get to eat breakfast, shower, or straighten up in the morning. If it wasn't for Mickey Mouse Clubhouse and DVR, DH and I would never be able to eat dinner together.


I don't know that a 3mo old can have a "favorite", but I'll tell you.... his whole attitude changes once MMCH comes home. He squeals and screams and laughs and kicks.

Posted 12/9/10 2:33 PM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by BethanyLynn

If it wasnt for Yo Gabba Gabba, I'd be dead!



Same here....and I was one of those who said "I will never let my kid watch TV until they're older"

Ahhh...how things change Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/10 2:38 PM
 

sj-girl
Happy Family of 4

Member since 5/08

5654 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I turn the tv 2 times a day for DS. He doesn’t always watch it; however it does make getting ready for work and cooking dinner just a tiny bit easier. He will watch for maybe 5-10 minutes max and then isn’t interested.

Posted 12/9/10 2:48 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

i think this one is 'to each his own'...

and my own is simple - i cannot have a quiet house - it freaks me out. i have the TV on all day long, as long as i'm awake - it's on.

what damage has it done to Em? NONE....she only truly sits & watches Wow Wow Wubbzy and occasionally Olivia. Every other show she'll play and look up if something sounds fun (she really likes jack's big music show & spongebob). She knows colors, has a LOT of words (MANY of the shows are inter-active), LOVES music, animals, knows 'beats'. even when she's watching - if she sees something funny, she'll laugh & turn to me or Dave to see if we're laughing too. it's precious & she's remarkably happy.

my sister in law is the opposite - she only lets her daughter watch an hour of television a day. Due to that fact - if the TV is on in their house, Lyla is COMATOSE...her eyes glaze over and she's in a daze. she will not look away, etc. my sister in law constantly comments how she can't believe Em doesn't do that.....but TV Is not a novelty to my daughter...so it's not all that special to her.

Posted 12/9/10 2:48 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

please..w/o NICK Jr & Moose..i'd be insane. I have the TV on most of the day for background noise when Im home. DS can play play play and not even give the TV a look. WHen moose comes on..he will watch..LOL.

I dont think its terrible if he watches here and there, and at times I sit with him and sing with the songs, point stuff out, engage him, etc. Using the tv as a babysitter for hours, however, is not cool.

I do not think TV causes autism and ADHD.

Posted 12/9/10 3:02 PM
 

JP826
=)

Member since 9/06

10903 total posts

Name:
Me!! All about ME!

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by Jonsgirl04

Posted by BethanyLynn

If it wasnt for Yo Gabba Gabba, I'd be dead!



GOD BLESS YO GABBA GABBA!!!

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


AND

Dora

AND

Diego !

Posted 12/9/10 3:09 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

I have no issues with DD watching TV. I don't use it to entertain her though. She's just not that into it. I'll have the news on while we play, and she barely glances at it.

But, if there's music on TV, she is entranced! She loves music, not TV..she'll never sit there an watch..wouldn't bother me if she did. I've tried the kids shows..and she's not really into them. But, she loved the rockettes on TV!

Posted 12/9/10 3:13 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: ok, can i ask a question about TV?

Posted by MarisaK

I think a lot of it is b/c people just dont' know how to do things in moderation - so a study comes out saying 'too much TV is bad for your kid" and people take it to the extreme and never put the TV on -

My son has been watching TV since he's born - My husband is the type that walks into the house and the 1st thing he does it put the TV on -So, he knows every show on Nick Jr. - He loves football, basketball and soccer games - He loves to watch my husband play the stupid Xbox ---

At 16 months he was speaking w/ a ridiculous vocabulary, and at 18 months in 3-4 work phrases, and now (19 moutns, sentences -

His communication skills are perfectly fine. His phycial skills are perfectly fine - He can whack a wiffle ball off of a T, hit a golf ball w/ a club and dribble a soccer ball -

He can eat with utensils, knows when to say Please, thank you and excuse me

He can put together a puzzle, he can name the simple shapes, he knows characters and names and animals and their corresponding sounds - he remembers the words and melody and sings songs - he loves his books -


He also makes a mad dash for the Living room the second he hears the Yo Gabba Gabba song -

Trust me, the TV has NOT rotten the kid's brain !!!



I agree with this theory. It's like the whole what can I eat or not eat during pregnancy. Just because they tell you no booze, it doesn't mean a sip will harm the baby, or a bite of a tuna sandwich or a cold cut.
People always take things to the extreme one way or the other- but I tend to practice moderation in everything and it has always served me well.
My DD watches Baby Einstein but even that won't hold her attention more than 20 minutes tops- so it's not like she is parked in front of the TV all day.
And she is meeting all her milestones early. So I can't see what harm it is doing right now.
She is in daycare most days with no TV at all so a few minutes here and there at home to save my sanity isn't going to harm her at all.

Message edited 2010-12-09 15:15:58.070000.

Posted 12/9/10 3:15 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another interview question - What is a good question to ask them back before leaving? MrsM 6/11/07 5 Career
May I ask you a question? LIPrincess 2/8/06 18 Pregnancy
Can I ask a dumb question? Dani00518 11/16/05 7 Parenting
Can I ask a dumb question about the flu KPtoys 11/8/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Ok, I have to ask a question... LIPrincess 10/5/05 10 TTC
can i ask a silly question? Dee 6/27/05 7 TTC