Neighbors tree
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Neighbors tree My neighbors enormous tree just came down in my backyard. Who’s responsible? Not sure what to do. Message edited 2020-08-04 18:22:30.590000. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Neighbors tree You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 4:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything.
|
|
Posted 8/4/20 5:09 PM
|
|
|
Neighbors tree If it was caused by them cutting it down then they are responsible. If its an act of nature then your homeowners insurance would cover it. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 5:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 6:15 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time |
Posted 8/4/20 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by NervousNell Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time That is not true. If a limb over hangs on your property you can cut to the line. I always tell my neighbor when I am having it done before hand. They make sure they are home the day of and will usually tell the tree service to cut more., I.e. over the line. But that is my neighbors, you should speak with yours in the future. If the tree blocks the road your town may remove just that one though. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 8:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Your neighbor will tell you to pound sand, tree law is really specific. I am super sorry to say you are responsible to pay your deductible and remove trees that fall on your property, even your neighbors tree. I am not your attorney. NY tree law is not a joke. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 8:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by LSP2005 Your neighbor will tell you to pound sand, tree law is really specific. I am super sorry to say you are responsible to pay your deductible and remove trees that fall on your property, even your neighbors tree. I am not your attorney. NY tree law is not a joke. I don’t understand why State Farm said she was responsible. |
|
Posted 8/4/20 9:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time That is not true. If a limb over hangs on your property you can cut to the line. I always tell my neighbor when I am having it done before hand. They make sure they are home the day of and will usually tell the tree service to cut more., I.e. over the line. But that is my neighbors, you should speak with yours in the future. If the tree blocks the road your town may remove just that one though. Actually it varies by town so check before you go cutting anything! |
|
Posted 8/5/20 7:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree My in-laws garage was destroyed by neighbors tree, it was all on them. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 8:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by LSP2005 Your neighbor will tell you to pound sand, tree law is really specific. I am super sorry to say you are responsible to pay your deductible and remove trees that fall on your property, even your neighbors tree. I am not your attorney. NY tree law is not a joke. I don’t understand why State Farm said she was responsible. tree law is really specific. It goes back to the 1800s where a rich guy won a lawsuit over a poorer neighbor and everyone has been scr@wed since. She can call her town, but in general you are responsible for your own property and the trees that fall on them. The only way a neighbor would be responsible is if they had notice a tree was diseased and did not care for it. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 9:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by alli3131 Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time That is not true. If a limb over hangs on your property you can cut to the line. I always tell my neighbor when I am having it done before hand. They make sure they are home the day of and will usually tell the tree service to cut more., I.e. over the line. But that is my neighbors, you should speak with yours in the future. If the tree blocks the road your town may remove just that one though. Actually it varies by town so check before you go cutting anything! which town? In NY you can cut overhanging limbs on your property to just before the property line. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 9:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by LSP2005 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by LSP2005 Your neighbor will tell you to pound sand, tree law is really specific. I am super sorry to say you are responsible to pay your deductible and remove trees that fall on your property, even your neighbors tree. I am not your attorney. NY tree law is not a joke. I don’t understand why State Farm said she was responsible. tree law is really specific. It goes back to the 1800s where a rich guy won a lawsuit over a poorer neighbor and everyone has been scr@wed since. She can call her town, but in general you are responsible for your own property and the trees that fall on them. The only way a neighbor would be responsible is if they had notice a tree was diseased and did not care for it. Whose property was damaged? The rich or the poor guy? |
|
Posted 8/5/20 10:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Rich persons tree landed on poor person's house. If the tree had been diseased and the owner knew then tree owner can be liable. Also if you cut a tree limb it can't do damage to the main part of the tree. But in general in NY you can cut overhanging. In other states the laws differ. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 11:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree In my experience a couple of years ago, it is your responsibility for damages to your property when the neighbor's tree falls onto your property. Unless you can prove they were negligent and a reasonable person could have predicted the tree was sick and should have been removed. That is extremely hard to do. Otherwise, it is considered an "act of god" and you'll have to file your own insurance claim with deductible paid by you. Sorry. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 11:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by LSP2005 Posted by alli3131 Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time That is not true. If a limb over hangs on your property you can cut to the line. I always tell my neighbor when I am having it done before hand. They make sure they are home the day of and will usually tell the tree service to cut more., I.e. over the line. But that is my neighbors, you should speak with yours in the future. If the tree blocks the road your town may remove just that one though. Actually it varies by town so check before you go cutting anything! which town? In NY you can cut overhanging limbs on your property to just before the property line. Town of Babylon. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree Posted by alli3131 Posted by LSP2005 Posted by alli3131 Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by quasi3 Posted by xosweetiexo Posted by quasi3 You are. Call your insurance company or a tree removal company. Really? Ugh. I thought they would be since I heard you can’t trim back your neighbors branches or anything. I believe you can cut back branches that overhang your property. We’ve done it and so has my neighbor to our tree. Yep, we do it all the time That is not true. If a limb over hangs on your property you can cut to the line. I always tell my neighbor when I am having it done before hand. They make sure they are home the day of and will usually tell the tree service to cut more., I.e. over the line. But that is my neighbors, you should speak with yours in the future. If the tree blocks the road your town may remove just that one though. Actually it varies by town so check before you go cutting anything! which town? In NY you can cut overhanging limbs on your property to just before the property line. Town of Babylon. okay, so I looked at the town code https://ecode360.com/6593916?highlight=trees&searchId=20864606045974009#6593916 and the tree would either have to be designated as a historic tree, or in the public right of way, which means the town has an easement over the tree and then the tree is not your tree. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 12:11 PM
|
|
|
Neighbors tree Your property. Your responsibility. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 4:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Neighbors tree I'm in the opposite situation. Most of the tree is on my neighbor's property but it's my tree. |
|
Posted 8/5/20 5:02 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our neighbors tree just came down in our front yard- who to call? | Teachergal | 10/29/12 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| HELP - Our tree fell and now we have neighbors! | karacg | 9/13/06 | 15 | Home |
| My neighbors tree | ISpoilHim | 7/15/14 | 6 | Home |
| Neighbors tree ruining my fence | Skenney17 | 4/20/14 | 2 | Home |
| Neighbors tree issues how to approach? | JennZ | 3/3/11 | 12 | Home |
| Neighbors Tree just smashed our fence | SupportACop | 12/31/08 | 10 | Home |








