| Posted By |
Message |
CrankyPants
I'm cranky
 Member since 7/06 18178 total posts
Name: Mama Cranky
|
Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
I posted about this last week and many of you weighed in which I really appreciate
I can use more help-but it's a long one!
As a quick background-we wanted to ask my brother and SIL to be Owen's god parents. My brother is estranged from the rest of the family due to drama with my mother (which is more my mother's fault than anyone else's). Brother and SIL came to Claire's Christening and it was very awkward for everyone, they told me at the time that they could never go through that again which made me struggle with this decision this time.
So, we finally got up the gumption to ask them-figured that we shouldn't let the awkwardness of one day overshadow the role that we want them to fill in Owen's life.
We live OOS so I called them. My SIL said all the right things-she knows it would be a challenging day but she is honored, etc etc etc. My brother wasn't home at the time so I called him later that night and asked my SIL to prepare him so he can digest a little since he has a habit of saying the first thought that flies into his head.
When I talked to him last night it went worse than I expected I feel crappy that Owen's Christening is being marred but this family BS.
I guess what I wanted to hear from my brother is that he is touched to be asked but that his excitement is tempered by anxiety over the day but that we will figure it out. I could completely understand that.
Instead, he said he questions why we would even ask them knowing how awkward things are, why I would want to make Owen's day stressful, that he doesn't need to be a god father to make Owen special to him and that the role of god father doesn't mean much to him since he didn't have much of a relationship with his own god father. I hung up in tears-not mad at him but just sad.
I think his statement that the role of god father doesn't mean much to him is malarky. I know that just a couple years ago, before any of us had kids, I mentioned to him that I wanted them to be god parents to one of our future kids. At the time he was soooo touched. So, I think that what he is saying now he is saying because he is letting the anxiety and stress of dealing with my family get the better of him.
At the same time, I want the best for my kid and is someone who has the above attitude really the best for my kid? We are very close with them-my brother gave me away at my wedding and my SIL was my MOH. So, to not have them in this role would be very said for me.
He called me back about 15 minutes later and we talked some more, but I don't think it was enough time to change his attitude a lot. But, in the second call he said that if it means something to me, if the title of godfather is important to me and has significance to me, then he will make it work, deal with the day for us and for Owen.
I spent the rest of the night thinking through solutions. I had told my brother that we would do a small lunch afterwards, just the 4 of us (and the kids). But he said he couldn't do that and honestly, I don't think that is fair to the rest of the family and friends that want to be there.
However, what I was thinking might work is if the 4 of us (and kids) do a nice brunch before the church and then I let them off the hook for the after party. In my eyes, it's just accepting the reality of the situation and in separating the events I give everyone a big stress reliever.
Here is my lingering question: am I selling Owen short? Is he getting the short end of the stick here? He is my primary concern and in going with my brother and SIL am I selling him short in some way?
If you've gotten this far, I thank you.
|
Posted 4/15/10 9:04 AM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe
 Member since 9/05 32436 total posts
Name: Stephanie
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
I think a nice brunch before church sounds good
sorry you are going through all this, family drama sucks
|
Posted 4/15/10 9:07 AM
|
| |
|
dpli
Daylight savings :)
 Member since 5/05 13973 total posts
Name: D
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
Here's how I see it. The party is one day in your son's life. The role of a godfather will (hopefully) last the rest of his life. If your brother is the one you really want as your son's godfather, I would go with your plan for letting them off the hook for the party.
It stinks that it falls to you to accommodate everyone else for an event that should be a joyful day, but unfortunately family can put those demands on you at times. I think your situation is sort of like a wedding. There's a lot of BS you put up with sometimes with the planning and sometimes things go wrong on the day itself, but you're still going to marry your DH, KWIM? IMO, I sort of see this the same way.
And if people ask where the godparents are, I would just say they couldn't make the party and leave it at that.
|
Posted 4/15/10 9:32 AM
|
| |
|
mooshyboo
So Blessed!
 Member since 11/07 6297 total posts
Name: Christine
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
I am sorry you are going through this and Owen's Day could not be drama free. (although I know from experience first hand with Family Drama so I feel for you )
To make your Brother & SIL more comfortable (and your brother have less anxiety about the day) to have a brunch before hand for them ~ That sounds nice.
Good Luck!
Message edited 2010-04-15 09:45:12.180000. |
Posted 4/15/10 9:44 AM
|
| |
|
ali120206
2 Boys
 Member since 7/06 17796 total posts
Name:
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
I don't think you are selling Owen short if your brother is very special to you and will remain part of your life.
I like the idea though of doing a separate party and keeping them off the hook for the big family party. I think that will be a lot easier on them and on you.
|
Posted 4/15/10 10:02 AM
|
| |
|
Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)
 Member since 5/06 23378 total posts
Name: remember, when Gulliver traveled....
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
the only way you could be selling Owen short is if you don't believe that going forward your brother will adore him, be there for him, cherish him and be a good role model for him.
you are probably right about his reaction, so I wouldn't hold that against him.
if the first part of my post is true, then NO, you are absolutely NOT selling him short. not one bit.
the "day" while important, is NOT as important as every day for the rest of his life. if your brother will fulfill the "duties" of Godfather, no worries.
|
Posted 4/15/10 10:46 AM
|
| |
|
CrankyPants
I'm cranky
 Member since 7/06 18178 total posts
Name: Mama Cranky
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
Can I just say I love you guys? Thank you so much for reading through all of this and weighing in
|
Posted 4/15/10 10:58 AM
|
| |
|
twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥
 Member since 11/07 10116 total posts
Name: Gabi
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
I think that a brunch beforehand is a wonderful idea! And from what you posted, I think your brother and SIL are a great choice for Godparents. The day of the baptism is just a small morsel in DS's life. I don't think you are selling DS short at all!! Good luck!
|
Posted 4/15/10 6:11 PM
|
| |
|
Celt
~~~~~~~~~~
 Member since 4/08 7758 total posts
Name: colette
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
Yep it's unanimous (so far ). They only way you'd be "selling him short" would be to pick GPs because it's "convenient" and "less drama". That does no good for anyone, least of all your son.
I think you've handled this extraordinarily well, frankly. The brunch before with your Bro and SIL is perfect; and I'm certain your brother *IS* touched by the request; he probably just was caught off guard, maybe never expecting that due to the family situation. I secretly kinda LOVE that you're standing your ground and picking the GPs you want for Owen, I think it says a lot about who you are.
And don't forget in years to come this shite between him and your mom may be resolved, we have no way to know what will happen in the future. I can only hope that is the case for your family
|
Posted 4/15/10 7:16 PM
|
| |
|
Deeluvsvinny
DONE
Member since 10/08 4952 total posts
Name: Whatever
|
Re: Need your input-Baptism drama take 2
Posted by dpli
Here's how I see it. The party is one day in your son's life. The role of a godfather will (hopefully) last the rest of his life. If your brother is the one you really want as your son's godfather, I would go with your plan for letting them off the hook for the party.
It stinks that it falls to you to accommodate everyone else for an event that should be a joyful day, but unfortunately family can put those demands on you at times. I think your situation is sort of like a wedding. There's a lot of BS you put up with sometimes with the planning and sometimes things go wrong on the day itself, but you're still going to marry your DH, KWIM? IMO, I sort of see this the same way.
And if people ask where the godparents are, I would just say they couldn't make the party and leave it at that.
ITA!!!
|
Posted 4/15/10 7:21 PM
|
| |
|