need advice regarding promotion.

Posted By Message

needadvice11312
LIF Zygote

Member since 1/12

2 total posts

Name:

need advice regarding promotion.

Apologies in advance for the fake name. I need advice and privacy. I interviewed for a promotion in my company.

I have been there five years. Let's say I have a child.

One of the questions asked during the interview for the promotion was related to how the promotion will affect me being a mother, or rather, how I could basically manage doing the position while being a mother. Is this allowed to even be asked? It left a bad taste in my mouth.

I said that I wouldn't have applied for the promotion if I knew I couldn't fulfill the duties accordingly, and that I have a good support system for child care. Meanwhile, the current postion I already have makes it hard to juggle being a mother and an employee, but I have always done an excellent job, never once called out sick due to my child, and having a child has never held me back in my career. I believe I am well-regarded, and my reviews are excellent.

The second issue is that during the interview, they pointed out that I never volunteered to come in for overtime. In all honesty, I haven't. The people that usually do need the money, and I work well over 40 hours a week as it is, so I never thought to offer to do overtime. I never needed the extra money, and being there for so many hours a week as it is (over 40), I just never thought to do so. It seems this is a major factor in obtaining the position, that an applicant should have been doing this all along in order to get ahead. However, this was never stated prior to the opening of the position (otherwise, lots of applicants would have been doing so in order to get the spot and I'm certain that other applicants haven't volunteered to come in for overtime, either).

I left with a bad taste in my mouth. I need advice on what you think I should do if I get passed up this time. Do I start to volunteer for overtime and hope for the best when this opens up again? I'm also interested to see what you think of this scenario, especially the child question.

Thanks again, and sorry for the fake name.Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 1:49 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I would actually speak with HR.

If you have children and how they are cared for, etc is illegal to ask in an interview. If they pass over you for the job because you have children, that can be a form of sex-based discrimination. Are they asking men with children the same questions? Generally asking about children and childcare is a BIG no no, so I would actually address it with HR.

I know we have some HR professionals on the site who can give better answers than I can, but I know any questions are children are generally forbidden. Even though they already know you have kids, asking about it on a job makes it seem they're using it as a consideration, which they are not allowed to do.

Posted 1/4/12 1:54 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Honestly it sounds like you will be weeded out since you have a child. Unfortunate, but true in many cases. I wouldn't volunteer to work overtime either if I didn't need the money, and they didn't ask. Good luck!

Posted 1/4/12 1:56 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

It sounds very heavily weighted toward someone who lives in the office.

It may not be the job for you if that's how they are conducting the interviews.

They are also conducting their interviews in a way that could open them up to a discrimination claim.

Posted 1/4/12 2:02 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I was definitely taken aback that they asked you that in the interview. I mean... I guess they CAN ask you that, but I didn't think you were allowed to turn someone down for a job because they had a kid. Chat Icon I have no idea if that's true or what the nuances of that are, but the question sat wrong with me, too.

As far as the overtime, I can see their point. Will this new position require more overtime? Above and beyond the 40+ you already do? If so, I can definitely see that. And I don't think they were wrong in not telling you that you should be offering to do overtime. It's not required but it's nice to see. If they said "Hey everyone, do some overtime and get a promotion!" then everyone would be doing it and it would take away from the fact the person who has been volunteering to do it without any prodding.

Posted 1/4/12 2:02 PM
 

beanie571
:-P

Member since 5/07

2509 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

It sounds like the job is going to require a lot more hours than you are already working and they might be weeding you out because of that. It's not illegal to ask you about your children/childcare, but it's what they do with that info that can get them into trouble. However, it's extremely difficult to prove that they promoted someone else over you because you have kids.

Good luck! I hope it works out how you want it to.

Posted 1/4/12 2:49 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I wonder if they already know who they want in the position. I wouldn't bother to say anything to HR because they will point out what you said to the manager you are speaking of. Maybe you will get the promo, but I wouldn't do OT because that is no guarantee

Message edited 2012-01-04 15:41:58.843000.

Posted 1/4/12 3:41 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Posted by jilliibabii
As far as the overtime, I can see their point. Will this new position require more overtime? Above and beyond the 40+ you already do? If so, I can definitely see that. And I don't think they were wrong in not telling you that you should be offering to do overtime. It's not required but it's nice to see. If they said "Hey everyone, do some overtime and get a promotion!" then everyone would be doing it and it would take away from the fact the person who has been volunteering to do it without any prodding.



I agree.. the overtime and mom sit hand and hand.

My kid comes first. Period. I take very few sick days and put in extra hours (but I'm salary) that said they know they can send me out of state if necesssary for days on end because I have the ability to find care for my daughter. My daughter does not hold me back.

However, if I were hourly and never thought to put in overtime because A) my job was done B) seems wrong just to make some extra cash, then I'd say that. But if they THINK I'm not putting in extra time because the pay vs my child was the reason, I'd clarify. *IF* I needed to work overtime, I would. But I strive to work efficiently not just personally profitably but what which is best for my customers and my company which in turn is best for me and my growth with the company.

I don't think its WRONG to ask about motherhood since it DOES affect work for some. Not every mom is willing to work late often or be sent away all for a job. Some moms would rather not take a position if it invovles less time at home. Career may not be the main goal for moms but for some its only a necessity. For me, my career is my investment in myself and for my child as a roll model.

But every woman is different so it seems a valid question. Just as much as they should ask a single father. But reality is they woudln't ask a married father as a woman's duty as mom is assumed. Ironic, isn't it?

Posted 1/4/12 3:56 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Posted by Xelindrya

But reality is they woudln't ask a married father as a woman's duty as mom is assumed. Ironic, isn't it?




This is exactly why it's a potentially discriminatory question

Posted 1/4/12 3:58 PM
 

Elizabeth720
LIF Infant

Member since 10/05

192 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I am a HR Manager and this:

One of the questions asked during the interview for the promotion was related to how the promotion will affect me being a mother, or rather, how I could basically manage doing the position while being a mother. Is this allowed to even be asked? It left a bad taste in my mouth.

is completely inapproppriate and illegal to ask.

The legal, appropriate way for them to approach the subject with you is some version of the following:

This job will require you to work from X time - X time, plus X hours of overtime. Are you able to do that?



Posted 1/4/12 10:25 PM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Posted by Elizabeth720

I am a HR Manager and this:

One of the questions asked during the interview for the promotion was related to how the promotion will affect me being a mother, or rather, how I could basically manage doing the position while being a mother. Is this allowed to even be asked? It left a bad taste in my mouth.

is completely inapproppriate and illegal to ask.

The legal, appropriate way for them to approach the subject with you is some version of the following:

This job will require you to work from X time - X time, plus X hours of overtime. Are you able to do that?






EXACTLY. It is irrelevant why the applicant may or may not be free during the extra/over time hours. I would be really turned off by any job in general that is weeding out potential employees by asking these types of q's...

Posted 1/4/12 10:26 PM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

You could always email a follow-up repeating the question and maybe expanding on your answer. Perhaps, this would create a paper trail for you if you don't get the promotion. Also, perhaps it would scare them that they did something wrong and then they would be more likely to give it to you.

Posted 1/4/12 11:46 PM
 

EnV-McC
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/10

885 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by Xelindrya

But reality is they woudln't ask a married father as a woman's duty as mom is assumed. Ironic, isn't it?




This is exactly why it's a potentially discriminatory question



I couldn't agree more. This doesn't sit right with me either. Having your work history speak for itself should be all that matters. Unfortunately I don't have any advice about what you should do, but I hope everything works out for the best.

Posted 1/5/12 12:06 AM
 

BigB
C & J are 10!

Member since 6/05

5914 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

Posted by Elizabeth720

I am a HR Manager and this:

One of the questions asked during the interview for the promotion was related to how the promotion will affect me being a mother, or rather, how I could basically manage doing the position while being a mother. Is this allowed to even be asked? It left a bad taste in my mouth.

is completely inapproppriate and illegal to ask.

The legal, appropriate way for them to approach the subject with you is some version of the following:

This job will require you to work from X time - X time, plus X hours of overtime. Are you able to do that?






It is so against the law to ask a question like this. Although I do not work in HR, I am an assistant principal and I could NEVER ask a question like this at all! Naughty, Naughty.....

Posted 1/5/12 2:40 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

While this is totally not cool they asked that, it sounds like they probably already know you are not the right fit......like another poster mentioned they need someone to be married to this role.

I would count your blessings if you DON'T get it.

I stepped down from a management position when I came back to work from having my son for similar reasons.

There's an unspoken rule at my place of business that in order to be in a management position, you need to put in 12 or more hours each day at work and do all kinds of things that no one really wants to do but you need to $uck it up if you are a higher up.

ETA: You already stated in your OP too that it has been a struggle being a mom and working at this place at times (even if you haven't called out). I am sure they totally pick up on that, and maybe felt comfortable bringing it up since you already work there and maybe disclose some of your family life. It sounds more like you want to "prove" something to them by getting this job.......not necessarily that it is something you even want or would be a good match for.

Back to what I said earlier on though........I would count my blessings if you get passed up. There are plenty of other positions I know I could do personally, but until my son is in school, I need to put him first and stay in a "lesser" role so to speak. My boss has a child my son's age and some of my co-workers and I have reflected about what the home life must be like as well as the relationship with their child since they are never there. If this is about following money, I just think in a case like this unless you are a single mom struggling to make ends meet, it is totally not worth it. And even then it may not be worth it ;).

I also wouldn't want to set myself up to be fired for taking on something I potentially would hate and could not handle. I've seen it happen before with people who have children and companies can always cover their tracks around the kid issue. I know I may offend some people and this isn't what a lot like to hear, but it is what it is out there, like it or not. Just because we want a position or think we are the best, doesn't mean we have to get it, or that we are the best candidate.

Message edited 2012-01-05 06:27:43.013000.

Posted 1/5/12 6:03 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I'm in HR too. It's definitely a discriminatory question but I think you handled the answer superbly.

I'm not sure what the promotion was for but this

Posted by needadvice11312
The second issue is that during the interview, they pointed out that I never volunteered to come in for overtime. In all honesty, I haven't. The people that usually do need the money, and I work well over 40 hours a week as it is, so I never thought to offer to do overtime. I never needed the extra money, and being there for so many hours a week as it is (over 40), I just never thought to do so. It seems this is a major factor in obtaining the position, that an applicant should have been doing this all along in order to get ahead. However, this was never stated prior to the opening of the position (otherwise, lots of applicants would have been doing so in order to get the spot and I'm certain that other applicants haven't volunteered to come in for overtime, either).




would give me pause on promoting someone. I want someone who goes above & beyond in a job. I'm not saying you have to work OT to get promoted but this doesn't strike me as someone who is driven.

Is this a management position? If asked this question again, I wouldn't say it's because you don't need the money. I would say something along the lines of "if this position requires additional hours & you're asking if I'd be willing to put in the extra time, the answer is yes. I will do what it takes to get the job done." I would also point to my workload getting done in a shorter amount of time (if that's the case).

Posted 1/5/12 9:05 AM
 

needadvice11312
LIF Zygote

Member since 1/12

2 total posts

Name:

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

thank you for all the responses. To the above two posters, I do have something to prove. I'm in a male dominated field and have gone through great lengths to be regarded as an excellent employee, not just the woman in the office. I have not spoken to collegeaues or managers about how hard it is to juggle being a mom. All I show is my great work ethic. I do want this position because I'm a career - driven person and desire to get ahead as far as I can go. I know I can do a wonderful job in this spot and I don't want anything stopping me.

In the interview, I didn't say I didn't do overtime because I didn't need the money or have the time. I spinned it and said I will do whatever it takes and I have child care covered and it wouldn't be an issue at all.

I just felt terrible, being employed here for awhile and with excellent reviews and then the idea that being a mom can hold me back. It hasn't yet and I wouldn't bite off more than I could chew. I only would apply for a position where I knew I could deliver 150%.

I want nothing more than to get ahead and further my career, without them taking me being a mom into question.

From what I heard, they also asked male candidates the same question about child care if they were a father.

Posted 1/5/12 10:49 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

It sounds to me like the issues go beyond this promotion interview. I'm sorry you are having a hard time. It would make me feel bad, too. I always hate it when surprises come up on interviews or reviews.

I CAN understand them saying you don't go above and beyond because you don't volunteer for overtime. I understand why you wouldn't, but it can make you seem less "hungry" to them.

Asking about your children is still totally illegal.

I'm not in HR but I do a lot of hiring and it's definitely on the list.

Posted 1/5/12 12:44 PM
 

rkl1130
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

1476 total posts

Name:
Rose Ann

Re: need advice regarding promotion.

I'm so sorry this interview went this way.

Asking about your children is illegal. I've spoken to many HR professionals who frown upon this because it is discrimanatory in nature and should be avoided. There was a better way to ask that question without bringing up the fact that you are a mother.

In addition, I understand that some positions may involve working OT, however I find it in poor taste to point out that you don't volunteer for it. It seems like they are geared towards people who volunteer and are willing to make their job their lives.

At the end of the day, if that's what they are looking for you may be better off not getting the position. My familiy always came first and unless it was needed, I didn't do OT because I got everything and then some done without doing it. If they see my efficiency as a negative, then that's on them because a lot of the times I saw people doing OT because they didn't do anything during the day and just messed around.

Posted 1/5/12 12:56 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Help need advice about going back to work Mindy0247 5/17/05 3 Parenting
Opinions (advice needed) PLEASE..job related dm24angel 5/17/05 32 Families Helping Families ™
Need friend Advice (& new relationship) butterfly22 5/17/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Need advice on stressful lawyer situation DKF1016 5/14/05 8 Home
Do you take your own advice HarleyGirlFLA 5/12/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
i need some advice janet 5/12/05 10 Families Helping Families ™