Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Drivers seeing red after receiving 'robo-tickets'

September 5, 2009 By WILLIAM MURPHY william.murphy@newsday.com

Motorists in Nassau County who make right turns on red without coming to a full stop are getting $50 "robo-tickets" from the county's red-light camera program, and some legislators said they never meant to approve that.

Legis. David Denenberg (D-Merrick) said Friday that he believed he was voting in favor of ticketing motorists who sped through red lights, and accused administration officials of playing "cat and mouse" in their answers when he had asked about such a possibility.

"It was clear from my questions that I was trying to establish that this program would not cover right-turn violations. Obviously, I wasn't asking the right questions because I was left with the impression that it would not apply to that," Denenberg said.

As of Friday morning, 4,500 summonses had been generated by the cameras since they went into operation Aug. 6, and 60 percent of those were for right-turn violations, according to figures from the Suozzi administration.

Legis. Edward Mangano (R-Bethpage) said that it was also his understanding that right-turn violations would not be covered, and the change reinforced his belief that the program was more about revenue than safety.

"The legislature was left with the impression 'Suozzi's Robots' were not issuing tickets for right-on-red infractions," Mangano said of the cameras, which are operational at 18 intersections with plans for 32 more.

Mangano, who is the Republican candidate for county executive against incumbent Thomas Suozzi, said he only became aware of it when constituents, including Bethpage resident Marion Pensabene, began calling his office last week.

"I was shocked. I've been driving 50 years and never got a ticket," Pensabene, 81, said. She said she got a mailed notice of violation saying she made an illegal turn on red at the intersection of Central and Stewart Avenues, and admitted she did not come to a full stop. "I have a neighbor who got one too, and people are very upset about this," she said. The cameras are activated when a car passes over a sensor while the light is red. The workers who monitor the cameras are alerted and tell the computer to either issue a summons or not, depending on what they see.

Revenue from violations is expected to reach $20 million next year, but Suozzi has said the cameras will also reduce accidents.

Deputy County Executive Ian Siegel said that it was always the intent of the program to include right-turn-on-red violations, but he could not point to any public statements or testimony of administration officials to the legislature to support that.

In announcing the installation of the first three cameras last month, Suozzi indicated that the program was aimed at motorists who blew red lights and sped through intersections.

"These red light cameras will improve both driver and pedestrian safety," he said on Aug. 4. "They will deter drivers from speeding through intersections and posing a serious danger to everyone on the road."

Legis. Denise Ford, a Long Beach Democrat who sits with the Republican delegation, appeared with Suozzi at the Aug. 4 event. She said Friday that she was unaware of the right-turn enforcement and had been led to believe it was not part of the legislation.

Federal studies have shown that the red-light cameras can increase rear-end accidents by motorists braking quickly to avoid a ticket. However, the Suozzi administration officials said that the cameras would reduce the number of more serious side-impact accidents that occur when a motorist runs a red light and is hit broadside.

http://www.newsday.com/long-island/nassau/drivers-seeing-red-after-receiving-robo-tickets-1.1425237


My position has always been - you break the law, pay the consequences, no whining. So the only thing that concerns me about these cameras is that last paragraph.

I don't know about anyone else, but when I knew I was coming to an intersection with a camera, I would slow down to be prepared to stop. But I could see how a panicked hard break could cause a problem. And yes, rear enders aren't as bad statistically as t-bones. But to acknowledge that and say - it's ok that you get into an accident as long as it isn't x kind of accident - is pretty out there to me.

What do you guys think?

Posted 9/6/09 8:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by greenfreak


Federal studies have shown that the red-light cameras can increase rear-end accidents by motorists braking quickly to avoid a ticket. However, the Suozzi administration officials said that the cameras would reduce the number of more serious side-impact accidents that occur when a motorist runs a red light and is hit broadside.

http://www.newsday.com/long-island/nassau/drivers-seeing-red-after-receiving-robo-tickets-1.1425237


My position has always been - you break the law, pay the consequences, no whining. So the only thing that concerns me about these cameras is that last paragraph.





If you're not speeding and/or tailgaiting, then this shouldn't be an issue. Traffic lights are timed relative to the speed limit. if you have to slam on your brakes when the light goes yellow to avoid going through the red light, you're either driving too fast or overreacting. Consequently, if you rear-end someone who stops short, then either you are following too closely or really have poor reaction time.

I know some rear-end collisions are unavoidable, but most ARE preventable by simply allowing a safe distance between cars.

Posted 9/6/09 8:25 AM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Yeah, I understand that and completely agree with you. What I'm saying is the politicians are accepting the risk of injury and property damage to increase revenue. That's the part that has me uneasy.

Posted 9/6/09 8:39 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Well I can't tell you how many times I have avoided accidents b.c you are in the intersection and a car comes speeding up and goes right into the turn without stopping so I either have to slam on my brakes or slow down to let them turn when I am going straight at a green light.

As far as rear ending. Sorry but if you are approaching a red light you should be assuming the person in front of you will break and you should be slowing down accordingly. If you are rear ending someone at a right on red then you are probably tailgating - and camera or NOT you shouldn't be that close b.c you take the chance that the person in front of you will do the right thing which is come to a full stop before turning anyway.

I actually don't have a problem with the tickets whether it was their intent or not. You are supposed to come to a full stop and if someone doesn't then I think they deserve the ticket.

Posted 9/6/09 8:55 AM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

I am so glad they are doing this. I'm sick of people driving selfishly and aggressively because they think noone's watching hey can get away with it. If this is what forces people to follow the rules like the rest of us and earns the county some revenue in the process, then I hope they keep doing this.

Posted 9/6/09 9:07 AM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

I think this is a great thing. They should implement it in more locations. Running rolling reds and running stop signs are both SO dangerous. People need to realize that they are endangering OTHERS when they break these rules.

Posted 9/6/09 9:36 AM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

I think they're full of bull that it's about safety.

They ripped down the cameras that were in incorporated villages because revenue from the tickets would be going to the village and not the county. If it's about safety - why would you take them down??? After eating crow they put them back up.

I also don't believe Denenberg when he said he asked about right turn violations. How can you incorrectly phrase that question? I think that no one thought of it.

In any case - I'm not fine with the cameras because it's NOT about safety.

Link to article

As far as them saying it's OK to get into an accident, as long as it's not a t-bone - it's the truth, no?

Posted 9/6/09 9:47 AM
 

KittyKatCopper
missing my handsome boy

Member since 3/09

1579 total posts

Name:
Kat - HamptonsBride (LIW)

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by seaside

I am so glad they are doing this. I'm sick of people driving selfishly and aggressively because they think noone's watching hey can get away with it. If this is what forces people to follow the rules like the rest of us and earns the county some revenue in the process, then I hope they keep doing this.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Seriously, I see people blowing thru red lights making right turns like they don't even have to slow down...you are supposed to STOP then turn...too bad if you didn't and you get a ticket. People don't signal...and they will do this crap in front of a police car...you'd be amazed at the stupidity out there and the disregard for others on the road.

Posted 9/6/09 10:10 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Suozzi is notorious for being a tightwad. Ask those who work for the county. They will tell you how he rations toilet paper. I have heard this from people in two different county offices.

Posted 9/6/09 10:12 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

I'm totally convinced it's about the money.

Parking in a two hour spot at the train station in Bethpage over 2 hours used to be a $30 ticket. As of about 6 months ago it went to $90. Triple!!!!!!

I went to court to fight 3 tickets recently where I was parked legally (not in two hour parking with no signs anywhere) and was told tough..

The clerk I spoke to actually said they need the revenue. Nice right?

So no, I don't believe it's about safety at all especially when federal studies already show it causes other problems.

You are going down Suozzi!

Posted 9/6/09 10:26 AM
 

lovemy2boys
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

puhleeeeeeeze! these cameras have nothing to do with "safety" and everything to do with Money. I'm sure we will be seeing a LOT more rear end accidents because people will slam on their brakes in order to avoid these tickets.

I think drunk driving is a much bigger issue, lets put money and resources into fixing that problem.

Posted 9/6/09 2:38 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

it sad that people need a deterrent from doing something that should of been doing in the first.

as each day that passes, driving is just getting worse and lazier.

yes, i agree, this more about money but sooner than later, we need to teach people to drive and really enforce it. heck, put a light on every corner. this a small way teaching people.

Posted 9/6/09 3:27 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

the cameras may not be there for safety reasons and may just be for revenue generation, but the bottom line is that a violation is a violation. people need to learn to follow the laws of the road and not drive like maniacs thinking the rules don't apply to them.

Posted 9/6/09 4:42 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by greenfreak


"I was shocked. I've been driving 50 years and never got a ticket," Pensabene, 81, said. She said she got a mailed notice of violation saying she made an illegal turn on red at the intersection of Central and Stewart Avenues, and admitted she did not come to a full stop. "I have a neighbor who got one too, and people are very upset about this," she said.




I love this line! I've been running red lights and stop signs for 50 years, I'm shocked that I was finally caught! Chat Icon


as for suozzi and trying to bring in revenue...why not?...no one wants their property taxes to go up - house values have gone down, so why not put a consequence on BREAKING the law! I've been almost hit many times when running when people don't come to full stops and I have the right of way.

Posted 9/6/09 7:10 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

This is a hot topic for me.

If you had posted this 2 months ago, I would say the same as most people "you just have to follow the rules".

Well, we did. DH and I NEVER saw this #@U*$@ red light we supposibly went throug WITHOUT stopping when we went to the zoo last month.

There are 2 pics that shows my car going DELIBERATLY through a red light without the brake lights. We NEVER drive this way.

But apparently we did. Well, on the photo it shows that way. Apparently we are not the only victims either.

So yes, they will time the red so it looks like you go through a red light on camera but it was green RIGHT before you entered the intersection.

It would be a good idea if it was not about tricking people. IT'S ALL ABOUT THE MONEY!!!

Posted 9/6/09 9:14 PM
 

lovemy2boys
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by smdl

This is a hot topic for me.

If you had posted this 2 months ago, I would say the same as most people "you just have to follow the rules".

Well, we did. DH and I NEVER saw this #@U*$@ red light we supposibly went throug WITHOUT stopping when we went to the zoo last month.

There are 2 pics that shows my car going DELIBERATLY through a red light without the brake lights. We NEVER drive this way.

But apparently we did. Well, on the photo it shows that way. Apparently we are not the only victims either.

So yes, they will time the red so it looks like you go through a red light on camera but it was green RIGHT before you entered the intersection.

It would be a good idea if it was not about tricking people. IT'S ALL ABOUT THE MONEY!!!



I believe this, I feel like it's a real quick yellow then they get you going through the "red"

Posted 9/6/09 11:56 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Im confused.

What's the story here?

You broke the law you get a ticket, where's the question?

If its for money, great, maybe folks will learn they have to come to the full count-to-three stop.

What harm is there in having people slow down and force them to come to very long stops at stop lights that are red?

In NYC you can't even make the right at red at all, so I think its a privilege not a right (no pun intended).

*shrug* I can't even see why this is news-worthy.

Posted 9/7/09 12:21 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by lovemy2boys

Posted by smdl

This is a hot topic for me.

If you had posted this 2 months ago, I would say the same as most people "you just have to follow the rules".

Well, we did. DH and I NEVER saw this #@U*$@ red light we supposibly went throug WITHOUT stopping when we went to the zoo last month.

There are 2 pics that shows my car going DELIBERATLY through a red light without the brake lights. We NEVER drive this way.

But apparently we did. Well, on the photo it shows that way. Apparently we are not the only victims either.

So yes, they will time the red so it looks like you go through a red light on camera but it was green RIGHT before you entered the intersection.

It would be a good idea if it was not about tricking people. IT'S ALL ABOUT THE MONEY!!!



I believe this, I feel like it's a real quick yellow then they get you going through the "red"



Yep, I'm at that light daily. I see exactly what happens.

Posted 9/7/09 8:25 AM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

The other day, we were making a right on to Wantagh Ave from Old Jerusalem Ave., and the camera flashed...but it was a right arrow!!! I'm concerned b/c we kind of made the turn just as it changed from regular green to the green arrow. It may have been solid red for half a second in between as it changed. We'll see what happens....

Posted 9/7/09 9:32 AM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

The county needs money, and they are taking it from the people who don't have any money, its very unfair.
between the taxes and now this, seems like it the average long islander will never be able to get ahead

Posted 9/7/09 10:29 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by Erica


as for suozzi and trying to bring in revenue...why not?...no one wants their property taxes to go up - house values have gone down, so why not put a consequence on BREAKING the law! I've been almost hit many times when running when people don't come to full stops and I have the right of way.



I was thinking the same thing. Make a complete stop, don't get the ticket. There are so many jerky drivers and hopefully hitting them where it hurts - their wallet - may get them to obey the law.

Posted 9/7/09 10:32 AM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

When I take into account how many people make rights onto busy streets while barely looking for oncoming traffic and how many serious accidents that can cause, I really don't see a problem with it. Just because someone never got caught before does not make it any less of an infraction (referring to the lady quoted in the article). If people would just slow down and not feel as though they had to be in a super hurry to get nowhere and curb their ego/inpatience, I don't see why this would cause more fender benders from rear crashes. Basicly if the person in front of you has not gone, you don't go...uh, isn't that drivers ed 101?

Message edited 2009-09-07 12:00:13.040000.

Posted 9/7/09 11:59 AM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by Xelindrya

Im confused.

What's the story here?

You broke the law you get a ticket, where's the question?

If its for money, great, maybe folks will learn they have to come to the full count-to-three stop.

What harm is there in having people slow down and force them to come to very long stops at stop lights that are red?

In NYC you can't even make the right at red at all, so I think its a privilege not a right (no pun intended).

*shrug* I can't even see why this is news-worthy.


Seriously. If the county can make some money while teaching people there are consequences to bad, dangerous driving and breaking the law, then I am all for it.

Posted 9/7/09 3:51 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

I actually think it's a smoke screen for bringing in revenue for other things. Like our car registration and license renewals going up. I hear the car regs are going to double. This is a way that the MTA gets theirs. They raised the fares only a certain amount and decided to get the rest from other places.

Stewart Ave is teaming with cops. There are so many traffic signs and rules on that road it's almost confusing.

The train parking lot is paroled by police who sit there and do nothing but write tickets.

It may just be that someone who drives for 50 years and never got a ticket doesn't break the law and doesn't deserve a ticket. I don't see how a camera could capture someone not stopping completely before making the right on red. Only video could.

Nassau county is one of the most corrupt counties. Money goes into everyone's pocket except the tax payers.



Posted 9/8/09 9:13 AM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Nassau cameras also catch right-on-reds

Posted by Blu-ize

I actually think it's a smoke screen for bringing in revenue for other things. Like our car registration and license renewals going up. I hear the car regs are going to double. This is a way that the MTA gets theirs. They raised the fares only a certain amount and decided to get the rest from other places.

Stewart Ave is teaming with cops. There are so many traffic signs and rules on that road it's almost confusing.

The train parking lot is paroled by police who sit there and do nothing but write tickets.

It may just be that someone who drives for 50 years and never got a ticket doesn't break the law and doesn't deserve a ticket. I don't see how a camera could capture someone not stopping completely before making the right on red. Only video could.

Nassau county is one of the most corrupt counties. Money goes into everyone's pocket except the tax payers.






ITA

Posted 9/8/09 9:24 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Traffic Cameras / Nassau County List Elbee 5/13/09 2 Families Helping Families ™