Nanny vs. Daycare

Posted By Message

LadyH
April Baby Girl is Here!

Member since 12/07

1077 total posts

Name:

Nanny vs. Daycare

I am thinking about having a nanny come to the house - can anyone give some advice if they were nervous about having someone alone with your infant?

I had DC #1 in a daycare center, and I had a peaceful mind dropping him off. There was a ton of security measures to keep people out and children in. They could also take breaks and lunch hours. My only issue with daycare is that the DC will get sick all the time like DC#1.

A nanny would be great, but when I think about the lack of security and support, I get really nervous. I don't have any referrals from friends or family that worked out, so I looked on sitter city and care.com, and the ladies seem really professional, but whats to stop anyone from getting frustrated and shaking DC or just walking out the door with the baby and not coming back?

Any input?

Posted 5/31/12 11:39 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JDandMe
LIF Adult

Member since 9/10

996 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

I chose daycare for a variety of reasons:
social interaction with other children his age, he is/was learning numbes letters, etc, safe environment and most important, if one teacher got sick, the daycare would still be opened, unlike a nanny, who if sick, will not come into work and you will need back.

It's a tough decision and you will have to make the decision that fits your schedule, etc

With regard to your DC getting sick in daycare, the ped told me that they have to strengthen there immune system and when he's in school, he will be less likely to get sick.

In my expereince DS#1 was sick alot and DS#2 hasn't even gotten a cold.

HTH!

Posted 6/1/12 7:13 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

I chose daycare. DS is there 2 days a weeks and with family 3 days. I am actually thinking of putting him in more days. I love that they really work with him and teach him.

I like that there are a ton of teachers and staff there so I never have to worry about a nanny being sick of taking time off.

Posted 6/1/12 7:36 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

My opinion in general is before 2 yrs nanny after daycare. I honestly prefer daycare except for infants/newborns. I like the schedule, the activities. My fear is a lack of stimulation from a nanny, of course there are many wonderful nannies these are just general thoughts. Also I am not a BTDT as my son is home with me until 2 JMO. Good luck Chat Icon

Posted 6/1/12 7:45 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

Here's the way I see it:

Nanny:
No socialization with other kids (unless nanny can drive DC to classes and other things)
What happens if Nanny is sick or on vacation?
Can the Nanny give DC all of her attention all day long? Or will she be watching tv, talking on her phone, etc.
You don't have to get DC out the door in the morning.
Will the nanny cook and clean? That's a huge plus.

Daycare:
Socialization with other kids
Don't have to worry about other arrangements if someone is sick or
Multiple teachers to interact with DC
Schedule and structure
Have to get DC out the door in the morning and do drop off / pick up
Monitored by New York State - Can check the website for inspections and any possible violations
DC can get sick often
Have to work around a schedule - can't leave DC late if needed (depends on the daycare)

I've never had a nanny, but MIL watched DD until she was 6 months old. DD is MUCH happier since we put her in daycare. She loves the socialization and her teachers and she has learned a lot from them. She also thrives on structure and a schedule, so that works well for her. MIL watched her, but also had her own home and life to tend to, which took some of her focus off of DD. With daycare, their sole job all day long is to take care of the children. There's no laundry, dishes, cooking, etc to worry about. But it's a very personal decision that really depends on your situation and child. I have a friend who had a live-in nanny who cooked and cleaned for her for less than what I pay for daycare. And with their schedules, it's the only option that worked for them.

Posted 6/1/12 8:27 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

with one i used daycare and when i had my twins we switched to a nanny

we hired the nanny when i started working from home while still pregnant - this way i got a feel for her. We had her until my twins were 6 weeks old then my dh talked me into hiring someone new and she is amazing. So the first may not be the best. it is hard to fire one but your kids are most important

daycare there is a lot of oversight but we lucked out and our nanny is now a part of our family. She has no problem taking all 3 kids places. She helps with laundry, washing bottle, does art projects with my kids. She keeps them enterained well.

my older son goes to a 2 year old program 3 days week because he needs socialization with other kids.

for us it is easier. She has no problem being there when the kids are sick. She helps me bring them to the doctor.

IF you find the right person it can be great. Tnik about what you want. Some people like the grandmother type, preference on them driving the kids, live-in or out, education level

we were lucky to find a young women in early twenties, with a teaching degree and married - who has energy to keep up with all the kids but is mature to handle all situations

Posted 6/1/12 9:11 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

I chose daycare for your exact concerns b/c I just couldn't get past that fear ......Not worth the trade off to me and DH b/c we were both wary of it.

And b/c, although they do get sick a lot, I think it's important for them to be w/ other kids .....

Either they're going to sick now, or they're going to get sick when they go to school - can't avoid the germs forever KWIM?

Posted 6/1/12 9:19 AM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

For me I am going to do nanny/parents until 2.5 then daycare/preschool. Financially it works better for us.

Posted 6/1/12 10:09 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

Posted by JDandMe

I chose daycare for a variety of reasons:
social interaction with other children his age, he is/was learning numbes letters, etc, safe environment and most important, if one teacher got sick, the daycare would still be opened, unlike a nanny, who if sick, will not come into work and you will need back.

It's a tough decision and you will have to make the decision that fits your schedule, etc

With regard to your DC getting sick in daycare, the ped told me that they have to strengthen there immune system and when he's in school, he will be less likely to get sick.

In my expereince DS#1 was sick alot and DS#2 hasn't even gotten a cold.

HTH!



I agree with all of this.
I can't say enough about what my DD has gained from being in a daycare - with structured activities and other children to interact with.

I also would never feel 100% comfortable with a stranger in my home and alone with my DD.
I just hear too many horror stories.
At least at daycare I know the people are highly screened, etc

Message edited 2012-06-01 10:17:23.410000.

Posted 6/1/12 10:14 AM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

We have a nanny, basically bc of logitics, our working hours were just not compatable with the daycares in our area. I was orginally upset abut DD not being able to go to daycare but we are sooo happy with the nanny. She has made our lives so much easier. She does DD's laundry, makes her food, straigtens up, bathes her so when I get home she is aready in her PJ's and ready for me to feed her and put her to bed.

I was really concerned about everything that everyone else mentioned but thats why you interview nannies, ask for references and get a "feel" for them. We got a reference for our nanny from a very close friend, we did a background check, called her references, etc. She had been a daycare teacher, and had certifications in other areas as well as cpr. She does lots of activities with DD ("art", flashcards, etc). This was important to us as we didnt want someone who would just watch tv all day. My DD def has a schedule during the day and she also gets a lot of one on one attention which I think is also important for young child. The nanny has made friends with the other nannies in the area so DD does have some interaction with other children and when she is older Im sure there will be more "official" playdates. Really, the only downside is that it is a lot more $ than daycare but since we didnt have a choice, it is what it is.
When DD is approaching 2 we will look for a daycare/preschool program

Posted 6/1/12 1:05 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

If you can find a nanny who you trust, I think a nanny is better when the child is younger. The nanny helps me immensely in the morning so I can get ready for work too.

Right now we pay for both a full time nanny and preschool for my older child.

DH and I were very anti-nanny until we found our current nanny. She is awesome. Sure, I think the tennis channel is on a bit more than we would like but overall she is great.

Posted 6/1/12 1:09 PM
 

DML
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

567 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

Posted by Bridex100

If you can find a nanny who you trust, I think a nanny is better when the child is younger. The nanny helps me immensely in the morning so I can get ready for work too.

Right now we pay for both a full time nanny and preschool for my older child.

DH and I were very anti-nanny until we found our current nanny. She is awesome. Sure, I think the tennis channel is on a bit more than we would like but overall she is great.



I agree with this. We have 3 kids. Nanny was the best way to go. My older two go to preschool. The oldest will be going to elementary school in the fall. She will be able to bring him to and from the bus, and will watch him the days he is off from school.

Posted 6/1/12 1:20 PM
 

summerbaby11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/10

779 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

we had to get a nanny b/c we never got into our daycare - the waitlist was insane.

it's the best thing ever - we went through a time where DH would drop the baby off and pick him up at my sisters 3x a week and it's just so much more convenient having someone come to us, not having to rush home (which, with our hours, can be really hard) and knowing how much she loves him.

he gets plenty of socialization (as much as a 10 month old can get) b/c she always has him out and about and arranges playdates. I would like him in some sort of program once he's 2, but I'm not sure I could ever get rid of her. especially if we have a 2nd.

Posted 6/1/12 2:38 PM
 

luckysox
LIF Infant

Member since 12/11

82 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

I did both - daycare and now a nanny (who I got from the daycare facility)

My son would not sleep at day care -ever! And he is a great sleeper - he was just too nosey. I didn't like that he was always getting sick, b/c then I had to take off of work. It was also much more expensive than the nanny when I had my second child.
I LOVE my nanny - she is amazing - and I trust her more than I trust my husband!

There are pro's and cons with both - the security is the same - bad things happen at daycare as well as in a home setting with a nanny. You just have to go with you guy and chose what works best for you

Posted 6/1/12 2:52 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

Newborn / infant - nanny.

Posted 6/1/12 3:27 PM
 

Athee
I believe in miracles!

Member since 8/07

2462 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Nanny vs. Daycare

Posted by MarisaK

I chose daycare for your exact concerns b/c I just couldn't get past that fear ......Not worth the trade off to me and DH b/c we were both wary of it.

And b/c, although they do get sick a lot, I think it's important for them to be w/ other kids .....

Either they're going to sick now, or they're going to get sick when they go to school - can't avoid the germs forever KWIM?



I agree, we also chose daycare for those exact concerns...

Posted 6/2/12 6:06 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How do you go about finding a sitter/nanny/daycare for ONE day a week? ChrisDee 2/16/11 11 Parenting
Does anyone use or plan to use a nanny/sitter rather than daycare? NervousNell 1/20/10 11 Pregnancy
WWYD: Which would you prefer - PT daycare or PT nanny? Bridex100 5/20/09 11 Parenting
Considering switching from daycare to nanny/sitter - with lots of questions! clwp 5/7/09 6 Parenting
Please help! PT daycare/nanny? pixie 7/1/08 6 Parenting
If money weren't an issue would you have a nanny or daycare? leighla 9/17/07 45 Parenting