Name question

Posted By Message

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Name question

So my parents apparently hate both names the we chose... For a girl it will be Samantha Lynn and for a boy Andrew Michael

apparently samantha reminds my father of a witch (nice right) and they just dont like andrew... now dh and i do not care about that issue.. we had been between three names for a boy and when we found out that his great grandfather was andrew we saw that as a sign that we should use that name


so now my parents then suggested all these boys names which are actually the names of everyone of of our male siblings so we said that we decided to not use a name from one of our siblings as the first name mainly because if they want to have a jr then our child will have a cousin with the same name.. and honestly it wasnt an issue to us, it was something that we just decided when we had ds... is that wierd to anyone else that we dont want to use a sibling of ours name??

Posted 11/14/09 8:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: Name question

First...let me start by saying do what makes YOU and your DH happy..that's all that matters in the long run. It always seems that everyone else always has something to say...forever.

Next, no, I don't think it's odd at all to not want to name your baby after one of your siblings.

My situation is that we have a million and one Roberts in both my family and DHs family...and our son is going to be Robert Patrick V... only b/c DH warned me waaay before our wedding that our first son would have to be that. It's not a bad name, I don't mind it...specially since my Dad was a Robert as well, BUT, ya know how many people look at us like were insane? Again, just do what makes you happy... Chat Icon

Posted 11/14/09 8:10 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Name question

i honestly think my parents expect us to name our child after my father.. which is also my borthers name and my nephews name... our first ds is joseph patrick... which joseph is dh name and patrick is after his late mother who was patricia... so they feel that they are owed their chance to have this child named after them... andrew really was a fluke, we talked about it and decided that since it was in the family it is perfect... i really do not care what they think i am just annoyed because they are giving me a hard time about not wanting to use the same name as a sibling

Posted 11/14/09 8:38 PM
 

nickipa
love my boys!

Member since 4/06

5648 total posts

Name:
Nicki

Re: Name question

I like both of your names! I think your parents got to name their kids, you get to name yours!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/14/09 8:41 PM
 

MrsScott
So in Love

Member since 1/09

3356 total posts

Name:
Shawna

Re: Name question

I like both names this is your child and you should give it the name you feel fits your child best they had their chance to name their child now its yours

Posted 11/14/09 9:05 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Name question

My brother is named after my Dad, who was named after my Grandfather and my Uncle on my Moms side also has same name. I was named after my Mom! To me it is too much in the immediate family! I am thinking about naming my Chat Icon after someone in my family BUT they wont be around them constantly..

Growing up it was way too many of the same name..it can be confusing at times- for doctors appt's, mail (always opening each others), hair salons we both go to, phone calls, etc...who do they want?

Even to this day I went to get my blood work done and they almost put me in as my MOTHER (we go to same group)! But I happened to be looking over their shoulder and saw the wrong date of birth Chat Icon Chat Icon

Its your child, you have to do whatever YOU and DH want!! You have to be happy with it and if you love those names then go for it!!

Message edited 2009-11-14 21:50:38.730000.

Posted 11/14/09 9:47 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Name question

My mom does not like my girl's name and you know what, I don't care! She had her kids and she got to name them what she wanted. DH and I get to name our kids what we want. I would not even entertain their concerns about what you are naming YOUR child!!!Chat Icon

Posted 11/14/09 10:28 PM
 

dsnyfrk
LIF Infant

Member since 11/09

278 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: Name question

I'll never understand why people feel they have the right to criticize or have a hand in naming someone else's child. Even the Grandparents! Like the previous posters have said, they had their time.. they've named their children. It's your turn to do the same.

I think both names you chose are great!

I don't think it's odd at all to not want to use a siblings name. In fact, I would think most people avoid that. If they (your siblings) want to name their child after themselves, they should have the opportunity to do so.

When I had my DD, we named her Kaelin. When my Mom first heard it, she didn't like it and kept trying to get me to change it. I just told her to get used to it because I loved the name and that's what it was going to be. lol Now that she see's the name attached to my daughter, she absolutely loves it and denies ever saying she didn't like it. Chat Icon

So, do what you and DH want. Once your family sees the baby with the name you chose, they'll forget everything else. Chat Icon

Posted 11/15/09 8:53 AM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Name question

I am definitely not going to think that it is weird not to want to use a siblings name, because in my faith (Judaism) we are not supposed to name after the living. I have a niece who has one of the names that was on the top of my list before meeting DH and we cannot use that name.

Now, what is wrong with the names you picked? I think they are beautiful.

This is your baby. You name your baby what you want and tell your parents that they got to name you, so you will name your child. The name will grow on them when they see how wonderful your baby is.

This is why we aren't sharing Miss Bean's name with many people-I find it funny how the rules of etiquette disappear when it comes to naming children/childrearing and pregnancy. Would you go up to someone you meet who is 20 and say, "Your name is fugly?" So why would someone tell a prospective parent the same thing? Chat Icon

Posted 11/15/09 9:08 AM
 

SuperLRN
Im a big boy now

Member since 5/08

2527 total posts

Name:

Re: Name question

I love both of the names you have chosen. Samantha is such a pretty name and I love Andrew (if it werent my brothers name I would consider it if we are having a boy). This is why DH and I havent shared our name choices for Chat Icon with anyone. Im not interested in anyones opinion.

Posted 11/15/09 9:19 AM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Name question

we had such issues choosing names this time around because the names for a boy that we really loved sounded awful... i think my parents just need to give us a hard time about something at all times... prior to the name thing it was the stroller we decided to get... which they are purchasing for us, but they refused to listen to why we chose the one we did until i was at the zoo with my mother and pointed out exactly why....

i think they really want the name to be from our family... which to be honest the middle name or lynn for a girl IS from my family because me and my mother both have that middle name... they are just determined to make me nuts as usual... they also feel that they should have a say in every aspect of their childrens lives... i still remember when i decided to by my house without my parents seeing it first (i purchased from family on dh side) my mother REFUSED to see the house for several months... it is all about control



However, when i told dh that my parents hated our name choices he had the same thought that i had which was that it gives us even more of a reason to use them....

Posted 11/15/09 10:02 AM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Name question

I wouldn't want to name any of our children after our siblings, so I agree with you there.

In our case, my older brother is named after our father and grandfather. My younger brother is named after my step dad. So we'd be using a name that was not only one of my siblings' names, but also one of our dad's names.

I remember clearly once my younger brother was old enough to get phone calls (friends, school, appointments, etc), there was ALWAYS confusion about who they were calling for. Same thing at family events etc. I can't imagine having a son with the same name as my brother and dad.

You have to go with your gut and use a name you will love forever. Chat Icon

Posted 11/15/09 10:51 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I just have one question.... JenniferEver 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Follow up to allergy question DramaQueen 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
BabyBoy question for you TAD 5/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
STAR question sasha96 5/11/05 2 Home
Silly Reality Question Redhead 5/11/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
I got a question fakie1 5/10/05 86 Families Helping Families ™