Front to Back or Side by Side?

Forum Opinion Poll
Front to back 7 20.59%
Side by side 27 79.41%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Posted By Message

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Went to BBB, and BRU today, and came home once again with nothing!!!

Front to Back/Tandem OR Side by Side?

Kids will be NB, and 21 months...with the 21 month old being a big boy.

If you can list the pros and cons that would be great.

For what its worth, both stores told me tandem is better, as the weight of a larger toddler will be more evenly distributed, leading to less tipping. They said that the side-by sides are geared more for twins...again...just what they said...I come on here for the real info!

Thank you so much!

Message edited 2011-07-10 18:51:40.817000.

Posted 7/10/11 6:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Lucky09
2017!

Member since 1/06

7539 total posts

Name:
DW

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

side by side ALL the way.

I had both, and I could not steer the tandem for the life of me.

I had 2 under 2 18 months apart.

I have the 2011 City Mini Double and I LOVE it.

eta: both of my kids are BIG (in the 96% for weight and height) and they fit great in it (DS #1 is 28 mos now).

Message edited 2011-07-10 18:54:43.650000.

Posted 7/10/11 6:53 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Okay - I honestly think it is a personal preference type of thing.

For some perspective on where I am coming from - I have 2 side by sides (bumbleride indie twin and City mini double) and one front to back (one step ahead - sit and stand - the one where you can remove the rear seat). My girls are 23 months apart.

I HATE my sit and stand. I think I have used it maybe 5-10 times total in 2 years. I hated the front to back b.c I felt I was pushing a boat when I had the kids in there. It was so hard and annoying to push and steer. My DD#1 is a peanut at 25% but DD#2 is 75% for height and 40% for weight. So they are not really big kids. I felt it was hard to get into the basket and with the sit and stand the baby is in the front - so DD#1 would NOT keep her hands off her sister - b.c she was right in front of her it was like dangling candy in front of her.

I LOVE my side by sides. I use my indie twin for walks and my City mini for trips. I like them for different reasons. I didn't have DD#1 touching DD#2 all the time, it was easier to watch them both, easier to put stuff in/on the stroller. I NEVER had them tip over. If I did it again I wouldn't bother with the front to back.

Interestingly enough. I took DD#1 with me when we were looking at strollers when I was pregnant with DD#2. At 2 she was about 25-26 lbs and I think about 33 inches to give you some idea of her size maybe even a bit smaller. Honestly when I put her into the front to back she looked HUGE and complained that she was uncomfortable in most of them.

Have you brought your DC with you and tried to push them around the store? I think that would make a big difference.

Posted 7/10/11 7:02 PM
 

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Posted by Lucky09

side by side ALL the way.

I had both, and I could not steer the tandem for the life of me.

I had 2 under 2 18 months apart.

I have the 2011 City Mini Double and I LOVE it.

eta: both of my kids are BIG (in the 96% for weight and height) and they fit great in it (DS #1 is 28 mos now).



So what happens if the older 30lb+ child is reaching over the side, or leaning to pick up something, etc, would the 8 lb NB on the other side be affected? This is what the woman at BBB was saying. Thanks for your helpChat Icon
ETA: She also said that the side by side is hard to fit places. I have the single city mini, and love it, but she said the double is more narrow in the seat area. Do you find this as well?

Message edited 2011-07-10 19:17:55.893000.

Posted 7/10/11 7:16 PM
 

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Posted by Lillykat

Okay - I honestly think it is a personal preference type of thing.

For some perspective on where I am coming from - I have 2 side by sides (bumbleride indie twin and City mini double) and one front to back (one step ahead - sit and stand - the one where you can remove the rear seat). My girls are 23 months apart.

I HATE my sit and stand. I think I have used it maybe 5-10 times total in 2 years. I hated the front to back b.c I felt I was pushing a boat when I had the kids in there. It was so hard and annoying to push and steer. My DD#1 is a peanut at 25% but DD#2 is 75% for height and 40% for weight. So they are not really big kids. I felt it was hard to get into the basket and with the sit and stand the baby is in the front - so DD#1 would NOT keep her hands off her sister - b.c she was right in front of her it was like dangling candy in front of her.

I LOVE my side by sides. I use my indie twin for walks and my City mini for trips. I like them for different reasons. I didn't have DD#1 touching DD#2 all the time, it was easier to watch them both, easier to put stuff in/on the stroller. I NEVER had them tip over. If I did it again I wouldn't bother with the front to back.

Interestingly enough. I took DD#1 with me when we were looking at strollers when I was pregnant with DD#2. At 2 she was about 25-26 lbs and I think about 33 inches to give you some idea of her size maybe even a bit smaller. Honestly when I put her into the front to back she looked HUGE and complained that she was uncomfortable in most of them.

Have you brought your DC with you and tried to push them around the store? I think that would make a big difference.



Thank you for this info. Oddly, enough, DS did come with me today, and we tried out a bunch. He is super tall at 18 months, and 38 inches tall...he looks awkward in most of them with his head hitting the sun shade..lol...that was in the Graco, and the BabyTrend. The CIty Mini was nice, but I felt like the seat got so much narrower, as I have the single...of course his head hits the shade in that one, too!

Posted 7/10/11 7:22 PM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

if you get a side by side that has 4 sets of wheels, there may be a weight distribution factor to consider. My sister had this with her combi side by side. One wheel wouldn't spin because it didn't touch the ground on the side with the her lighter child

Posted 7/10/11 8:33 PM
 

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Thank you for your help...anyone this morning?

Posted 7/11/11 7:28 AM
 

medikalmomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/09

511 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

I had both for my girls. I had a graco duogliger and the city mini double. I hated the front back and used it 2 times then gave it away. It was heavy and bulky and I felt like I was pushing a school bus. I love my citi mini. I had no problem fitting through doorways or anywhere else really. My girls are 19 months apart and I was using it up to a few months ago. Both of my girls are big girls and fit without a problem. I only stopped using it cause my 5 year old likes to walk. I will be pulling it out again soon for my 3 year old and newborn. I have no concerns about the weight distribution or tipping or anything.

It's a personal decision. I know people who do like the front to back, but it just wasn't for us.

Posted 7/11/11 7:40 AM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

Side by side all the way. Im a mom of 2 under 1 with two extremely bug boys (weight & height).

After much research & testing of stroller we went with tbd Bumbleride Indie from & I an so glad I did. The away max us 45lbs per seat & the height is kit an issue. Both boys are extremely comfy in there. It has very smooth ride & you can maneuver the stroller with one hand if necessary. For me it folded extremely compact for s double.

Posted 7/11/11 7:46 AM
 

DML
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

567 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

What about the phil and ted. I love mine! It is so easy to push and get around places. there are some down sides to it - not easy to store things with the jump seat on, and you can't use it with the infant car seat, but I still LOVE mine.

Posted 7/11/11 8:35 AM
 

EckoRed81504
We are complete <3

Member since 12/07

6299 total posts

Name:
April

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

I just got the City Mini Double- I have 2 under 2 as well. DD is 18 months and DS is 1 month.

I love it. I prefered the side by side. I haven't had any problem going in and out of doorways-and most people do help if you are by yourself. The only problem I have is if I'm in a store and the aisles are narrow.

But otherwise, I'm so happy with it.

Posted 7/11/11 8:41 AM
 

MRSBA
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

923 total posts

Name:

Re: My FINAL Stroller poll...please help me out!!

So glad you asked this. My NB will be born in august and DS will be 21 months and I'm still debating this. I am now leaning towards the city mini double but I just haven't pulled the trigger yet. I'm still worried about the side by side fitting through doors and getting the kids into and out of the stroller from the car (probably no room between cars in parking spots so would you leave one behind the car in the stroller while you put the other one in the car?KWIM)
I really just need to make a decision.

Posted 7/11/11 10:25 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
X-Post PSA Quinny Stroller on Sale at Albee Baby jellybean78 5/8/09 0 Pregnancy
X-post My craigslist posting for a jogging stroller Stefanie 4/24/09 0 Pregnancy
X Post Great Stroller on Shnoop for cheap jellybean78 1/12/09 0 Pregnancy
x post - selling my double stroller Teri 6/11/08 2 Multiple Births
X-Post: Graco Quattro Tour Stroller... BaroqueMama 2/16/08 1 Pregnancy
Spinoff to Sophie (smdl) post - stroller group... lipglossjunky73 8/13/07 16 Parenting