Media Hysteria
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Media Hysteria If i hear one more report that "radiation is going to reach our shores" today......Im going to scream. By the time it reaches our shores, itll be less that you receive from an xray.... |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:05 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Media Hysteria Not sure which news agency is reporting that, but I watched BBC this morning and listened to NPR in the car and nobody reported anythng like that. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria I can tell you that BBC seems sometimes less alarmist that US major news outlets...I can't speak for NPR but our news is unfortunately very alarmist... |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria The media always does this, it's very annoying. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog I can tell you that BBC seems sometimes less alarmist that US major news outlets...I can't speak for NPR but our news is unfortunately very alarmist... Maybe this is why I avoid most US news outlets. Last I heard was that they are dumping water on the reactors to try and keep them cool and the Japanese were attemting to get the cooling system back online by rerouting power to it. I also heard that Americans were being advised to leave the country or at minimum, maintain a 50 mile radius distance from the reactors. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria I cannot even watch CNN or go to their website anymore. It's like a bunch of village idiots reporting. Sensational headlines with stories that are so remarkably different than the headlines. Conflicting data within the same story (even paragraph) ... so annoying. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog I can tell you that BBC seems sometimes less alarmist that US major news outlets... This is true. I also like BBC because they cover a lot more about what's going on in the world as opposed to just the 'big' stories. But to the OP, I have been hearing some stuf like that on the news as well. I think I saw something last night about some health stores running out of iodine pills in Hawaii because people have been stocking up on them. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria People are calling my job (vitamins) asking if the fish oil--that's been on the shelf for months--is affected by radiation in Japan? |
|
Posted 3/17/11 8:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria The radiation in the air will be minimal. However, the radiation that will impact the ocean and sea life is what we really need to be concerned about. Not only in the short term, but in how it will effect certain species and balances in the long run. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by acm1899 Not sure which news agency is reporting that, but I watched BBC this morning and listened to NPR in the car and nobody reported anythng like that. And that is why you haven't heard anything. You are listening to decent sources. I can't stand the regular news outlets anymore. I watched CNN on Friday and a little on Saturday as everything was still (truly) breaking news. Now I just turn it on in 10 minute bits to see if they are coming up with anything new or just sensationalizing recycled news. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. Not necessarily true. When Chernobyl exploded, the way that anyone outside of Ukraine first became aware of it was when another nuclear plant located about 650 miles away in Sweden saw radiation levels in the air spike. The wind had carried the radiation that far. Now you think about Japan, which is a coastal island. If the winds were to be blowing Southeasterly, they would be going over the Pacific Ocean with little or no natural barrier in their way. No mountains, no buildings. Nothing but hundreds and hundreds of miles of clear air. So I can see how people in living in the Pacific islands or on the Pacific Coast may have cause for alarm. And yes, I do agree with you about the impact on oceanic life Message edited 2011-03-17 09:10:50.440000. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. However, the radiation that will impact the ocean and sea life is what we really need to be concerned about. Not only in the short term, but in how it will effect certain species and balances in the long run. Totally agree with this. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria I have no expertise in radiation, I have no idea if it will reach the shores of Hawaii or the US, but I did hear on 1010 wins that Potassium Iodide is flying off the shelves in California. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by IrishLass I have no expertise in radiation, I have no idea if it will reach the shores of Hawaii or the US, but I did hear on 1010 wins that Potassium Iodide is flying off the shelves in California. ' People are jamming our customer service line asking we make potassium iodine. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria I'm with you all! I hate the sensationalism!!! I trust the BBC news much more. I never rely on US sources of news. It's ALL about ratings and money. DH even works for a major news network and I never watch. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by heathergirl Posted by IrishLass I have no expertise in radiation, I have no idea if it will reach the shores of Hawaii or the US, but I did hear on 1010 wins that Potassium Iodide is flying off the shelves in California. ' People are jamming our customer service line asking we make potassium iodine. I have to say, I'm surprised we're not getting the calls yet, but I bet my parent company in Germany is. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 9:56 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Media Hysteria it is really pissing me off. |
Posted 3/17/11 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by Ophelia it is really pissing me off. we are FINE. FINE. we should be worrying about the people of JAPAN and sending all of our energy there. instead we are turning it on to ourselves. so ******* selfish. it's is pissing me the flock off!!!! do they really think the only way we as a peole will care about the story is if we Kevin Bacon it to our shores? continued prayers for the people of Japan. this is exactly what I was thinking when CNN covered "it reaching our shores" TWICE in a half hour perioud this morning. It will disperse and breakdown over the water, there is ZERO risk here. It will be less than the amount that you get from a single Xray. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by acm1899 Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. Not necessarily true. When Chernobyl exploded, the way that anyone outside of Ukraine first became aware of it was when another nuclear plant located about 650 miles away in Sweden saw radiation levels in the air spike. The wind had carried the radiation that far. Now you think about Japan, which is a coastal island. If the winds were to be blowing Southeasterly, they would be going over the Pacific Ocean with little or no natural barrier in their way. No mountains, no buildings. Nothing but hundreds and hundreds of miles of clear air. So I can see how people in living in the Pacific islands or on the Pacific Coast may have cause for alarm. And yes, I do agree with you about the impact on oceanic life this is completely wrong. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by memi7206 Posted by acm1899 Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. Not necessarily true. When Chernobyl exploded, the way that anyone outside of Ukraine first became aware of it was when another nuclear plant located about 650 miles away in Sweden saw radiation levels in the air spike. The wind had carried the radiation that far. Now you think about Japan, which is a coastal island. If the winds were to be blowing Southeasterly, they would be going over the Pacific Ocean with little or no natural barrier in their way. No mountains, no buildings. Nothing but hundreds and hundreds of miles of clear air. So I can see how people in living in the Pacific islands or on the Pacific Coast may have cause for alarm. And yes, I do agree with you about the impact on oceanic life this is completely wrong. *informative* |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by acm1899 Posted by memi7206 Posted by acm1899 Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. Not necessarily true. When Chernobyl exploded, the way that anyone outside of Ukraine first became aware of it was when another nuclear plant located about 650 miles away in Sweden saw radiation levels in the air spike. The wind had carried the radiation that far. Now you think about Japan, which is a coastal island. If the winds were to be blowing Southeasterly, they would be going over the Pacific Ocean with little or no natural barrier in their way. No mountains, no buildings. Nothing but hundreds and hundreds of miles of clear air. So I can see how people in living in the Pacific islands or on the Pacific Coast may have cause for alarm. And yes, I do agree with you about the impact on oceanic life this is completely wrong. *informative* This made me laugh
|
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by acm1899 Posted by memi7206 Posted by acm1899 Posted by LiveForMoments The radiation in the air will be minimal. Not necessarily true. When Chernobyl exploded, the way that anyone outside of Ukraine first became aware of it was when another nuclear plant located about 650 miles away in Sweden saw radiation levels in the air spike. The wind had carried the radiation that far. Now you think about Japan, which is a coastal island. If the winds were to be blowing Southeasterly, they would be going over the Pacific Ocean with little or no natural barrier in their way. No mountains, no buildings. Nothing but hundreds and hundreds of miles of clear air. So I can see how people in living in the Pacific islands or on the Pacific Coast may have cause for alarm. And yes, I do agree with you about the impact on oceanic life this is completely wrong. *informative* OK fine: Chernobyl was a brand new reactor with no containment units that exploded during its testing phase bc of human error when workers tried to start it up to soon after shutting it down. The fact that this was an unforeseen explosion left no time to react or take steps to prevent widespread damage. Nevermind the fact that the reactors had no barrier or containment units in place so the explosion caused immediate expulsion into the air. Furthermore, the plant at Chernobyl produced FAR MORE power than the reactors in Japan do. Not to mention, the reactors are two completely different designs, the ones in Japan being far more stable and trusted. As for Japan, they have had over a weeks time to take steps and measure that would minimize the damage should meltdown occur. If they are going to meltdown, it is more likely a partial meltdown, as opposed to a complete meltdown like in Chernobyl. Like I said, these reactors also have containment units in place, some of which have been compromised, yes, but not all, and not completely which Chernobyl had none. Again, these reactors also produce a FRACTION of the power that the plant at Chernobyl was meant to, so even a meltdown, while damaging and not good, is not going to be on the same level as Chernobyl. As for there being no buildings or structure to block the transportation of radiation, that actually works in our favor as radiation is mostly spread on land, in dust particles. There first would have to be major winds to blow the radiation to our shores, and if there were, it would have to travel so far 2000+, that all of the moisture, winds and rains will have dispersed it by the time it were to reach our shores anyway. Message edited 2011-03-17 10:42:34.897000. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by memi7206 OK fine: Chernobyl was a brand new reactor with no containment units that exploded during its testing phase bc of human error when workers tried to start it up to soon after shutting it down. The fact that this was an unforeseen explosion left no time to react or take steps to prevent widespread damage. Nevermind the fact that the reactors had no barrier or containment units in place so the explosion caused immediate expulsion into the air. Furthermore, the plant at Chernobyl produced FAR MORE power than the reactors in Japan do. Not to mention, the reactors are two completely different designs, the ones in Japan being far more stable and trusted. As for Japan, they have had over a weeks time to take steps and measure that would minimize the damage should meltdown occur. If they are going to meltdown, it is more likely a partial meltdown, as opposed to a complete meltdown like in Chernobyl. Like I said, these reactors also have containment units in place, some of which have been compromised, yes, but not all, and not completely which Chernobyl had none. Again, these reactors also produce a FRACTION of the power that the plant at Chernobyl was meant to, so even a meltdown, while damaging and not good, is not going to be on the same level as Chernobyl. As for there being no buildings or structure to block the transportation of radiation, that actually works in our favor as radiation is mostly spread on land, in dust particles. There first would have to be major winds to blow the radiation to our shores, and if there were, it would have to travel so far 2000+, that all of the moisture, winds and rains will have dispersed it by the time it were to reach our shores anyway. So in your expert opinion, is it impossible, highly unlikely, unlikely, maybe, or likely that any contaminated particles will reach shores outside of Japan? BTW, I don't mind being corrected, and I'm not attacking you either, but you can't just tell someone that they're completely wrong about something and end it at that. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria While I don't agree with all the sensationalism, I don't think it is a bad thing to worry about ourselves and our own families and wonder "what if it happened to us." There is nothing wrong with using this tragedy as a reminder that it can happen to anyone, anywhere and there is nothing wrong with taking a few extra precautions that may help our families. It doesn't take away from our prayers and donations for Japan. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Media Hysteria Posted by acm1899 but you can't just tell someone that they're completely wrong about something and end it at that. I can and I will. Im not interested in turning this into a huge debate and responding to snide remarks. I told you what I know, do what you will with it. |
|
Posted 3/17/11 10:53 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| My TV boyfriend causing hysteria in China! (Wentworth Miller) | Michi | 10/16/08 | 5 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Moms! Let me see your ONE TRUE MEDIA videos! | CouponKT | 10/5/07 | 27 | Parenting |
| I hate the media..re:David Garvin..killer of the 2 auxillary cops.. | NS1976 | 3/15/07 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| do you think anna nicole smith would have gotten the same amt of media coverage.... | Jessica | 2/21/07 | 22 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| kinda double spinoff....Do you trust ANY news/media source out there to tell the UNBIASED truth? | Ophelia | 10/12/06 | 22 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| has anyone ordered a video from one true media? | MrsR | 8/24/06 | 2 | Parenting |












