Re: Media Hysteria
Posted 3/17/2011 10:47:53 AM by acm1899
Posted by memi7206
OK fine:
Chernobyl was a brand new reactor with no containment units that exploded during its testing phase bc of human error when workers tried to start it up to soon after shutting it down. The fact that this was an unforeseen explosion left no time to react or take steps to prevent widespread damage. Nevermind the fact that the reactors had no barrier or containment units in place so the explosion caused immediate expulsion into the air. Furthermore, the plant at Chernobyl produced FAR MORE power than the reactors in Japan do. Not to mention, the reactors are two completely different designs, the ones in Japan being far more stable and trusted.
As for Japan, they have had over a weeks time to take steps and measure that would minimize the damage should meltdown occur. If they are going to meltdown, it is more likely a partial meltdown, as opposed to a complete meltdown like in Chernobyl. Like I said, these reactors also have containment units in place, some of which have been compromised, yes, but not all, and not completely which Chernobyl had none. Again, these reactors also produce a FRACTION of the power that the plant at Chernobyl was meant to, so even a meltdown, while damaging and not good, is not going to be on the same level as Chernobyl.
As for there being no buildings or structure to block the transportation of radiation, that actually works in our favor as radiation is mostly spread on land, in dust particles. There first would have to be major winds to blow the radiation to our shores, and if there were, it would have to travel so far 2000+, that all of the moisture, winds and rains will have dispersed it by the time it were to reach our shores anyway.
So in your expert opinion, is it impossible, highly unlikely, unlikely, maybe, or likely that any contaminated particles will reach shores outside of Japan?
BTW, I don't mind being corrected, and I'm not attacking you either, but you can't just tell someone that they're completely wrong about something and end it at that.
|