Manipulative Children.

Posted By Message

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Manipulative Children.

*PLEASE DON'T QUOTE*
Last week I had a meeting at the school with regard to an incident that Robbie was involved in a few weeks prior.

During the meeting I was told that Robbie will sometimes not 'admit' to his feelings. For example.. the principal asked him if he was upset. Robbie said "No".

I said that his response would indicate to me one of 2 things. The first is that he really wasn't upset and was answering your question honestly. The second is that he was upset but didn't know if admitting that would get him in more trouble. I said he is generally an honest kid.. but sometimes he will try to weigh his answers to avoid being in trouble.

The principal said "I say that means he is manipulative."

I have such a problem with this term being applied to my child. I mean - yeah - by definition lying is an act of manipulation. But when you apply that term as a descriptor it's just DIFFERENT. It somehow seems more nefarious. Saying actions are manipulative is one thing.. labeling an 8 year old as 'manipulative' just seems wrong.

But - before I go and demand another meeting or write a scathing letter - I figured I would get some input from the LIF folks.

Is it typical that 8 year olds sometimes lie to avoid being punished? Is that behavior one that deserves a label like "Manipulative"?

Message edited 2010-03-31 09:14:59.303000.

Posted 3/31/10 9:13 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Manipulative Children.

Every living creature on the face of this earth is manipulative.

People get angered at being manipulated when they want something out of someone they aren't getting. Because someone's manipulation won over theirs.

As a behaviorist - I stand firm on the fact that there is no such thing as manipulation. You want to see steam come out of my ears? Tell me a student - with a disability or not - is being manipulative.

We all behave the way we want to behave to get something out of a situation.

God help the person who ever tells me my kid is being manipulative. I will get gangsta-Behaviorist on his/her azz.

Posted 3/31/10 9:18 AM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Manipulative Children.

I would say that is a very powerful term to use. I would be upset if someone said that about my child.

Isnt lying something all kids do?

e.g. "Who took the last cookie"
kid says lying "My sister" lol

I mean c'mon
We teach our kids NOT to lie and I think they eventually learn NOT to

Manipulative is too strong a word IMO

Posted 3/31/10 9:20 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Manipulative Children.

Also - does Robbie admit his feelings to you? If so, maybe he doesn't feel it's anyone else's business if he is upset or not. He doesn't have to walk around with his heart n his sleeve.

Is it necessary for him to admit his feelings, or follow the rules and be a good kid in class?

If he got in trouble for doing something inappropriate that is 1 issue. Admitting his feelings - a separate issue completely.

I would ask which one is most important for the issue at hand - his behavior, his feelings, or his "manipulativeness?"

Posted 3/31/10 9:24 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Manipulative Children.

Exactly, I agree with YOU and the PPs!!!!!! What a rotten thing to label an 8 year old. Robbie wasn't even trying to "get something" i.e. a reward - it was to AVOID something, i.e. punishment. I think 'dishonest' is as far as I would go! People throw words around without thinking sometimes, I'm pretty sure I'd have a followup with them to make sure we 'understand each other' going forward....

Posted 3/31/10 9:27 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Manipulative Children.

I think that is an awful thing to say about an 8 year old boy. I'm sure he knows right and wrong, but this is such a small thing to lie about. It's not like he manipulated a little girl into thinking she could fly so she'd jump off the roof. He said he wasn't sad...Chat Icon I know that's an extreme example, but the principal is being ridiculous here.

Posted 3/31/10 9:34 AM
 

NW2006
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

535 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Manipulative Children.

I think that it is typical behavior for kids, and anyone, to lie to avoid many things, including punishment.

If it was me, I would probably not be able to just "let it go" because I think to say he was or is manipulative is way too strong a term. I might say that you are worried about your DS being improperly labeled, and want a follow-up conversation. In that, I would ask the school for their suggestions on how to deal with a specific issue or specific behavior - as I feel that they should be doing that instead of criticizing or labeling kids. JMO. Chat Icon

Posted 3/31/10 9:35 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by colette

Exactly, I agree with YOU and the PPs!!!!!! What a rotten thing to label an 8 year old. Robbie wasn't even trying to "get something" i.e. a reward - it was to AVOID something, i.e. punishment. I think 'dishonest' is as far as I would go! People throw words around without thinking sometimes, I'm pretty sure I'd have a followup with them to make sure we 'understand each other' going forward....



Colette - perfectly said.

Every living being's behavior is governed by an acronym MEATS:

Medical
Escape/Avoidance
Attention
Tangible (to obtain somehting tangible)

Everything we do is either based on how we are feeling healthwise, to escape or avoid something (typically what we perceive as aversive or punishing), to get someone else's attention (or a consistent response even if it appears to be "bad attention") or to get a tangible desired item.

Based on the above, we are ALL manipulative. We manipulate our environment using the behavior that has worked for us in the past!

Posted 3/31/10 9:38 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Manipulative Children.

The only manipulative person in this story is the principal. He's throwing around terms to get a reaction out of you, and to try and further his cause (I'm not sure what that actually is, though...).

An 8 yo not saying that he's upset is NOT manipulative....Chat Icon

Posted 3/31/10 9:38 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Also - does Robbie admit his feelings to you? If so, maybe he doesn't feel it's anyone else's business if he is upset or not. He doesn't have to walk around with his heart n his sleeve.

Is it necessary for him to admit his feelings, or follow the rules and be a good kid in class?

If he got in trouble for doing something inappropriate that is 1 issue. Admitting his feelings - a separate issue completely.

I would ask which one is most important for the issue at hand - his behavior, his feelings, or his "manipulativeness?"



Robbie is a mush with me and very open about his feelings. But overall he's kind of hyper-rational and driven by logic. It just is who he is.

With regard to the situation she was referencing.. he was called to the principal's office and she said "You were upset when you did x,y,z" and he responded that he wasn't. So she told him.. "Well you MUST have been upset.. don't you think?" and Robbie said "No.. it was a joke" and she said "Well it's not a good joke, I think you were upset. Weren't you upset?" . Robbie finally said "Yeah.. I guess I was upset." And then he came home frustrated and truly upset and said he REALLY was not upset.. he was joking and the principal kept telling him he HAD to have been upset. THAT pizzed me off too.

Posted 3/31/10 9:38 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by rojerono

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Also - does Robbie admit his feelings to you? If so, maybe he doesn't feel it's anyone else's business if he is upset or not. He doesn't have to walk around with his heart n his sleeve.

Is it necessary for him to admit his feelings, or follow the rules and be a good kid in class?

If he got in trouble for doing something inappropriate that is 1 issue. Admitting his feelings - a separate issue completely.

I would ask which one is most important for the issue at hand - his behavior, his feelings, or his "manipulativeness?"



Robbie is a mush with me and very open about his feelings. But overall he's kind of hyper-rational and driven by logic. It just is who he is.

With regard to the situation she was referencing.. he was called to the principal's office and she said "You were upset when you did x,y,z" and he responded that he wasn't. So she told him.. "Well you MUST have been upset.. don't you think?" and Robbie said "No.. it was a joke" and she said "Well it's not a good joke, I think you were upset. Weren't you upset?" . Robbie finally said "Yeah.. I guess I was upset." And then he came home frustrated and truly upset and said he REALLY was not upset.. he was joking and the principal kept telling him he HAD to have been upset. THAT pizzed me off too.



UMMMMM - WHO is being manipulative in the above scenario?????

Posted 3/31/10 9:39 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Manipulative Children.

I think all kids are manipulative to a certain extent. I don't typically share a lot about this, but my DS is currently getting a lot of EI services. I have described him as manipulative myself, but it's more in the context of what Liza is saying. He behaves in a way that gets him what he wants. I do define that as being manipulative, but I don't necessarily think of it as a bad thing.

In the context of what the principal is saying, I would probably have a problem with it. I think in that context the term is being used as "deceitful". I am not sure I really object to the principal's use of the term, but rather how it was said to you. I am sure I can think of times I have said I wasn't upset, because it wasn't the place or time to get into a big discussion of my feelings. Why is it so wrong for a kid to do the same? Why can't he say no, and then come home and fall apart in front of you or his dad? I think as an educator, one should try to hone one's skills to get students to talk to you and it doesn't sound like that's what's happening here.

I just saw what the principal said to him. Why the interrogation? He's not upset, it's a joke, deal with the problem at hand and move on. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-03-31 09:43:40.810000.

Posted 3/31/10 9:39 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by GoldenRod

The only manipulative person in this story is the principal. He's throwing around terms to get a reaction out of you, and to try and further his cause (I'm not sure what that actually is, though...).

An 8 yo not saying that he's upset is NOT manipulative....Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ITA

I already can't stand my DS's principal and now I can't stand yours!

I also have to say even if you think it who says that to a parent?!!!Chat Icon I am so pizzzed for you!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/31/10 9:42 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Manipulative Children.

I think that he is being manipulative - by virtue of the definition of manipulative.

Etymology: back-formation from manipulation, from French, from manipuler to handle an apparatus in chemistry, ultimately from Latin manipulus
Date: 1834
1 : to treat or operate with or as if with the hands or by mechanical means especially in a skillful manner
2 a : to manage or utilize skillfully b : to control or play upon by artful, unfair, or insidious means especially to one's own advantage
3 : to change by artful or unfair means so as to serve one's purp

Both of my kid are manipulative too.

He's changing his answer to get a different reaction from the principal. EVERYONE is manipulative to some extent. The term wouldn't upset me. But I would have the feeling my child was being scrutinized to death. He's 8 for Pete's sake...he's no different than any other kid that would consider his options before he answers the question to an authority figure.

Tell the principal to stop playing child psychologist & get back to his job.

Edited:

I didn't read the update before...now I think your principal is even more of an azz. I'll ammend my last statement to - tell the principal to stop playing cop & get back to his job.

Message edited 2010-03-31 10:58:10.703000.

Posted 3/31/10 10:19 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by rojerono
With regard to the situation she was referencing.. he was called to the principal's office and she said "You were upset when you did x,y,z" and he responded that he wasn't. So she told him.. "Well you MUST have been upset.. don't you think?" and Robbie said "No.. it was a joke" and she said "Well it's not a good joke, I think you were upset. Weren't you upset?" . Robbie finally said "Yeah.. I guess I was upset." And then he came home frustrated and truly upset and said he REALLY was not upset.. he was joking and the principal kept telling him he HAD to have been upset. THAT pizzed me off too.



Maybe she was frustrated that he didn't show remorse for what he did? It's hard to say without knowing what exactly he did, but I could see it being frustrating if he hurt another student/stole, etc., and didn't seem to be upset or anxious at all about what he did (this is all a big "if"--without knowing what it was that he should have been upset about).

Posted 3/31/10 10:47 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Manipulative Children.

she def. did not use the right word, I would be really annoyed but not sure if I would escalate Chat Icon

Posted 3/31/10 11:03 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Manipulative Children.

I do not consider not admitting to feeling as being manipulative at all. This is such a severe labeling of a child or anyone.

Everybody does not feel like confortable sharing feelings. Whether you are upset or not. That does not make anyone manipulative because you do not open up to others.

Manipulative for me would be admitting you are upset or not upset so you know you will get something from someone out of it.


DS can be manipulative. Example: He does not want to nap and gets out of his toddler bed. After weeks of putting him back for the past 2 days he has come with a book in his hand to come see me when getting up. As he wants me to read him a story. He knows I like to read stories to him. Or he will come with one of his blanket and give it to me. He purposely give me an object to "appease" me in order to skip his nap. That's the definition of manipulative.

In regards to "forcing" feelings on how your son MUST be feeling, this is almost disturbing to tell you the truth.

Message edited 2010-03-31 11:18:55.350000.

Posted 3/31/10 11:14 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Manipulative Children.

Posted by GoldenRod

The only manipulative person in this story is the principal. He's throwing around terms to get a reaction out of you, and to try and further his cause (I'm not sure what that actually is, though...).

An 8 yo not saying that he's upset is NOT manipulative....Chat Icon



ITA.

Telling how your son MUST be feeling IS also manipulative.

Posted 3/31/10 11:19 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Manipulative Children.

can I suggest you bring Liza to the school? Chat Icon Chat Icon

when I hear manipulative 8-year-old, I think Damien of the Omen kind.

clearly that isn't going on here.

I will reiterate what Liza said...EVERYONE is manipulative.

It is built in our psyche!!!!!

I am sorry the principal was not able to ilicit a Dr. Doolittle response from Robbie. but you have the disposition of a SAINT for not going berzerker on this person.

why the need for the label?! how bad was Robbie's offense OR his general behavior for this to be happening. he would have to have a serious behavior issue before I would entertain such a label for my kid.

hugs to you and robbie.

and iIi (read between the lines *******) to the principal. Chat Icon

Posted 3/31/10 12:40 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Vaccines for Children, a must read Texas4Good 6/22/05 3 Parenting
all my children fans / general hospital fans luvsbob4603 6/14/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Do your children resemble you or their father? JennChris 6/11/05 17 Parenting
Children's Tylenol recalled dld4e 6/3/05 3 Parenting
All my children fans(only come in) luvsbob4603 5/31/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Children and relationships Redhead 5/31/05 14 Families Helping Families ™