Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted By Message

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

DH and I have been REALLY struggling to come up with a name for our Chat Icon . I have made list after list after list, and he shoots every name down. He has yet to offer up any names on his own, though.

He said "no" to my favorite name ever without so much as a reason for why he didn't like it.

The other night, I brought up the idea of naming him after my grandfather, whom I loved and adored beyond words. I thought it would be nice - this way the baby is named after both sides of our family. The middle name is going to be Richard (all the men in his family for 5 generations have been Richard with different middle names - I put my foot down on that because this is most likely going to be our only child and I didn't want the name pre-determined for us, KWIM?) He has an uncle that his family doesn't get along with by that same name that my grandfather had. I said to him "We can't base our name decision on knowing ONE person with that name - and besides, he would be OUR 'X'" He's also questioning the fact of why am I bringing up and loving this name NOW - Ummmm - maybe because we've gone through every other single name in the English language and you've shot them all down? Chat Icon

I know how much it would mean to my family to have this baby named after my Grandpa but I'm not doing it for that reason - it's just a good, solid, classic name that flows well with our last name.

I almost want to cave in and just name the freakin child Richard and call it a day because that would be SO much easier, but I'm sticking to my guns.

Any thoughts on how to persuade DH to come around?

Are we the only ones who, at almost 35 weeks, still have a nameless child?


Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-08-08 09:53:12.180000.

Posted 8/8/09 9:52 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

We were in the same situation with DS. Day after day I came up with lists of names and he shot down every single one of them. He came up with stupid reasons for each one. Like your DH he only came up with 2 names on his own. In the end I basically told him to get him azz on the computer and get me a list of names or he would have no say...lol. He saw one really liked and had on my list and said it wasn't that bad and he would think about it. the next day he called from work and agreed to the name. Personally I just think he didn't want to have to look for names and gave in to me...lol.

I am honestly dreading picking a name for this baby. I don't find it fun at all and wish they came with a name or number. J/K but I really don't want to do it again...lol.

Posted 8/8/09 10:01 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted by DmarieK

I don't find it fun at all and wish they came with a name or number. J/K but I really don't want to do it again...lol.



Like a Cabbage Patch Kid! How much easier would that be? Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/8/09 10:19 AM
 

MrsAT
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

881 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I wouldn't give in to a name that you didn't love just because your DH has shot down all of the names you've suggested. I think making a list would be a good idea. Perhaps you each sit down and make a list of 5 boy names each (on separate sheets of paper) and next to each name a reason why you like it or what you like about it. Then discuss and come to and stick to the names on this list to make a decision. (Because I know you're a teacher, think of it like a Think-Pair-Share prior to Shared Discussion Chat Icon )

Posted 8/8/09 10:44 AM
 

Marbo
LOVE

Member since 7/08

2374 total posts

Name:

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I am 32 wk and have the same problem...my dh wants to name the baby after his mom...and shoots down pretty much every other name i mentions...there is a short list though that he seemed to be ok with so even though he keeps going back to his mom's name he does say 'whatever you want', so i think i will pretty much be picking the name. The reason I refuse to use his mom's name is that he never brought up that he wanted to use that till the level 2. He is named after his dad and his brother had a boy last year and named him the same name and if we have a boy I am giving in and letting him use his name even though I dont love that there would be 4 of them with the same name. So I don't want each of my children if I ever have a boy in the future being named after his parents...You are not alone-I have no advice but plenty of Chat Icon b/c it is really tough.

Posted 8/8/09 11:07 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

What if you used the first initial of your grandfather's name?

I would definitely not give in to the name Richard just to make things easier.

Posted 8/8/09 11:45 AM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

we came up pretty easily with a name for a girl (well we had a BIG list but we agreed on one easily)
we are disagreeing about the boys name bc DH wants the baby named after him (dont like the idea of that or the name) any name I pick he says are too Italian and dont go with our last name. Plus I have a feeling this baby is a boy

Posted 8/8/09 2:06 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

we origionally planned with our first child to name it after dh's late mother... YEAH THAT WENT OVER BIG... our theory was that this was the first grand child and it would be a nice thought... my fil didnt care.. my bil was like but i want to name my first born that... MIND YOU he is not even dating anyone.. So in the end we opted to make the middle name after her...and irronically we had a boy and ds's middle name is still after her, but since it is the male version (patrick instead of patricia) i dont thing anyone has picked up on it...
however my family gave us a hard time because they felt it should have been after someone else.... we basically said it was our decision...



now for baby #2 we cant even decide on a boys name.. girls name is going to be the same choices as last time because we never used it....it is such a headache

Posted 8/8/09 2:52 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I love my grandfather's name also, Anthony, but it's also the name of my SIL's ex (who she has a kid with) that the family despises. DH says I can't use that name. It kind of really irks me to say the least. That name has happy memories for me - not sure why it has to be associated with someone they don't like.

I digress lol....This uncle of his has passed away right? Time for them to move on IMO - you should use the name! PS - I want to know what it is! Chat Icon

Posted 8/8/09 3:12 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Umm...im hitting 30 weeks this week and Chat Icon is still unnamed.

In our childbirth class when they went around and introduced everyone there was one other couple (out of 10 maybe) that didn't have a name. I felt like an ***..but oh well.

MY dh is stuck on Jack. Not john and we'll call him Jack, just Jack. The middle name is Thomas no matter what after his late father. Which im totally fine with that part.

My favorites are Eric, Daniel, & Dylan. He liked Jack and Brian. But every name i come up with he just shoots down with no reason.

I said i would agree to Jack Thomas if...I can call him JT..and i get naming rights to the 2nd baby..LOL

so far, we're at an impasse.

Posted 8/8/09 8:46 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I went through about a dozen names before deciding on the one we plan on using....My Mom gave me such a hard time with almost every name I chose...Either she didn't like it or told me that my Dad wouldn't like. (Mind ya he passed away in 2001). When we new he was no longer going to be with us, I made a promise to him and myself that I would name my first born son after him. My Mom flipped out. She can barely say his name now. So my son's name is going to be Brendan Aidan....And we plan on calling him Aidan. I was originally going to call him Aidan Brendan, but after thinking about it a while, I changed it back. I know of a lot of people who are called by their middle name. And when he gets older I can tell him all about his "Grandpa" and let him decide what he wants to be called....

Don't let others decide for you. You go with what you want....

Posted 8/8/09 9:22 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Having been through the name game before, it won't make a difference what name you pick. For me the name came to stand for my child, so as much as I was not onboard with the name, it means something different now.

Given the family history, I would probably pick Richard as the first name & your grandfather's name as the middle name, but call him by his middle name.

Message edited 2009-08-09 07:08:32.457000.

Posted 8/9/09 7:08 AM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I am Chat Icon to say that we were not able to pick a name for DS until he was THREE days old! The whole naming thing was absolutely so difficult for me and my DH too. It was torture trying to pick a name we both liked, especially boy names. We finally just had to compromise. We both like DS's name. It was not either of our first choices for different reasons, but we both like it a lot. We did not want to pick a name that I loved and my DH hated, or vice versa. So that's what we did.

I really have no advice, I just totally sympathize with you having just gone through it. But know that no matter what you pick, it is just a name. No matter what it is, you will love it because it is your DS's name, for that reason alone. Good luck!!

Posted 8/9/09 9:03 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Thanks girls - we went out with some friends yesterday and they brought up the whole "So, do you have a name yet?" thing (which, by the way, is becoming my #1 most hated question Chat Icon ) and I just looked at DH and gave him the sad eyes and said "I don't know, do we?" he responded with "You really want that name?" I said "Yeah" and then he said "You ALWAYS win!Chat Icon " - Granted, this was after MANY MANY pints of Guinness on his part, so I don't exactly know where we stand with it....

He also brought up another name and asked if we could give the kid 2 middle names (Richard and my grandfather's) - but then the initials would be either C.A.R.B. or C.R.A.B. Chat Icon and I'm not loving loving the name he suggested, even though it was on my list. Chat Icon

ARGHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/9/09 11:49 AM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted by Peainapod

Umm...im hitting 30 weeks this week and Chat Icon is still unnamed.

In our childbirth class when they went around and introduced everyone there was one other couple (out of 10 maybe) that didn't have a name. I felt like an ***..but oh well.

MY dh is stuck on Jack. Not john and we'll call him Jack, just Jack. The middle name is Thomas no matter what after his late father. Which im totally fine with that part.

My favorites are Eric, Daniel, & Dylan. He liked Jack and Brian. But every name i come up with he just shoots down with no reason.

I said i would agree to Jack Thomas if...I can call him JT..and i get naming rights to the 2nd baby..LOL

so far, we're at an impasse.



Personally, I LOVE the name Jack. Gave in to DH since it was his Uncle's name but so glad I did. I know its super popular but its such a great boys name. Especially when paired with a great middle name. Chat Icon

Posted 8/9/09 12:09 PM
 

bellaro
LIF Adult

Member since 7/06

927 total posts

Name:
Rosalia

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted by SweetTooth

What if you used the first initial of your grandfather's name?

I would definitely not give in to the name Richard just to make things easier.



I agree if you dont like that name richard stick to your guns..

Posted 8/9/09 12:41 PM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted by bellaro

Posted by SweetTooth

What if you used the first initial of your grandfather's name?

I would definitely not give in to the name Richard just to make things easier.



I agree if you dont like that name richard stick to your guns..



I don't mind the name Richard, but I prefer the nickname "Rick" which is what my DH goes by. I'm not a fan of "Rich" (my FIL) or the full name Richard. If my Rick wasn't a Rick, I'd have no problem with Richard. Hope that made sense!

Also, I want the baby to have his own identity and I would like him to have *something* from my side of the family. He'll have DH's last name (of course) why should he have to have his first name as well? I hope I'm not being a b!tch about this.... Chat Icon I know people name their DC's after parents all the time and I have no problem with that, just not for MY child.

Posted 8/9/09 1:15 PM
 

kms717
St Philomena Protect My Son

Member since 2/06

2747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

I had the same problem with DH coming up with a girl's name. Every name I picked out he shot down, I went through lists and lists and lists. The name I really love "Kyla" which means "a beauty that only poetry can capture." He would budge on, so I kept coming up with new ones, that sounded like "porn star names" to him "Krista" and "Courtney." I was ready to bang my head against the wall. Finally last night we had a break through. A couple of weeks ago I suggested the name "Shanna" and he shot it down. Well last night we went to see G.I. Joe and one of the characters', Scarlette, has a file name of Shana, now he loves the name Chat Icon! Go figure, it took a stupid movie to get him to change his mind. The only problem is now he wants to tell our child that she was named after a GI Joe character, when in fact I came suggested the name before I knew that.

Posted 8/9/09 1:31 PM
 

oktom22
Loving every minute

Member since 2/09

1663 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Posted by scarletbegonia

Posted by bellaro

Posted by SweetTooth

What if you used the first initial of your grandfather's name?

I would definitely not give in to the name Richard just to make things easier.



I agree if you dont like that name richard stick to your guns..



I don't mind the name Richard, but I prefer the nickname "Rick" which is what my DH goes by. I'm not a fan of "Rich" (my FIL) or the full name Richard. If my Rick wasn't a Rick, I'd have no problem with Richard. Hope that made sense!

Also, I want the baby to have his own identity and I would like him to have *something* from my side of the family. He'll have DH's last name (of course) why should he have to have his first name as well? I hope I'm not being a b!tch about this.... Chat Icon I know people name their DC's after parents all the time and I have no problem with that, just not for MY child.




WOW! I am in the EXACT same situation as you! My DH's name is Richard and so is his dad w/ different middle names. I don't mind the name Richard, but I'm not in love with it, and DH only likes one nickname and that's Rich, so what would we call DS?

Every single boys name I suggest DH shoots it down b/c he relates the name to some athlete or is indifferent about the name. And to add even more complications he told his immediate fam and now of course they shared their "opinions" on our top choices of names.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/9/09 1:32 PM
 

HillW9608
Hello Summer!

Member since 5/08

5916 total posts

Name:
Hill

Re: Man, this name thing is tough! (longish)

Ugh Im having the name problem now.. and there's less than 6 weeks left till my due date!!!! We had 2 names picked out for a girl.. but now we cant agree lol.. so we're still looking. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

If its a boy we're good.. but if its a girl she might be "baby" for a day or two!!!

Posted 8/9/09 7:21 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Totally a "man" thing to do... SummerMom 10/24/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Funny pic I found. My grandmother playing pin the "thing" on the man... Jessica 12/10/06 17 Families Helping Families ™
Good thing/Bad thing...longish TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog 1/23/09 2 Families Helping Families ™