Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Posted By Message

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

The ONLY rule in my house growing up was “DO NOT LIE” it was huge. It was literally the only thing we could count on. You could royally mess things up but as long as you told the truth you knew you’d get through it. Lie, and man oh man things were a thousand times worse.

But she’s 3.5yrs old. How far do I go?

She wanted pirates booty (poofs) last night because she saw the bag but dinner was like 5-10mins to the plate. We both said no. She starts in on Daddy. “BUT I *NEED* it daddy” He offers her a chicken nugget instead or her favorite thing – bread. She starts to cry “NO I don’t want it. I want poofs.” She comes to me. I back up Daddy. “Daddy said no because its almost dinner time” She goes back to Daddy and starts to have a melt down.

In case you don’t know I do not tolerate stupid whiney mayhem lightly. I storm in with my stern voice “AJ!” Tears in eyes she stops to look at me. “What’s going on?”

Here where things get bad.

“Daddy shooed me” Which is her saying he shoved her
What? No AJ tell me the truth
*nods* Yes Daddy pushed me
AJ! That’s not nice. Don’t lie
I’m not *shakes head*
AJ, I was right there (pointing to hall) I saw it all. Daddy did NOT push you and he did NOT shove you, right?
*shakes head no* “Yes he did”
??!?!?!
AJ???.. What did daddy do?
He hit me
Jim: I did NOT hit you AJ!
“yes you did”

I put her on my lap wipe away some tears and keep asking her in different ways to tell the truth. She is determined he hit her, cut her, shoved her AND pushed her! I ask where he cut her, she shows me a scratch I saw when she came home from school. I ask where he pushed her, shoved her or hit her and she points to various parts of her body.

To say I’m angry is an understatement.

I feel terrible but I basically call her a liar and say none of those things happened.. all the while my brain is thinking “what if a kid or adult did do one of these things, how can I trust her?”

Finally tears still silently falling from her cheeks she agrees Daddy didn’t do any of those things and she was upset because she couldn’t have poofs. During this time I had threatened time out/thinking time and she looked upset I didn’t believe her and would get frantically upset.

So as much as I wanted to punish her for lying to me. I held her, told her I loved her, explained that lying is bad. Told her if she tells the truth she doesn’t go to time out. She apologized to daddy actually choking up in tears through it.

Then I distracted her by saying what happened to her arm “I scratched it” she told the truth. So we had a mini-operation in the house (aka paper towels, water, Band-Aid and Neosporin). She got over it, we had dinner and moved on.

Later as we were putting up the dishes I tell my hubby. “do you know how hard it was for me not to punish her for that?”

Sorry so long but really this is the only major rule I have. No lying. What the heck am I going to do. She’s been getting worse and worse at these little lies. She had a hang nail, my aunt gave her a band aid and she told people her fingers were smashed in a door. What?! She keeps making stuff up. But to lie about hitting. Ugh.

(here’s to hoping that putting it out there means she’ll stop doing it, ha)

Sorry so long

Message edited 2012-02-22 12:43:15.180000.

Posted 2/22/12 12:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

I think it's too early to punish her for lying...because she doesn't understand what it is that she's doing. I mean, she's hearing stories from books, watching tv, movies, etc...where all sorts of things are being made up for her. She's imitating what she's seeing in her environment...not understanding that it's wrong to do.
I think talking to her, and explaining why it's wrong to lie is the best way to go at this age. She's exploring her world, testing her boundaries and using her imagination...all good things!
Punishment can come later when she knows it's wrong to lie and does it any way!

(Lily did the same thing)

Posted 2/22/12 12:47 PM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Posted by Palebride

I think it's too early to punish her for lying...because she doesn't understand what it is that she's doing. I mean, she's hearing stories from books, watching tv, movies, etc...where all sorts of things are being made up for her. She's imitating what she's seeing in her environment...not understanding that it's wrong to do.
I think talking to her, and explaining why it's wrong to lie is the best way to go at this age. She's exploring her world, testing her boundaries and using her imagination...all good things!
Punishment can come later when she knows it's wrong to lie and does it any way!

(Lily did the same thing)



ITA
It's the age. I remember when my nieces and nephews went through it (and still do it once in a while).
It's when the manipulating starts and really doesn't stop.
As the PP said. Too early to punish, but explain to her about hurting other people through words. How wrong words can hurt people. Also, how important it is to tell the truth when it comes to lying about abuse.
Sorry, besides dealing with it with my older nieces and nephews I'm not there yet with my boys b/c they're too young

Posted 2/22/12 12:50 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Ds has been lying and it drives me insane. He is now 4 so if I see him do something like hit is sister and then lie and say he didn't I will send him to his room until he apologizes to her for hitting and me for lying. He has no toys in his room and no TV just books. But he usually just sits on his bed crying. We are at the point where I try keep talking with him until he admits he lied and apologizes for lying. He also needs to tell me why he lied. But sometimes he is just too suborn and as to got think in his room.
For ds it is usually he doesn't want to get in trouble. SO I have been making a big deal about when he tells me the truth and point out that mommy didn't get mad that you spilled the juice because you told the truth. Or you are not supposed to draw on the walls with crayon. I am glad you told mommy the truth but please do not draw on the walls. We draw on paper only. Then I give him a baby wipe and make him clean the wall himself. I think this week we have finally been making some progress after a very very long month of lying.

Posted 2/22/12 1:18 PM
 

Jenny614
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1065 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Maybe introduce the story of the boy who cried wolf....but make it into this huge dramatic story with a pretty serious consequence. that way when you think she may be lying you can remind her of the boy who cried wolf...i dont know just an idea

Posted 2/22/12 1:19 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Thanks ladies.

It is hard. I feel bad for her but also a little lost. Good to know I'm not alone.

Hubby says "Well she probably felt like I was cutting, shoving, hurting her when I said she couldn't have the puffs"

I guess I made a gut choice that she was hurting enough and was struggling to understand why all of a sudden I was sitting with her eye to eye asking such important questions about something she thought very little about.

I don't want to scare her into always saying what an adult WANTS to hear either. Chat Icon

Posted 2/22/12 5:24 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: Lying.. how do you deal with it? (long)

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/22/12 7:58 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
ok whats the real deal with lying on your back? nancygrace 9/4/06 14 Pregnancy
Looking for Sympathy ...how do you deal with MrsJ 9/8/05 35 Pregnancy
where to get the best deal on appliances? Dani 8/8/05 6 Families Helping Families ™
AMAZING DEAL ALERT!!! (xpost from liw) Shorty 6/27/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
How do you deal with cheapness? LFitzy79 6/6/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
What's the deal with stretching? jcndd 6/2/05 6 Pregnancy