Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Lutheran vs. Catholic

What are the differences?

Posted 9/5/12 2:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

I am Catholic and STBX is Protestant but Methodist. I think the one big difference is they don't pray to saints. Anyway that's what he always told me. Though it never made any sense since his church was SAINT John's United Methodist. Not sure if that helps you

Posted 9/5/12 2:06 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

This is probably a terrible generalization, but Lutheranism is like Catholicism without the heavy emphasis on the saints and Mary. And no pope Chat Icon

Posted 9/5/12 2:07 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?

Posted 9/5/12 2:09 PM
 

ItsaJoya19
my cup runneth over

Member since 1/10

2949 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

I was baptized Catholic and confirmed Lutheran...

I was married in my DH's Catholic church.

Some churches are strict about it, some aren't. You can call and ask.


The main differences are there are no saints, no First Holy Communion (that comes at Confirmation), no crucifix (He is risen), no pope, and it's generally more laid back.

eta: we had a Pastor - no priests, no cardinals, no bishops, etc.

Message edited 2012-09-05 14:21:56.057000.

Posted 9/5/12 2:18 PM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

They have saints they just don't pray to them and they don't pray to Mary or follow the pope. They were one of the first to break off from the Catholic church so the Lutheran branch of Protestantism is very closely related to the Catholic church.

Posted 9/5/12 2:20 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?



Yes, it is definitely allowed and possible. I'm sure that you will find a church or two that won't allow it, but these are the basic rules to the best of my knowledge (and I have done a lot of research on this):

If they are married in the Catholic church, a Lutheran minister can be part of the ceremony. DH and I are both Catholic, married in a Catholic church, and an Episcopalian reverend was part of the ceremony (loooong story).

If they are married in a Lutheran church, the Catholic can still have the marriage recognized by Rome. I believe that there is just some paperwork that needs to be completed.

Posted 9/5/12 2:23 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by 2boys4me

They have saints they just don't pray to them and they don't pray to Mary or follow the pope. They were one of the first to break off from the Catholic church so the Lutheran branch of Protestantism is very closely related to the Catholic church.



Yes, they believe in saints and churches are named after them, etc. They also believe that Mary is the mother of Jesus. But they don't honor them to the level that the Catholics do. Basically, when a Lutheran loses his keys, he doesn't pray to St. Anthony Chat Icon

Posted 9/5/12 2:25 PM
 

laurabora
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2712 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?



Yes, I'm Catholic and DH is Lutheran...my dad is Lutheran and my mom is Catholic...DH's dad is Catholic and his mom is Lutheran...my brother is Catholic and SIL is Lutheran! Apparently it's a common mix!Chat Icon

Posted 9/5/12 2:31 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Do Lutherans believe in the true presence and transubstantiation?

Posted 9/5/12 2:33 PM
 

BeachGrl
LIF Adult

Member since 10/11

2140 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?



Yes, I'm Catholic and my husband is Lutheran. We got married in my Catholic church. They were fine with it, as long as he made all his sacraments.

The main differences that I notice are they don't pray to saints or Mary(for ex, they don't recite the hail mary). They don't have any statues of saints or Mary in their churches. They do not have holy water for dipping your fingers in when you enter and exit church. They do not have a pope or figure head. They also don't have Jesus hanging on the cross in their church. There are no candles to light.

There are a bunch of other differences too, I just can't remember them all off the top of my head.

Posted 9/5/12 2:44 PM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

also, Lutherans do not do individual confessions

Posted 9/5/12 2:53 PM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?

Yes, I did.

Posted 9/5/12 3:11 PM
 

Kris
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1051 total posts

Name:
Kristine

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

They do have 1st Communion. I went to my Lutheran friend's son's in MAy!

Posted 9/5/12 3:16 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by JenniferEver

Do Lutherans believe in the true presence and transubstantiation?



No. From what I have read, it is sort of a gray area, closer to consubstantiation.

Posted 9/5/12 3:37 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

ok here's a monkey wrench...can a divorced Catholic (who was previously married in a church) marry a Lutheran who has never been married?

For those of you that know my story, I am NOT getting married/engaged....but it's been a topic of conversation for BF and I. Just asking out of curiosity.

Posted 9/5/12 3:38 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

ok here's a monkey wrench...can a divorced Catholic (who was previously married in a church) marry a Lutheran who has never been married?

For those of you that know my story, I am NOT getting married/engaged....but it's been a topic of conversation for BF and I. Just asking out of curiosity.



In which church?
In a Catholic church it wouldn't be allowed unless the Catholic marriage had been annulled.

Message edited 2012-09-05 15:47:05.597000.

Posted 9/5/12 3:46 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

ok here's a monkey wrench...can a divorced Catholic (who was previously married in a church) marry a Lutheran who has never been married?

For those of you that know my story, I am NOT getting married/engaged....but it's been a topic of conversation for BF and I. Just asking out of curiosity.



To get married in the Catholic church, you'd have to get the marriage annulled through the church.

I am not 100% sure on this, but I do not believe you'd have to have the marriage annulled to be married in a Lutheran church.

Posted 9/5/12 3:55 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?



Yes...my husband is Catholic and Im Lutheran and we got married in my church by a woman minister! Chat Icon

Posted 9/5/12 3:55 PM
 

laurabora
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2712 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

ok here's a monkey wrench...can a divorced Catholic (who was previously married in a church) marry a Lutheran who has never been married?

For those of you that know my story, I am NOT getting married/engaged....but it's been a topic of conversation for BF and I. Just asking out of curiosity.



I am 99% sure you can get married in the Lutheran church (my MIL divorced and remarried).

You can't in the Catholic church, like a PP said, unless the marriage was annulled.

Posted 9/5/12 4:51 PM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

From
http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/The-Basics/What-Lutherans-Believe.aspx


Lutherans are Christians who accept the teachings of Martin Luther (1483 – 1546). Luther was a German theologian who realized that there were significant differences between what he read in the Bible and the practices of the Roman Catholic church at that time. On October 31, 1517, he posted a challenge on the door of Wittenberg University, titled “95 Theses” (to debate 95 theological issues). His hope was that the church would reform its practice and preaching to be more consistent with the Word of God as contained in the Bible.

What started as an academic debate escalated into a distinct separation between the Roman Catholic church of the time and those who accepted Luther’s suggested reforms. "Lutheran" became the name of the group that agreed with Luther’s convictions.

Today, nearly five centuries later, Lutherans still celebrate the Reformation on October 31 and still hold to the basic principles of Luther’s theological teachings, such as Grace alone, faith alone, Scripture alone. These comprise the very essence of Lutheranism:

We are saved by the grace of God alone -- not by anything we do;
Our salvation is through faith alone -- a confident trust in God, who in Christ promises us forgiveness, life and salvation; and
The Bible is the norm for faith and life -- the true standard by which teachings and doctrines are to be judged.
Over the years, different Lutheran church bodies have been established and organized to meet the needs of Lutherans in communities and nations all over the world. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America is the largest Lutheran group in North America, founded in 1988 when three North American Lutheran church bodies united: The American Lutheran Church, the Association of Evangelical Lutheran Churches and the Lutheran Church in America. Learn more about the History of the ELCA.

Lutherans are part of a reforming movement within the whole Christian church; as a part of practicing their faith, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and its predecessors have engaged in ecumenical dialogue with other church bodies for decades. In fact, the ELCA has entered into cooperative "full communion" agreements (sharing common convictions about theology, mission and worship) with several other Protestant denominations, including

the Moravian Church
The Episcopal Church
the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
the Reformed Church in America
the United Church of Christ
the United Methodist Church

The ELCA has an ongoing dialogue with the Roman Catholic Church, and in 1999, representatives of the Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. This represented a historic consensus on key issues of faith and called for further dialogue and study together.

To learn more about these ecumenical relationships, visit Ecumenical and Inter-Religious Relations.

Lutheranism is a faith tradition that is open to all, regardless of background. The ELCA alone is almost five million members strong, with nearly 10,500 congregations across the U.S., Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. In fact, there’s probably an ELCA congregation right in your community We welcome you to learn more about our church and find out how we can help you along life’s path.



Posted 9/5/12 7:37 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by Pooka

so can a Lutheran and Catholic marry in a church?



yep my bff is catholic and her dh is lutheran

Posted 9/5/12 8:11 PM
 

Alexandra17
Keep It Positive

Member since 4/09

6262 total posts

Name:
Alexandra (ali)

Lutheran vs. Catholic

I am pretty sure you have to get annulled first but if you call a rectory up and just say you were wondering, they are pretty good at answering questions. I know that my mom and bf have to get annullments if they get married in an actual church.

Posted 9/5/12 8:47 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
♥

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by JenniferEver

Do Lutherans believe in the true presence and transubstantiation?



We believe in True Presence, but we believe that at Communion we are taking bread and body and wine and blood. We do not believe that the bread/wine turns into the body/blood but that we are taking all 4 at the same time. Does that make sense? We are Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran.

Posted 9/5/12 10:17 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Lutheran vs. Catholic

Posted by PeasandCarrots

Posted by JenniferEver

Do Lutherans believe in the true presence and transubstantiation?



We believe in True Presence, but we believe that at Communion we are taking bread and body and wine and blood. We do not believe that the bread/wine turns into the body/blood but that we are taking all 4 at the same time. Does that make sense? We are Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran.


Interesting! Thanks for sharing. I didn't realize that Lutherans believe in true presence.

Posted 9/5/12 10:45 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone send their kid to Trinity Lutheran School in Hicksville? trnity44 4/4/11 0 Parenting
Has anyone been to the pumpkin patch at the Lutheran church on Hempstead Tpke in Levittown? trnity44 10/20/10 3 Parenting
east rockaway mother's center VS grace lutheran (malverne)--anyone able to recommend one over the other? browneyedgirl 5/3/10 1 Parenting
What are the requirements to teach in Catholic School? JenniferEver 5/31/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Catholic Posters - What are you giving up for Lent? Elbee 3/1/06 47 Families Helping Families ™