LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted By Message
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by mathteach

Posted by Leeners

I'm so surprised at all of the negative reviews of the finale on this thread. I honestly thought it was genius!

*The island was real - all of the craziness, the sci fi crap that kept us all glued every week. "Whatever happened, happened" Chat Icon

*Never did we but we always should have taken the show at face value. Always looking for answers - the why's - instead of living in the "Now" that no longer exists once we're dead.

*Jack died when we saw him shut his eyes at the end but the rest of them died at completely different periods. They were the ages / looks they were when they knew each other - because "this is the place [they] all created". That was the most important time in their lives, per Christian, so when they died, that was the community they recreated.

*We, the audience, and we, humans, make things more complicated than they need to be. We took what were plot points to get us to this ultimate ending and put all of our emphasis on 'the little things' - as we tend to do in life - when all that matters at The End is our relationships and the community we build.

*Humanity is inherently flawed but we can change, we can make up for our misgivings. "Nothing is irreversible" Chat Icon

I felt so content when the show ended, so at peace Chat Icon There will always be a few plot points they could have ironed out, a few things they could have done differently, explained better (ahem, WALT??) but I think it organically adds to the 'we're not perfect, we can't do it alone, we make mistakes, things can be changed' part of the resolution.

I loved it and I will miss this show desperately Chat Icon



ITA!!!



I agree...

I also loved the ending...and I love how the island is still mysterious...it would take FOREVER to end the show to explain all...I'm glad it ended like it did.

I will say though the first half of the series I liked best

and DH and I are going to take a break and then watch the whole series again from the beginning...are we crazy?Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 8:27 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jen2999
Baby girls & beagles rock!

Member since 8/06

10356 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

The island can't be explained....it just can't.

No one know what happens when we die, but I sure hope Lost got it right....

I love that Jack didn't "die alone" bc Vincent was with him....
Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 8:30 AM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by DirtyBlonde

Posted by DPerotti

so then they WERE in purgatory this whole damn time!!!!



no - the writers came out and said a while ago that the island is NOT purgatory



Right! The island was real, but the flash sideways was purgatory where they were all waiting for each other.

Posted 5/24/10 8:54 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Leeners

I'm so surprised at all of the negative reviews of the finale on this thread. I honestly thought it was genius!

*The island was real - all of the craziness, the sci fi crap that kept us all glued every week. "Whatever happened, happened" Chat Icon

*Never did we but we always should have taken the show at face value. Always looking for answers - the why's - instead of living in the "Now" that no longer exists once we're dead.

*Jack died when we saw him shut his eyes at the end but the rest of them died at completely different periods. They were the ages / looks they were when they knew each other - because "this is the place [they] all created". That was the most important time in their lives, per Christian, so when they died, that was the community they recreated.

*We, the audience, and we, humans, make things more complicated than they need to be. We took what were plot points to get us to this ultimate ending and put all of our emphasis on 'the little things' - as we tend to do in life - when all that matters at The End is our relationships and the community we build.

*Humanity is inherently flawed but we can change, we can make up for our misgivings. "Nothing is irreversible" Chat Icon

I felt so content when the show ended, so at peace Chat Icon There will always be a few plot points they could have ironed out, a few things they could have done differently, explained better (ahem, WALT??) but I think it organically adds to the 'we're not perfect, we can't do it alone, we make mistakes, things can be changed' part of the resolution.

I loved it and I will miss this show desperately Chat Icon



ITA!

I loved the ending!



I agree that this is what it was all about.

I didn't like the left open things though. I never really understood what the " light" was on the island, how jabob and the MIB were choosen, how the lady who raised them was choosen, what Dharma was trying to do, why teh babies couldnt be born there,where Walt went.

Posted 5/24/10 9:11 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

ehhhh I was disappointed. They definitely let a LOT of points slip and the ending was so-so IMO.

Posted 5/24/10 10:19 AM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

The Greatest Con of All=LOST

I love this show and was not happy with the ending


Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 10:34 AM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

I can't remember for the life of me and I don't have time to watch it again, right now...

What happened to Desmond once Hugo and Ben pulled him up from the waterfall/light? How did they "send him home"? Did they show that?

Posted 5/24/10 10:44 AM
 

bird382
.

Member since 7/07

1712 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

I liked the ending. It was so moving watching them all reconnect. It was peaceful and sort of perfect.

I'm fine with not getting all the answers. It was pretty clear early on -- like in Season 2 or 3 -- that we'd never really know everything.

Posted 5/24/10 10:44 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by Deedlebugs

I can't remember for the life of me and I don't have time to watch it again, right now...

What happened to Desmond once Hugo and Ben pulled him up from the waterfall/light? How did they "send him home"? Did they show that?



No, they didn't show that.

Add me to the "I was disappointed" crew.

I did cry at the end, but only because I was still SO confused, and was frustrated with the ending.

I "get" it, ya know.... but for me it was very anit-climatic. There were still alot of questions unanswered. I had even said to DH a couple of weeks ago how I thought the sideways world was like an after-life, but I think I just expected ALOT more for the end of the series. The writing and the show has been genious for 6 years and I really felt the end was so lack luster for the how creative the show has been, kwim?

Posted 5/24/10 10:50 AM
 

tiki03
*************

Member since 9/05

8660 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by PumpkinGirl

So... Chat Icon

If Penny was at the church with Desmond but wasn't in the crash or on the island... Then why was Sayid with Shannon instead of with Nadia (or whatever her name was)?

and where were Michael & Walt??


BTW.. I LOVE that Vincent the dog was included, I was really hoping he would be! Chat Icon



That's exactly what I said to DH. Where was Michael and Walt? How come they weren't there at the end.

Posted 5/24/10 10:54 AM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by MrsRbk

No, they didn't show that.

Add me to the "I was disappointed" crew.

I did cry at the end, but only because I was still SO confused, and was frustrated with the ending.

I "get" it, ya know.... but for me it was very anit-climatic. There were still alot of questions unanswered. I had even said to DH a couple of weeks ago how I thought the sideways world was like an after-life, but I think I just expected ALOT more for the end of the series. The writing and the show has been genious for 6 years and I really felt the end was so lack luster for the how creative the show has been, kwim?



I agree completely.

Anti-climactic. That's a good way to describe it.

And I "got" it too. I'd like to see the alternate endings. Maybe that will clear some other things up.

DH has been watching since the beginning and he's just glad that it's over and he can move on with his life now Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 10:56 AM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

I loved it.

I cried more times than I can count.

I feel satisfied with it and can move on peacefully. Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 11:12 AM
 

Ma-n-Pa2008
Mommy's Big Boy

Member since 3/09

2584 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by timanda

Posted by MrsRbk

No, they didn't show that.

Add me to the "I was disappointed" crew.

I did cry at the end, but only because I was still SO confused, and was frustrated with the ending.

I "get" it, ya know.... but for me it was very anit-climatic. There were still alot of questions unanswered. I had even said to DH a couple of weeks ago how I thought the sideways world was like an after-life, but I think I just expected ALOT more for the end of the series. The writing and the show has been genious for 6 years and I really felt the end was so lack luster for the how creative the show has been, kwim?



I agree completely.

Anti-climactic. That's a good way to describe it.

And I "got" it too. I'd like to see the alternate endings. Maybe that will clear some other things up.

DH has been watching since the beginning and he's just glad that it's over and he can move on with his life now Chat Icon



i agree with both of you also.
anti-climactic is exactly how i would describe it. and from what i heard the alternate endings on Jimmy Kimmel are just spoofs! I was very disappointed when i heard that!

Posted 5/24/10 11:27 AM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Ok, after thinking about it more. I do "get" it, but I'm still annoyed. It's still like a cop-out to me and not for nothing, why should I have to figure it all out or even a majority of stuff? I'm not getting paid millions like the writers. My impression since the writers said "Oh, it's not purgatory" was that it WAS supposed to be purgatory on the island and when people figured it out, they had to scramble to come up with another explanation, and that's what I thought it completely seemed like.

Posted 5/24/10 11:42 AM
 

Diva
I am what I am

Member since 12/05

2825 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

In the scheme of things it's not a big deal, but why was faraday's mom so worried that Desmond was going to take her son? And why was she so adamant about stopping him from making everyone "aware"?
And I also don't understand Charles Widmore's return to the island? Did he know about Jacob?

Posted 5/24/10 12:12 PM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by Diva

In the scheme of things it's not a big deal, but why was faraday's mom so worried that Desmond was going to take her son? And why was she so adamant about stopping him from making everyone "aware"?
And I also don't understand Charles Widmore's return to the island? Did he know about Jacob?



I don't know about the first two qeustions. But, Whidmore said that Jacob came to him and showed him the error of his ways and told him he had to go back to the island, and told him to bring Desmond as a "fail safe".



The more I think about it, the more frustrated I get about it.

Now that I see how the end all worked out, I'm unhappy with how they were still introducing new characters (Ilana, Dogan) all the way into the 5th season. Especially when in the grand scheme of things, those characters explained very little (and certainly not anything that Jacob couldn't have explained himself that last night by the fire). It was just confusing and unnecessarily dragged the story out just to have them die off.

Posted 5/24/10 12:26 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by timanda

Posted by Diva

In the scheme of things it's not a big deal, but why was faraday's mom so worried that Desmond was going to take her son? And why was she so adamant about stopping him from making everyone "aware"?
And I also don't understand Charles Widmore's return to the island? Did he know about Jacob?



I don't know about the first two qeustions. But, Whidmore said that Jacob came to him and showed him the error of his ways and told him he had to go back to the island, and told him to bring Desmond as a "fail safe".



The more I think about it, the more frustrated I get about it.

Now that I see how the end all worked out, I'm unhappy with how they were still introducing new characters (Ilana, Dogan) all the way into the 5th season. Especially when in the grand scheme of things, those characters explained very little (and certainly not anything that Jacob couldn't have explained himself that last night by the fire). It was just confusing and unnecessarily dragged the story out just to have them die off.



Ilana was supposed to be Jacob's daughter but they didn't have time in the season to explore that story line.

Our house isn't happy with season 6 and the end, just seems too disconnected from seasons 1-5

Posted 5/24/10 12:41 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by timanda

Posted by Diva

In the scheme of things it's not a big deal, but why was faraday's mom so worried that Desmond was going to take her son? And why was she so adamant about stopping him from making everyone "aware"?
And I also don't understand Charles Widmore's return to the island? Did he know about Jacob?



I don't know about the first two qeustions. But, Whidmore said that Jacob came to him and showed him the error of his ways and told him he had to go back to the island, and told him to bring Desmond as a "fail safe".



The more I think about it, the more frustrated I get about it.

Now that I see how the end all worked out, I'm unhappy with how they were still introducing new characters (Ilana, Dogan) all the way into the 5th season. Especially when in the grand scheme of things, those characters explained very little (and certainly not anything that Jacob couldn't have explained himself that last night by the fire). It was just confusing and unnecessarily dragged the story out just to have them die off.



Ilana was supposed to be Jacob's daughter but they didn't have time in the season to explore that story line.

Our house isn't happy with season 6 and the end, just seems too disconnected from seasons 1-5




Chat Icon Chat Icon was that mentioned somewhere?

Posted 5/24/10 1:22 PM
 

Elbee
Zanzibar

Member since 5/05

10767 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

I'm left with more questions than answers. It seems they took on a whole new story with bringing them all together to go in heaven. Not sure how that correlates to the last 6 seasons. Great, they all go into their heaven together, but why were they brought together?

I have so many questions, maybe some were answered and I don't realize but

1. what is the purpose of the good vs evil plot? Who cares about the MIB - what harm did he do on the island? Why wasn't he allowed to leave? What would have happened if he did?

2. Why did Jacob have to protect the light? What purpose did it serve? What would have happened if Jack didn't replug it? The island would sink? So? Why can't it sink?

3. Why did Darhma and Whitmore and others come to the island? To do what exactly? And why did Whitmore want control so bad? What powers does the Island actually hold? And why were they so important?

4. Where did all the elctromagnetism go? If that's why Darhma was there, where did it go? And what purpose did it have in the plot?

I watched for 6 years and honestly don't get a 'full circle' feeling. I feel like it was completely disjointed. Maybe I am taking everything too face value, but in the end, Jack died, and what did it do? Who did Hurley protect the island from now? Why did he need to protect it now that Locke/MIB is dead?

UGHHH

Message edited 2010-05-24 13:26:22.210000.

Posted 5/24/10 1:25 PM
 

landj
After 4 years, 1000 posts!

Member since 7/06

1124 total posts

Name:
L

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Arieschick29

OK DH had to explain it to me because I was crying too much during the Christian/Jack scene


The island was NOT purgatory- the sideverse WAS!

The plane crash and island were real but when you died, on the island (or anytime afterward- time did not count "there"/sideverse/church whatever.)

So once they remembered, it was time for them to move on. They all met together, looking like they did on the island but actually most of them probably lived long lives once the few of them got off the island.


So far that's my best understanding- so the writers didnt lie about them being dead and in purgatory on the island, it was actually the opposite!





This was my take on it too!!

I actually loved it! I was happy they were all together again. I loved the Sayid/Shannon reunion and the Charlie/Claire one.Chat Icon


Did anyone else think when Jack first walked into the back of the church that Eko would be the priest?



Agreed. I needed to "sleep on it" but I think that makes total sense. I woke up thinking the same thing.

anyone watch Kimmel? I couldnt make it up.

I think they all "waited" for eah other int he flash sideways until they could all be together.

Also think that Ben couldnt "move on" yet. He apologizes to Locke but is still unhappy with the way he lived his life.

Christian says that it is a place that they all created to find each other again.... the place was the flashsideways, not the island.

When Hurley says "you were a great number 2" it made me think that a lot of time has passed since the island/jack dying ect which makes sense as to why Penny was there.

Sun and Claire being pregnant makes sense with this theory too. They both had their babies and knew their names in the real timeline of their lives...

I keep thinking of more....



YES! These are the main theories being circulated around the internet. The island was NOT purgatory but the flash sideways world was a place that I guess you could call purgatory. All of the people needed to find each other again (in flash sideways world) before they could move on (toward the "light"). Remember Jack's father said that some people at the church died before him and some long after he was gone? And remember Hurley said to Ben he was a good #2? Hurley is an example of one person who lived long past Jack's time, protecting the island. That's why he made that statement. In the flash sideways world, there is no time. Sawyer, Miles, Kate, etc. all did get off the island and went on to live their lives. But the island helps to bring them all back together and find each other once they have passed on.

Posted 5/24/10 1:30 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Ok, I loved the ending. It did take me a while to figure it out, but it makes so much sense. Like two or so episodes before when Jacob's and MIB's mom said to thier real mom. Every question will lead to another question. All of the questions that people want really doesn't matter. Desmond even told Jack this. "All this doesn't matter". What matter was the relationships with each other on the island. Nothing else really mattered. The MIB, Jacob, the new people were there simply to shape the individuals on the island to be who the would ultimately be in their lives.

Posted 5/24/10 1:43 PM
 

diva7531
My Peanut

Member since 2/07

5199 total posts

Name:
Ryan 3 boys EDD 11/6!

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

My Theory:
Ben and Michael didn't go to heaven, they did too many bad things. I felt very, very peaceful at the end. Kinda how I am hoping it feels to "pass on".

I think the island was real and the flash sideways was the purgatory. And Kate made it off the island and died later (that's why she had different clothes on). And like how Hurley said to Ben "you were a great #2, like they were on the island for a while after Jack's death.

I just remember crying, but feeling completely safe, confident and peaceful. LOVED it!

PS- I knew they couldn't bring Walt back, purely because he is 6'5", it just wouldn't make sense.

Posted 5/24/10 1:48 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by diva7531

My Theory:
Ben and Michael didn't go to heaven, they did too many bad things. I felt very, very peaceful at the end. Kinda how I am hoping it feels to "pass on".

I think the island was real and the flash sideways was the purgatory. And Kate made it off the island and died later (that's why she had different clothes on). And like how Hurley said to Ben "you were a great #2, like they were on the island for a while after Jack's death.
.



I agree except that I think Ben is still alive & has not redeemed himself sufficiently.

I like the theory of the light as the "lifeforce" that all of mankind has inside them but yet wants more. Someone on Lostpedia posted their theory of how because the MIB was good & evil, the good was sucked back into the lifeforce & the evil came out of the tunnel as the smoke monster.

I also am completely amused that my sister called me last night to explain what was happening because she decided to watch it for the first time. Where the heck do you start an explanation of all of this?Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 2:23 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by MrsRbk

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by timanda

Posted by Diva

In the scheme of things it's not a big deal, but why was faraday's mom so worried that Desmond was going to take her son? And why was she so adamant about stopping him from making everyone "aware"?
And I also don't understand Charles Widmore's return to the island? Did he know about Jacob?



I don't know about the first two qeustions. But, Whidmore said that Jacob came to him and showed him the error of his ways and told him he had to go back to the island, and told him to bring Desmond as a "fail safe".



The more I think about it, the more frustrated I get about it.

Now that I see how the end all worked out, I'm unhappy with how they were still introducing new characters (Ilana, Dogan) all the way into the 5th season. Especially when in the grand scheme of things, those characters explained very little (and certainly not anything that Jacob couldn't have explained himself that last night by the fire). It was just confusing and unnecessarily dragged the story out just to have them die off.



Ilana was supposed to be Jacob's daughter but they didn't have time in the season to explore that story line.

Our house isn't happy with season 6 and the end, just seems too disconnected from seasons 1-5




Chat Icon Chat Icon was that mentioned somewhere?



Interview at last weeks end of season party

She was asked about her comment in the show about Jacob being as close to a father as I've ever had

Posted 5/24/10 2:41 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: LOST.... the finale!!!!!!

Posted by MrsRbk

Posted by Deedlebugs

I can't remember for the life of me and I don't have time to watch it again, right now...

What happened to Desmond once Hugo and Ben pulled him up from the waterfall/light? How did they "send him home"? Did they show that?



No, they didn't show that.

Add me to the "I was disappointed" crew.

I did cry at the end, but only because I was still SO confused, and was frustrated with the ending.

I "get" it, ya know.... but for me it was very anit-climatic. There were still alot of questions unanswered. I had even said to DH a couple of weeks ago how I thought the sideways world was like an after-life, but I think I just expected ALOT more for the end of the series. The writing and the show has been genious for 6 years and I really felt the end was so lack luster for the how creative the show has been, kwim?



Thats how I feel too-I mean this is basically the theory everyone had from the beginning. Thats the best they could come up withChat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 2:45 PM
 
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
The Lost Finale Party Prepares Us For a Bittersweet Goodbye! Michi 5/14/10 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
What's up with LOST? Tonight is the season Fall finale? peabody 11/8/06 13 Families Helping Families ™
TONITE: Last episode of LOST before series finale! greek627 5/18/10 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
LOST Series Finale Party? greek627 5/11/10 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
Breaking News - Lost Series Finale Extended by 30 Mins Michi 5/4/10 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
Lost Season Finale at 9pm danielleandscott 5/29/08 7 Families Helping Families ™