Libya anyone?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by mbg1007 I wasnt making a statement or conclusion at all about Israel's problems or whether the people in these countries want democracy, my point was that Israel's safety now with all the civil wars going on in that region is a valid concern and it is obviously a concern of hers and I just didnt think it was right to tell her that she was taking something away from the issue and should start her own post, I mean she was responding to a general question after all, jmo. Thank you - I'm glad someone can understand the relevancy of my concerns, because they ARE valid concerns that have been echoed by the press. I don't think it detracts from my empathy with the people in Libya or Egypt who are suffering in any way, and I really did not realize that there are restrictions on when, where and how you can express your concerns on a relevant subject. I made it clear in my initial post, it was for "selfish" and "personal" reasons that I have this concern. And I don't think it's out of left field for a discussion regarding the current state of instability in the Middle East would evoke those concerns - it IS relevant to what is going on there, and to deny that is to stick your head in the sand and pretend that the fight for democracy is all peaches and cream, when it isn't, and it's going to involve a LOT of bloodshed, both internally, and my concern, also, externally. |
|
Posted 2/25/11 9:08 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by mbg1007 I wasnt making a statement or conclusion at all about Israel's problems or whether the people in these countries want democracy, my point was that Israel's safety now with all the civil wars going on in that region is a valid concern and it is obviously a concern of hers and I just didnt think it was right to tell her that she was taking something away from the issue and should start her own post, I mean she was responding to a general question after all, jmo. Thank you - I'm glad someone can understand the relevancy of my concerns, because they ARE valid concerns that have been echoed by the press. I don't think it detracts from my empathy with the people in Libya or Egypt who are suffering in any way, and I really did not realize that there are restrictions on when, where and how you can express your concerns on a relevant subject. I made it clear in my initial post, it was for "selfish" and "personal" reasons that I have this concern. And I don't think it's out of left field for a discussion regarding the current state of instability in the Middle East would evoke those concerns - it IS relevant to what is going on there, and to deny that is to stick your head in the sand and pretend that the fight for democracy is all peaches and cream, when it isn't, and it's going to involve a LOT of bloodshed, both internally, and my concern, also, externally. I don't think anyone said they didn't understand, nor did I see anyone "sticking their head in the sand".I think this is a bit unfair. we could also turn the discussion towards Italy and the impact this revolution with have on their economy since they get so much of their energy from the country and Berlusconi invested heavily there in the last few years. my intention, as the OP of this particular thread, was to discuss what was going on inside of Libya. to the people of that nation. of course I realize that tangents do come up, but I was just trying to steer it back in the direction I originally intended, as I assume were the other posters who felt the same. my concern is the bloodshed for ALL people. and I put most of my current concern to where the people are DYING in large numbers fighting a brutal dictator. |
Posted 2/25/11 9:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by Ophelia we could also turn the discussion towards Italy and the impact this revolution with have on their economy since they get so much of their energy from the country and Berlusconi invested heavily there in the last few years. Which IS relevant - personally, I would never dream of begrudging you for raising a peripheral, or relevant point, that is of concern to you personally. THAT is what a discussion is about, no? |
|
Posted 2/25/11 9:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Libya anyone? I heard a commentator this morning call Libya the Mogadishu of the 21st century. I thought that was a good way to describe it. |
|
Posted 2/25/11 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Libya anyone? Forget it.. I don;t want to start a war on LIF Message edited 2011-02-25 09:36:23.370000. |
|
Posted 2/25/11 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by Bxgell2 I know it's selfish, but my greatest fear right now is for Israel with all the instability surrounding it. Many, of not most of the leaders of the surrounding countries were questionable dictators, but they at least maintained fairly reasonable relations with Israel. God knows what's going to start filtering through now that there isn't any order You don't think that they're revolting because for the most part, they want democracy? |
|
Posted 2/25/11 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Ophelia we could also turn the discussion towards Italy and the impact this revolution with have on their economy since they get so much of their energy from the country and Berlusconi invested heavily there in the last few years. Which IS relevant - personally, I would never dream of begrudging you for raising a peripheral, or relevant point, that is of concern to you personally. THAT is what a discussion is about, no? but, as the OP, I didn't want a political discussion. which is why all I did is PRAY for the Libyan people in my post. I CAN focus on one thing for a moment without losing a global perspective, no? I was not trying to invalidate your concerns in ANY way, but I wanted to make sure that the thread did not turn away from what I had intented as much as I could, a discussion of Libya and what is happening within the country. It was not personal, and I was not begruding your opinion at all. it would be a great spinoff and I would enjoy the discussion. |
Posted 2/25/11 9:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Libya anyone? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by mbg1007 I wasnt making a statement or conclusion at all about Israel's problems or whether the people in these countries want democracy, my point was that Israel's safety now with all the civil wars going on in that region is a valid concern and it is obviously a concern of hers and I just didnt think it was right to tell her that she was taking something away from the issue and should start her own post, I mean she was responding to a general question after all, jmo. Thank you - I'm glad someone can understand the relevancy of my concerns, because they ARE valid concerns that have been echoed by the press. I don't think it detracts from my empathy with the people in Libya or Egypt who are suffering in any way, and I really did not realize that there are restrictions on when, where and how you can express your concerns on a relevant subject. I made it clear in my initial post, it was for "selfish" and "personal" reasons that I have this concern. And I don't think it's out of left field for a discussion regarding the current state of instability in the Middle East would evoke those concerns - it IS relevant to what is going on there, and to deny that is to stick your head in the sand and pretend that the fight for democracy is all peaches and cream, when it isn't, and it's going to involve a LOT of bloodshed, both internally, and my concern, also, externally. Sorry to resurrect this thread but I was the poster who suggested creating another thread. I completely understand the relevancy of your concerns but as Ophelia stated the purpose was to speak of the situation inside Libya. Of course the ramifications of the situation will be far reaching and will come up in the discussion. However, your post was entirely about Israel and not concerning the original topic. I just felt it was best to continue that discussion elsewhere and not hijack this thread. I was not trying to invalidate your concerns, if anything I was saying they were extremely valid and deserved an entire thread for separate discussion. |
|
Posted 2/25/11 2:15 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |





I don't think anyone said they didn't understand, nor did I see anyone "sticking their head in the sand".

