L5 S1 Disk herniation

Posted By Message

teachermom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

843 total posts

Name:

L5 S1 Disk herniation

Hi all, I had a disk herniation in March of last year that got re-injuredin September and I just can't get it to heal. On top of that it is casing really terrible leg pain and spasm Acupuncture and physical therapy haven't done much. If you had this problem, how did you ultimately find relief? Any exercise recommendations would be great!

Posted 2/5/14 5:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Chat Icon Chat Icon Have you tried a chiropractor? This is what we specialize in. Feel free to FM me if need help finding someone. I am also a vendor on LIF and practice in East Islip (Islip Chiropractic). Feel better!

Posted 2/5/14 6:24 PM
 

babymakes3
Almost there!

Member since 7/06

7376 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Do not do a chiropractor without showing them an MRI! DH had a bad experience. He did a few steroid injections after trying chiro, acupuncture but eventually had surgery. It was a long three months til he felt normal again and he's still very cautious about reinjuring (as he should be) but he said it was the best decision. During his research, he found that it takes about two years to heal on your own (doing all the dr recommended therapy) if you don't do the surgery. He only lasted about 9 months of constant pain before he requested it. The steroid shots only lasted two weeks tops for him. Hope this helps!

Posted 2/5/14 6:58 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I'm currently recovering from a disectomy of L4 and L5. I had my surgery one month ago Saturday.

I had herniated discs 4 of them actually after my oldest dd was born. I tried physical therapy which did nothing and than I had a cortisone shot into my back. The cortisone shot worked well for about a year and than the pain returned. I lived with bad back pain for months. One day I lost complete use of my leg and could not walk. The pain became so intense I knew I had no choice but to go the ER. There I was given another MRI and I had to emergency surgery on disc l4 and l5. If I didn't have the operation I was facing losing control of my bladder and permanent damage to my leg. I do have some leg damage but I am able to walk again.

I tell you this because you really need to be persistent in trying to find relief and make sure your drs know just how much pain you are in.
You could try a chiropractor as some people have success.I never tried one but many people swear by them. You could ask for a cortisone shot it really helped me within a week of getting it. Or if none of those help have surgery. Surgery has changed my life. I still have back pain as I have other herniated discs but I am free of intense pain and shooting pain down my legs for right now.

Message edited 2014-02-05 19:05:29.680000.

Posted 2/5/14 7:02 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I had a large herniation at L5/S1 and a moderate one at L4/5. I had the L5/S1 rermoved about 3 years ago. It was called a microdisectomy...not a fusion. I do NOT recommend a fusion unless absolutely necessary. I'll still require a fusion later in life. my herniation was pressing against my nerve and i was losing feeling in my foot.

My doctor is Dr. Vincent Leone in Great Neck. I trust that man with my life. He will never operate unless absolutely necessary.

Before the surgery I tried chiropractor, epidural and PT. i do not recommend a chiropractor with a severe injury...sometimes it can make it worse (JMO) from experience. PT helped but not 100%.

I was completely against surgery for years but I got to the point where I had no choice. It's been 3 years and SOOOO much better! No more out of work for a week because I can't move. I still have aching from the arthritis which will only be cured by getting the fusion. but for now i can live with it. no more pain down my legs. life is good! lol

Message edited 2014-02-05 19:32:39.113000.

Posted 2/5/14 7:32 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I had one.
I was miserable for almost a year.
I tried PT, accupuncture, steriods and steroid injections and nothing helped.
I had a tough time making the decision for surgery as my pain was not severe but it was limiting me and affecting my job.
I saw Dr. Mullins in West Islip.....AMAZING man...he spent so much time with me in the process before having the surgery. He explained everything that I would feel after surgery to a "T" I had a micro disectomy. I went in in the am and was released by the pm. He did tell me that the pain in my leg would take a while to go away because the nerve was irritated for a long period of time. So that was expected but within 3 months it was gone.
The only thing I can't (or shouldn't do) is run. I was a HUGE runner before and I still do it but I am very careful and try not to do too much.
I did intense physical therapy after I was cleared after surgery because I was so weak and I needed to really gain stability.

This surgery was the best thing I did! It gave me my life back. I am not one to recommend doctors but I feel so strongly about Dr. Mullins I would highly suggest going to see him even if it is just for a consult.

Please feel free to FM me if you have any questions. Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/14 7:54 PM
 

Tinyswife
My family is complete

Member since 4/07

1819 total posts

Name:
Cathleen

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

No Chiropractor with herniations, I have had it all done. I have done epi-dural steriod injections. They helped for a while. If you go that route you a dr that does it under fluro scope. I then had a laminectomy, that lasted a few years, then I had a spinal fusion. I have done it all. All helped at some point.

Posted 2/5/14 8:09 PM
 

ThePinkGoose
In Your Hands

Member since 8/08

4706 total posts

Name:
Nunya

L5 S1 Disk herniation

Yes, I have the same injury.. Actually, L2-S1 all the way down!! I did therapy, chiro, acupunture, lidocaine injections, epidurals, nothing helped except getting in shape. Lots of exercise. It's been about 8 years now and I do have my moments but overall I feel great!

Posted 2/5/14 8:29 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I had one. Very painful for many years. Went to several doctors, first one wanted to do surgery right away. We went for second and 3rd opinions and I am so glad we did.

What ended up working for me was steroids to reduce the inflammation at the L5 S1 herniation and complete bed rest for 2 weeks. Complete. Only getting up for bathroom and shower.

It wasn't easy. I was out of work during that time and the steroids made me gain weight (which I lost once I stopped taking them).

But nothing worked before then. There was no exercise or physical therapy that worked. The conservative therapy worked. Been many years and no issues since then.

Posted 2/5/14 8:40 PM
 

mrsyoungmommy
can't wait to meet Sophia!

Member since 6/10

1441 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I would suggest you first meet with a pain management doctor. I wouldn't go chiro or PT. If after a series of injections, you still aren't better, seek the opinion of a neurosurgeon, to discuss surgery. Any doctor in Dr. Mullins group is amazing.

The herniation itself isn't that uncommon, it would be more serious if the herniation was causing an impingement on your nerves and causing lower extremity radicular symptoms.

I would also try to get an MRI, which you need a doctor to order. Your pcp may be able to help with that if the pain management doctor won't.

Good luck!

Message edited 2014-02-05 22:12:42.300000.

Posted 2/5/14 10:06 PM
 

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

L5 S1 Disk herniation

My Chrio told me I needed to do exercises to strengthen my core. I have been doing Bar Method for 4 months now and not a back pain in sight. I have had to take it easy or modify some of the exercises in the beginning, but now I am OK.

Posted 2/5/14 10:50 PM
 

Lola64
She is my heart!

Member since 1/11

1110 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I think it has to do with the level of herniation. I had the same disc herniation that took a couple months to diagnose. When dr's figured out the problem I went in for a discetomy and laminectomy. I have some nerve damage in the back of my right leg (I think it's minor - I just don't have the reflex in the back of my heel). Granted this was many years ago - but all has been ok since.

It flares up every now and then if I strain it or gain weight. I did have a dr look at it a few years back and wanted to jump right into fusing my spine.

My suggestion would find a neurologist or orthopedist from recommendations. Not all herniations will need surgery but it's all trusting the dr to tell you when it's gone too far and surgery needs to be done.

Feel free to FM me if you would like who I used.

Posted 2/6/14 8:48 AM
 

lorich
.

Member since 6/05

9987 total posts

Name:
Grammie says "Lora Gina"

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Same here, the only thing that works for me is decompression therapy and my chiropractor.

Posted 2/6/14 9:02 AM
 

MrsSpring
I'm a lucky mama

Member since 1/10

7585 total posts

Name:
L

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

i did pt chiro and trigger points. every week. it helped a lot. my leg pain was so bad from my back. it was scary but i had a great team of people i worked with.

Posted 2/6/14 9:07 AM
 

fabrichick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2479 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

I had L5 S1 Micro Discectomy

Nothing worked for me - inlcuding pain management. I had the cortisone shot and it didn't work. If you want to FM, I can tell you what happens if you wait too long.
My disc was bulging so, I had more or less emergency surgery.

I had the numbness in the toes and couldn't walk. Not even bed rest did anything for me.

When I woke up in recovery, I felt relief immediately. 10 days later I was on a plane to Florida.

I had to do PT and some other therapy but I have never had an issue since. I had the surgery at Winthrop and was very happy with my Dr.

My father had the surgery years before at the same age I was and on the same level. I think it's hereditary.

Any questions, please FM me.

Posted 2/6/14 9:26 AM
 

NYPDlove
LIF Infant

Member since 1/12

80 total posts

Name:

L5 S1 Disk herniation

I am in the same situation! I just reinjured mine walking down the hallway (Ishould really think of something better to tell people, but thats really how it went out again) and have been stuck on the couch since last Monday. Im waiting for dr to read new mri I just had done to make sure there is no new surprises going on. Im def curious on how others have found relief from this terrible pain and discomfort.
I too have the leg pain and haven't been able to drive myself anywhere since....Its frustrating!

Message edited 2014-02-06 09:35:21.997000.

Posted 2/6/14 9:30 AM
 

teachermom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

843 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Thanks for the responses everyone. I have really bad leg pain and spasm and twitching going on and I think I will see an orthopedist. My doctor said to go back to PT but it just isn't working. I've been to pain management before for an unrelated injury and it helped- maybe that is the way to go. Thanks again

Posted 2/6/14 4:29 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Posted by teachermom

Thanks for the responses everyone. I have really bad leg pain and spasm and twitching going on and I think I will see an orthopedist. My doctor said to go back to PT but it just isn't working. I've been to pain management before for an unrelated injury and it helped- maybe that is the way to go. Thanks again



See a neuro not an Ortho

Posted 2/6/14 9:56 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Posted by IansMommy23

Posted by teachermom

Thanks for the responses everyone. I have really bad leg pain and spasm and twitching going on and I think I will see an orthopedist. My doctor said to go back to PT but it just isn't working. I've been to pain management before for an unrelated injury and it helped- maybe that is the way to go. Thanks again



See a neuro not an Ortho

couldn't agree more

Posted 2/7/14 7:56 AM
 

teachermom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

843 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Posted by allIwant

Posted by IansMommy23

Posted by teachermom

Thanks for the responses everyone. I have really bad leg pain and spasm and twitching going on and I think I will see an orthopedist. My doctor said to go back to PT but it just isn't working. I've been to pain management before for an unrelated injury and it helped- maybe that is the way to go. Thanks again



See a neuro not an Ortho

couldn't agree more



Thanks for the responses, not to sound like a total moron, but just a regular neurologist right? I called someone I saw a few years ago for an unrelated injury and the receptionist said call ortho. Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/14 4:06 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: L5 S1 Disk herniation

Posted by teachermom

Posted by allIwant

Posted by IansMommy23

Posted by teachermom

Thanks for the responses everyone. I have really bad leg pain and spasm and twitching going on and I think I will see an orthopedist. My doctor said to go back to PT but it just isn't working. I've been to pain management before for an unrelated injury and it helped- maybe that is the way to go. Thanks again



See a neuro not an Ortho

couldn't agree more



Thanks for the responses, not to sound like a total moron, but just a regular neurologist right? I called someone I saw a few years ago for an unrelated injury and the receptionist said call ortho. Chat Icon
A neurosurgeon is probably best


Posted 2/8/14 6:56 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How can I get something from computer to disk? DmarieK 2/7/11 8 Families Helping Families ™
Computer Peeps...What would be eating up all my disk space? dm24angel 12/22/10 9 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone have experience with the new HD DVD camcorders/hard disk type? TaraHutch 6/8/09 5 Families Helping Families ™
Edited to add back - Anyone with neck or back problems (herniated disk, etc) deliver vaginally? Goobster 10/23/08 3 Parenting
Herniated disk-sciatica-did pain radiate down your leg? waterspout4 4/23/08 5 Health!
Does anyone know anyone w/a herniated disk in their back? DanaRenee 2/9/08 34 Health!