just to play devils advocate...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MrsR
My love.

Member since 5/05

6247 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

just to play devils advocate...

I am wondering if anyone thinks that Jamie Lynn is doing an admirable thing by keeping the baby??

Posted 12/20/07 9:33 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Ireally didn't have to think about this much...
I would really not expect her to do anything else..I mean they have money so she can get help...I am sure adoption is out and I only think abortion is for extreme circumstances...but...
what blows my mind is what I wrote in my post on the other thread...
*** was she thinking???????/
she wanted to be big? this definitely will not be helping. I would have thought seeing her sister is birth control enough...but I guess it was not.
it is the same as other things I guess.
They all know driving drunk is bad yet they do it..WHY?
BECAUSE IT WILL NEVER HAPPEN TO THEM.

Posted 12/20/07 9:42 PM
 

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Yes I do. She could have "taken care of it" and not let anybody know. She is accepting a consequence, a beautiful consequence , of her actions.

I think she has the means to raise the child and hope she does a good job.

Elvis, on Z100, brought up a very good point this morning. He said because of her pregnancy, parents and children everywhere will be having the "sex talk" and learning from it. That it is inevitable because she is such a huge public figure for young girls. Maybe this will be positive for others as welll.

I wish her love, health, and happiness.

Posted 12/20/07 9:47 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I don't think keeping a baby that you make is admirable. But I do think she is being responsible and take ownership of what she has done. I honestly think she is handling the entire situation very maturely. She found out, made the decision on her own (according to her) and then told her mom. She knew the public would find out, so she did an interview with a magazine to say to the world, "Yes, I did this. And I'm going to face the consequences. I'm not going to run from my problem." We all know many many many 16 year old girls are having sex. Shyt, I was 14 (not that I'm proud)! For young girls these days to see, "this can happen to me, and if it were to, the right thing to do is take responsibility," can be a positive thing. She knows she's going to be criticized and she's facing it head on. I give her credit. We don't know the whole story. Maybe she was on BC. Maybe he did use a condom. Since we don't know, who are we to judge? Do we have papparazzi filming our every move? No. So I do think she is handling the situation the best she can and is doing great. I hope she has a healthy pregnancy and delivery and is a great Mom.

Posted 12/20/07 9:47 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: just to play devils advocate...

with all the media attention-that she is bringing on herself

I don't see this choice coming from the right place- it seems more like a publicity stunt- then an "admirable" decision to me

I think the postion her parents allowed her to be in at 16- living with a boy with no supervison boarders on abuse

it's bad enough she lost her childhood to fame- but now she is going to be a mother at 16- I just wish kids could be kids- what is the freaking rush to be an adult- it's not that fun


Posted 12/20/07 9:57 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I am not sure if "admirable" is the word I would use Chat Icon

Posted 12/20/07 10:06 PM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by Jennifer907

I don't think keeping a baby that you make is admirable. But I do think she is being responsible and take ownership of what she has done. I honestly think she is handling the entire situation very maturely. She found out, made the decision on her own (according to her) and then told her mom. She knew the public would find out, so she did an interview with a magazine to say to the world, "Yes, I did this. And I'm going to face the consequences. I'm not going to run from my problem." We all know many many many 16 year old girls are having sex. Shyt, I was 14 (not that I'm proud)! For young girls these days to see, "this can happen to me, and if it were to, the right thing to do is take responsibility," can be a positive thing. She knows she's going to be criticized and she's facing it head on. I give her credit. We don't know the whole story. Maybe she was on BC. Maybe he did use a condom. Since we don't know, who are we to judge? Do we have papparazzi filming our every move? No. So I do think she is handling the situation the best she can and is doing great. I hope she has a healthy pregnancy and delivery and is a great Mom.



very well said. ITA- I think she's handling an unfortunate situation as well as can possibly be expected. I pray that she will be a better mother than her sister.

Posted 12/20/07 10:14 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

no

Posted 12/20/07 10:44 PM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by Beth1210

with all the media attention-that she is bringing on herself

I don't see this choice coming from the right place- it seems more like a publicity stunt- then an "admirable" decision to me




Unfortunately this is how I see it too...Chat Icon

Posted 12/20/07 10:48 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Admirable would be if she came out and said to her audience "Don't make the same mistake I did. I am too young to be a mother."

Posted 12/20/07 10:50 PM
 

lkrpaul
Becoming a Big Brother!

Member since 5/07

2541 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I think it's not so much her keeping the baby, but her attitude that makes it admirable. She's saying she has to take responsibility and she's going to be strong, do what she needs to do and be a good mom.

Posted 12/20/07 10:50 PM
 

Kierasmom
I love my kids

Member since 5/05

2885 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by Jennifer907

I don't think keeping a baby that you make is admirable. But I do think she is being responsible and take ownership of what she has done. I honestly think she is handling the entire situation very maturely. She found out, made the decision on her own (according to her) and then told her mom. She knew the public would find out, so she did an interview with a magazine to say to the world, "Yes, I did this. And I'm going to face the consequences. I'm not going to run from my problem." We all know many many many 16 year old girls are having sex. Shyt, I was 14 (not that I'm proud)! For young girls these days to see, "this can happen to me, and if it were to, the right thing to do is take responsibility," can be a positive thing. She knows she's going to be criticized and she's facing it head on. I give her credit. We don't know the whole story. Maybe she was on BC. Maybe he did use a condom. Since we don't know, who are we to judge? Do we have papparazzi filming our every move? No. So I do think she is handling the situation the best she can and is doing great. I hope she has a healthy pregnancy and delivery and is a great Mom.



ITA with this. I don't know if I would say admirable. But I do think that it's great that she is being responsible at this point. I hope she does a much better job of raising this kid then Britney did but if you believe what people say about her I do think she will.

I also think that it's a great lesson for younger kids to learn. Some people will say that kids will now want to get pregnant because of it. But I think that kids will actually learn from this how yes you can get pregnant. I really don't think that any "normal" teenager thinks of getting pregnant as cool. I think if anything this will scare more kids than inspire. And I do think that her speaking out about it is admirable rather than hiding it.

Posted 12/20/07 10:56 PM
 

J9-13
We're gonna be big sisters!

Member since 6/06

14887 total posts

Name:
J9

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I kinda feel like she didn't have a choice given the lifestyle she lives. Maybe she did what was best for her situation and not herself. Maybe her mom made the decision for her! If she was not a celebrity, who knows....she might have made a different choice.

Posted 12/20/07 11:14 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: just to play devils advocate...

She has way more money than any adult, let alone another 16 yr old kid... I'd be afraid some gilr would say - hmmm, well if Jamie Lynn can do this, so can i....

Posted 12/20/07 11:54 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I know what you mean, maybe not admirable, but I really admire her honesty in the matter.

Posted 12/21/07 4:24 AM
 

bella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1871 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

no, I would not in any way shape or from call it admirable. The girl was irrresponsible and now has to deal with the conseuqneces. Don't live with your boyfriend when you are 16!!! And I don't care who you are, if you have sex, even on birth control, you can get pregnant!! Got to be aware of your actions and possible consequences....to me, the spears girls seem like girls who were never told no and had no boundaries, all in an effort to get famous.....if anything its quite sad!

Posted 12/21/07 6:31 AM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Not really. I'll save my admiration for when she starts volunteering at a planned parenthood clinic to see how this situation would look like in the real world. Anyone can keep the baby. It's one of the 3 choices you have when you are in that situation. The fact that she has a butt load of money only helps her to make the choice she made. I'm sure she's still in the babies are cute phase.

Posted 12/21/07 6:35 AM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: just to play devils advocate...




Posted by Jennifer907

I don't think keeping a baby that you make is admirable. But I do think she is being responsible and take ownership of what she has done. I honestly think she is handling the entire situation very maturely. She found out, made the decision on her own (according to her) and then told her mom. She knew the public would find out, so she did an interview with a magazine to say to the world, "Yes, I did this. And I'm going to face the consequences. I'm not going to run from my problem." We all know many many many 16 year old girls are having sex. Shyt, I was 14 (not that I'm proud)! For young girls these days to see, "this can happen to me, and if it were to, the right thing to do is take responsibility," can be a positive thing. She knows she's going to be criticized and she's facing it head on. I give her credit. We don't know the whole story. Maybe she was on BC. Maybe he did use a condom. Since we don't know, who are we to judge? Do we have papparazzi filming our every move? No. So I do think she is handling the situation the best she can and is doing great. I hope she has a healthy pregnancy and delivery and is a great Mom.




ITA!

Posted 12/21/07 6:39 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: just to play devils advocate...

The word "admirable" is hard to define in this case...

I think it is great she is keeping her baby....BUT...lots of people in this world "keep" their unplanned pregnancy and go on to abuse, neglect, mistreat etc...the child. THEY are not admirable solely because they kept their child.

What will be admirable is to see herself triumph over this situation..to come out of it more mature, having learned something and being able to get through all the good AND bad that comes with a newborn.

Posted 12/21/07 7:20 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: just to play devils advocate...

why is it "admirable" to take responsibility for the consequences of your own actions? Chat Icon

she made her bed, slept in it, and got PG in it. now it's admirable that she didn't terminate the pregnancy or choose to give the baby up for adoption? i don't get that AT ALL.

Posted 12/21/07 10:10 AM
 

bee
Secret Agent

Member since 8/06

1087 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by headoverheels

why is it "admirable" to take responsibility for the consequences of your own actions? Chat Icon

she made her bed, slept in it, and got PG in it. now it's admirable that she didn't terminate the pregnancy or choose to give the baby up for adoption? i don't get that AT ALL.



ITA.

Posted 12/21/07 10:23 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by Goldi0218

Admirable would be if she came out and said to her audience "Don't make the same mistake I did. I am too young to be a mother."



ITA!

Posted 12/21/07 1:42 PM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: just to play devils advocate...

I think it is good she is keeping it...i just hate that she got preggo to begin with....but, it could happen to anyone

Posted 12/21/07 1:52 PM
 

Whamtastic
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

997 total posts

Name:
Big Fat Baby with a Blackberry

Re: just to play devils advocate...

IMO there is nothing admirable about a 16-year-old having sex. This is the consequence and now she has to live with her decisions for the rest of her life. I hope that she is a wonderful, loving mother and raises her child well and I wish her the best in what has to be an incredibly difficult situation, but to say that she is admirable? No.

Posted 12/21/07 2:20 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: just to play devils advocate...

Posted by bee

Posted by headoverheels

why is it "admirable" to take responsibility for the consequences of your own actions? Chat Icon

she made her bed, slept in it, and got PG in it. now it's admirable that she didn't terminate the pregnancy or choose to give the baby up for adoption? i don't get that AT ALL.



ITA.



ITA. I will judge her on the basis of what a good mother she becomes...As of now, nothing she has done, from selling her story and baby pics has shown me that she is someone to admire or emulate.

Posted 12/21/07 2:48 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
OK - the gajillionth post about breastfeeding today - but I'm about to play devil's advocate... lipglossjunky73 6/6/07 12 Families Helping Families ™
Play Groups- Fixed!!!! luvmiboy 3/22/06 3 Parenting
Lets play Real or Fake??? Mariah's abs.... KaRiSsA 3/22/06 22 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone play Texas Hold'em!! NoStressMom 3/14/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
play groups Samlove 3/9/06 9 Parenting
Pack N Play ?? Faithx2 3/4/06 13 Parenting