Do you think Paternity tests should be mandatory for every child born?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Just had a heated debate at work....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Just had a heated debate at work.... The reason being to let children know who their real father is rather than trying to cover up a mistake/accident. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:42 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Absolutely not. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... mandatory, absolutely NOT |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... there are a few things going on here. Should the kid know about his real father? Yes. I would be very angry if that was kept from me. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... yikes, that would be so insulting to women! |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... um, no. |
Posted 4/17/08 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... I agree with Absolutely NOT! It's between the couple. No, it's not good that people cheat and lie, it's not anyone's business but the couple's. Plus, a child knowing that the father that is raising them is not their biological father may cause unnecessary resentment. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by stephanief mandatory, absolutely NOT if the father requests one then yes I agree. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. I do think it's important that while they are children the mother have a family health history of the biological father, and that get passed onto the child when they reach an age where they can understand why things happened the way they did. I totally agree with that but how many women that get pregnant cheating on their husbands would actually do that? I'm honestly on the fence on this topic and just wanted to see other people's thoughts on it. Hopefully this won't get out of hand, lol |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by glinda-goodwitch it's not anyone's business but the couple's. Plus, a child knowing that the father that is raising them is not their biological father may cause unnecessary resentment. I have to ask - what about the resentment that occurs when the child grows up and THEN finds out the father that has raised them is not their biological father? This happened to someone very close to me, and he found out at age 24 that the man he thought was his dad hsi whole life, whose name is on his birth certificate, is not his father. Finding out his parents had betrayed him was painful, and he would much rather have known the truth since he was a child. But for the record, I voted no too. There's no reason it should be mandatory for everyone. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by stephanief mandatory, absolutely NOT if the father requests one then yes ITA! |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by MagicFairyDust Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. I do think it's important that while they are children the mother have a family health history of the biological father, and that get passed onto the child when they reach an age where they can understand why things happened the way they did. I totally agree with that but how many women that get pregnant cheating on their husbands would actually do that? I'm honestly on the fence on this topic and just wanted to see other people's thoughts on it. Hopefully this won't get out of hand, lol When I answered I just read what you wrote, not the poll question. It is not the government's role to get involved in my marriage issues. If I'm a big enough scum bag that I'd get pregnant by another man and then risk my child's health by not disclosing that to my DH, I'm probably not making great parenting decisions all around. Sorry if that insults anyone, but I think that once a child gets brought into the situation it's time to grow up and own up to your mistakes. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. At what point/age do you think they should be told the truth? |
|
Posted 4/17/08 11:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by JessInCA Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. At what point/age do you think they should be told the truth? I don't know that there is a magic number. Some kids mature faster than others. I think that a responsible parent would be able to gauge when to start laying the groundwork for the discussion, KWIM? |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by glinda-goodwitch It's between the couple. QUOTE] But what about the person who actually fathered the child. If you cheat and get pregnant, it's not just between the couple anymore I know the question was asked regarding the childs side of it. But what about the actual fathers? Child support issues, health issues? I honestly don't know how I feel about it. ETA: Isn't this Maury's job anyway Message edited 2008-04-17 12:09:10.660000. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... the idea is so contrary to what "America" is supposed to be. |
Posted 4/17/08 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Mandatory? No. Message edited 2008-04-17 12:07:45.770000. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Absolutely not. It is an invasion of privacy. What would be the value? |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Absolutely not! |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by Tilde yikes, that would be so insulting to women! This is my immediate reaction as well. If/when I have a child, you can be damn sure the kid won't need a DNA test to determine his or her father. To suggest otherwise is a complete insult. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... If it was mandatory for all, I wouldn't have a problem with it, knowing I have nothing to hide...but that's just me. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by JessInCA Posted by glinda-goodwitch it's not anyone's business but the couple's. Plus, a child knowing that the father that is raising them is not their biological father may cause unnecessary resentment. I have to ask - what about the resentment that occurs when the child grows up and THEN finds out the father that has raised them is not their biological father? This happened to someone very close to me, and he found out at age 24 that the man he thought was his dad hsi whole life, whose name is on his birth certificate, is not his father. Finding out his parents had betrayed him was painful, and he would much rather have known the truth since he was a child. But for the record, I voted no too. There's no reason it should be mandatory for everyone. That is a good point. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by CathyB Posted by JessInCA Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. At what point/age do you think they should be told the truth? I don't know that there is a magic number. Some kids mature faster than others. I think that a responsible parent would be able to gauge when to start laying the groundwork for the discussion, KWIM? That makes sense. I think this is just one of those things - kind of like adoption: is it better to tell the child very young so they know while they're growing up and it's not a surprise later on, or is it better to wait until they're psychologically mature and ready to handle and understand that kind of conversation? Both can probably be done successfully with conscientious parenting. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Just had a heated debate at work.... Posted by JessInCA Posted by CathyB Posted by JessInCA Posted by CathyB No, I don't think children need to know that the male figure in their life isn't their biological father. Some men just aren't good influences, and it can be upsetting for the child, possibly impact their self esteem. They may feel like it's their fault the bio-dad isn't in their life, like they weren't good enough. At what point/age do you think they should be told the truth? I don't know that there is a magic number. Some kids mature faster than others. I think that a responsible parent would be able to gauge when to start laying the groundwork for the discussion, KWIM? That makes sense. I think this is just one of those things - kind of like adoption: is it better to tell the child very young so they know while they're growing up and it's not a surprise later on, or is it better to wait until they're psychologically mature and ready to handle and understand that kind of conversation? Both can probably be done successfully with conscientious parenting. And both are none of the government's business. |
|
Posted 4/17/08 12:49 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Let's get some heated debate going to move this afternoon along-8 teenager who beat up a girl | CrankyPants | 4/11/08 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| steroid question-DH and I are in a heated debate! | apb17 | 11/14/06 | 3 | Pregnancy |
| This may spark some heated debate but | MamaNDaddyof3 | 6/13/06 | 16 | Parenting |
| friends at work that drive you crazy.... | LFitzy79 | 4/17/08 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Should be on recipes, but DH and I are having a debate! | MissJones | 3/16/06 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |


















