Just a question...

Posted By Message

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Just a question...

If your DH accidentally broke an expensive lamp (about $500) at your parents house, would they expect you to replace it?

Stupid situation but -- a moth the size of a bird was flying around my mother's house. She was freaking out about "getting it out". It flew into a vintage Lenox table lamp and DH took the lamp carefully outside so that the moth could fly away -- of course it fell over and shattered. I felt so sorry for him -- he was really torn up about it. I don't think he slept all weekend.

To make a long story short, my mother found the same lamp (except it is being sold with another one as a pair) on EBay and is after me to replace it. The starting bid is at $200 and shipping is $57. It was just posted today and hasn't been bid on yet - so it could go up pretty high. She's told me her lamp was appraised at about $500 several years ago. My mother exaggerates everything so I'm not quite sure if this is the truth.

I wouldn't mind replacing it happily if she would just back down (I've gotten 3 calls already today about the one on EBay). It upsets me that we are "expected" to replace it because my husband of 14 years broke it. I don't think she really cares about how much we have to spend (and believe me I don't have the money just sitting around for this) -- she's worried about her lamp getting replaced. I don't think she will be satisfied if I replace it with a different one.

I just feel that if something in my house got broken accidentally by someone, I don't think I would go after them for it. To me if you have things out there is always the possiblity of something happening to it.

Am I wrong to feel a little miffed?

Message edited 2009-06-08 15:52:35.110000.

Posted 6/8/09 3:51 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Just a question...

I think you should replace it
but I can see your annoyance about her harping on it Chat Icon

Posted 6/8/09 3:53 PM
 

4ForMe
:)

Member since 11/05

5666 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Just a question...

Posted by Mikismom

I think you should replace it
but I can see your annoyance about her harping on it Chat Icon



That's kind of how I felt -- and when it happened I thought right away we should replace it.

She's just not being very gracious about it.

Posted 6/8/09 3:54 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Just a question...

I would NEVER expect someone to replace something they broke in my house, especially my children (if I had any). Your DH was just trying to help, and it was an accident. I would be mad too.

Posted 6/8/09 3:54 PM
 

mydreamisabelle
LIF Infant

Member since 6/09

141 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: Just a question...

That is why they call it an accident. I don't think she should expect you to replace it. You can also try Craigs list.

Posted 6/8/09 4:06 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Just a question...

Also, the accident was because SHE wanted to get rid of the moth, so your DH was doing HER a favor.... in my mind, she's just as much at fault as DH. Probably more so, since he would never have touched the lamp if it wasn't for her.

Posted 6/8/09 4:11 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Just a question...

Posted by GoldenRod

Also, the accident was because SHE wanted to get rid of the moth, so your DH was doing HER a favor.... in my mind, she's just as much at fault as DH. Probably more so, since he would never have touched the lamp if it wasn't for her.



I agree. My parents would never ask me to replace it, it would be considered an accident. I have broken something before on accident, and did replace it (not near $200 or $500) but it was not expected of me. Nor would I ever expect anyone to replace something they broke in my house.

Posted 6/8/09 4:22 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Just a question...

I would offer to pay for the value of the one lamp or $250, and let your mom deal with ebay.

ETA: Try replacements.com b/c they have lamps that match china patterns.

Message edited 2009-06-08 16:33:15.423000.

Posted 6/8/09 4:30 PM
 

imthecindyofcindyandkevin
Four-nado

Member since 8/07

7972 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: Just a question...

Your mom asked DH to get the moth out of the house, it's not his fault that the moth landed on the lamp. I presume that she didn't stop him from taking the lamp outside. It's not like he got drunk and knocked it over, he was trying to be helpful and it's incredulous that this is the thanks he gets.

It was an accident. I couldn't imagine asking a guest to replace something that they accidentally broke. I'd hope that the relationship between your mom and your husband is more valuable than some lamp. Explain to her that you're willing to replace it but that her actions (calling you 3x times today about the ebay auction) is driving a wedge and is really upsetting you.

Posted 6/8/09 4:45 PM
 

Phyl
R.I.P. Sweet Mia ♥

Member since 5/06

28918 total posts

Name:
The Mystical Azzhorse! ™

Re: Just a question...

I think the moth should be held liable to pay.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

It was an accident.

Posted 6/8/09 5:03 PM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Just a question...

Why is she even asking to replace it?? I would feel embarrassed to make someone replace something they accidentally broke.. Especially trying to help me..

Now if he was fighting or drunk and broke it then I would be pizzed off!!

Posted 6/12/09 4:07 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Just a question...

My parents would not expect us to replace a lamp.

However, I would be scouring eBay & bidding on one to replace it if I knew it was one that they really loved or if she was the slightest bit upset about it breaking because I'd feel bad.

Posted 6/12/09 4:15 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Just a question...

I would be ****** bc she keeps breathing down your back.

And I would be frustrated bc she is partly to blame in the situation for having your DH go after the bug.

I would probably want to replace, but I would have to set a limit. You can't be expected to spend loads of money on a friggin lamp.

Would she be as persistant and annoying about it if one of your DC broke the lamp.... BY ACCIDENT???

Chat Icon

Posted 6/12/09 4:24 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Just a question...

I would be annoyed at her expecting me to replace it. I would definitely replace it, which it seems you had intentions of doing right from the start, but her harping on it would really get to me.

Posted 6/12/09 5:08 PM
 

Bellaocchi
Hope Faith Love

Member since 2/07

5694 total posts

Name:

Re: Just a question...

Posted by glinda-goodwitch

I would NEVER expect someone to replace something they broke in my house, especially my children (if I had any). Your DH was just trying to help, and it was an accident. I would be mad too.

ITA with all of this..

Posted 6/12/09 7:30 PM
 

Jennifer
Happy

Member since 5/05

4230 total posts

Name:
.

Re: Just a question...

Posted by ToriaRae

Posted by glinda-goodwitch

I would NEVER expect someone to replace something they broke in my house, especially my children (if I had any). Your DH was just trying to help, and it was an accident. I would be mad too.

ITA with all of this..



I agree.

Posted 6/14/09 11:52 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Just a question...

the right thing to do would be to replace it, but i totally understand the frustration about being nagged constantly to do it. obviously you know the right thing to do and dont need to be reminded of it.

see if you can contact Lenox..there is a breakage replacement program..even though its from many years ago, they may be able to help.

Posted 6/14/09 11:56 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Just a question...

that's got to be VERY awkward for your DH!

I would replace the lamp. but I think it's really crappy they they're hounding you about it. Chat Icon

Posted 6/14/09 3:45 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Just a question...

There is no way my parents would ask us to replace it. Especially if my hubby was trying to help my mom when it broke.

Posted 6/14/09 7:03 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: Just a question...

My parents WOULD NEVER expect us to replace something that we accidently broke. Doesn't matter how much it cost or was appraised for. If we tried to replace it, they would make us return it. The same goes for my inlaws.

The same goes if someone accidently broke something at my house.

Posted 6/14/09 7:18 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Just a question...

Posted by lehcar

There is no way my parents would ask us to replace it. Especially if my hubby was trying to help my mom when it broke.



Same here.

I would actually be pretty upset if my mother asked me to replace it, especially is she was freaking out about a mothChat Icon

Now if it got broken by my DH negligence that would be different.

Posted 6/14/09 7:26 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Timeframe Question beena 3/24/06 3 Home
Personal question...... Diane 3/24/06 3 Multiple Births
To Find out or To NOT find out..that is the question!!! MrsSchwags 3/24/06 22 Pregnancy
Morbid but neccesary question sunny 3/23/06 15 Parenting
Question about walk through LIBOUND 3/23/06 4 Home
kinda silly question JavaJunkie 3/23/06 16 Pregnancy