Just a question...
Posted 6/8/2009 3:51:00 PM by 4ForMe

If your DH accidentally broke an expensive lamp (about $500) at your parents house, would they expect you to replace it?

Stupid situation but -- a moth the size of a bird was flying around my mother's house. She was freaking out about "getting it out". It flew into a vintage Lenox table lamp and DH took the lamp carefully outside so that the moth could fly away -- of course it fell over and shattered. I felt so sorry for him -- he was really torn up about it. I don't think he slept all weekend.

To make a long story short, my mother found the same lamp (except it is being sold with another one as a pair) on EBay and is after me to replace it. The starting bid is at $200 and shipping is $57. It was just posted today and hasn't been bid on yet - so it could go up pretty high. She's told me her lamp was appraised at about $500 several years ago. My mother exaggerates everything so I'm not quite sure if this is the truth.

I wouldn't mind replacing it happily if she would just back down (I've gotten 3 calls already today about the one on EBay). It upsets me that we are "expected" to replace it because my husband of 14 years broke it. I don't think she really cares about how much we have to spend (and believe me I don't have the money just sitting around for this) -- she's worried about her lamp getting replaced. I don't think she will be satisfied if I replace it with a different one.

I just feel that if something in my house got broken accidentally by someone, I don't think I would go after them for it. To me if you have things out there is always the possiblity of something happening to it.

Am I wrong to feel a little miffed?
Print Post      Close Window