Islip Pines

Posted By Message

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Islip Pines

I'm a little surprised with all the Sayville/Holbrook residents on here there has been no talk of this lately. If you live in the area what do you think of the project? For those not familiar with the project proposed Islip Pines

Posted 3/23/12 9:33 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Islip Pines

I hadn't heard of it. It looks attractive and it is proposed in an area that is already zoned for commercial use so I don't really have an issue with it. Plus it looks like it has the ability to put a lot of people back to work during construction and after. It will have an impact on traffic north and east of me (I think). I'm having a hard time understanding WHERE since it says it's facing both Sunrise and Vets.. I'm thinking it must be right over by Costco? but I guess I'd have to see the reports on traffic and environmental impact on the area before i can be fully on board or against.

I've been too concerned with the Bristol Assisted Living facility that is being put on Lakeland to notice much else.

Message edited 2012-03-23 09:49:43.470000.

Posted 3/23/12 9:45 AM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

They are proposing a similar project in Yaphank. That being said, I do not know how I feel about it. It is easy for me to see the immediate benefits of it.

Posted 3/23/12 9:46 AM
 

hazeleyes33
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

13060 total posts

Name:
Ginger

Re: Islip Pines

I only read into it last night, too late to get to the meeting.

Posted 3/23/12 11:03 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Islip Pines

They had the meeting last night which I couldn't attend. I am completely against it. I live in Parkland and that is where this project will bump up against.

They are talking about putting a movie theathre when Island 16 is right up the street. They are adding more retail when we already have a good slew of stores empty on Main Street and Sayville is boasting a 33% vacancy rate. We have Sunset Mall that has a ton of vacancy and your are going to build something like this across the street. Two big box stores they wont to add when we already have home depot, walmart, bbb, tru, costco, and a slew of others. We don't need any additional stores.

Say goodbye to our downtown areas. The few that is left will go out of business.

The traffic which is already chaos in this area will be more dangerous then it is already. Anyone who goes to Costco know what a fiasco it is to get in and out of that place.

Our property values will decrease. They are adding workforce housing which they say the two bedroom will sell for $300,000. There are homes in my area that you can get for less than this. 200 new apartments will be hard to sell quickly and will start to make homes in the rest of the are decrease. Now you want to sell your home for $350, but when the appraiser compares your home with the new empty apartments that will range from $200 to $300 I guarantee you won't get anywhere your asking price.

Yes it will bring more jobs, but it's temporary at best and the ones that aren't are minimum wage jobs which isn't what we need right now.

I am so against this. It was defeated three years ago when it was first brought to the table and hopefully if will be defeated this time around.

Posted 3/23/12 11:14 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by LeShellem

They had the meeting last night which I couldn't attend. I am completely against it. I live in Parkland and that is where this project will bump up against.

They are talking about putting a movie theathre when Island 16 is right up the street. They are adding more retail when we already have a good slew of stores empty on Main Street and Sayville is boasting a 33% vacancy rate. We have Sunset Mall that has a ton of vacancy and your are going to build something like this across the street. Two big box stores they wont to add when we already have home depot, walmart, bbb, tru, costco, and a slew of others. We don't need any additional stores.

Say goodbye to our downtown areas. The few that is left will go out of business.

The traffic which is already chaos in this area will be more dangerous then it is already. Anyone who goes to Costco know what a fiasco it is to get in and out of that place.

Our property values will decrease. They are adding workforce housing which they say the two bedroom will sell for $300,000. There are homes in my area that you can get for less than this. 200 new apartments will be hard to sell quickly and will start to make homes in the rest of the are decrease. Now you want to sell your home for $350, but when the appraiser compares your home with the new empty apartments that will range from $200 to $300 I guarantee you won't get anywhere your asking price.

Yes it will bring more jobs, but it's temporary at best and the ones that aren't are minimum wage jobs which isn't what we need right now.

I am so against this. It was defeated three years ago when it was first brought to the table and hopefully if will be defeated this time around.



Chat Icon
I agree 100%
The LAST thing Long Island needs is more develoment.
We are KILLING ourselves already.
It's truly disturbing.
Long Island is getting ruined.

Posted 3/23/12 11:16 AM
 

Naner325
waiting on nugget!

Member since 6/10

4432 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Islip Pines

This is the first I am hearing of it but I think it looks really cool and something different that they can use around the area. I no longer live in Holbrook but my family does and knowing that this would bring in jobs and add a nice new touch to the area seems like a good idea to me. But, if I had the ability to decide, I would much rather see them turn the area into a park instead of more buildings.

Posted 3/23/12 11:17 AM
 

ODonnell
.

Member since 9/05

5983 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

I don't live too close to the area but I am near enough that it would be a place I would patronize and I work for a company that would likely have stores there but I would be very concerned about how it could affect main street businesses and the small towns in the locality.

Posted 3/23/12 11:25 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by LeShellem

They had the meeting last night which I couldn't attend. I am completely against it. I live in Parkland and that is where this project will bump up against.

They are talking about putting a movie theathre when Island 16 is right up the street. They are adding more retail when we already have a good slew of stores empty on Main Street and Sayville is boasting a 33% vacancy rate. We have Sunset Mall that has a ton of vacancy and your are going to build something like this across the street. Two big box stores they wont to add when we already have home depot, walmart, bbb, tru, costco, and a slew of others. We don't need any additional stores.

Say goodbye to our downtown areas. The few that is left will go out of business.

The traffic which is already chaos in this area will be more dangerous then it is already. Anyone who goes to Costco know what a fiasco it is to get in and out of that place.

Our property values will decrease. They are adding workforce housing which they say the two bedroom will sell for $300,000. There are homes in my area that you can get for less than this. 200 new apartments will be hard to sell quickly and will start to make homes in the rest of the are decrease. Now you want to sell your home for $350, but when the appraiser compares your home with the new empty apartments that will range from $200 to $300 I guarantee you won't get anywhere your asking price.

Yes it will bring more jobs, but it's temporary at best and the ones that aren't are minimum wage jobs which isn't what we need right now.

I am so against this. It was defeated three years ago when it was first brought to the table and hopefully if will be defeated this time around.



I can definitely see your point.. but what is the area used for now? How can it be developed to add value to the community without having a negative impact on the homeowners and business owners around it?

The landscape of Long Island is changing and will continue to evolve. Once upon a time - not too long ago - this was a 'rural' part of the Island and now it's not. The urbanization of the Island will continue to push eastward as the population grows. We cannot stop that.. but we can ask for some control over what that progress looks like. I'd rather see an attractive complex over a set of ugly warehouses or flat industrial factories thrown in there. I mean - the property WILL be developed, that's a given. Whether it happens next year or 5 years from now it will happen.

As I said... I don't know enough about this particular project to be on board or against it - but I think the only way any residents against it can really 'win' time and again is if they have an idea for alternative plans for development or ideas, ya know?

Posted 3/23/12 11:30 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Islip Pines

I don't live in that area, but overall, there are so many vacant stores and buildings that are just decaying and making areas look gross.

And traffic everywhere is already so horrendous.

I take Montauk Highway/Merrick Rd. from Babylon to Seaford to pick up my son and in the evening, it's like a parking lot the whole way.

If you look out the window in just these towns alone, so many places are empty.

I think overall we should make do with what we have already, and re-vamp some of the old world charm instead of bringing in new which will probably ultimately go bust in a couple of years anyways.

Posted 3/23/12 11:33 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by rojerono

Posted by LeShellem

They had the meeting last night which I couldn't attend. I am completely against it. I live in Parkland and that is where this project will bump up against.

They are talking about putting a movie theathre when Island 16 is right up the street. They are adding more retail when we already have a good slew of stores empty on Main Street and Sayville is boasting a 33% vacancy rate. We have Sunset Mall that has a ton of vacancy and your are going to build something like this across the street. Two big box stores they wont to add when we already have home depot, walmart, bbb, tru, costco, and a slew of others. We don't need any additional stores.

Say goodbye to our downtown areas. The few that is left will go out of business.

The traffic which is already chaos in this area will be more dangerous then it is already. Anyone who goes to Costco know what a fiasco it is to get in and out of that place.

Our property values will decrease. They are adding workforce housing which they say the two bedroom will sell for $300,000. There are homes in my area that you can get for less than this. 200 new apartments will be hard to sell quickly and will start to make homes in the rest of the are decrease. Now you want to sell your home for $350, but when the appraiser compares your home with the new empty apartments that will range from $200 to $300 I guarantee you won't get anywhere your asking price.

Yes it will bring more jobs, but it's temporary at best and the ones that aren't are minimum wage jobs which isn't what we need right now.

I am so against this. It was defeated three years ago when it was first brought to the table and hopefully if will be defeated this time around.



I can definitely see your point.. but what is the area used for now? How can it be developed to add value to the community without having a negative impact on the homeowners and business owners around it?

The landscape of Long Island is changing and will continue to evolve. Once upon a time - not too long ago - this was a 'rural' part of the Island and now it's not. The urbanization of the Island will continue to push eastward as the population grows. We cannot stop that.. but we can ask for some control over what that progress looks like. I'd rather see an attractive complex over a set of ugly warehouses or flat industrial factories thrown in there. I mean - the property WILL be developed, that's a given. Whether it happens next year or 5 years from now it will happen.

As I said... I don't know enough about this particular project to be on board or against it - but I think the only way any residents against it can really 'win' time and again is if they have an idea for alternative plans for development or ideas, ya know?



I'm not sure how they could develop it so that it's a win for everyone, but they could start by developing it the way it has already been zoned for which is industrial. The best thing would be an industrial park with McAurthur Airport right there. We have so much potential with the airport that honestly anything that goes there should support the airport and bringing big business in not retail but actual business. We would not have housing that would decrease property value, we won't have more retail that puts mom and pop stores out of business, with the airport nearby when can bring real jobs (not to say min. wage jobs arent real), jobs where people can support their families here on long island.

You are right this land will be devoloped, it is already owned. But I think there should be no zoning change which is what the real issue is right now.

Posted 3/23/12 11:38 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Islip Pines

The more I think about this the more conflicted I get.

Has the developer gotten lease commitments from retailers already or are they counting on a handshake from a big box store to draw smaller retailers in? A better proposal might be to spruce up the existing retail space - the Sunrise mall is a mess and can do with a facelift - and we still need a store to fill the old Border's spot in the KMart complex. I am wondering how many retailers would really want to take those spaces knowing that there is not only competition in the immediate area - but a huge mall within 30 minutes.

I think a proposition to the developer to attempt to bring in non-retail business in an industrial setting, plus maybe a cultural center and play area (Children's museum, arts center, etc..) might be a better and more effective use of their funds. They may find it easier to sell the space to businesses and also grab community approval. Making it attractive is great - but a huge retail complex may not work. I could get on board with a nice higher end hotel and conference center since it is close to the airport.

I'm thinking a resident committee that can take action and start finding businesses that would be willing to move into a nice industrial park in that area could help the developer re-think their proposal.

Message edited 2012-03-23 11:50:21.763000.

Posted 3/23/12 11:49 AM
 

RoleModel
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/08

500 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I don't live in that area, but overall, there are so many vacant stores and buildings that are just decaying and making areas look gross.

And traffic everywhere is already so horrendous.



And if these businesses don't open up, there are no tax dollars to improve the infrastructure that is already "so horrendous."

As long as it is intelligently placed, and not like the planned Walmart in East Patchogue (near a one-lane bridge and a hospital!), I don't see a problem.

Posted 3/23/12 12:45 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Islip Pines

I went to the meeting last night since I am concerned for the community and wanted to hear what they have to say. It was full by the time I got there but the overflow was permitted to stand in the main lobby and listen and we were given a chance to submit the form if we wanted to speak. I stood there listening and basically I heard great questions from the community. It was not NIMBY responses it was real concerns and questions. But all I heard in response form the developers team was that this is only a proposed site plan and subject to change. They gave no real answers. Granted I left at around 9:15 because I had to get home to my kids. I had no idea it would last so long. They estimated it would be another 2 hours of speaking. I am curious to hear what happened after I left but have not found anyone else that went.

Posted 3/23/12 1:27 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

I am hugely opposed to it because it will affect my quality of living. And this is coming from someone married to union Chat Icon To cut down acres of forest for a mega mall when Sun-Vet is around the corner and mostly vacant is ridiculous! Half industrial and half residential doesn't make sense. Why would you want employee housing there? We already have apartment complexes off Broadway. Most people I've come across are opposed. There is a FB page of them as well.

Posted 3/23/12 2:55 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by RoleModel

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I don't live in that area, but overall, there are so many vacant stores and buildings that are just decaying and making areas look gross.

And traffic everywhere is already so horrendous.



And if these businesses don't open up, there are no tax dollars to improve the infrastructure that is already "so horrendous."

As long as it is intelligently placed, and not like the planned Walmart in East Patchogue (near a one-lane bridge and a hospital!), I don't see a problem.



Because acres of forest aren't being ripped out in your backyard Chat Icon this whole park would butt up against a development of homes that have been there for 36 years! Traffic is already horrendous over there. This will be a disaster of epic proportions!

Posted 3/23/12 2:58 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by OneOfEach

Posted by RoleModel

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I don't live in that area, but overall, there are so many vacant stores and buildings that are just decaying and making areas look gross.

And traffic everywhere is already so horrendous.



And if these businesses don't open up, there are no tax dollars to improve the infrastructure that is already "so horrendous."

As long as it is intelligently placed, and not like the planned Walmart in East Patchogue (near a one-lane bridge and a hospital!), I don't see a problem.



Because acres of forest aren't being ripped out in your backyard Chat Icon this whole park would butt up against a development of homes that have been there for 36 years! Traffic is already horrendous over there. This will be a disaster of epic proportions!


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/23/12 2:59 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by LeShellem

They had the meeting last night which I couldn't attend. I am completely against it. I live in Parkland and that is where this project will bump up against.

They are talking about putting a movie theathre when Island 16 is right up the street. They are adding more retail when we already have a good slew of stores empty on Main Street and Sayville is boasting a 33% vacancy rate. We have Sunset Mall that has a ton of vacancy and your are going to build something like this across the street. Two big box stores they wont to add when we already have home depot, walmart, bbb, tru, costco, and a slew of others. We don't need any additional stores.

Say goodbye to our downtown areas. The few that is left will go out of business.

The traffic which is already chaos in this area will be more dangerous then it is already. Anyone who goes to Costco know what a fiasco it is to get in and out of that place.

Our property values will decrease. They are adding workforce housing which they say the two bedroom will sell for $300,000. There are homes in my area that you can get for less than this. 200 new apartments will be hard to sell quickly and will start to make homes in the rest of the are decrease. Now you want to sell your home for $350, but when the appraiser compares your home with the new empty apartments that will range from $200 to $300 I guarantee you won't get anywhere your asking price.

Yes it will bring more jobs, but it's temporary at best and the ones that aren't are minimum wage jobs which isn't what we need right now.

I am so against this. It was defeated three years ago when it was first brought to the table and hopefully if will be defeated this time around.



Absolutely!

Posted 3/23/12 3:01 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Islip Pines

Posted by RoleModel

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I don't live in that area, but overall, there are so many vacant stores and buildings that are just decaying and making areas look gross.

And traffic everywhere is already so horrendous.



And if these businesses don't open up, there are no tax dollars to improve the infrastructure that is already "so horrendous."

As long as it is intelligently placed, and not like the planned Walmart in East Patchogue (near a one-lane bridge and a hospital!), I don't see a problem.



MY point is that I wish businesses would utilize what we already have, and open up there.

I could be off-base but I would imagine if you are a businessowner in any of these towns, you'd have to pay taxes too back into and supporting the community at large ;).

Posted 3/23/12 3:11 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Islip Pines - Update Town of Islip are taking your comments

If you are concern, you can send the town comments. They will be accepting comments until April 2.

You can write to the Town Board to the following people.
Write to Supv. Croci, Councilpeople Bergin-Weichbrodt, Senft, Cochrane, Flotterton at
655 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751

Posted 3/28/12 8:51 AM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: Islip Pines

The only thing that I see that is good about this project is that the taxes being paid on this land now is abotu $50k while after the project is done is willbe $3-$4 million.

I LOVE my Main Street in Holbrook and do everything I can to support my local business. I would hate to see this go away! Chat Icon

Posted 3/28/12 9:10 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
We now have a new neighbor at Avalon Pines.... maybride2004 5/16/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Irish Coffee Pub in East Islip danielleandscott 1/7/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Dog park in West Islip? pinky 11/16/05 10 Pets
Full Martini, Islip butterfly22 10/6/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Has anyone been to Tellers Resturant in Islip? Giannas-mama 7/21/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Nice house in Islip danielleandscott 6/10/05 0 Home