Is this true???

Posted By Message

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Is this true???

Will a baby really stop eating/drinking when they are full?

DH thinks that, like adults, they need to let their brain catch up to their stomach. Like, how we are told to eat slowly and it takes about 20 minutes for our brains to feel that our stomachs are full.

The reason I am asking:
I BF and supplement with formula. The other day DD nursed for 15 min each side and still seemed hungry (fussy/sucking on hands). So I experimented with giving her 2 oz of formula and she SUCKED it down! She cried when I took the empty bottle away so I thought, let me see what happens if I give her 2 oz more...and she drank it all! I just knew she would spit up lots because that is A LOT! She spit up once, very little. Did she even get anything from my boob??? Do I have an EATER on my hands or what?!?!?!?

Sorry so long!

Posted 10/27/11 5:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

Do you know roughly what you are giving her oz wise on the boob? How old is she?. I pumped and couldnt keep up with ds, because he was a chow (I also hated it, but not the point) she may just be hungry, and want more. There is nothing wrong with doing both.

Posted 10/27/11 5:37 PM
 

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is this true???

I stopped pumping because after DD would eat, I would get a little more than 1 oz combined! I did this for a few weeks and hated it. It was time consuming and wasn't helping my supply Chat Icon Sometimes she is a good eater from me and sometimes she doesnt seem to want my boob, but she's hungry. Its been a LONNNNG 9 weeks of BFing....not sure how much longer I'm going to last!

Posted 10/27/11 6:22 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

i asked my dr the same thing when DS wanted more formula. at 2 weeks we were told to feed him 2.5 - 3 oz every 3-4 hours

well DS wanted 3-4 oz, every 2 hours sometimes and when i asked the dr if that was ok, he said absolutely.. feed him as much as he wants. he'll stop eating when he's full (or spit up)
So, now when he's hungry, we feed him and if its only been 2 hours, tha'ts ok. sometimes he eats 3 oz, sometimes 4, sometimes he goes 4 hours in between, sometimes only 2

seems to work for now..

Posted 10/27/11 6:26 PM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is this true???

I just saw something similar on Kelly Mom. It was about people worrying they had low supply because the baby would suck down formula after bfing. I'll cut and paste.

Parents who don't know this is "normal" frequently respond as you did by giving a bottle because they think the baby isn't "happy or satisfied" with the breast. When the bottle goes in the baby's mouth the mouth fills with milk, the baby is obligated to swallow and the action of swallowing initiates another suck. The suck again fills the mouth and the cycle repeats, giving an appearance of the baby "gulping the bottle down hungrily".

This of course only contributes to mom and dad's fear that the baby wasn't getting enough at the breast and they keep offering more and more bottles (understandably). Which then causes a true low milk supply. Often the baby falls asleep peacefully after this episode which also reinforces to the parents that the bottle was just what the baby needed. What has really happened is the baby has by coincidence come to the natural conclusion of the fussy spell (most parents give the bottle as a last resort which means the fussiness has been going on for awhile) and/or the baby has withdrawn because "gulping" down the bottle was actually stressful and NOT what the baby wanted but she could not stop the flow, so exhausted, she falls asleep. So don't offer bottles during any fussy time.

Posted 10/27/11 7:40 PM
 

MrsW2010
Mommy of two!

Member since 5/10

2202 total posts

Name:
Jill

Re: Is this true???

babies dont over eat...as far as my ped says and I agree...ds let us know when he wants more or is done

Posted 10/27/11 7:47 PM
 

InHiding4Now2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

386 total posts

Name:
EDD: 8/27/11

Re: Is this true???

Everyone tells us that our baby should tell us when she is full but she doesn't always. 2 nights ago she had a big bottle of expressed milk, 5 oz, then had a big poop and 30mins later seemed hungry still so I BF her and she threw is all up right after. I won't be doing that again!

Posted 10/27/11 8:00 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

I EBF and sometimes dd will go way longer than 15 mins/side. Sometimes only 7-8 mins per side. Also, sometimes she goes 4 hrs in between and sometimes she is hungry again after only 2 hours. I followe her lead which was hard to trust in the beginning but now at 4.5 months it's easy to tell. I also stopped listening to my ped who said 10 mins per side bc that just didn't work for us.

Posted 10/27/11 8:44 PM
 

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is this true???

I started supplementing with formula because DD did not pass any poop without stimulation for the first 2.5 weeks of her life. We were sent to a GI who had me give her formula (2 oz 3/day) because he felt she wasn't getting enough in to be able to poop out. This being my first, I just listened to the doctor. She started to poop on her own, like once every 4 days. So I weaned her off of the formula and continued to BF. But then she wasn't having "appropriate" weight gain, so he had me go back to formula. And I did because he made me feel like I was putting a pause on her growth. When I give her formula, she is a more satisfied, happy baby who doesn't need to feed every hour and that makes this mommy happier too Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/11 5:24 AM
 

cloddy
Holiday 2011 photo

Member since 8/05

8088 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: Is this true???

I wouldn't count on a BF baby stopping drinking a bottle when they're full b/c they're not used to the quick and easy flow from the bottle. I would tend to believe the info posted from kellymom.

Posted 10/28/11 8:16 AM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

I had my ped watch me feed my DS multiple times (in the hospital, in her office, etc).

DS LOVED to eat & could be at my breasts for over 3 hours. This was, according to my ped, damaging my milk supply.

Her rules:

20 minutes per breast.

Feed every 2 hours (timed from the start of the feedings... so I'd start feeding at, let's say 6:00, feed until 6:40 & then have to feed again at 8:00).

IF DS is still hungry... still wanting to suck from breast... give a bottle supplement.

Eventually, the bottle supplement was no longer needed & DS was exclusively breastfeeding.

1 year later... DS STILL eats a lot (but is at a great height & weight). People are SHOCKED to see how much he eats & the fact that he eats EVERYTHING (yesterday he had tofu). He just NEEDS it.

Posted 10/28/11 8:23 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

Posted by Silibee3

I started supplementing with formula because DD did not pass any poop without stimulation for the first 2.5 weeks of her life. We were sent to a GI who had me give her formula (2 oz 3/day) because he felt she wasn't getting enough in to be able to poop out. This being my first, I just listened to the doctor. She started to poop on her own, like once every 4 days. So I weaned her off of the formula and continued to BF. But then she wasn't having "appropriate" weight gain, so he had me go back to formula. And I did because he made me feel like I was putting a pause on her growth. When I give her formula, she is a more satisfied, happy baby who doesn't need to feed every hour and that makes this mommy happier too Chat Icon



I had VERY low milk supply too! The first week after my DD was born she lost 2 lbs, I was literally starving her but I didn't know. I thought she was getting enough. I ended up having to supplement with formula too and once I did I started pumping too and I couldn't believe how little came out. It's no wonder she lost weight.

But to answer your question, I don't think babies can overeat. I think they know exactly what they need and want, at least that was my experience with DD. I just followed her lead, usually an increase in ounces coincided with a growth spurt, when she couldn't go more than an hour and a half between bottles that all of a sudden went from 6oz to 9oz I realized she needed more than formula and started solids and then her ounces dropped back and she was satisfied for hours at a time. As long as they are gaining and growing properly there isn't a need to worry. Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/11 8:31 AM
 

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is this true???

So it looks like as with everything, I am learning - it depends on the baby?!?! So far the supplementing is working for us. And I guess I will just use my better judgement but follow her cues at the same time. Babies! They sure do keep you on your toes!!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/11 9:55 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Is this true???

My first DS was an over eater! He woudl have ate all day if I let him! Then he would spit up a TON!

DS2 will not eat if he doesnt want to , even if he hasnt eaten in 4 hours, if he doesnt feel like eating he will not do it for anything!!

GL with the BF. I made it 3 months with DS2 because like you I was supplementing and foudn that at the end of hte day DS was just a happier baby on formula. And I was more relaxed, knowing how much he was taking in, knowing htat what I was eating was affecting him. Do it for as long as you can but in the end know that the most important thing is that your baby is well nourished and you are both happy campers!!!

Posted 10/28/11 10:08 AM
 

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is this true???

Posted by Kelly9904


GL with the BF. I made it 3 months with DS2 because like you I was supplementing and foudn that at the end of hte day DS was just a happier baby on formula. And I was more relaxed, knowing how much he was taking in, knowing htat what I was eating was affecting him. Do it for as long as you can but in the end know that the most important thing is that your baby is well nourished and you are both happy campers!!!



It has taken me 9 weeks to be OK with this. I was so determined to BF, but it was making me VERY unhappy. To add to all the worries, my mom and MIL had A LOT to say, lots of suggestions and facial expressions that would leave me in tears. I am hoping to get to 3 months

Posted 10/28/11 10:20 AM
 

PoppySeed
LIF Infant

Member since 10/09

358 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this true???

I've read the same info that PP have posted and it seems logical, though I don't know anything for sure. But bf babies suck to eat and then continue sucking to soothe. So you put a bottle in her mouth, she'll suck to soothe, but obviously formula comes out, so she ends up drinking it.

Your DD is 9 weeks? At that age I would let my DD bf for longer than 15 per side if she wanted. I nursed her until she was content. Keeping her at the breast will also help build your supply up, if the supplementing has lowered it.

Have you tried a pacifier? If she's just looking to suck, that might do the trick. It might also help you know if she's actually hungry or not.

Posted 10/28/11 11:06 AM
 

Silibee3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

799 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is this true???

Posted by PoppySeed

I've read the same info that PP have posted and it seems logical, though I don't know anything for sure. But bf babies suck to eat and then continue sucking to soothe. So you put a bottle in her mouth, she'll suck to soothe, but obviously formula comes out, so she ends up drinking it.

Your DD is 9 weeks? At that age I would let my DD bf for longer than 15 per side if she wanted. I nursed her until she was content. Keeping her at the breast will also help build your supply up, if the supplementing has lowered it.

Have you tried a pacifier? If she's just looking to suck, that might do the trick. It might also help you know if she's actually hungry or not.



I don't time her every feeding, that was just an example...I usually let her stay on until she stops and thats usually when she falls asleep. And that is usually around the 20 minute ish mark. Believe me there have been longer times than that. I also don't formula feed in place of nursing, I give her formula after a feeding because I wanted my boobs to get the action to help build my supply. So DD feedings at times lasted hours. I was pumping after feedings as well and was lucky to get 3oz a day...very frustrating! I also took fenugreek and drowned myself with water. My boobs and brain are exhausted!

Supposedly your DC can always get milk from you, so following the same theory if milk is in their mouth their reaction is to swallow/soothe....couldn't a baby be overfed from the breast?

Posted 10/28/11 12:06 PM
 

NoStressMom
My Heart and Soul

Member since 5/05

11122 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Is this true???

Posted by Silibee3

So it looks like as with everything, I am learning - it depends on the baby?!?! So far the supplementing is working for us. And I guess I will just use my better judgement but follow her cues at the same time. Babies! They sure do keep you on your toes!!! Chat Icon



Very True!!! If only they came with Manuals!!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/11 12:10 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Not sure how true these are... other uses for Bounce dryer sheets SweetestOfPeas 5/1/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Gap Maternity? How true are the sizes? CookiePuss 1/9/06 10 Pregnancy
I just got this e-mail about Moms, I thought it was funny and true! JennChris 12/12/05 1 Parenting
Heard on the news but a clip is this true about assistant principals? MommyofG 11/16/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
Hi ladies I got some news from a coworker but dont know how true it is regarding the3 D sonogram MommyofG 11/6/05 2 Pregnancy
N.Bellmore $425k, sound to good to be true? Disneygirl 6/30/05 7 Home