Is she asking for it?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Is she asking for it?

spinoff to one of my own posts.

If a girl/woman is wearing an outfit....showing some skin or form fitting is it HER fault when and if a man oogles or aggressively checks her out?

do you think if she's made to feel uncomfortable, she was asking for it?

does it depend what she is wearing? how deep the neck is/how push up the bra is/how tight/short/slit the skirt/jeans/shorts are?

what are your thoughts?

Posted 7/24/08 11:47 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Is she asking for it?

No. IMO, runs the same line as if she's wearing those type of clothes and gets raped she'd asking for it. A woman should be able to dress however she wants without being made uncomfortable, or worse.

Although, I think there are some women out there who dress provactively on purpose because they enjoy the attention.

Posted 7/24/08 11:49 AM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Is she asking for it?

I took a break from work yesterday and went to the supermarket where I had a manwho was behind me walk next to me, staring, pass me and turn to me and say..."nice"......

I was wearing long pants and a fitted v-neck top that was not showing too much at all.....

My point is that it sometimes doesn't matter WHAT you wear and you still get negative attention.......

But there most definitely ARE people out there who wear what they wear to get any kind of attention they can get, and I guess they deserve whatever comes their way.

Posted 7/24/08 11:52 AM
 

anonttcer
BOOOO for fall!

Member since 7/06

10082 total posts

Name:
Meaning a NON ttcer!

Re: Is she asking for it?

Awesome question.

And a tough one.

I think that a woman has the right to wear whatever she wants and feels comfortable with.
However, you also have to expect-when wearing certain things- that men are going to look.

I am not saying men have the right to touch you inappropriately or make lewd remarks.... however, men are only human and if you have it- and are flaunting it- they are going to look.

And in a sense- isn't that one of the reason you are wearing something revealing- to catch a little attention?
That's yet another good question!




Message edited 2008-07-24 11:53:22.307000.

Posted 7/24/08 11:52 AM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

Sometimes I feel like people do it for attention, but I don't think they always realize that it was going to attract the attention it does.

But I do think some people are completely oblivious and don't even realize.

I think some people do want the attention and then try to play if off for more attention and complain about it Chat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 11:53 AM
 

MeeshkaMich
LL=Yum

Member since 2/06

5616 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

I don't think it matters what clothes you can be covered up or not people who want/will still stare regardless.

Yesterday I was waiting to cross queens blvd and this guy driving stared me down smiling and shouting you look hot and because he was staring at me instead of paying attention to the road he almost crashed into the car in front of himChat Icon

I was wearing a dress that was flowly didnt even hug my curves. Dress ended just above my knees and I had a tank underneath it so my chest was covered as well. It did make me feel very uncomfortable though, esp. since he almost caused an accident.Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-07-24 11:57:21.443000.

Posted 7/24/08 11:56 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by curliegirl

My point is that it sometimes doesn't matter WHAT you wear and you still get negative attention.......
.



totally agree and it happens to me all the time-

Posted 7/24/08 12:09 PM
 

skew
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

6794 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

some woman crave attention and therefore wear outfits that encourage others to stare/gawk. i am guilty of it myself sometimes when one is wearing an overly revealing "WTH are you thinking?" trashy outfit.

i wore a short (couple inches above the knees) vneck dress with flip flops yesterday. i wore the dress because it is cute and comfortable. nothing about the dress is slutty (yeah, a little short and low cut but NOT tight). i felt totally confident when i left the house but after being out in public (running errands) i felt overly self conscious. i DID NOT wear the dress to attract attention but i definitely received it. i was appalled with the way the men blatantly stared at my chest and legs. it is one thing to glance at or admire what one is wearing or how they look in an outfit but QUITE another to make someone feel uncomfortable by blatantly staring.

Message edited 2008-07-24 12:26:53.610000.

Posted 7/24/08 12:22 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Is she asking for it?

this is a toughie--i agree that women should be able to wear whatever they want and not feel like someone is oogling them like crazy.

BUT...

i absolutely can not stand women who wear 2 pieces of dental floss over the nips and a skirt so short you could see up to her heart if she bent over---and then when a guy stares, says "omg WHY is he LOOKING at me???!" particularly when you see that in a bar or club. the girl who is OBVIOUSLY wanting someone to loook---a guy stares and then she boo hoos to her boyfriend "omg that guy is like totally STARING at meeeeeeee"

i loathe that kind of behavior.

Posted 7/24/08 12:25 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Is she asking for it?

I think if you wear a low cut top with your tatas showing, people ARE going to look...not saying it is right to stare or say stupid **** to someone

Posted 7/24/08 12:27 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by anonttcer

Awesome question.

And a tough one.

I think that a woman has the right to wear whatever she wants and feels comfortable with.
However, you also have to expect-when wearing certain things- that men are going to look.

I am not saying men have the right to touch you inappropriately or make lewd remarks.... however, men are only human and if you have it- and are flaunting it- they are going to look.

And in a sense- isn't that one of the reason you are wearing something revealing- to catch a little attention?
That's yet another good question!




I completely agree word for word.

A woman has a right to wear whatever she wants but needs to understand that depending on what the outfit looks like, it could get her some attention - negative or positive.

I think this can be applied to both men and women.

Posted 7/24/08 12:29 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

100% No IMO; she is not "asking" for ANY hostile/aggressive treatment, includng gawking.

A separate issue is what those around her may think of her. I definitely form opinions of the way people come off if they're dressed "trashy," etc., and I would expect that others do in a professional or social situation.

That said, men need to control themselves. Aggressive gawking, animal noises like barking and hissing... I truly wish it were illegal to make women feel violated and demeaned like that in public. I also think that each of theiir mothers, wives, sisters must feel humiliated to know that "their guy" is such a lech, disprespectful beas.

As for women feeling violated when they're not dressed inappropriately--we've all been there & it stinks. You're completely helpless and trapped until its over--feeling demeaned and objectified--and wondering who raised/married someone who thinks it's alright to treat women--any women-- like that.

Message edited 2008-07-24 12:30:27.263000.

Posted 7/24/08 12:30 PM
 

MrsMerlot
Unconditional Love

Member since 4/06

6005 total posts

Name:
Chrissy

Re: Is she asking for it?

If a girl/woman is wearing an outfit....showing some skin or form fitting is it HER fault when and if a man oogles or aggressively checks her out?
I wouldn't say it's a fault, but to get upset about it b/c someone is oogling at her or checking her out - honestly, it's more of a compliment no?

do you think if she's made to feel uncomfortable, she was asking for it?
No one is made to feel uncomfortable - it's an emotion, to let it get to her THAT much where she's uncomfortable - that can be controlled by her. She can let it get to her or she can let it brush off her shoulders...ignore it.

does it depend what she is wearing? how deep the neck is/how push up the bra is/how tight/short/slit the skirt/jeans/shorts are?
Yes. We don't walk around this earth with our brains on the outside of heads. We walk with our bodies out there, and depending on your clothing, our bodies are revealed or not so much revealed to others. First sense that we use is SIGHT...so someone is going to react based on what they see....

Posted 7/24/08 12:35 PM
 

Waste06
Waste not, want not

Member since 6/06

7219 total posts

Name:
Lois Mom Mommy Mama Ma

Re: Is she asking for it?

Good question.

Tough to answer because I read your other post, and my gut response is no, but here are my thoughts.

If a man oogles and aggressively checks another out a women, it's not her fault. Doing anything agressively, where it makes someone else feel uncomfortable, is wrong.

I don't think it matters much as to what the girl is wearing. Everyone's opinion as to what is sexy is different. Kahki's and a white polo might turn one guy's head, whereas a pleather miniskirt and halter top might do it for another guy. Heck, even someone wearing a moo-moo could turn heads!

The girl in the pleather skirt might feel just as violated as the girl in the kahkis if some random guy started to rub up on her. So it doesn't matter how conservatively or provacatively you dress, there are guys out there who will stare no matter what. Chat Icon

This all can be said if the roles were reversed. Although it's not often I hear from one of my guy friends that they just got checked out by a woman and they feel violated! They usually strut around a bit more Chat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 12:39 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by MrsMerlot

If a girl/woman is wearing an outfit....showing some skin or form fitting is it HER fault when and if a man oogles or aggressively checks her out?
I wouldn't say it's a fault, but to get upset about it b/c someone is oogling at her or checking her out - honestly, it's more of a compliment no?

do you think if she's made to feel uncomfortable, she was asking for it?
No one is made to feel uncomfortable - it's an emotion, to let it get to her THAT much where she's uncomfortable - that can be controlled by her. She can let it get to her or she can let it brush off her shoulders...ignore it.

does it depend what she is wearing? how deep the neck is/how push up the bra is/how tight/short/slit the skirt/jeans/shorts are?
Yes. We don't walk around this earth with our brains on the outside of heads. We walk with our bodies out there, and depending on your clothing, our bodies are revealed or not so much revealed to others. First sense that we use is SIGHT...so someone is going to react based on what they see....



I agree with this. though I do think that it can sometimes go from being compimentary to obnoxious and rude.

also, up to a certain point you can brush off certain behaviors or attentions...but there is a line that can be crossed where you feel violated. YES, again it's an emotion, but it is evoked by something. so there is a catalyst for the feeling.

I agree wholeheartedly with your last statement.

ftr: today I am wearing a wrap dress with a 3/4 sleep wrap and cowboy boots (b/c of the rain Chat Icon - I have sandals in my bag)

Posted 7/24/08 12:57 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

I walked by a construction site this week (wearing pants and a top--NOTHING provacative), and got the demeaning animal noises(actual hissing and growlingChat Icon ), and I literally wanted to go home and cry--I felt so demeaned. I worked so hard, went to school to be a respected professional, and I can be made to feel unsafe and violated in broad daylight on the street, and I'm completely helpless to do anything about it. I HAVE to wonder who married/gave birth to these "men." It happens to so manyof us every summer--regularly--, and there's nothing we can do. All that hard work, "empowerment," and achievement...and we're reduced to their prey. Chat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 1:07 PM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Is she asking for it?

Just discussed this in my office with a male co-worker....

His take......if a girl is walking down the street it is totally rude and obnoxious to cat-call or ogle. Admiring is one thing, anything else is just plain rude and NOT complimentary.
If she's in a club with her nips hangin out and her skirt up to her nether regions, then she has to accept whatever type of attention she gets, she KNOWS she's dressing like that for a purpose, and she can't freak when guys notice.

And my boss told me a few days ago a story. He was out getting lunch and there was an attractive young woman on line for a sammie. A 30-ish guy wals past her and subtly says, but loud enough for others to hear "nice boobies sweetie".

AND SHE SAYS THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Chat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 1:10 PM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Is she asking for it?

"asking for it" sounds so negative, should she be surprised? no.

Posted 7/24/08 1:10 PM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by curliegirl


My point is that it sometimes doesn't matter WHAT you wear and you still get negative attention.......

But there most definitely ARE people out there who wear what they wear to get any kind of attention they can get, and I guess they deserve whatever comes their way.



My thoughts as well.

Posted 7/24/08 1:11 PM
 

ladybug8
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

2660 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

I agree that guys will stare if a girl looks good or if she is showing way too much skin. If the girl is stared at she might really like it, not be bothered by it, or feel uncomfortable. I guess depending on how you feel it will dictate whether you would where a certain outfit again. (Although if it's just a case of a girl being pretty with a conservative outfit, I guess she should embrace her beauty.)

Looking or saying hello is one thing but undressing with his eyes and saying disrespectful comments are another. Two teachers from a school in my district went for a walk during their lunch. Two guys were in their driveway yelling, "Gimme that p***y!"
The teachers were dressed appropriately for the classroom and were pretty girls. What a way to strike up a conversation with a lady!Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-07-24 16:00:14.720000.

Posted 7/24/08 1:28 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?



My point is that it sometimes doesn't matter WHAT you wear and you still get negative attention.......
ITA .
When I was 8 MONTHS pregnant I bought a black maternity dress for summer, it was cotton dress ruched on the sides ,below the knee, form fitting ,but not open anywhere, it didn''t even have a low neck line, it was just very comfy and wore it a lot when I first bought it . Every time I wore it I got men staring at me and making comments like, "hello sexy" or something like that, and to this day I wonder why. What was it about that dress that drove men into horny SOB-s
I guess what I am trying to say is that yes, sometimes it really doesn't matter what you wear , men will be menChat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 1:49 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by seaside

I walked by a construction site this week (wearing pants and a top--NOTHING provacative), and got the demeaning animal noises(actual hissing and growlingChat Icon ), and I literally wanted to go home and cry--I felt so demeaned. I worked so hard, went to school to be a respected professional, and I can be made to feel unsafe and violated in broad daylight on the street, and I'm completely helpless to do anything about it. I HAVE to wonder who married/gave birth to these "men." It happens to so manyof us every summer--regularly--, and there's nothing we can do. All that hard work, "empowerment," and achievement...and we're reduced to their prey. Chat Icon



Aw, do NOT let yourself feel demeaned by anything anyone else says to you in a situation like that.. thats just letting someone else have control over you. Try to think of it as harmless and not as if someone is violating you. if you give an event like that the power over you, its going to make you feel horrible. brush it off if you can.

Honestly, when something like this happens to me, i ignore it and grin inwardly because its so juvenile. Do these guys actually think you're going to turn around and say 'ooh, thanks honey, why dont you come over here and do me?'
no way..
its harmless IMO. its only if someone says something actually rude - then i'll turn around and give it right back to them. but a few appreciative comments don't bother me at all.

Posted 7/24/08 3:17 PM
 

anonttcer
BOOOO for fall!

Member since 7/06

10082 total posts

Name:
Meaning a NON ttcer!

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by ladybug8

Two guys were in their driveway yelling, "Gimme that p***y!"
What a way to strike up a conversation with a lady!Chat Icon



I'm sorry- I know that is awful and such a pig thing to yell out.
But it did make me Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon to read it like that!
Nice line there! Ugh!

Posted 7/24/08 3:18 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Is she asking for it?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by seaside

I walked by a construction site this week (wearing pants and a top--NOTHING provacative), and got the demeaning animal noises(actual hissing and growlingChat Icon ), and I literally wanted to go home and cry--I felt so demeaned. I worked so hard, went to school to be a respected professional, and I can be made to feel unsafe and violated in broad daylight on the street, and I'm completely helpless to do anything about it. I HAVE to wonder who married/gave birth to these "men." It happens to so manyof us every summer--regularly--, and there's nothing we can do. All that hard work, "empowerment," and achievement...and we're reduced to their prey. Chat Icon



Aw, do NOT let yourself feel demeaned by anything anyone else says to you in a situation like that.. thats just letting someone else have control over you. Try to think of it as harmless and not as if someone is violating you. if you give an event like that the power over you, its going to make you feel horrible. brush it off if you can.

Honestly, when something like this happens to me, i ignore it and grin inwardly because its so juvenile. Do these guys actually think you're going to turn around and say 'ooh, thanks honey, why dont you come over here and do me?'
no way..
its harmless IMO. its only if someone says something actually rude - then i'll turn around and give it right back to them. but a few appreciative comments don't bother me at all.




I agree with this too.

when someone is polite and compliments me, I smile and say thanks (though not to HEY nice TITS or something like that Chat Icon Chat Icon ) but even that doesn't really bother me.

I was just wondering what people thought I guess upon witnessing it happen to someone....what are you notions on where the "fault" lies for lack of a better word...the chick poppin her rocks, or the guy who calls her out???

there is sometimes a tendency to find fault in the "victim"...the whole "she asked for it' thing.

I for one, don't feel I ask for anything, posivite or negative...unless the comments are coming directly from inside my dh's pants (haha no pun intended) Chat Icon

Posted 7/24/08 3:25 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Is she asking for it?

some guys just need saltpeter!


10+ years ago, I was walking to Penn at 5:30ish - but it was pretty dark (winter). there was a woman, wearing a pleather, high boots type outfit, walking in front of me. Of course, she got some cat calls from some men, but man did they get their medicine, when she turned around to respond and we were all surprised that she was a transvestite. She gave a little snarky response and went on her way!

Posted 7/24/08 3:37 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ok, I know I have been asking about the Robeez shoes--who sells them on the island? bean 10/7/06 6 Parenting
I made it to 38 weeks! Now I am asking for labor vibes, lol! maybebaby 8/22/06 4 Pregnancy
Do you ever wake your baby up? And yes, I'm asking the pregos! BaroqueMama 3/23/06 24 Pregnancy
Do you think the prompt asking "abortion" searchers "Did you mean adoption?" was a political statement DebG 3/22/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
as proud aunt, i am asking you to please vote for my niece!!! oops my sister already posted it on here..sorry!!!! ggt08 3/1/06 13 Families Helping Families ™
My Grandfather passed away...update from post asking for help with 24 hr. care HalloweenBride04 1/25/06 22 Families Helping Families ™