I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

I'm in binky weaning HELL

Any BTDT advice? We gave her all the binky she wanted in Israel to give ourselves relief, but she stopped eating, talking or drinking as much, so we resolved that once we got back we were going to start the weaning process. Tonight is the first night without, and ever since I took her home from school, she has been in hysterics, signing every 10 seconds for her binky. It doesn't help that she's teething badly right now... any tips on how to handle this? How long does withdrawal take?

Posted 1/22/07 6:44 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I just can't bear the whining and crying and sleepless nightst that would ensue. She can have it until she's in college for all I care (OK maybe not Chat Icon )
What about cutting a hole in it? Will that maybe make her not want it?
Are you letting her have it at all or going cold turkey?

Posted 1/22/07 6:46 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by monkeybride

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I just can't bear the whining and crying and sleepless nightst that would ensue. She can have it until she's in college for all I care (OK maybe not Chat Icon )
What about cutting a hole in it? Will that maybe make her not want it?
Are you letting her have it at all or going cold turkey?



At first we decided for a week we'd go back to normal, which means a binky for naptime and for bedtime, but heck, if I'm ALREADY going through hell, I may as well make it cold turkey and go all the way, right?

Posted 1/22/07 6:47 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by monkeybride

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Are you letting her have it at all or going cold turkey?



yes, we will be avoiding binky hell for a few more months I think. She only uses it at night and for naps, but she is as addicted as you can possibly be, we will probably concoct a story when she is old enough to understand or cut a whole in it...

I would like her weaned by summer time or like 20 months...

is there any way to limit it's use and phase it out, or is Alex an all or nothing kind of gal?

Posted 1/22/07 6:49 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by monkeybride

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I just can't bear the whining and crying and sleepless nightst that would ensue. She can have it until she's in college for all I care (OK maybe not Chat Icon )
What about cutting a hole in it? Will that maybe make her not want it?
Are you letting her have it at all or going cold turkey?



At first we decided for a week we'd go back to normal, which means a binky for naptime and for bedtime, but heck, if I'm ALREADY going through hell, I may as well make it cold turkey and go all the way, right?



Yeah I would think cold turkey would be easier because I don't think at their age they understand compromise and limits.
If she was 2 or 3 I can see how you could reason bedtime and naps but at this age I think it's probably all or nothing.

Posted 1/22/07 6:51 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by mommy2bellabean

Posted by monkeybride

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Are you letting her have it at all or going cold turkey?



yes, we will be avoiding binky hell for a few more months I think. She only uses it at night and for naps, but she is as addicted as you can possibly be, we will probably concoct a story when she is old enough to understand or cut a whole in it...

I would like her weaned by summer time or like 20 months...

is there any way to limit it's use and phase it out, or is Alex an all or nothing kind of gal?



Alex, unfortunately, inherited my addictive personality, so I'm afraid she's an all or nothing kind of gal Chat Icon Oh well, guess I should just prepare myself for a week of hell... at least we just came back from real hell travelling 12 hours to and from Israel, so this doesn't seem quite as bad Chat Icon

Posted 1/22/07 6:52 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Did you try poking holes in it and giving it to her?

Posted 1/22/07 6:55 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by Bxgell2

Alex, unfortunately, inherited my addictive personality, so I'm afraid she's an all or nothing kind of gal Chat Icon Oh well, guess I should just prepare myself for a week of hell... at least we just came back from real hell travelling 12 hours to and from Israel, so this doesn't seem quite as bad Chat Icon



well, in a few months at least you can laugh at the rest of us as we wade into the demon pool!

Posted 1/22/07 7:19 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by mommy2bellabean

Posted by Bxgell2

Alex, unfortunately, inherited my addictive personality, so I'm afraid she's an all or nothing kind of gal Chat Icon Oh well, guess I should just prepare myself for a week of hell... at least we just came back from real hell travelling 12 hours to and from Israel, so this doesn't seem quite as bad Chat Icon



well, in a few months at least you can laugh at the rest of us as we wade into the demon pool!



Mu-ha-ha-ha Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/22/07 7:35 PM
 

Samlove

Member since 5/05

4729 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I am planning to do the same in a few months, Sara willl be one in February. I know with my son I cut off the nippple and he looked at me like i was crazt - he only asked for it one time after that and once again thre was no nipple. Mean yes, but it worked

Posted 1/22/07 7:36 PM
 

MomofMandB
LIF Infant

Member since 7/06

323 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I don't have any good advice, just lots of Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon . DD gave up her "pappy" when she had a very bad mouth/throat infection at 18 months. She couldn't use it at all for a week, so we just took it away. I do know a lot of people who have had success with cutting off the nipple. Good luck!

How old is she? Maybe if you only give it to her for naps/bedtime for a couple of days, and let her scream at other times, she will eventually get that it is just for sleep. Would it make the transition easier?

Posted 1/22/07 7:42 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I know for a fact a severe case of cox sackie works wonders.

Seriously they're like a heroin addict gone cold turkey. Joseph thrashed around & was a mean little boy for about 4-5 days. The second week was better. After day 10, he asked about it. I said "All gone."

eta. It's tough but if you give it to her now, you've wasted the hell you just went through. Stick to it, you'll be glad you did.

Message edited 2007-01-22 20:05:33.240000.

Posted 1/22/07 8:04 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

The best way to get rid of binkies is to let them get old and flat and totally unappealing to the baby. Then they will give it up on their own. That's what I did without even realized that it was the oldest trick in the book. I just kept on forgetting to replace them and Benjamin completely refused them at 10 months old and never looked at it again.

I had no idea that it was an old trick till my dentist told me about it adn i was like "Oh, wow, that's exactly what I did, without it even knowing it!"

Message edited 2007-01-22 21:16:34.773000.

Posted 1/22/07 9:16 PM
 

Melbernai
I am a lucky Momma!

Member since 7/05

15652 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I can't really offer much advice because Emily gave it up fairly easily at a year. The only thing I can recommend is that if you go cold turkey, make sure you get rid of EVERY single binky that you might have somewhere in the house. We had some that were in the bottom of the toy box, diaper change bin on her changing table and she found them months later and luckily had no interest but we freaked for the first few seconds thinking she'd want it all the time afte that.

Can you try and distract her when she does the sign for binky? Get down on the floor and start playing patty-cake or playing with a favorite toy? Maybe take her into another room for a total change of scenery and offer her something fun to do?

I hope you guys get through it! Good luck! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/22/07 9:42 PM
 

CheeChee
HI THERE!!!!

Member since 5/05

3416 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I really cant offer much advice either since Jacob lost interest in the binky at about 9 months, and just downright refuses to even suck it at all anymore, so i threw them all out. I have heard of cutting holes in them too, and other things but i think Alex is too small to understand those "other things".. I would suggest you stick to the hell now, or she may wind up like my neighbors daughter who is 5 and still walks around day and night with the binky in her mouth..Chat Icon Chat Icon

Good luck.. and hang in there..Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/22/07 10:28 PM
 

JennChris
life moves fast

Member since 5/05

4225 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Mallory was totally addicted to her binky too... we cut a hole in it and she was a little mad at first, but eventually realized that it just wasn't doing it for her any longer... after a week of nastiness she was completely done.Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/07 7:54 AM
 

LuvMy2Girls
@>---------

Member since 5/05

11165 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

We are just starting this now too, not looking forward to it.

DD only uses it to fall asleep at night and for naps. She drives me crazy cause she is teething and wakes up looking for it.

I am too much of a softy to do it cold turkey, and I can't bear to hear her cry.This is what we are going to do.

I just read the no-cry solution, and to wean baby from paci, she recommends starting at bedtime.
Give the baby paci, just as starts to fall asleep when s u c k ing subsides, break seal and take paci out and push chin back up. IF she fusses give it back and try again, 10-15 seconds of hard s u cking, then it should slow to fluttery as she drifts off, remove it again. Keep trying til she falls asleep.
Supposedly if you do this for 10 days or less baby should teach themselves to fall asleep without soothing themselves with the paci, and know they can fall asleep with out it. After nighttime is conquered, try naps.

I hope this works, if you try it let me know. I am not a fan of CIO at all, so a no cry, less traumatic way to do it would be the way i would go.

Good luck!
Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/07 8:44 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Thanks everyone Chat Icon
We decided to ease back into her routine prior to leaving for Israel - which is Paci only for naps and bedtime. After about an hour of crying yesterday, she finally realized she wasn't getting what she wanted, so she stopped crying and started playing a little Chat Icon After a week of this, we'll start the transition to NO binky for naps or bedtime as well... THAT I'm not looking forward too!

Posted 1/23/07 9:22 AM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I remember my brother had the binky until he was about 2 1/2. My parents thought he was getting too old so they took them all away and said that they got hit by a truck.

he said "OK" and never asked for it againChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/07 9:27 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

We so need to do this soon- Jordana is SO addicted to it. My goal is to wean her after 1 year. I am not looking forward to it Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/07 9:30 AM
 

Marybeth222
My Girls!

Member since 5/05

2688 total posts

Name:
Marybeth

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I plan on taking Peyton's away at one also. I've heard of a few methods:

1. Put a small hole in it

2. Use smaller binkies (not sure why)

3. Vinegar (this one seemed mommy dearest like to me)

3. Cold turkey

I'm going to try the small hole first.

Posted 1/23/07 10:07 AM
 

Dani00518
Gorgeous

Member since 5/05

2730 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by pmpkn087

I remember my brother had the binky until he was about 2 1/2. My parents thought he was getting too old so they took them all away and said that they got hit by a truck.

he said "OK" and never asked for it againChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



That is a riot.......I am hystericalChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/07 8:18 PM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

Posted by monkeybride

Don't ask me because I have no plans of stepping foot in hell Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I just can't bear the whining and crying and sleepless nightst that would ensue. She can have it until she's in college for all I care (OK maybe not Chat Icon )



I couldve written this myself...

When I asked my Dr how old was too old, and he replied 3... I took a breath of relief and continued on my way....

I would try the whole in the nipple- I hear it works well

Posted 1/23/07 9:18 PM
 

Jenhos
Maeve

Member since 6/05

3273 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

We went cold turkey. Over it in 3 nights.

Posted 1/23/07 9:29 PM
 

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: I'm in binky weaning HELL

I am going to say that if she is in teething hell she may physically need her binky to help with pain. I would personally not do a major transition like this during a physically painful time for her. JMO.

Posted 1/23/07 9:41 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Binky weaning JennChris 2/27/06 7 Parenting
Weaning the binky Jenhos 12/6/05 11 Parenting
I think Hell froze over - my company is being way too nice... HarleyGirlFLA 3/17/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
What the H.ELL is wrong with people????? Scotty-CassidysMom 2/10/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
I don't care what the hell is on Joey's head BabyAvocado 11/28/05 12 Families Helping Families ™
I am in sciatica hell and ready to chop off my leg Janice 9/19/05 10 Diet & Fitness