I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted By Message

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I called EI b/c I was concerned DS was falling behind with speech. He has a lot of words and puts 2 and 3 words together but still does some baby talk and I felt he might need a little help so I called EI. Two evaluators came and found his expressive speech was actually only slightly delayed but were more concerned about his attention span/focus and receptive speech. He did not really respond well or answer questions I know he knows for the evaluators and was kind of all over the place. Part of it I feel was his personality but I also do agree that he does have a short attention span and is very self-directed. They also brought up some possible "sensory" issues b/c he is still very oral with putting things in his mouth and occasionally toe walks.

The ironic thing is when the evalutor asked him to point to his body part he wouldnt do it, but we do it EVERY day so I know he knows. He wouldnt stay on task or stay focused on what the evaluator wanted to do, such as play with blocks, yet we took him to see Thomas the Train at the coliseum and he sat through the entire show. Where is the line drawn between what is their personality and what is really an issue? KWIM.

anyway, they came last week for the meeting to go over his plan. They are going to do 2 - 45min. sessions a week for speech and 2 - 45min. sessions a week for special instructions to work on his attention span/focus, etc. They also said they wanted to do an OT evaluation although they didnt think he would qualify only on sensory issues.

The OT evaluator came over the weekend and this is where I am now borderline pi$$ed. The evaluator says technically he doesnt qualify. He was not concerned about the occasional toe walking (and neither were any of the other therapist Chat Icon yet they mentioned it...they said it is not constant so dont worry about it). He wasn't even that concerned about being putting things in his mouth and still being very oral b/c he said the speech will help him with that. But he DID say he will put down he should get OT b/c get this...he asked me if DS has ever cut anything with a scissorChat Icon I never though to give a 2 yr. old a scissor. THAN, he draws lines on a piece of paper and gives DS a crayon and expected him to trace the lines Chat Icon He JUST turned 2...it's not like he is 2, going on 3. Obviously DS just scribbled on the page. THAN, he wanted DS to put beads on a string. I have never done that with DS...I would never think of giving him beads when he puts everything in his mouth still Chat Icon

So now, on top of the 2 speech and 2 spec. instruction, he is going to get 2 session of OT. That is 6 sessions a week...yet there is no concern from any of the evaluators, no concern from my ped., no concern from his Mommy and Me teacher that he has autism or any other serious developmental issue or delay Chat Icon Chat Icon Am I happpy he is going to be getting servies? Yes. But I honestly figured he would have maybe 2 sessions a week and that's that. But 6 for a child who noone see's anything really wrong with other than he's a boy and is "slightly" behind in speech.

I am confused. I feel that 6 sessions is too much. I am going to try it out for the summer and if it gets to be too much let them know.

Does anyone understand where I am coming from? I dont want to sound like that mom who think nothing is wrong with their child. But hoenstly, no matter who I tell who knows DS (some of my friends whom are teachers) look at me like I have 6 heads. My husbands cousin son has apraxia of speech and is 3 and doesnt talk at all and was turned down by EI THREE times...yet my son gets all these services and there is no serious concern for anything Chat Icon Noone can believe, including my ped. that he qualified for anything. And eveyrone is telling me, take the services it can't hurt.

I just dont get it! They had me going crazy thinking someone was really wrong with him when I really just feel like they picked him apart and pulled out all his "quirks" and told me I need to fix them.


ETA: And just to give you a better idea of where I am coming from the other day we were playing blocks. I called DS and asked him to come over and help me pick up the blocks. He looked at me and than turned his head away. He was watching cartoons and wanted no part of cleaning up. I called him 10 x's and he continued to ignore me. I turned off the TV. He walked up to the TV and put his hand on it and asked "what happened" and looked at me. I told him, if you come clean up the blocks I will put the cartoons back on. He walked over to me, put blocks in the bag and walked back over to the tV waiting for me to turn back on the cartoons.

Maybe I'm being naive, but that does not seem like a kid with a receptive issue...it seems like a kid who is a smart-arse Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-06-29 15:32:03.793000.

Posted 6/29/09 3:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I sort of know what you mean.

I was pushed by my mother to call EI about speech.

he did not quailify with one test, so they tested him differently to get him to qualify.

He had a word explosion and talks all the time now.

now I am sort of stuck in EI.

since he is turning 3, they are talking about school....I said no way. This kid's asthma starts up out of no where, I don't want him in school, and I don't think he would come close to quailifying.

Coordinator said yeah, he probably will only get in if you push for it. Chat Icon either he needs it or not.

I think 6 is a lot. I would keep 2 speeches and knock the others to once a week.

I was at josh's art class this week...tons of 2 year olds aren't using scissors correctly.

Posted 6/29/09 3:40 PM
 

emc
The Boys!

Member since 5/05

2065 total posts

Name:
Erin

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I haven't posted on here in ages, but I felt compelled to answer this post. I work as a speech therapist for the birth to 5 population and I am an evaluator. Being an evaluator is a tough job, you only get a *glimpse* of what the child does for that short evaluation period. I hope they asked you a lot of questions- like, "Although he wouldn't touch his eyes, nose, and mouth for me today, is this something he does on a consistent basis for you?" Assuming that the evaluators were thorough, there must have been some behaviors that they found to be concerning in order for your son to qualify. It is not easy (at least for speech) to qualify for services if there is only one area of weakness (you said his receptive language) as they take the combination of his receptive language and his expressive language to obtain a "total language score". My niece was nonverbal, no eye contact, hand flapping, etc at two years old and they only wanted to give her ONE session of speech a week. So, if your service coordinator is willing enough to give your son 2X speech and 2X ed, TAKE them and cut back as they are not needed. I never feel like 1X a week is enough, 6 days is a long time in a toddler's lifeChat Icon so if there are too many days in between services, it may be hard to establish and maintain rapport. The OT on the other hand sounds COMPLETELY off the mark. I would have that re-tested or suggest that you felt the expectations were tasks your son has never been exposed to and that you would rather start with the special ed teacher who could "monitor" his progress and refer back for an evaluation if he needs it.

Posted 6/29/09 4:02 PM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I have not called EI. But I can see where you are coming from. DS is almost 2. I have never given him scissors. It has never crossed my mind. I know he can't draw a line. As a mom how are we supposed to know to introduce these things. They are 2 years old.

Posted 6/29/09 4:13 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by emc

I haven't posted on here in ages, but I felt compelled to answer this post. I work as a speech therapist for the birth to 5 population and I am an evaluator. Being an evaluator is a tough job, you only get a *glimpse* of what the child does for that short evaluation period. I hope they asked you a lot of questions- like, "Although he wouldn't touch his eyes, nose, and mouth for me today, is this something he does on a consistent basis for you?" Assuming that the evaluators were thorough, there must have been some behaviors that they found to be concerning in order for your son to qualify. It is not easy (at least for speech) to qualify for services if there is only one area of weakness (you said his receptive language) as they take the combination of his receptive language and his expressive language to obtain a "total language score". My niece was nonverbal, no eye contact, hand flapping, etc at two years old and they only wanted to give her ONE session of speech a week. So, if your service coordinator is willing enough to give your son 2X speech and 2X ed, TAKE them and cut back as they are not needed. I never feel like 1X a week is enough, 6 days is a long time in a toddler's lifeChat Icon so if there are too many days in between services, it may be hard to establish and maintain rapport. The OT on the other hand sounds COMPLETELY off the mark. I would have that re-tested or suggest that you felt the expectations were tasks your son has never been exposed to and that you would rather start with the special ed teacher who could "monitor" his progress and refer back for an evaluation if he needs it.




The big part of the receptive speech was that he did not respond to his name consistently. He only responded to the evaluator if it was smoething he wanted to do. At home, he responds to me and listens to me "when he wants" like I showed in the example in my original post. He follows direction (get that book, get the phone for mommy). I was shocked when they said his receptive scores were lower than expressive.

As for the tasks they asked him to do such as building blocks, he did for one evaluator and not the other. Maybe it was the day, maybe it was his mood, maybe he just didnt like the woman Chat Icon I dont know...but we build with blocks all the time. I told them he knows how to do it.

Their BIG concern was his attention span/focus. I did tell them my husband was diagnosed with ADD as a child. maybe they pushed for services for that reason.

Posted 6/29/09 4:16 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I used Cooper Kids for evaluations. I wonder if he would have scored the same had he been evluated by another agency. Do certain agency's have a rep. for qualifying kids more than others?

Posted 6/29/09 4:18 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by emc

"Although he wouldn't touch his eyes, nose, and mouth for me today, is this something he does on a consistent basis for you?" .



We do this on almost a daily basis. And if you want to hear something funny. the other day we were doing it and I had on my glasses. I said, "where are mommy's eyes". He stuck his finger under my glasses and pointed to my right eye and counted "1", pointed to my left eye and counted "2" and than he pointed to the right lens of my glasses, counted "3" and than the left lens and counted "4". Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

DH and I were hysterical....basically he called me 4 eyes Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-06-29 16:22:01.613000.

Posted 6/29/09 4:20 PM
 

elyssa222
******

Member since 5/05

1541 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by jellybean1420

I used Cooper Kids for evaluations. I wonder if he would have scored the same had he been evluated by another agency. Do certain agency's have a rep. for qualifying kids more than others?



DING DING DING...you just hit the jackpot. The more services they provide the more money in their pocket!!!

I would take the services and then cut back as u feel it is no longer needed. It is a lot harder to get the services back after you turn them down.

Message edited 2009-06-29 16:29:24.550000.

Posted 6/29/09 4:23 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I told you before and will say it again, something is OFF with this evaluation. But that is just my opinion and I could b wrong... I dont know your son nor can I comment too much on his actions, yet your being pretty detailed and based on your descriptions I think something is not right.

Noah's behaviors were MUCH worse then what your describing, and we were told they were typical.

First- a 2 yr old is NOT expected to cut with a scissor nor trace a line.....And this is coming from our very recent testing...that was a 3 yr old 3 month trait. That is ABSURD that they tested him or asked him to do that.

Second....Noah put a lot of things in his mouth too, constantly, he grew out of it...and in part due to the speech. It is just a sensory thing, oral fixation.

I think 2 sessions of special training a week is a LOT. I would actually based on your description not agree to it.

But like the PP mentioned, you can see how it goes and cut back. You dont HAVE to continue with the services...we are cutting back our Parent training right now b/c its not really helping much anymore.

I think the thing your most worried or annoyed with is that they are seeing something your not and I really feel like thats not the case.

Kids ( 2 yr olds for goodness sakes) are STUBBORN. Noah didnt point out his body parts either for the evaluator....but of course he knows them and I told them he knows they all, they took my word for it, b/c commands like that are hard for a 2 yr old to follow with a stranger....

Not sure what you want to do at this point? Maybe just feel validated and I think you are in how your feeling. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/29/09 4:39 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

as a mother, whose child is autistic, by reducing his services would be a great injustice.

i am not saying that you as a parent are doing wrong, but its apparent that these evaluators see something wrong with your DS to recommend the services he needs.

my DS at 15 months old had Special Ed, Speech & OT.

at 18 months old he had 7 1/2 hours of ABA, 2 speech @ 45 min & 2 OT @ 45 min.

at 20 months he is now getting 15 hours of ABA, 3 speech @ 45 min & 2 OT @ 45 min.

most straight up evals for speech, OT, pt and SpEd should NOT say whether they think your child is autistic or not.

that should be done by a clinical psychologist. his therapists after working with him should be able to give some sort of indication if he should have the Clinical psych done.

most of us do not know what our child should and shouldnt be doing at this age, but a typically developing child would know and would be able to perform such tasks without really being taught to some extent.

i understand where you are saying that teachers and what not don't understand how he can qualify but they also are not trained to the eye to look for certain things in a child. yes EVEN TEACHERS.

my friend is a special ed teacher and said she really didnt think anything was wrong with my DS and was shocked when i told her that he was autistic... now with all the services he has been receiving she notices differences.

ok i am not trying to hijack your post here, but you should NOT be sorry you called EI, it was the BEST thing you could have done for your DS...

Posted 6/29/09 4:40 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by elyssa222

Posted by jellybean1420

I used Cooper Kids for evaluations. I wonder if he would have scored the same had he been evluated by another agency. Do certain agency's have a rep. for qualifying kids more than others?



DING DING DING...you just hit the jackpot. The more services they provide the more money in their pocket!!!

I would take the services and then cut back as u feel it is no longer needed. It is a lot harder to get the services back after you turn them down.




Oh boy... I didnt want to go there Chat Icon Chat Icon

I agree...I am going to give it a couple of months and see how it goes. If it becomes too much for him (he is only 26 mo.) I will cut back as needed. To be honest, when the OT evaluator came he couldnt understand why he was getting speech services Chat Icon
But I also think DS liked him more Chat Icon

I will wait until their 3 mo. report/review and go from there.

Posted 6/29/09 4:41 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by dm24angel

Kids ( 2 yr olds for goodness sakes) are STUBBORN. Noah didnt point out his body parts either for the evaluator....but of course he knows them and I told them he knows they all, they took my word for it, b/c commands like that are hard for a 2 yr old to follow with a stranger....





They asked me a lot of questions but I dont think they took my word for it.

Even their reports were inconsistent and they admitted the evaluators didnt find the same things (other than his lack of attention/focus) b/c he performed one task for one evaluator and not for the other.

Posted 6/29/09 4:48 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I agree with you that you are probably right and DS probably doesn't need all of these services - if any at all. I guess if it were me at this point I would take advantage of them for a little bit (assuming you are getting them for free) and DS can get ahead of the came - right? Too much learning can never be a bad thing! Then it will b/c apparent to them soon enough that it isn't necessary and I am assuming it will end.

I'm always so curious when I read about these evaluations at this age and how they are done b/c although thank god DS def. doesn'tneed it I can't imagine that this would ever come through. If a complete stranger came into our house and started asking him to do things he would NEVER respond to him unless he REALLY liked him. So I can't imagine how these things can always work. My DS talks like crazy and does a million things that are advanced for his age. But, if a stranger in public that he doesn't know asks him for a high five he will just stare at him or walk away! At this age I think it is alot to expcet a toddler to "perform" for a complete stranger!

Posted 6/29/09 4:51 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

As an OT, I can honestly say a 2 year old should NOT be cutting with scissors, even at 3 yrs old, we are just expecting them to start learning how to put them on and possibly start snipping paper (granted every child is different but most standardardized testing used by OT's for evaluation purposes, don't even look at this skill till they are atleast 3)Chat Icon I am so angry knowing there are people in my profession who obviously dont know about development. Don't forget, just b/c it's recommended doesn't mean you have to take the services if you feel any of them are not right for your sonChat Icon

Message edited 2009-06-29 16:55:18.540000.

Posted 6/29/09 4:54 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by mommyonli

most straight up evals for speech, OT, pt and SpEd should NOT say whether they think your child is autistic or not.

that should be done by a clinical psychologist. his therapists after working with him should be able to give some sort of indication if he should have the Clinical psych done.




None of the 3 evaluators nor the coordinator thought a psych. eval was necessary and I asked for one. They said he does not show the signs of autism although they do not make that diagnosis. I also met with my pediatrician (who has seen DS on almost a monthly basis since he was born b/c I split vaccines) who also said he does not display signs of autism.

he responds to his name (although inconsistently if he knows you want him to do something he doesnt want to do). he makes eye contact. he socializes well with other kids. he is very affectionate and likes to get hugs and kisses and give them. plays appropriately with his toys. reacts appropriately to situations (crying when he gets hurt, laughing at something funny). adjusts well to change in environments/routine.

Posted 6/29/09 4:58 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I can't see any county rep giving you OT based on what this evaluator said. They always roll their eyes At scissors skills! You don't have to take the services If you don't feel they are appropriate!

Posted 6/29/09 5:16 PM
 

emc
The Boys!

Member since 5/05

2065 total posts

Name:
Erin

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

I agree with a pp that something seems "off" about this evaluation overall. I have never heard of them (not that that means anything). I would start with the services and see what you think of the professionals, maybe pick therapists from a different agency..

Posted 6/29/09 6:55 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Honestly, I only called EI about my son's speech and thought everything else was fine. I didn't know he was supposed to jump with 2 feet by xx age, throw a ball a certain way, etc. I wasn't expecting for him to get OT/PT and special instruction on top of speech. So while I can understand being completely surprised by the findings and recomendations for therapy, I personally would accept the services. If he doesn't need them when they re-evaulate him, then great, but you really have nothing to lose here.

As far as stringing beads and scissors, are you sure the OT evaulator had your DC's correct age? Maybe he thought your son was 36 months not 26 months? I remember stringing beads an scissors being an age 3 thing when DS was younger.

Posted 6/29/09 7:34 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

Posted by EmmaNick

As far as stringing beads and scissors, are you sure the OT evaulator had your DC's correct age? Maybe he thought your son was 36 months not 26 months? I remember stringing beads an scissors being an age 3 thing when DS was younger.



I'm sure he had his correct age b/c he told me that it was a little "old" for him to do now but being this was something they would expect him to do in another 3 or 4 months and he can't do it now and hasn't been introduced, he doesnt think he'll be able to do it than Chat Icon

Posted 6/29/09 9:45 PM
 

KarenK122
The Journey is the Destination

Member since 5/05

4431 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: I'm almost sorry I called EI (long)

You do not have to accept any services that are offered to you if you do not want them. You make the final decisions not the county or your evaluators.

My daughter gets ABA for 15 hours a week and speech twice a week. She also "technically" qualified for OT/PT but I declined. Mostly because the things they were "dinging" her on during the testing were things I have never taught her such as cutting with a scissor. I, and her current teachers, really didn't think she needed more services and if for some reason I think she is falling father behind on those areas, I can get her evaulated again at a later date.

You know your child better than anyone so do what your gut is telling you to do. Good luck!

Posted 6/29/09 10:41 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
AF after BCP sorry if TMI patti08 3/20/06 3 TTC
TMI, sorry..... BaroqueMama 3/19/06 4 Pregnancy
sorry, wrong board! VirginiaDeb 3/19/06 0 Pregnancy
Sorry to post here - re: Question about smoking... KittyCat 3/17/06 9 Parenting
A Couple of Questions- kind of long, sorry! casey31 3/17/06 6 TTC
Ok girls, I need advice...(long post with poll, sorry) dandr10199 3/15/06 6 Pregnancy