Idol 3/11

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Dream426
DD: July 11, 2011!!

Member since 6/08

1859 total posts

Name:
Gina Marie

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by LSP2005

Posted by bklyngirl

dh think simon was a little rude how he said it.


i do too....I did not realize that they could only use the rescue once. I don't think that they will use it until the very end.



I agree. I don't think they will use it in the beginning.

Posted 3/11/09 10:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jewels
Stop and smell the flowers

Member since 7/06

1538 total posts

Name:

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.

Posted 3/11/09 10:27 PM
 

BabyMommaSomeday
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

365 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by jewels

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.



I thought Chris Daughtry was third place? DH said the same thing...this new rule wouldn't have saved him either way. Tamyra Gray was a fourth place finisher so the new rule would have done her no good either. Jennifer Hudson on the other hand came in 7th place and I personally think Simon just didn't like her and his remarks were why she got the boot.

Posted 3/11/09 10:37 PM
 

Kierasmom
I love my kids

Member since 5/05

2885 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Idol 3/11

I like the new rule because every season there is always a really good singer who goes home too early. This will allow them to have another chance. I don't think the judges will use it until there are only like 6 or 7 people left.

Posted 3/12/09 7:31 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Idol 3/11

I don't like the new rule, I think it is silly. They aren't going to use for a really long time anyway.

I am so glad Anoop stayed-he hasn't been so great the few weeks but I loved his performance of My Prerogative back in Hollywood week.

Posted 3/12/09 9:52 AM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by BabyMommaSomeday

Posted by jewels

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.



I thought Chris Daughtry was third place? DH said the same thing...this new rule wouldn't have saved him either way. Tamyra Gray was a fourth place finisher so the new rule would have done her no good either. Jennifer Hudson on the other hand came in 7th place and I personally think Simon just didn't like her and his remarks were why she got the boot.



Nope, he was 4th...Elliot Yamin, Taylor Hicks and Katherine McPhee ended up the top 3 - Elliott was 3rd, Katherine 2nd and Taylor won.

Posted 3/12/09 10:20 AM
 

Dream426
DD: July 11, 2011!!

Member since 6/08

1859 total posts

Name:
Gina Marie

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by jewels

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.



Really? I thought they could save anyone at any time. Ryan was asking them if they wanted to save anyone last night.

Posted 3/12/09 10:39 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by Dream426

Posted by jewels

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.



Really? I thought they could save anyone at any time. Ryan was asking them if they wanted to save anyone last night.




They can save 1 person over the course of the entire season, until they get down to the final five and then they can save no one.

In the past, I haven't seen anyone dropped before the final 5 worth saving really.

I think the rule is pretty silly and I am concerned with all these twists that this is the year AI jumps the shark.

Posted 3/12/09 1:06 PM
 

Dream426
DD: July 11, 2011!!

Member since 6/08

1859 total posts

Name:
Gina Marie

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Dream426

Posted by jewels

Posted by bklyngirl

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by LSP2005

ca someone please fill me in - my tv went silent and I did not click on mute. Chat Icon




The judges are allowed one "save" this season. The next week two people will be voted off.



Thanks.

I actually kinda like this rule. If they had that rule a few seasons ago Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been robbed.



that's why they're doing it



Actually Chris Daughtry still woulda gone home cuz he was 4th place and they are only allowing the saving until there are 5 contestants left.



Really? I thought they could save anyone at any time. Ryan was asking them if they wanted to save anyone last night.




They can save 1 person over the course of the entire season, until they get down to the final five and then they can save no one.

In the past, I haven't seen anyone dropped before the final 5 worth saving really.

I think the rule is pretty silly and I am concerned with all these twists that this is the year AI jumps the shark.



Oh ok. Thank you. I agree with you with all the changes.

Posted 3/12/09 3:37 PM
 

MommaTo3Dogs1Boy
All of My Dreams Came True

Member since 2/09

1989 total posts

Name:
Kimmie

Re: Idol 3/11

i can't believe anoop won over jorge. anoop was TERRIBLE that night!

Posted 3/12/09 6:02 PM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Idol 3/11

Posted by MommaTo3Dogs1Boy

i can't believe anoop won over jorge. anoop was TERRIBLE that night!



Totally agree. I never saw what all the hype was about anoop in the first place. Poor jorge. Chat Icon

Posted 3/12/09 7:14 PM
 

NS1976
My princess!

Member since 5/05

6548 total posts

Name:

Re: Idol 3/11

I actually wanted Scott and Jasmine to go.

Jorge was an awesome singer and I think Anoop can do better.

I also dont really get the hype about Adam as I have said before..he makes me SICK! I honestly think they created this save stuff for him! It looks like they want him to sail through..

My money though is on Danny and Matt. I LOVE them!

Posted 3/12/09 8:40 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Idol pregnancy? Did anyone else hear the teaser on Fox news? Shorty 3/18/08 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
can someone recap IDOL for me.. I FELL ASLEEP AHHHHHHHHH 04bride 5/3/07 1 Families Helping Families ™
My friend made it thru to Hollywood on American Idol last night!!!! Pic added J9-13 1/17/07 23 Families Helping Families ™
American Idol fans -guess who visited the troops? PIC ADDED 05mommy09 1/10/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Party Favors: TomKat in John Lennon's Old Building? ... Pam Anderson Returns to TV ... "Idol" Vixen Antonella Barba Makes Cut MrsQ 3/2/07 1 Celebrities & Entertainment
IDOL? chris605 3/22/06 6 Families Helping Families ™