I wonder..........
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
I wonder.......... if people against this form of a national healthcare system (regardless of the specific reasons why) and whom elect not to participate and pay the penalty...what they would do, if they one day found themselves, unemployed with a serious medical condition or a very sick child and no access to private company sponsored insurance? Would they participate then or still stand their ground on principal and rack up 10s of thousands in medical bills or just forgo care altogether in the name of principal? Would they be singing a different tune if it saved their child, their own life or the life of a loved one and spared them from bankruptcy? Would they be grateful for it being in place then? Message edited 2010-03-23 21:51:52.093000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 7:54 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: I wonder.......... good question... |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... I will make my stance yet again. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by MikesWife I will make my stance yet again. Affordable health care coverage should be available to those who truly need it. I even made a proposition regarding unforeseen financial interruptions and temporary relief. There are certain aspects of the bill that are applaudable - no denial or dropping of coverage for pre-existing conditions, no cap, etc. However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. Thats all fine and good but thats not what I asked....I asked if you oppose it, if you one day found you, yourself or a loved one/child in need, would you then elect to take it? Message edited 2010-03-23 20:15:55.900000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... I think you are misconstruing most people's stance against this legistlation. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by stickydust I think you are misconstruing most people's stance against this legistlation. For ME, I am not against healthcare reform. I have a MILLION ideas of what can and should have been done but I like many others have no voice in our government no matter how active we try to be. That being said - I am against THIS plan and the manner in which it was pushed through. To reiterate what was said by many already - I am not heartless, nor do I lack compassion but I do not agree with getting something done just for the sake of getting it done. I wanted any healthcare reform to be a result of really creative, intelligent thinking about what is best for EVERYONE. With respect to your question, in the UNLIKELY event that your scenario were to happen ( I say unlikely because it would mean that both DH and I had to lose our jobs, and healthcare and develop a serious illness and lose all savings all in one foul swoop - but I never say never) I honestly do not know what I would do. I would never be so presumptious as to make any declarations now as to what I would do in a crisis. Also I would not have to pay a penalty now as a sign of protest as I am currently insured and the penalty only applies to those who do not have current insurance. I should rephrase and say the healthcare reform bill as it stands. Also, Im not misconstruing anything, I get peoples stances, I dont necessarily agree but I get it. This was a what if scenario, regardless of the "why" you oppose it. Im just curious what you (the collective) would do if they were then in that situation. Its not so far fetched to think you could find yourself unemployed at the same time, it happened to DH and I a few months before our wedding. The purpose of me posing the question was not to again debate the logistics, flaws, technicalities and what have you of the current bill. It was a simple question, if you oppose the current bill for whatever reason, but one day found yourself with a serious medical issue and no insurance, would you then elect to participate? Message edited 2010-03-23 20:58:21.093000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by MikesWife Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. I know you cant go without , without paying the penalty, I said that. And again, this is HYPOTHETICALLY, and regardless of the reasons you oppose the bill. If you oppose the bill for whatever reasons, and one day find yourself without or are ineligible for private insurance and/or elect to not participate and pay the penalty....if you one day, hypothetically, need that coverage....would you participate, would you be grateful it was in place then, would you still turn it down? Or would you continue to hold your stance against the bill and just accumulate the costs of the medical bills or forgo the care you need? Message edited 2010-03-23 21:09:28.913000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MikesWife Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. I know you cant go without , without paying the penalty, I said that. And again, this is HYPOTHETICALLY, and regardless of the reasons you oppose the bill. If you oppose the bill for whatever reasons, and one day find yourself without or are ineligible for private insurance and/or elect to not participate and pay the penalty....if you one day, hypothetically, need that coverage....would you participate, would you be grateful it was in place then, would you still turn it down? Or would you continue to hold your stance against the bill and just accumulate the costs of the medical bills or forgo the care you need? You must be related to my DH - he is always asking hypotheticals with a million "what ifs"
|
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MikesWife Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. I know you cant go without , without paying the penalty, I said that. And again, this is HYPOTHETICALLY, and regardless of the reasons you oppose the bill. If you oppose the bill for whatever reasons, and one day find yourself without or are ineligible for private insurance and/or elect to not participate and pay the penalty....if you one day, hypothetically, need that coverage....would you participate, would you be grateful it was in place then, would you still turn it down? Or would you continue to hold your stance against the bill and just accumulate the costs of the medical bills or forgo the care you need? If I opted out of the government plan I would be opting out for life? I'm assuming that in your hypothetical scenario the reason for my needing the government plan is because I can no longer afford a private plan in which case I've already made the argument that it should be available in those circumstances - but I shouldn't be going to Aruba in the same sentence and asking tax payers to foot part of my medical bill through increased taxes. I don't have all the answers. Maybe I'm just too tired to even know if you are asking me the question. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by stickydust Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MikesWife Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. I know you cant go without , without paying the penalty, I said that. And again, this is HYPOTHETICALLY, and regardless of the reasons you oppose the bill. If you oppose the bill for whatever reasons, and one day find yourself without or are ineligible for private insurance and/or elect to not participate and pay the penalty....if you one day, hypothetically, need that coverage....would you participate, would you be grateful it was in place then, would you still turn it down? Or would you continue to hold your stance against the bill and just accumulate the costs of the medical bills or forgo the care you need? You must be related to my DH - he is always asking hypotheticals with a million "what ifs" I could be, but what really got me thinking was that just this week DS was diagnosed with asthma and WE HAVE been in a position where we both lost our jobs at the same time. I do support this bill, although I do think its flawed but it got me thinking. If I didnt and was adamantly against this bill, and lost my company sponsored insurance, would I stand my ground and forgo the 4 medications and medical equipment it now takes to control is asthma all for the sake of "principal". Would I risk bankrupting my family to pay for the medical bills associated with it bc I dont agree with the bill? I was just thinking about it to myself, and my answer was , No I wouldnt, I would absolutely participate if it, even if I opposed it, if it meant access to care for my son, if it meant him being able to breathe and for my family to not go bankrupt. Honestly, Im glad its there as a safety net bc it has happened to DH and I, we have lost means to insurance at the same time. If it were to ever happen again, Im glad its in place so I am still able to care for my son. Just so you know where its coming from, and know that Im really not posing the question to start drama or fuel another debate. Im genuinely curious. Its intention is more from an emotional and personal standpoint rather than a political/economic one. There are millions in that "hypothetical" situation now. Message edited 2010-03-23 21:27:30.940000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... You're asking if we'd cut off our noses to spite our faces. I don't think it makes anyone a hypocrite to be against this bill as passed and to take advantages of any benefits it may offer should they be in the hypothetical situation you described. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Honestly, it is really difficult for me to annswer your question because it presupposes so many things. I am sorry to hear about your son. I have had major health issues in the past - in fact I am missing a piece of my lung because if itt. I received EXCELLENT care for which I paid not a cent. I realize how fortunate that makes me and believe everyone should have the same good fortune. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by Kara You're asking if we'd cut off our noses to spite our faces. I don't think it makes anyone a hypocrite to be against this bill as passed and to take advantages of any benefits it may offer should they be in the hypothetical situation you described. And I've been in the situation of being very seriously injured and without health insurance... and I'm still against the bill that was passed for a laundry list of reasons. (But other than this post, I'm not even OPENING the threads on the bill. I don't care to debate my political beliefs on this forum anymore.) I only opened this one b/c I didn't know it was about the bill. I didnt imply that it would make them a hypocrite, I was just curious if they would participate and be grateful to have the access to healthcare if they were ever in a situation to need it. Thats all. Im not asking this with the intent in inflame or instigate. Message edited 2010-03-24 11:46:55.560000. |
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by stickydust Again, I agree that something has to be done I just disagree on the execution. To answer your question - since I believ that those under the system will receive less than stellar care then I would scrounge to get the top care I can possibly buy. thank you. I dont care how you answer, I was just curious what your answer would be.
|
|
Posted 3/23/10 9:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... so no one against this bill can answer this question? No one at all, Im so curious. Oh well. |
|
Posted 3/24/10 8:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by eddiesmommy so no one against this bill can answer this question? No one at all, Im so curious. Oh well. I am for the bill, and if that situation you posted were to occur- I would be happy that my tax dollars are helping to save someone's life. |
|
Posted 3/24/10 8:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Call me dumb... I still don't completely understand the bill ,so for now I am staying neutral and going with the flow |
|
Posted 3/24/10 9:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by My3girlsMylife Call me dumb... I still don't completely understand the bill ,so for now I am staying neutral and going with the flow You're not dumb Here is a pretty easy break down from the meat of the billBill |
|
Posted 3/24/10 9:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by Kara You're asking if we'd cut off our noses to spite our faces. I don't think it makes anyone a hypocrite to be against this bill as passed and to take advantages of any benefits it may offer should they be in the hypothetical situation you described. And I've been in the situation of being very seriously injured and without health insurance... and I'm still against the bill that was passed for a laundry list of reasons. (But other than this post, I'm not even OPENING the threads on the bill. I don't care to debate my political beliefs on this forum anymore.) I only opened this one b/c I didn't know it was about the bill. I agree. I am for the health care reform but I don't think your question is really fair or realistic... |
|
Posted 3/24/10 9:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by HeathKernandez Posted by Kara You're asking if we'd cut off our noses to spite our faces. I don't think it makes anyone a hypocrite to be against this bill as passed and to take advantages of any benefits it may offer should they be in the hypothetical situation you described. And I've been in the situation of being very seriously injured and without health insurance... and I'm still against the bill that was passed for a laundry list of reasons. (But other than this post, I'm not even OPENING the threads on the bill. I don't care to debate my political beliefs on this forum anymore.) I only opened this one b/c I didn't know it was about the bill. I agree. I am for the health care reform but I don't think your question is really fair or realistic... I think its a perfectly legitimate question....even if you oppose it now, would you in the future take advantage of it if you needed to? I think its a perfectly fair question and for ten of thousands of Americans its not such a far fetched situation....there are thousands living that RIGHT NOW. |
|
Posted 3/24/10 10:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... Posted by MikesWife Posted by Beth Posted by MikesWife . However, why should those who have sacrificed certain items and/or luxuries so they can have medical coverage subsidize those that have not made those same sacrifices? I just think the bill as it stands face value right now is lopsided and flawed. you keep saying this- but where is this in the bill????? I am self employed and I drive a luxury car (shot me- I bought it while I had health coverage and if I could sell it- I would but b/c of my business I put 25k miles on it 10 months- so it's worthless) I am under the impression the bill allows for me- and people like me- hard working business owners and self employed people to pool together to BUY a lower cost health plan- b/c we are in a pool - instead of alone I scarafice plenty and I pay taxes too I just refuse to work at a job a hate b/c it offers health coverage- I would rather go with out and get my business off the ground while I am young and healthy and be happy But under this bill you can't go without -not without penalty. I'm not talking about denying people who are in dire straights - I'm really not. But why should taxpayers pick up the bill - because let's face it, you can't have a public service without the cost being funded by the "public", for those who are opting for cable packages and blackberries over their own families health? At some point we the people - all of us individually, have to shoulder some responsibility for our choices. Do I know the ins and outs of the entire bill, no, I do not. Does it address these issues? I'm not being snarky, I'm asking with sincerity. but I do NOT want to go with out health insurace....I want to to able to buy a good plan that isn't going to break me - like buying into a group pool I have been looking for months- the plans I want are close to $1k the plans I can afford...are under $500 and they cover nothing I never said I would rather drive a benz then have health coverage I wish my husband didn't run up tens of thousands of dollars worth of debt in my name and force me to sign for a car that I can't even drive- which is really what's stopping me from being covered- my situation is temporary if I cancel my blackberry- I can't work if I cancel my cable- which is with my internet I can't work if I sell my car- I can't work if I can't work- I can't live so what is it you would like me to do? I never asked for you to pay for my health coverage- I just want to be able to BUY a plan- on a group rate - like people who are employed by a larger company - and they plan is being bought thru a private company and that is one of the things this bill provides it's not a public service- it's not a public option- it's run by private health insurace companies that already exsist |
|
Posted 3/24/10 10:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: I wonder.......... I am not 100% in favor of the way this plan is laid out but if god forbid, some where down the line I am in the position you describe I would use health care and insurance plan resources available to me. I would consider it a service that I was part of paying for and therefore entitled to use. |
|
Posted 3/24/10 10:56 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I wonder if DH saw the light? Short update... | MrsJ | 6/9/06 | 34 | Parenting |
| Wonder what it can be? UPDATE! | MelToddJulia | 6/8/06 | 31 | Parenting |
| With all the recent celebrity preggos, I can't help but wonder... | BaroqueMama | 2/13/06 | 26 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| HMMM...... I WONDER!!!!!!!!! | nancygrace | 12/19/05 | 16 | TTC |
| Got this in an email... I wonder if its real... | MrsDiamondgrlie | 9/21/05 | 12 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I wonder if Hell's Kitchen is coming back next season... | CaseyGirl | 8/8/05 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |











Here is a pretty easy break down from the meat of the bill
